Page 750 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia

@B9>39@9? 45 3?>7BE5>391 5> <?C

@B?35C?C 39F9<5C

;/F7;7:7/<= 1/: :/557/@2

8 8=CA>3D228È=

4]bT„P 64;B8 1830AC `dT( °SZ ^`W\QW^W] RS Q]\U`cS\QWO bWS\S W[^]`bO\QWO Tc\RO[S\bOZ aW aS ZS S\QO`O RSaRS SZ ^c\b]
RS dWabO RS ZO Q]\QS^QW„\ g UO`O\bO RSZ aWabS[O Xc`RWQ]± 8]\TSXPcP\T]cT PVaTVP) °3\ SZ ^ZO\] ^`]QSaOZ W\d]ZcQ`O
bS[Oa bOZSa Q][] SZ RS ZO \Obc`OZShO ] Q]\aWabS\QWO RSZ ^`]QSa] RS ZO OQQW„\ g RS ZO Xc`WaRWQQW„\ RS ZO aWbcOQW„\ SfWabS\QWOZ
RSZ 8cSh g RS ZOa >O`bSa S\ SZ ^`]QSa] ²

;Pb _P[PQaPb ST[ X[dbcaT _a^RTbP[XbcP X]SXRP] [P caPbRT]ST]RXP ST [P RdTbcX ] P TbcdSXPa P [P eTi `dT [^b
\Š[cX_[Tb T]U^`dTb `dT _dTST] _[P]cTPabT
4[ _aTbT]cT caPQPY^ _PacT ST [P ]^RX ] ST R^]VadT]RXP _PaP [^ `dT bT aTRdaaXau P [^b X\_^acP]cTb P_^acTb
cP]c^ ST S^RcaX]P ]PRX^]P[ R^\^ X]cTa]PRX^]P[ Pb€ R^\^ [Pb QPbTb ]^a\PcXePb ST[ _aX]RX_X^
3T[X\XcPSP [P ]^RX ] ST R^]VadT]RXP bT P]P[XiPau] [^b Ud]SP\T]c^b ST[ _aX]RX_X^
4[ _[P]cT^ R^]cX]ŠP R^] d] _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^ b^QaT [P STUXRXT]RXP T] [P R^]VadT]RXP Tg_XSX|]S^bT b^QaT
[Pb SXeTabPb \P]XUTbcPRX^]Tb ST[ eXRX^ ST X]R^]VadT]RXP T] [^b T[T\T]c^b Ud]SP]cTb ST [P _aTcT]bX ] ^QYTc^
bdYTc^b h RPdbP
2^aaTb_^]ST cP\QX|] _a^]d]RXPabT b^QaT [Pb \P]XUTbcPRX^]Tb ST [P R^]VadT]RXP T] [^b SXeTab^b PRc^b h
TcP_Pb _a^RTbP[Tb X]SXRP]S^ [P X]RXST]RXP `dT cXT]T T[ _aX]RX_X^ STbST [^b bX\_[Tb PRc^b ST X\_d[b^ _a^RTbP[
_PbP]S^ _^a [P UXYPRX ] ST[ ^QYTc^ _a^RTbP[ [P bT]cT]RXP [P P_T[PRX ] h [P RPbPRX ]
BT T]RPaPau] [^b aT\TSX^b P [P X]R^]VadT]RXP _a^]d]RXu]S^bT b^QaT T[ cX_^ ST Taa^a T] `dT X]RdaaT d]P
bT]cT]RXP `dT R^]cT]VP cP[ STUTRc^
?^a Š[cX\^ bT X]eTbcXVPau b^QaT [P eX]Rd[PRX ] ST [P R^]VadT]RXP R^] ^ca^b _aX]RX_X^b Tb_TRXP[\T]cT T[
_aX]RX_X^ Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO CP\QX|] b^QaT [Pb cT]ST]RXPb S^RcaX]PaXPb `dT bT \P]XUXTbcP] b^QaT [P U[TgXQX[XiPRX ]
ST[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP

88 =>28È=

;P ]^RX ] ST 2^]VadT]RXP ]^ STb_XTacP \Ph^aTb SXbRaT_P]RXPb S^RcaX]PaXPb 0[ aTb_TRc^ bT _a^]d]RXP 34E8B
4270=3Ä0 `dT STUX]T P [P 2^]VadT]RXP R^\^) °3Z ^`W\QW^W] \]`[ObWd] _cS SfWUS ZO WRS\bWROR Xc`RWQO S\b`S Z] `SacSZb]
S\ QcOZ_cWS` aS\bWR] ^]` SZ 8cSh S\ ZO aS\bS\QWO g ZOa ^`SbS\aW]\Sa g SfQS^QW]\Sa ^ZO\bSOROa ^]` ZOa ^O`bSa¨ ²
!
CPaXV^ TbcdSXP [P R^]VadT]RXP ST]ca^ ST [^b aT`dXbXc^b U^a\P[Tb ST [P bT]cT]RXP T]cT]SXT]S^ P [P \Xb\P
R^\^ [P R^aaTb_^]ST]RXP T]caT [P _aTcT]bX ] h [P bT]cT]RXP 4[ Pdc^a eTa]uRd[^ R^\_[T\T]cP bd T]cT]SX\XT]c^
caPbRaXQXT]S^ T[ _T]bP\XT]c^ ST 6dPb_ `dT aTUXTaT P [P 2^]VadT]RXP R^\^) °¨c\O `SZOQW„\ S\b`S R]a b{`[W\]a(
c\] RS Z]a QcOZSa Sa ZO aS\bS\QWO [Wa[O g [ta Q]\Q`SbO[S\bS ac TOZZ] ] ^O`bS RWa^]aWbWdO g ]b`] SZ ]PXSb] ^`]QSaOZ S\ aS\bWR]
`WUc`]a]) \] ^]` Z] bO\b] ZO RS[O\RO \W ZOa QcSabW]\Sa \W SZ RSPObS \W ZOa OZSUOQW]\Sa g ZOa ^`cSPOa aW\] ZO ^`SbS\aW„\
^`]QSaOZ g ZO ]^]aWQW„\ O ZO [Wa[O S\ QcO\b] ZO RSZW[WbO ] OQ]bO bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO b]R]a Z]a SZS[S\b]a W\RWdWRcOZWhO\bSa
RS bOZ ]PXSb]( Z]a acXSb]a _cS S\ {Z TWUc`O\ ZO [ObS`WO a]P`S _cS `SQOS g SZ bbcZ] _cS Xc`RWQO[S\bS Z] ^S`TWZO ±
!
10AA8>B 34 0=64;8B aTUXTaT P [P \Xb\P R^\^ [P R^]U^a\XSPS TgXbcT]cT T]caT T[ ^QYTc^ ST[ _a^RTb^ h [P
bT]cT]RXP `dT bT _a^]d]RXP b^QaT T[ \Xb\^
#
=dTbca^ ^aST]P\XT]c^ Yda€SXR^ bT R^]SXRT R^] [Pb STUX]XRX^]Tb ST \PaaPb Tb_TRXP[\T]cT R^] [^ SXb_dTbc^
_^a T[ Pac€Rd[^ (' ST[ 26? `dT QPY^ T[ \][S\ Wc`Wa ST °1]\bS\WR] RS ZO AS\bS\QWO± aTiP) °:Oa aS\bS\QWOa Q]\bS\
R`t\ RSQWaW]\Sa Sf^`SaOa ^]aWbWdOa g ^`SQWaOa @SQOS`t\ a]P`S ZOa Q]aOa ZWbWUOROa Q]\ O``SUZ] O ZOa ^`SbS\aW]\Sa RSRcQW
ROa RSQZO`O`t\ SZ RS`SQV] RS Z]a ZWbWUO\bSa g aS ^`]\c\QWO`t\ a]P`S ZOa Q]\RS\OQW]\Sa S\ Q]abOa g Q]ab]a± 4[ bTVd]S^
T]d]RXPS^ ST[ Pac€Rd[^ bT„P[P R[PaP\T]cT T[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP Tb STRXa T[ _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^ [X\XcPS^ P
$
[Pb °^`SbS\aW]\Sa RSRcQWROa± cP[ R^\^ T]bT„P E4B2>E8 [P R^aaTb_^]ST]RXP T]caT [P _aTcT]bX ] h [P bT]cT]RXP
64;B8 1830AC ±4[ ?aX]RX_X^ ST 2^]VadT]RXP T] c^S^ ?a^RTb^² @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ (' _uV !#
! 34E8B 4270=3Ä0 BS]`O 5S\S`OZ RSZ ^`]QSa] c _uV #(
" C0A86> :SQQW]\Sa RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ 1WdWZ c ! _uV '%
# 10AA8> 34 0=64;8B 7\b`]RcQQW„\ OZ >`]QSa] _uV "$
$ E4B2>E8 3Z @SQc`a] RS 1OaOQW„\ _uV (!