Page 755 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia

4'8+56# &' &'4'%*1 &' .# 70+8'45+&#& &' /106'8+&'1
%

HP bT WP P]P[XiPS^ [P _PacT aT[PcXeP P[ ^QYTc^ STYP]S^ PbT]cPSPb [Pb SXUXRd[cPSTb `dT VT]TaP] ]^RX^]Tb cP]
P\_[XPb R^\^ [P ST Sfb`O ^SbWbO
0cT]SXT]S^ P [P X]R^]VadT]RXP aTUTaXSP P [^b bdYTc^b 34 ;>B B0=C>B aTUXTaT P [P \Xb\P R^\^ ±X]R^]VadT]RXP
bdQYTcXeP² \P]XUTbcP]S^ `dT TgXbcT RdP]S^) °:O RSQWaW„\ Xc`WaRWQQW]\OZ Q]\RS\O O _cWS\Sa \] a]\ ^O`bS Xc\bO[S\bS
Q]\ _cW{\Sa a Z] a]\ W\Q]\U`cS\QWO acPXSbWdO ^]` SfQSa] c ]ZdWRO Q]\RS\O` O _cW{\ Q]``Sa^]\RS VOQS`Z] W\Q]\U`cS\QWO
#!
acPXSbWdO ^]` RSTSQb] ] Q]\RS\O c\O ^S`a]\O RWabW\bO RS ZO RS[O\RORO W\Q]\U`cS\QWO [WfbO ² BX\X[PaTb P_aTRXPRX^
]Tb aTP[XiP 6aTXU `dT X]SXRP) ±;P bT]cT]RXP WP ST P[RP]iPa P `dXT]Tb cdeXTa^] [P RP[XSPS ST PRc^aTb Pb€ R^\^
[^b ST\P]SPS^b 4[[^ X]R[dhT P [^b cTaRTa^b h P [^b RPb^b ST bdRTbX ] ^ bdbcXcdRX ]

#"
:O aS\bS\QWO VO RS aS` ^`SQWaO S\ ZO WRS\bWTWQOQW„\ RS Z]a acXSb]a OZQO\hOR]a ²
ETbR^eX _[P]cTP [P X]cTaTbP]cT RdTbcX ] ST [P _^bXQX[XSPS ST aT[TePa ST ^UXRX^ [P UP[cP ST [TVXcX\PRX ] ^
X]cTa|b ST [P _PacT h bX T] RPb^ ST WPRTa[^ SXRWP bT]cT]RXP bTau ^ ]^ X]R^]VadT]cT 0[ aTb_TRc^ RXcP [P _^bcdaP
ST <X[[u] `dT R^]bXSTaP `dT [P RP_PRXSPS _PaP bTa _PacT ^ [P PdbT]RXP ST RP_PRXSPS _a^RTbP[ bT T]RdT]caP]
ST]ca^ ST[ _^STa ST SXb_^bXRX ] ST [^b [XcXVP]cTb h `dT _^a T]ST b^[P\T]cT _^Sau] bTa SXb_dTbcP RdP]S^
\TSXP [P X]bcP]RXP ST _PacTb
CP\QX|] RXcP [P _^bcdaP ST 3TeXb 4RWP]S€P `dT T]cXT]ST `dT [P UP[cP ST [TVXcX\PRX ] RPdbP[ P[ XVdP[ `dT
[P UP[cP ST X]cTa|b T] [P RPdbP ^QbcP] P [P STRXbX ] b^QaT T[ \|aXc^ h STQT] bTa aT[TePSPb ST ^UXRX^
0]cT [Pb SXbhd]cXePb S^RcaX]PaXPb h T] PcT]RX ] P [^ SXb_dTbc^ T] T[ Pac€Rd[^ "" ST[ 26? b^QaT TgRT_RX^]Tb
_a^RTbP[Tb T[ Pdc^a eTa]uRd[^ bT X]R[X]P _^a T[ RPauRcTa ]^ cPgPcXe^ ST [Pb TgRT_RX^]Tb `dT _dTST] aT[TePabT
ST ^UXRX^ RXcP]S^ T[ RPb^ ST PdbT]RXP ST STcTa\X]PS^b _aTbd_dTbc^b `dT _dTST] WPRTabT eP[Ta ST ^UXRX^ BT
RXcP] d]P bTaXT ST UP[[^b `dT SP] PaVd\T]c^ P bd _^bcdaP Pb€ Tg_aTbP `dT d]P bT]cT]RXP ST _aX\TaP X]bcP]RXP
##
UdT aTe^RPSP T] [P P[iPSP P[ ]^ aT[TePa [P PdbT]RXP ST [TVXcX\PRX ] RPdbP[ _PbXeP

