Page 753 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia

4'8+56# &' &'4'%*1 &' .# 70+8'45+&#& &' /106'8+&'1
#

BT WP T]cT]SXS^ `dT Tb X]R^]VadT]cT _^a cZb`O ^SbWbO [P bT]cT]RXP ST BTVd]SP 8]bcP]RXP `dT STQ€P aTb^[eTa
b^QaT [P R^\_TcT]RXP R^aaTb_^]SXT]cT RXeX[ ^ [PQ^aP[ `dT bT _a^]d]RX b^QaT T[ \|aXc^ ST [P RdTbcX ] P[
!&
aTb_TRc^ bT„P[ [P 2^acT `dT cP[ _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^ ed[]TaP T[ STQXS^ _a^RTb^
D]^ ST [^b \Š[cX_[Tb TYT\_[^b aTR^VXS^b _^a [P S^RcaX]P Tb [P R^]ST]PRX ] P X]cTaTbTb RdP]S^ ]^ WP] bXS^
b^[XRXcPS^b _^a [Pb _PacTb T] TbT bT]cXS^ T[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb T] [^ 2XeX[ & aTe^R d]P bT]cT]RXP T] [P
RdP[ bT b^[XRXcPQP [P PRcdP[XiPRX ] ST X]cTaTbTb bX] X]e^RPa bd \^]c^ _^a [^ RdP[ aTV€P [P PRcdP[XiPRX ] [TVP[
!'
`dT ]^ UdT cT]XSP T] RdT]cP _^a T[ O _c] `dT R^]ST] P d]P cPbP \Ph^a
ETbR^eX aTR^VT d]P bTaXT ST TYT\_[^b ST bXcdPRX^]Tb PRPTRXSPb T] [P YdaXb_adST]RXP Pb€ Tb `dT WPQau cZb`O
^SbWbO RdP]S^ bT R^]ST]P P[ aTPYdbcT aTR[P\PS^ _Ta^ STbST d]P UTRWP P]cTaX^a P [P _[P]cTPSP T] [P ST\P]SP*
RdP]S^ bT TgXVT STcTa\X]PSP d]XSPS \^]TcPaXP h bT R^]ST]P P _PVPa T] ^caP* RdP]S^ bT X\_dcP P [^ aTR[P\PS^
adQa^b PQ^]PS^b _^a d]P _PacT P [P ^caP bX] `dT T[[^ WPhP bXS^ P[TVPS^ ^ _a^QPS^ CP\QX|] bT X]R[dhT T] T[
T[T]R^ ST aTb^[dRX^]Tb X]R^]VadT]cTb [Pb `dT bT _a^]d]RXP] b^QaT TgRT_RX^]Tb `dT ]^ _dTST] bTa T[TePSPb
!(
ST ^UXRX^ R^\^ _^a TYT\_[^ [P _aTbRaX_RX ]
3XRW^ Pdc^a cP\QX|] aTbT„P d]P bTaXT ST RPb^b T] [^b `dT ]^ Tb _TacX]T]cT T[ PVaPeX^ ST X]R^]VadT]RXP
_^a TYT\_[^ [P PS\XbX ] ST d]P _aTcT]bX ] ^ ST d]P TgRT_RX ] P[TVPSP _Ta^ `dT ]^ WP bXS^ STQXSP\T]cT
_a^QPSP SPau [dVPa P d]P bT]cT]RXP X]YdbcP ^ X[TVP[ _Ta^ ]^ X]R^]VadT]cT BX\X[Pa bXcdPRX ] bT _[P]cTP R^] [^b
Taa^aTb ]d\|aXR^b ^ \PcT\ucXR^b ST [P bT]cT]RXP `dT _^Sau] bTa aT[TePS^b ST ^UXRX^ _^a caXQd]P[ OR _cS[
!
0 \^S^ ST RXTaaT T] [^ `dT aTUXTaT P [P cZb`O ^SbWbO RdP]cXcPcXeP RPQT PR^cPa `dT |bcP bT R^]UXVdaP RdP]S^
T[ YdiVPS^a R^]RTST \ub ST [^ aT`dTaXS^ T] [P _aTcT]bX ] UXVdaP]S^ T] T[ u\QXc^ ST bd SXbRaTRX^]P[XSPS
[P _^bXQX[XSPS ^c^aVPa \T]^b ST [^ b^[XRXcPS^ 3XRW^ T]cT]SX\XT]c^ Tb PQ^]PS^ T] \Š[cX_[Tb bT]cT]RXPb P[
aTb_TRc^ bT _a^]d]RX T[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb T] [^ 2XeX[ Tg_aTbP]S^ `dT) °:Oa QO\bWRORSa ^SbWQW]\OROa
^]` ZO ^O`bS OQQW]\O\bS \] bWS\S\ ^]`_cS Q]\abWbcW` ZO POaS RSZ QtZQcZ] RSZ ^]`QS\bOXS ]PXSb] RS Q]\RS\O ^]`_cS SZZ]
ac^]\R`O c\ OQ]UW[WS\b] W\ b]bc[ RS Z] RS[O\ROR] :Oa ac[Oa SabOPZSQWROa ^]` ]b`O ^O`bS Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS ZO `STS`WRO
OZ ROƒ] []`OZ a]\ ^]` SaS\QWO SabW[ObWdO S W\bSU`O\ SZ [O`US\ RS RWaQ`SQW]\OZWROR RSZ XchUOR]` acXSb] O ZO dOZ]`OQW„\
!
RSPWRO O ZO Zch RS ZOa ^`]PO\hOa RS Ocb]a g RS[ta `SacZbO\QWOa RS 2S`SQV] ± 4[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb ST 5P\X[XP
]TV [P TgXbcT]RXP ST X]R^]VadT]RXP P]cT d]P b^[XRXcdS ST RTbT ST d]P _T]bX ] P[X\T]cXRXP `dT UdT aTbdT[cP
T] _aX\TaP X]bcP]RXP SXb_^]XT]S^ [P aTSdRRX ] ST [P \Xb\P T[ CaXQd]P[ Ud]SP\T]cP bd STRXbX ] P[TVP]S^
`dT SXRWP aTb^[dRX ] bT caPcP ST d] °U`OR] [S\]` RS ZO [Wa[O ^`SbS\aW„\ ±
!
Q " 9^S_^WbeU^SYQ `_b 4gcaP ?TcXcP

ATbcP P]P[XiPa [P X]R^]VadT]RXP _^a Sfb`O ^SbWbO `dT VT]|aXRP\T]cT Tb STUX]XSP P_T[P]S^ P [P bT]cT]RXP `dT
R^]RTST P[V^ SXbcX]c^ P [^ _TSXS^ T] c|a\X]^b VT]TaP[Tb Tg_aTbP 10AA48A> `dT WPh TbcT cX_^ ST X]R^]VadT]RXP
RdP]S^ [P bT]cT]RXP bT _a^]d]RXP °acabWbcgS\R] ZO ^`SbS\aW„\ RSZ OQb]` ^]` ]b`O gO aSO Q]\QSRWS\R] OZU] RWabW\b] O
Z] ^SRWR] ] Q]\QSRWS\R] OZU] ORWQW]\OZ ² 4[ P]u[XbXb ST [P STUX]XRX ] P]^cPSP aT`dXTaT T[ aTR^]^RX\XT]c^ ST [Pb
""
SXUXRd[cPSTb `dT X\_[XRP [P ]^RX ] P TbcdSX^ hP `dT |bcP Tb ST cP[ P\_[XcdS `dT _auRcXRP\T]cT PQPaRP [P ]^RX ]
\Xb\P ST X]R^]VadT]RXP Pb€ Tb `dT RdTbcP _aTRXbPa [^b [€\XcTb T]caT [^b SXbcX]c^b cX_^b ST X]R^]VadT]RXP =^
^QbcP]cT ]^ STQT STYPa ST PSeTacXabT `dT ]^b T]R^]caP\^b P]cT _[P]cT^b S^RcaX]PaX^b [^b RdP[Tb cXT]ST] P
RaTPa RaXcTaX^b ^aXT]cPS^aTb ST]ca^ ST d]P \Xb\P RPcTV^a€P `dT Tb [P X]R^]VadT]RXP 0ST\ub P _TbPa ST [Pb
R^]UdbX^]Tb `dT _dTST] _[P]cTPabT T[ aTRXQ^ ST SXRW^ _[P]cT^ T] [^b P]P[Tb YdaXb_adST]RXP[Tb X\_^]T bd
TbcdSX^
0R^aST R^] [^ SXRW^ h T] R^]b^]P]RXP R^] T[ _[P]cT^ ST 10AA48A> bT _a^]d]RXP E4B2>E8 P]P[XiP]S^ [Pb
SXeTabPb _^bXQX[XSPSTb T] [Pb `dT _dTST _[P]cTPabT [P X]R^]VadT]RXP _^a Sfb`O ^SbWbO bT„P[P) [P bdbcXcdRX ]
ST d]P _aTcT]bX ] ST[ PRc^a _^a ^caP* RdP]S^ PST\ub ST [^ _aTcT]SXS^ bT R^]RTST P[V^ PSXRX^]P[* RdP]S^ bT

2Pb^ !"$ _uV (&%
!& BT]cT]RXP !&" ! # ST [P Bd_aT\P 2^acT ST 9dbcXRXP T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! $ 4S 52D 2Pb^
!%% _uV ('$
!' BT]cT]RXP ## ! $ C02 & C 1]cb] ` 0SZZ] :„^Sh T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c ! ! % 4S 52D 2Pb^
"% _uVb #!' #!(
!( E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV (
" E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV (
" BT]cT]RXP ## ! $ C02 C 1OTOaa] ` 5cbW{``Sh >O`UO T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! 4S 52D
2Pb^ _uV %' 4] bX\X[Pa bT]cXS^) BT]cT]RXP ! " ! & C02 & C 1]cb] ` :„^Sh CPSRO 0SZZ] T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS
2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c ! $ 4S 52D 2Pb^ ( " _uV !(!
"! BT]cT]RXP $ ! C05 C ;]\aS``Ob ` ;O`b\Sh AWZdS`[O\\ 0ObbWabSZZO R T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ
c # ! 4S 52D 2Pb^ & _uV %'!
"" 10AA48A> ^_ RXc _uV $(