Page 758 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia
P. 758
R^]VadT]RXP T] [P _aX\TaP X]bcP]RXP bTau [P \TSXSP ST [P _aTcT]bX
] \XT]caPb `dT T] bTVd]SP X]bcP]RXP bT
%!
T]R^]caPau [X\XcPSP _^a [^b PVaPeX^b STSdRXS^b B^QaT T[ P[RP]RT ST [P P_T[PRX
] T] bTVd]SP X]bcP]RXP bT WP
_a^]d]RXPS^ [P Bd_aT\P 2^acT bTP[P]S^) °3abO 1]`^]`OQW\ VO a]abS\WR] _cS Oa Q][] VOg c\O Q]``Sa^]\RS\QWO
S\b`S ^`SbS\aW\ g RS[O\RO RSPS SfWabW` ZO [Wa[O `SZOQW\ S\b`S ZOa _cSXOa RSZ `SQc``S\bS ] aca OU`OdW]a g ZO RSQWaW\
RSZ `UO\] RS aSUc\RO W\abO\QWO RS [{`Wb] aSOZt\R]aS S\ A < "#% '" b`OaZORO\R] Sf^`SaW]\Sa RS ZO < "# '
_cS( ²3a SZ OU`OdW] ] SZ ^S`XcWQW] acT`WR] ^]` SZ ZWbWUO\bS g [O\WTSabOR] S\ ac `SQc``S\QWO SZ _cS RSbS`[W\O Z]a OZQO\QSa
RSQWa]`W]a RS ZO OZhORO gO _cS Q]\T]`[S OZ ^`W\QW^W] ²bO\bc[ RSd]Zcbc[ _cO\bc[ O^^SZObc[³ a]\ Z]a Q]\Q`Sb]a []bWd]a
RS OU`OdW] Z]a _cS RSZW[WbO\ SZ ^`]\c\QWO[WS\b] RSZ b`WPc\OZ RS ZO O^SZOQW\¨ ±
$!
S <QeT_ 1bRYdbQ\
0 \^S^ ST RXTaaT h T] R^]b^]P]RXP R^] [^ _[P]cTPS^ P[ X]XRX^ ST TbcT ]d\TaP[ bT PVaTVP [P TgXVT]RXP ST
R^]VadT]RXP T] [P aTb^[dRX
] ST[ _a^RTSX\XT]c^ PaQXcaP[ P[ aTb_TRc^ T[ PacRd[^ #(( h ST[ 26? aTVd[P R^\^
RPdbP[Tb ST ]d[XSPS ST[ [PdS^ PaQXcaP[ T[ WPQTabT Tg_TSXS^ b^QaT _d]c^b ]^ R^\_a^\TcXS^b ^ T[ ]^ Tg_TSXabT
%#
b^QaT _d]c^b R^\_a^\TcXS^b
E8 A4<438>B 0 ;0 8=2>=6AD4=280
2^] P]cTaX^aXSPS P STbPaa^[[Pa [^b aT\TSX^b P[ eXRX^ ST X]R^]VadT]RXP bT WPRT _aTRT_cXe^ Tg_TSXabT b^QaT
[P ]PcdaP[TiP ST[ Taa^a T] `dT X]RdaaT d]P bT]cT]RXP eXRXPSP ST X]R^]VadT]RXP 3TQTau STcTa\X]PabT bX [P
bT]cT]RXP X]R^]VadT]cT \P]XUXTbcP d] S``]` W\ ^`]QSRS\R] ^ d] S``]` W\ WcRWQO\R] ;P STcTa\X]PRX
] ST[ cX_^ ST
Taa^a T] YdTV^ QaX]SP [P b^[dRX
] `dT STQTau bTa PS^_cPSP
2>DCDA4 QaX]SP [Pb bXVdXT]cTb _PdcPb _PaP XST]cXUXRPa T[ S``]` W\ ^`]QSRS\R] SXRW^ Pdc^a bTP[P) °Q]\aWabS S\
ZO RSadWOQW\ ] O^O`bO[WS\b] RS Z]a [SRW]a aSOZOR]a ^]` SZ RS`SQV] ^`]QSaOZ ^O`O ac RW`SQQW\ RSZ XcWQW] >]` S``]` RS ZOa
^O`bSa ] ^]` S``]` ^`]^W] ^cSRS Q]\ SaS O^O`bO[WS\b] RWa[W\cW` ZOa UO`O\bOa RS Q]\b`ORWQb]`W] g ^`WdO` O ZOa ^O`bSa RS
c\O RSTS\aO ^ZS\O RS ac RS`SQV] 3abS S``]` Q][^`][SbS ZO T]`[O RS Z]a OQb]a ac Sab`cQbc`O SfbS`\O ac []R] \Obc`OZ RS
$#
