Page 757 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia
P. 757
4'8+56# &' &'4'%*1 &' .# 70+8'45+&#& &' /106'8+&'1
P [P UXYPRX
] ST[ ^QYTc^ 4bc^b _[P]cTP] S^b WX_
cTbXb RdP]S^ bT P\_[XP T] [P bT]cT]RXP STUX]XcXeP T[ ^QYTc^
T]cXT]ST] bXV]XUXRPau aTca^caPTa T[ _a^RTb^ T] cP]c^ T[ ^QYTc^ P\_[XPS^ aT`dTaXau ]dTePb X]bcP]RXPb _a^QPc^aXPb
h P[TVPRX^]Tb ST [Pb _PacTb 4] RP\QX^ RdP]S^ bT aTSdRT T[ ^QYTc^ ]^ bT eT] \T]VdPSPb [Pb _^bXQX[XSPSTb ST
STUT]bP h ]^ bT aT`dXTaT e^[eTa b^QaT X]bcP]RXPb _a^RTbP[Tb _TaX\XSPb [P aTSdRRX
] ST[ ^QYTc^ bTaeXau R^\^
$#
TeT]cdP[ PVaPeX^ T] [P P_T[PRX
]
4] aTUTaT]RXP P [^b aPi^]P\XT]c^b `dT eXT]T] ST Tg_^]TabT 34 74643DB R^]R[dhT `dT RdP]S^ T[ ^QYTc^
ST[X\XcPS^ T] [P 0dSXT]RXP WP ^\XcXS^ _a^]d]RXPabT b^QaT _aTcT]bX^]Tb `dT UdTa^] P[TVPSPb _^a [Pb _PacTb
h b^\TcXSPb P X]bcadRRX
] h [P bT]cT]RXP STUX]XcXeP bT _a^]d]RXP b^QaT SXRWPb _aTcT]bX^]Tb bTaP TgRTbXe^
R^]bXSTaPa `dT [P \Xb\P WP X]RdaaXS^ T] X]R^]VadT]RXP SPS^ P `dT ]^ bT eX^[P T[ STQXS^ _a^RTb^ 4] RP\QX^
SXRWP Pdc^aP b^bcXT]T bTau X]R^]VadT]cT d]P bT]cT]RXP `dT T] eXacdS ST [^ SXb_dTbc^ _^a T[ PacRd[^ ! % ST[
$$
26? bT _a^]d]RXP b^QaT _aTcT]bX^]Tb `dT ]^ UdTa^] R^]bXSTaPSPb 3XRW^ aPi^]P\XT]c^ WP bXS^ bTVdXS^
_^a T[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb T] [^ 2XeX[ `dT aTUXaX|]S^bT P[ ^QYTc^ _a^]d]RXP) °¨_cS W\QZca] ^cSRS aS`
`SdWaOR] S\ aSRS RS aS\bS\QWO RSTW\WbWdO RS OQcS`R] O Z] RWa^cSab] ^]` SZ O`b $ RSZ 15> S\ bO\b] \] W[^ZWQO `Sb`]b`OS`
#$
SZ ^`]QSa] gO _cS ZcSU] RSZ b`OaZOR] ][WbWR] ZOa ^O`bSa Q]\bO`]\ Q]\ b]ROa ZOa UO`O\bOa ^`]QSaOZSa ±
;^b _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^b ST E4B2>E8 h bdb 2>;01>A03>A4B _PacT] ST [P U^a\P T] `dT WP bXS^ ST[X\XcPS^ T[
^QYTc^ ST[ _a^RTb^ BX T] bd ST[X\XcPRX
] WP] \TSXPS^ PVaPeX^b ST [Pb _PacTb WPQau `dT TbcPabT P [^ aTbdT[c^
$&
T] [P aTb^[dRX
] ST [^b \Xb\^b 4[ _a^Q[T\P bT _[P]cTP RdP]S^ ]^ WP \TSXPS^ PVaPeX^ ST [Pb _PacTb 4] cP[
bXcdPRX
] [^b Pdc^aTb aTUXTaT] P d]P ]^RX
] Te^[dcXeP ST[ ^QYTc^ ePaXP]cT P [^ [PaV^ ST[ _a^RTb^ R^]RX[XPRX
]
caP]bPRRX
] _PaRXP[ TcR 4] [P [cX\P bXcdPRX
] RdP]S^ ]^ WdQ^ PVaPeX^b _[P]cTPS^b ]^ bdaVT [P e^[d]cPS
ST [Pb _PacTb ST aTSdRXa T[ ^QYTc^ _a^RTbP[ `dT Tb \ub aTSdRXS^ P[ `dT bdaVT ST [^b PRc^b ST _a^_^bXRX
]
2^]R[dhT] [^b STbcPRPS^b S^RcaX]^b `dT [P b^[dRX
] ST PcT]STa P [^b PRc^b ST _a^_^bXRX
] X]XRXP[Tb bT
X]b_XaP T] T[ eP[^a ST YdbcXRXP `dXcu]S^[T aT[TeP]RXP P[ R^]bT]cX\XT]c^ cuRXc^ QaX]SPS^ T] [P 0dSXT]RXP ?aT
$'
[X\X]Pa
R CUWe^TQ 9^cdQ^SYQ i 3QcQSY^
?aTeX^ Tg_TSXabT b^QaT [P R^]VadT]RXP T] [P bTVd]SP X]bcP]RXP h RPbPRX
] Tb ST aTRXQ^ aTUTaXa P d]P
RdTbcX
] R^]TgP P [P \Xb\P BT _PacT ST [^ Tg_aTbPS^ _^a 34 74643DB `dT aTUXTaT P [P ST\P]SP R^\^ °SZ
^c\b] RS `STS`S\QWO ]PZWUOR] RS ZO RSTS\aO ] SfQS^QW\ _cS dO O OR]^bO` SZ RS[O\ROR] g ORS[ta ^WZO` Tc\RO[S\bOZ S\
#'
ZO RSbS`[W\OQW\ RSZ ]PXSb] RSZ ^`]QSa] RS ZO ^`cSPO g SZ OZQO\QS RS ZO aS\bS\QWO ± 0 [P T]d]RXPRX
] `dT aTP[XiP 3T
7TVTSdb _^SaP PVaTVPabT [^ aTUTaT]cT P [P P_T[PRX
] T] RdP]c^ R^\^ bT P]P[XiPau [dTV^ |bcP bT T]RdT]caP
[X\XcPSP _^a [^b PVaPeX^b X]R^PS^b _^a [Pb _PacTb 2^]cX]dP]S^ T[ aPi^]P\XT]c^ SXRW^b PVaPeX^b P bd eTi
TbcPau] STcTa\X]PS^b _^a [Pb _aTcT]bX^]Tb X]ca^SdRXSPb T] [^b [XQT[^b X]ca^SdRc^aX^b 3T [^ Tg_aTbPS^ bdaVT
[P ]TRTbXSPS ST R^]R^aSP]RXP T]caT [^b PVaPeX^b _[P]cTPS^b h [Pb _aTcT]bX^]Tb STSdRXSPb ]^ ^QbcP]cT SXRWP
R^]R^aSP]RXP `dT T] T[ RPb^ bTau T]caT S^b PRc^b ST _PacT ]^ bT XST]cXUXRP R^] T[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP
bX]^ R^] T[ ST _aTR[dbX
] `dT bXVdXT]S^ P 2^dcdaT bT STUX]T) °Q][] ZO ^{`RWRO SfbW\QW\ ] Q]\ac[OQW\ RS c\O
TOQcZbOR ^`]QSaOZ ±
$
4] aT[PRX
] P [^ `dT eXT]T ST _[P]cTPabT bT _a^]d]RXP T[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb T] [^ 2XeX[ ! `dT SXRT)
°3Z B`WPc\OZ RS OZhORO \] ^cSRS RSQWRW` a]P`S ^c\b]a \] ^`]^cSab]a OZ b`WPc\OZ RS ^`W[S`O W\abO\QWO O`b #% 15>
gO _cS SZ XcSh RS aSUc\RO W\abO\QWO bO[PW{\ RSPS OQbcO` RS\b`] RS Sa]a Z[WbSa RSZ ]PXSb] RSZ ^`]QSa] gO _cS ZO O^SZOQW\
\] W[^]`bO RSRcQQW\ RS c\O \cSdO ^`SbS\aW\ ]`WUW\O`WO RS c\ \cSd] ^`]QSa] aW\] _cS aZ] bWS\S QO`tQbS` `SdWaWd] RS ZO
aS\bS\QWO 3Z ]PXSb] RSZ ^`]QSa] ^cSa Q]\bW\cO aWS\R] SZ [Wa[] _cS SZ RS ZO ^`W[S`O W\abO\QWO¨ SZ t[PWb] RS Q]\]QW[WS\b]
RS Z]a b`WPc\OZSa RS OZhORO Sabt ZW[WbOR] ^]` SZ Q]\bS\WR] RS ZOa RSQWaW]\Sa ^`]^cSabOa O ZO RSQWaW\ RSZ W\TS`W]` ±
$
ATb_TRc^ P[ P[RP]RT ST [P R^]VadT]RXP T] X]bcP]RXPb bd_TaX^aTb cP]c^ T] [P P_T[PRX
] R^\^ T] RPbPRX
]
Tb ST aTRXQ^ T[ _[P]cT^ ST <>A4;;> `dT Tb c^\PS^ _^a E4B2>E8 T] bd ^QaP R^[TRcXeP SXRW^ Pdc^a bT Tg_aTbP
VauUXRP\T]cT _[P]cTP]S^ `dT [P R^]VadT]RXP T] X]bcP]RXPb bd_TaX^aTb bT P]V^bcP hP `dT T[ R^aaT[Pc^ ST [P
$# E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV " $
$$ 34 74643DB ^_ RXc AD3? c ! _uV !&
$% BT]cT]RXP &% ! C02 C >O`UO ` 1OTOaa] 5cbW{``Sh T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! 4S 52D
2Pb^ _uV %'
$& E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV #
$' E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV $
$( 34 74643DB ^_ RXc _uV $!#
% 2>DCDA4 4c\RO[S\b]a RSZ 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ 1WdWZ _uV %
% BT]cT]RXP $ ! # C02 ! C A]aO ` AOaa\ 1VSRWOY T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! $ 4S 52D
2Pb^ !#! _uV (&'