S 5^ BU\QSY†^ Q \Q 2PdbP ?TcT]SX

2^] UX]Tb PR[PaPc^aX^b _dTST STUX]XabT T] VaP]STb aPbV^b P [P QOcaO ^SbS\RW R^\^) °SZ []bWd] ZO `Oh„\ Z]a
OQOSQW[WS\b]a RS VSQV] _cS Tc\RO\ g RSZW[WbO\ ZO ^`SbS\aW„\ OZSUORO S\ XcWQW] SZ SabOR] RS VSQV] Q]\b`O`W] OZ SabOR] RS
"#
RS`SQV] _cS RO ZcUO` O ZO RS[O\RO g QcgO []RWTWQOQW„\ {abO ^S`aWUcS ±
3TQT PVaTVPabT `dT ]dTbca^ 26? Pac & ]aP[ # bT WP _[TVPS^ P [P °BS]`O RS ZO AcabO\QWOQW„\± [^ `dT
bTVŠ] E4B2>E8) °aWU\WTWQO _cS QORO ^`SbS\aW„\ RSPS ^`SaS\bO`aS Q]\ SZ `SZOb] RS Z]a VSQV]a VWab„`WQ]a _cS ZO acabS\bO\
g RS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa Xc`RWQOa _cS ^`SbS\RS\ Sfb`OS`aS RS Z]a [Wa[]a
<] POabO S\b]\QSa Q]\ c\O [S`O W\d]QOQW„\ US\{`WQO `Sa^SQb] RS Z] _cS aS ^`SbS\RS aW\] _cS S\ b]R]a Z]a QOa] RSPS\
"$
ORcQW`aS Z]a VSQV]a `SZSdO\bSa _cS RS\ acabS\b] O ZO OQQW„\ ] SfQS^QW„\ ^`]^cSabO ±
BTVŠ] [Pb PUXa\PRX^]Tb aTP[XiPSPb [P X]R^]VadT]RXP bT _aTbT]cT R^\^ [P X]STQXSP R^aaT[PRX ] T]caT [P RPdbP
ST _TSXa h [P bT]cT]RXP T] ^caPb _P[PQaPb [^b WTRW^b WXbc aXR^b R^] caPbRT]ST]RXP Yda€SXRP h [P aTb^[dRX ] `dT
aTRPT b^QaT [^b \Xb\^b B^] T]cTaP\T]cT R^\_PacXQ[Tb [Pb Tg_aTbX^]Tb ST ?0;028> aTc^\PSPb _^a E4B2>E8
`dT eTabP]) °ZO QOcaO ] Tc\RO[S\b] ] bbcZ] RS ZO ^`SbS\aW„\ Q]\aWabS S\ ZO W\d]QOQW„\ RS c\O Q]\Q`SbO aWbcOQW„\ RS
VSQV] O ZO QcOZ SZ OQb]` ZS OaWU\O RSbS`[W\ORO Q]\aSQcS\QWO Xc`RWQO¨ SZ XcSh RSPS RSQWRW` aW VO ]^S`OR] ] \] ZO Q]\aS
QcS\QWO Xc`RWQO OTW`[ORO ^]` SZ OQb]` `SacZbt\R]ZSa W\RWTS`S\bS ZO RSaWU\OQW„\ b{Q\WQO _cS VOgO aWR] OaWU\ORO ^]` ZO
"%
^O`bS ± 3TQT PR^cPabT `dT bT PQd]SPau \ub b^QaT Tbc^b R^]RT_c^b P[ P]P[XiPa [P aT[PRX ] T]caT T[ _aX]RX_X^
ST R^]VadT]RXP h T[ _aX]RX_X^ °Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO±
0 \^S^ b€]cTbXb RPQT PUXa\Pa `dT T[ YdTi ]^ bT T]RdT]caP [X\XcPS^ _^a [Pb RP[XUXRPRX^]Tb Yda€SXRPb ST [Pb
_PacTb _Ta^ bX _^a [P X]e^RPRX ] ST WTRW^b aTP[XiPS^b [^b `dT ]^ _^Sau] \dcPabT
4] TbcT ^aST] ST XSTPb bT _a^]d]RXP T[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb ST CaPQPY^ ! aTe^RP]S^ [P bT]cT]RXP ST
_aX\TaP X]bcP]RXP T] S^]ST bT ^c^aVPQP T[ STb_XS^ X]SXaTRc^ _^a d]P RPdbP[ SXbcX]cP P [P _aTcT]SXSP _^a T[
PRc^a \P]XUTbcP]S^ T[ CaXQd]P[ `dT) °aS VO TOZZOR] TcS`O RS Z] a]ZWQWbOR] gO _cS aS `SacSZdS SfQSRWS\R] Z]a Z[WbSa
"&
RSZ ]PXSb] g Tc\RO[S\b]a SaU`W[WR]a ^]` SZ OQb]` ±

#! 34 ;>B B0=C>B ±;P 5[TgXQX[XiPRX ] ST [P 2^]VadT]RXP² X]) 00 EE) F777 8]`\OROa <OQW]\OZSa RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ _uV
(
#" 6A485 ^_ RXc _uV !$%
## E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uVb (& ('
#$ 20BCA> A8E4A0 A4H4B >47=8=64A ±0[V^ \ub b^QaT [P 2^]VadT]RXP T] T[ 2 SXV^ 6T]TaP[ ST[ ?a^RTb^² @SdWabO
C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c ! ((( _uV !%
#% E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c 888 _uV #
#& E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV ((
#' BT]cT]RXP (& ((( C0C ! C >`Sh ` 3QVSdSabS Dth_cSh T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! 4S
52D 2Pb^ " $ _uV &&#