`SOZWhO`aS ± B^QaT T[ Taa^a X] XdSXRP]S^ T[ X]bXV]T _a^RTbP[XbcP [^ aTUXTaT P[ R^]cT]XS^ ST[ _a^RTb^ SXRT) ±=^
bT caPcP hP ST [P U^a\P bX]^ ST[ U^]S^ ST[ STaTRW^ bdbcP]RXP[ `dT Tbcu T] YdTV^ T] |[ qbcT Taa^a R^]bXbcT ]^a
%%
\P[\T]cT T] P_[XRPa d]P [Th X]P_[XRPQ[T T] P_[XRPa \P[ [P [Th P_[XRPQ[T ^ T] ]^ P_[XRPa [P [Th P_[XRPQ[T ²
;P caPbRT]ST]RXP ST [P SXbcX]RX
] ST \PaaPb aPSXRP T] [P R^]bTRdT]RXP ST RPSP cX_^ ST Taa^a Pb T[ S``]` W\
WcRWQO\R] X\_[XRP d]P bT]cT]RXP X]YdbcP RdhP Tg_aTbX
] bTau T[ PVaPeX^ 4] RP\QX^ [P bT]cT]RXP eXRXPSP _^a
S``]` W\ ^`]QSRS\R] R^]bcXcdhT d]P RPdbP[ ST ]d[XSPS
%&
;P STR[PaPRX
] ST ]d[XSPS X\_[XRP T[ aTT]e^ P d] caXQd]P[ bdQa^VP]cT `dT R^]cX]dPau T[ _a^RTb^ P _PacXa
ST[ \^\T]c^ T] `dT bT SXRc
T[ PRc^ eXRXPS^ SPS^ `dT R^\^ R^]bTRdT]RXP ST [P ]d[XSPS RPT] c^S^b [^b PRc^b
%'
_^bcTaX^aTb `dT bTP] R^]bTRdT]RXP ST[ P]d[PS^ 0[ R^]caPaX^ T[ S``]` W\ WcRWQO\R] STcTa\X]Pau `dT T[ caXQd]P[
%(
ST P[iPSP bT _a^]d]RXT b^QaT T[ \|aXc^ ST[ Pbd]c^
;P ]d[XSPS Uadc^ ST d] S``]` W\ ^`]QSRS\R] PRaTSXcPau P[ aTRdab^ ST ]d[XSPS T] P`dT[[^b bXbcT\Pb `dT [^
aTVd[P] Tb_TRUXRP\T]cT T] ]dTbca^ ^aST]P\XT]c^ YdaSXR^ bT SXbRdcT [P eXVT]RXP ^ ]^ ST [P PRRX
] Pdc
]^\P
ST ]d[XSPS RdTbcX
] `dT TgRTST T[ cT\P ST TbcT caPQPY^ =^a\P[\T]cT [P ]d[XSPS bT PRaTSXcPau P caPe|b ST[
aTRdab^ ST P_T[PRX
] SPS^ T[ R^]cT]XS^ P\_[X^ ^c^aVPS^ P SXRW^ \TSX^ X\_dV]PcXe^ _^a T[ PacRd[^ !#( ST[
&
26? cP\QX|] _a^RTST [P RPbPRX
] RdP]S^ T[ Taa^a aTRPT T] d]P bT]cT]RXP ST bTVd]SP X]bcP]RXP
4[ Taa^a ST U^]S^ h T[ PVaPeX^ VT]TaPS^ _^a |bcT bT WPau eP[Ta \TSXP]cT [P P_T[PRX
] ^ [P RPbPRX
] bTV]
[P X]bcP]RXP T] `dT WPhP PRPTRXS^
&
%! E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV '$
%" BT]cT]RXP "# ! # ST [P Bd_aT\P 2^acT ST 9dbcXRXP T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! $ 4S 52D 2Pb^
!%$ _uV ('#
%# E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV '$
%$ 2>DCDA4 ^_ RXc _uV !'
%% 2>DCDA4 ^_ RXc _uV !'
%& 2>DCDA4 ^_ RXc _uV !'"
%' E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV %
%( E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV &
& E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV &
& E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV &
