Page 751 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia

4'8+56# &' &'4'%*1 &' .# 70+8'45+&#& &' /106'8+&'1

;P R^\_aT]bX ] ST[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP aT`dXTaT ]TRTbPaXP\T]cT ST [P R^\_PaPRX ] h [P STQXSP
Pa\^]€P T]caT [^b PRc^b ST [Pb _PacTb h [P bT]cT]RXP Rdh^ aTbd[cPS^ STcTa\X]Pau `dT TbcP Š[cX\P P_PaTiRP
R^\^ YdbcXUXRPSP ^ RPdbPSP
%
888 5D=30<4=C>B

4[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP _dTST YdbcXUXRPabT aTRdaaXT]S^ P SXeTab^b _aX]RX_X^b `dT X]U^a\P] T[ _a^RTb^
RXeX[
<Ph^aXcPaXP\T]cT bT [P Tg_[XRP P_T[P]S^ P[ _aX]RX_X^ SXb_^bXcXe^ 4bcT Š[cX\^ T]RPQTiP T[ PacXRd[PS^ ST
]dTbca^ 26? h _dTST STUX]XabT bXVdXT]S^ [Pb ^aXT]cPRX^]Tb c^\PSPb _^a E4B2>E8 R^\^) °SZ aSƒ]`] WZW[WbOR]
RS ZOa ^O`bSa bO\b] RSZ RS`SQV] acabO\QWOZ []bWd] RSZ ^`]QSa] ZWbWUW]a] Q][] a]P`S b]R]a Z]a Oa^SQb]a dW\QcZOR]a Q]\ ZO
W\WQWOQW„\ [O`QVO g QcZ[W\OQW„\ RS {abS ² 4] R^]b^]P]RXP R^] [^ Tg_aTbPS^ [^b [€\XcTb ST [P STRXbX ] WP] ST
&
T]RdPSaPabT T] [Pb _aTcT]bX^]Tb STSdRXSPb _^a [Pb _PacTb' 0 [^ `dT PVaTVP 3T 7TVTSdb [P XST]cXSPS T]caT
(
[P R^]VadT]RXP h [P ]PcdaP[TiP Yda€SXR^ SXb_^]XQ[T ST[ STaTRW^ T] YdXRX^
=^ ^QbcP]cT Tb PRT_cPSP [P R^]RdaaT]RXP ST d]P bTaXT ST _aX]RX_X^b `dT X]U^a\P] [P R^]VadT]RXP 4] TbcT
^aST] ST XSTPb 34E8B 4270=3Ä0 \P]XUXTbcP) °aS ZWUO \bW[O[S\bS Q]\ SZ RS`SQV] Q]\abWbcQW]\OZ RS RSTS\aO gO _cS {abS
SfWUS _cS SZ OXcabWQWOR] S\ QcOZ_cWS` QZOaS RS ^`]QSa] Q]\]hQO ZOa ^`SbS\aW]\Sa ] W[^cbOQW]\Sa _cS Q]\b`O {Z ] T`S\bS O {Z

aS VO\ T]`[cZOR] ^]` Z] _cS ZO dW]ZOQW„\ RS ZO Q]\U`cS\QWO W[^ZWQO ZO RS O_c{Z RS`SQV]¨ ± 3T [^ SXRW^ bT X]UXTaT
[P aPXVP\QaT R^]bcXcdRX^]P[ ST[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP T\P]P]S^ hP bTP ST[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]caPSXRRX ]
^ QX[PcTaP[XSPS ^ ST[ STQXS^ _a^RTb^

CP\QX|] P[Vd]^b Pdc^aTb WP] YdbcXUXRPS^ [P R^]VadT]RXP Tb_TRXP[\T]cT aTUXaX|]S^bT P [^b RPb^b T] `dT
T[ YdTi ^\XcT _a^]d]RXPabT b^QaT P[Vd]^b _d]c^b _[P]cTPS^b R^\^ d]P \P]XUTbcPRX ] ST [^b STQTaTb X]WT
!
aT]cTb P [P PRcXeXSPS YdaXbSXRRX^]P[ 4] SXRW^ ^aST] ST XSTPb E4B2>E8 Yd]c^ P bdb R^[PQ^aPS^aTb aTR^VT] T[
_T]bP\XT]c^ ST[ hP RXcPS^ 34E8B 4270=3Ä0 `dT bT \P]XUXTbcP b^QaT [P aT[PRX ] TgXbcT]cT T]caT [P R^]VadT]RXP
h [P YdaXbSXRRX ] R^\^ STaTRW^ STQTa ST[ 4bcPS^ bXT]S^ [P _aX\TaP d]P R^]bTRdT]RXP [ VXRP ST [P aT[PRX ]
STaTRW^ STQTa `dT bdaVT R^] [^b STaTRW^b ST PRRX ] h R^]caPSXRRX ] `dT _^]T] T] \^eX\XT]c^ T[ _a^RTb^
h ^Q[XVP] P[ TbcPS^ P UP[[Pa PR^aST R^] [Pb _aTcT]bX^]Tb h TgRT_RX^]P\XT]c^b `dT \P]XUXTbcP] T[ TYTaRXRX^ ST
"
[^b \T]RX^]PS^b STaTRW^b
34 74643DB PVaTVP R^\^ Ud]SP\T]c^ P [P R^]VadT]RXP [P ]TRTbXSPS ST TeXcPa PaQXcaPaXTSPSTb h TgRTb^b
#
_^a _PacT ST [^b caXQd]P[Tb [^ `dT aTbd[cP ST \PaRPa [€\XcTb P bdb STRXbX^]Tb
?^a Š[cX\^ b^] T]cTaP\T]cT R^\_PacXQ[Tb [Pb R^]R[dbX^]Tb P [Pb `dT PaaXQP] E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B
`dT Tg_aTbP]) °¨SZ ^`W\QW^W] RS Q]\U`cS\QWO Sa RS POaS Q]\abWbcQW]\OZ Q]\TWUc`O c\O O^ZWQOQW„\ RW`SQbO RSZ ^`W\QW^W]
RWa^]aWbWd] g O ZO dSh Q]\abWbcgS c\O RS ZOa UO`O\bOa RSZ RSPWR] ^`]QSa] S\ ZO [SRWRO S\ _cS aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ SZ Z[WbS
_cS aS ZS W[^]\S O ZO XcRWQObc`O RS \] W\b`]RcQW` QcSabW]\Sa RS VSQV] `Sa^SQb] RS ZOa QcOZSa ZOa ^O`bSa \] VOgO\ ^]RWR]
SXS`QS` ac ^ZS\O g ]^]`bc\O RSTS\aO ±
#
8E C8?>B

0 R^]cX]dPRX ] bT P]P[XiPau] [Pb SXbcX]cPb U^a\Pb T] `dT _dTST \P]XUTbcPabT T[ eXRX^ ST X]R^]VadT]RXP
BXT]S^ [P X]R^]VadT]RXP QubXRP\T]cT [P UP[cP ST PSTRdPRX ] T]caT [P _aTcT]bX ] h [P bT]cT]RXP T[ P]u[XbXb _Pa
cXau ST[ T]U^`dT ST [^b T[T\T]c^b R^]UXVdaPcXe^b ST [P _aTcT]bX ] h [P X]RXST]RXP ST[ eXRX^ ST X]R^]VadT]RXP
T] [^b \Xb\^b
%
8ST]cXUXRP] [P _aTcT]bX ] caTb T[T\T]c^b) T[ ^QYTc^ [^b bdYTc^b h [P RPdbP 4] T[ bT]cXS^ ST [^ P]cTaX^a Tb
RPcTV aXR^ T[ _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^ ST ?P[PRX^ `dT bT _a^]d]RXP T] [^b bXVdXT]cTb c|a\X]^b) °¨ZO ]PaS`dO\QWO RSZ

% E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B 1„RWU] 5S\S`OZ RSZ >`]QSa] 1][S\bOR] O\]bOR] g Q]\Q]`ROR] c E8 _uV &'
& E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B 1„RWU] 5S\S`OZ RSZ >`]QSa] 1][S\bOR] O\]bOR] g Q]\Q]`ROR] c 8 _uV $%
' E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c 8 _uV %#
( 34 74643DB ±4[ ?aX]RX_X^ ST 2^]VadT]RXP h T[ ?aX]RX_X^ 8daP =^eXc 2daXP Bd 2^]RX[XPRX ]² X]) 00 EE) 3abcRW]a RS
2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ S\ 6][S\OXS O 5SZaW 0WRO`b _uV $ '
34E8B 4270=3Ä0 ^_ RXc _uV $
34 74643DB ^_ RXc _uV $ '
! E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV '!
" E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV '"
# 34 74643DB ^_ RXc _uV $ '
$ E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV '#
% E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c 888 _uV #' h bb