Page 752 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia
P. 752
^`W\QW^W] RS Q]\U`cS\QWO SfWUS c\O `WUc`]aO ORSQcOQW\ RS ZO aS\bS\QWO O Z]a acXSb]a SZ ]PXSb] g ZO QOcaO _cS W\RWdWRcO
ZWhO\ O ZO ^`SbS\aW\ g ZO ]^]aWQW\ %±
Q 5^ BU\QSY^ Q\ ?RZUd_
;^b aT_Tac^aX^b YdaXb_adST]RXP[Tb h caPQPY^b S^RcaX]PaX^b \ub TgcT]b^b bT RT]caP] T] T[ ^QYTc^ `dT bd
RX]cP\T]cT _dTST bTa STUX]XS^ R^\^ T[ _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^ `dT bT b^[XRXcP P[ YdTi ^QYTc^ X]\TSXPc^ h T[ QXT]
R^a_^aP[ ^ X]R^a_^aP[ \dTQ[T ^ X]\dTQ[T b^QaT T[ `dT aTRPT SXRW^ _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^ bTV] Tg_[XRPRX^]Tb
'
aTP[XiPSPb _^a C48C4;10D< h aTR^VXSPb _^a E4B2>E8
(
;P X]R^]VadT]RXP aTb_TRc^ P[ ^QYTc^ Tg_aTbP 1PaaTXa^ bXVdXT]S^ P 6dPb_ bT \P]XUXTbcP T] caTb \^SP
[XSPSTb bTau _^bXcXeP RdP]S^ bT UP[[T b^QaT \ub ST [^ _aTeXbc^ ]TVPcXeP RdP]S^ bT _a^]d]RXT b^QaT \T]^b
ST [^ aT`dTaXS^ h \XgcP RdP]S^ bT _a^]d]RXP b^QaT P[V^ SXbcX]c^ ST [^ _TSXS^
0QP[ >[X SXbcX]VdT bTV] [P X]R^]VadT]RXP aTb_^]SP P[ aT`dTaX\XT]c^ ^ P [^b WTRW^b `dT U^a\P] _PacT
ST[ ^QYTc^ ^ aTUTaXSP P[ STaTRW^ 0 bd eTi T] [P X]R^]VadT]RXP aT[PcXeP P[ aT`dTaX\XT]c^ ^ P [^b WTRW^b _^Sau
bTa _^a TgRTb^ ^ aTbcaXRRX
] 4] RP\QX^ [P X]R^]VadT]RXP aTUTaT]cT P[ STaTRW^ b
[^ _dTST bTa _^a aTbcaXRRX
]
hP `dT T[ caXQd]P[ SXb_^]T ST c^S^ T[ STaTRW^ ^QYTcXe^ _PaP Ud]SPa bd UP[[^ [^ `dT bT P]P[XiPau _^bcTaX^a\T]cT
P[ aTUTaXa T[ _aX]RX_X^ XdaP ]^eXc RdaXP 2^\^ TYT\_[^ ST TbcP [cX\P U^a\P ST X]R^]VadT]RXP T[ S^RcaX]^ RXcP
!
T[ RPb^ T] `dT T[ YdTi UP[[P bTV] T`dXSPS ]^ TbcP]S^ WPQX[XcPS^ P T[[^ _^a [Pb _PacTb
E4B2>E8 caP]bRaXQT d]P R[PbXUXRPRX
] TbQ^iPS^ _^a [P S^RcaX]P Tb_P^[P `dT _PacT ST [P SXbcX]RX
] T]caT
X]R^]VadT]RXP RdP]cXcPcXeP aTUTaXSP P[ ^QYTc^ h RdP[XcPcXeP aTUTaXSP P [Pb _aTcT]bX^]Tb 3T PRdTaS^ P [P
R^\QX]PRX
] ST cP[Tb RaXcTaX^b WPQau X]R^]VadT]RXP) RdP]S^ bT R^]RTST d] ]\Ta^ \Ph^a ST R^bPb `dT [Pb
aTR[P\PSPb T] RdP]c^ P [^b R^bPb * RdP]S^ [P X]R^]VadT]RXP ]^ Tb d]XcPaXP bX]^ `dT aTUXTaT P [Pb \[cX_[Tb
_aTcT]bX^]Tb STSdRXSPb T] RdP]c^ P [^b RPb^b _^a [cX\^ RdP]S^ [P X]R^]VadT]RXP aTbdT[eT SXbcX]c^ P [^
b^[XRXcPS^ _^a [Pb _PacTb T] RdP]c^ P[ \^S^ ;P [cX\P \^SP[XSPS PQPaRP [P ePaXPRX
] T] [P RPdbP ST _TSXa
^ \TSX^b ST STUT]bP
!
=^ ^QbcP]cT [Pb R[PbXUXRPRX^]Tb S^RcaX]PaXPb _[P]cTPSPb T[ RaXcTaX^ caPSXRX^]P[ PR^VXS^ _^a [P YdaXb_ad
ST]RXP _PacT ST [^b [PcX]PiV^b) \S SOb WcRSf cZb`O ^SbWbO ^O`bWc[ RdP]S^ bT R^]RTST \ub ST [^ _TSXS^ \S SOb
WcRSf Sfb`O ^SbWbO ^O`bWc[ RdP]S^ bT R^]RTST P[V^ SXbcX]c^ \S SOb WcRSf QWb`O ^SbWbO ^O`bWc[ WPh ^\XbX^]Tb T]
!!
T[ _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^
Q ! 9^S_^WbeU^SYQ `_b D[caP ?TcXcP
;P X]R^]VadT]RXP _^a cZb`O ^SbWbO R^]bXbcT T] [P SXbc^abX
] T]caT [^ _TSXS^ _^a [Pb _PacTb hP bTP T] [P ST
\P]SP ^ T] [P STUT]bP h [^ ^c^aVPS^ T] T[ SXb_^bXcXe^ ST[ UP[[^ 0ST\ub [P cZb`O ^SbWbO bTau RdP]cXcPcXeP _^a
TYT\_[^ P[ R^]RTSTabT \ub SX]Ta^ ST[ _TSXS^ ^ RdP[XcPcXeP aT`dXaX|]S^bT [P aTbRXbX
] ST[ R^]caPc^ PST\ub
ST P`d|[[P bT R^]ST]P T[ _PV^ d]P \d[cP B^QaT TbcP [cX\P SXbcX]RX
] ETbR^eX bXVdXT]S^ T[ aPi^]P\XT]c^
!"
ST <X[[u] R^]R[dhT `dT [P d[caP _TcXcP RdP[XcPcXeP T] ]PSP bT SXbcX]VdT ST[ eXRX^ ST Sfb`O ^SbWbO SPS^ P `dT bT
R^]ST]P P[V^ SXbcX]c^ P [^ b^[XRXcPS^ ?^a ^caP _PacT PUXa\P `dT T] aXV^a [P cZb`O ^SbWbO Tb d] STaXePS^ ST [P
!#
TgcaP _TcXcP T]cT]SXSP TbcP [cX\P R^\^ bT WP SXRW^ T] [P R^]RTbX
] ST P[V^ SXbcX]c^ P [^ _TSXS^
0R^aST R^] [^ SXRW^ aTiP [P bT]cT]RXP ST[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb T] [^ 2XeX[ "( °AS W\Qc``W S\ cZb`O ^SbWbO
#
OZ ZW_cWRO`aS SZ Q`{RWb] S\ c\O ac[O ac^S`W]` O Z] a]ZWQWbOR] ^]` SZ SXSQcbO\bS S\ ZO RS[O\RO ZW_cWROb]`WO ± 4] bX\X[Pa
bT]cXS^ bT aTe^R
_^a _PacT ST[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb T] [^ 2XeX[ d]P bT]cT]RXP T] S^]ST bT R^]ST]PQP
!%
P \ub ST [^ _TSXS^
& ?0;028> 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ 1WdWZ c E _uV # $
' E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c 888 _uV $!
( 10AA48A> ±?aX]RX_X^ ST 2^]VadT]RXP) Bd eX^[PRX
] R^\^ RPdbP[ ST 2PbPRX
] ;^b _^STaTb ST[
aVP]^ ST RPbPRX
]²
X]) 00 EE) F777 8]`\OROa <OQW]\OZSa RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ _uV $%
! 010; >;8Ë 3abcRW]a RSZ 1RWU] 5S\S`OZ RSZ >`]QSa] c 88 _uV #!
! E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV ''
!! E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV ''
!" E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV '(
!# E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV '(
!$ BT]cT]RXP %( ! C02 ! C 1VSRWOY ` AOaa\ A]aO T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! 4S 52D
2Pb^ " _uV &$
!% BT]cT]RXP ' ! # C02 C 1Oab`] ` Dth_cSh ;O`b\Sh T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! $ 4S 52D
