Page 760 - Pleno Jurisdiccional Nacional Civil Familia

%&
_cSRO` dW\QcZOR] ^]` ZOa OZSUOQW]\Sa Xc`RWQOa RS ZOa ^O`bSa ± 4[ \T]RX^]PS^ _aX]RX_X^ bT Ud]SP T] [P \ugX\P
%'
[PcX]P ±RO [WVW TOQbc[ ROP] bWPW Wca ±
0VaTVP 34 74643DB aTb_TRc^ P[ \Xb\^) °¨ZO SZSQQW„\ RS ZO \]`[O RS RS`SQV] O^ZWQOPZS OZ QOa] Q]\abWbcgS ZO
[O\WTSabOQW„\ [ta W\bS\aO RS ZO OQbWdWROR Xc`WaRWQQW]\OZ Q]``Sa^]\RW{\R]ZS S\ T]`[O SfQZcaWdO ^]` QcO\b] RSPS ORSQcO`
ac OQbcOQW„\ OZ ]`RS\O[WS\b] Xc`RWQ] G SZZ] S\ ZO [SRWRO S\ _cS ^]` c\ ZOR] SZ 8cSh OQb‰O Q]\ W\RS^S\RS\QWO RS ZOa
QOZWTWQOQW]\Sa Xc`RWQOa RS ZOa ^O`bSa ^S`] ^]` ]b`] RSPS `Oh]\O` S\ RS`SQV] g O^ZWQO` SZ RS`SQV] _cS Q]``Sa^]\RO g RS\b`]
RSZ [O`Q] [Og]` RS `STS`S\QWO _cS Q]\abWbcgS b]R] SZ RS`SQV] ^]aWbWd] ±
&
=^ ^QbcP]cT T[ _aX]RX_X^ Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO STQT RT„XabT P STcTa\X]PS^b R^]SXRX^]P\XT]c^b _PaP `dT [P
RP[XUXRPRX ] Yda€SXRP X]e^RPSP _^a T[ caXQd]P[ ]^ TgRTST [P R^]VadT]RXP
4] _aX\Ta [dVPa ]^ _dTST] P[cTaPabT [^b Ud]SP\T]c^b UuRcXR^b ST [P _aTcT]bX ] R^]bcXcdhT]S^ Tbc^b d]P
'
°dOZZO W\Sf]`OPZS± _PaP T[ YdiVPS^a bTVŠ] Tg_aTbP 34 74643DB ;P \T]cPSP Pdc^aP bX]cTcXiP [^b [€\XcTb ST
SXRW^ _aX]RX_X^ b^bcT]XT]S^ `dT R^aaTb_^]ST P [P _PacT [P STcTa\X]PRX ] ST [P _aTcT]bX ] [P RdP[ ]^ _^Sau
bTa bdbcXcdXSP _^a T[ ^UXRX^ YdSXRXP[ P [P eTi [P X]cTa_aTcPRX ] ST[ PRc^ ST _PacT WPST bTa PR^aST P[ UX] _TabT
VdXS^ STQXT]S^ PcT]STabT bXT\_aT T] cP[ X]cTa_aTcPRX ] P [P ]^ ed[]TaPRX ] ST[ _aX]RX_X^ ST X\_PaRXP[XSPS
'!
Pb€ R^\^ [Pb VPaP]c€Pb ST STUT]bP T] YdXRX^
4[ aT_Tac^aX^ YdaXb_adST]RXP[ Tb ePaXPS^ P[ aTb_TRc^ [P Bd_aT\P 2^acT ST 9dbcXRXP ]^ R^]bXSTa ed[]TaPS^
T[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP P[ ePaXPa T[ aTVX\T] Yda€SXR^ ST W^aPb TgcaPb X]e^RPS^ _^a [Pb _PacTb P[ aTb_TRc^
aTUXTaT P d] _a^]d]RXP\XT]c^ P]cTaX^a T] T[ `dT [P 2^a_^aPRX ] Tg_aTb ) °RWTQWZ[S\bS W\Qc``W`t SZ XcSh S\ W\
Q]\U`cS\QWO QcO\R] SXS`QWbO\R] OZ O[^O`] RSZ ^`W\QW^W] Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO ac ^]RS` RSPS` RS cPWQO` ZO aWbcOQW„\ TtQbWQO
^]abcZORO g ^`]PORO S\ ZO VW^„bSaWa \]`[ObWdO ^S`bW\S\bS VOUO ZcUO` O ZO ^`SbS\aW„\ S\ POaS O c\ Tc\RO[S\b] ZSUOZ
RWdS`a] RSZ W\d]QOR] aW\ []RWTWQO` SZ ac^cSab] TtQbWQ] ^`]^cSab] Sa RSQW` aW\ dO`WO` ZO QOcaO ^SbS\RW¨ 1]\aWUcWS\bS
[S\bS S\ ZO ZOP]` RS W\bS`^`SbO` ZO RS[O\RO SZ 8cSh \] aS S\QcS\b`O Q]\ab`SƒWR] \W ^]` ZO QObSU]`WhOQW„\ RS Z]a OQb]a
] \SU]QW]a \W ^]` ZO W\bS`^`SbOQW„\ _cS RS RWQV]a OQb]a ] \SU]QW]a STSQb‰S\ ZOa ^O`bSa( Sa SZ XcSh SZ _cS W\RWdWRcOZWhO SZ
RS`SQV] O^ZWQOPZS O‰\ S\ Q]\b`ORWQQW„\ Q]\ Z] ^`Sac^cSab] ] acUS`WR] ^]` O_c{ZZOa¨ ±
&!
0[ aTb_TRc^ T[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb T] [^ 2XeX[ & T]cT]SX _TacX]T]cT \dSPa [P RP[XUXRPRX ] Yda€SXRP
aTP[XiPSP _^a T[ PRRX^]P]cT QPbPSP T] [P aTb_^]bPQX[XSPS TgcaPR^]caPRcdP[ P [P aTb_^]bPQX[XSPS R^]caPRcdP[
\P]XUTbcP]S^) °3\b]\QSa RSPW„ SZ O _c] RSTW\W` SZ Q]``SQb] OaWS\b] ZSUOZ Q]\T]`[S OZ ^`W\QW^W] Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO _cS¨
S\ \ORO W\QWRS S\ ZO Q]\U`cS\QWO RSZ ^`]\c\QWO[WS\b] _cS TW\QO S\ c\O ^`SbS\aW„\ RS Q]\RS\O ±
&"
=^ ^QbcP]cT STbST d]P _Tab_TRcXeP \ub caPSXRX^]P[ 6D4AA0 SXbRaT_P R^] [^b _[P]cTP\XT]c^b P]cTaX^aTb
Tg_aTbP]S^ `dT T[ _aX]RX_X^ Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO ]^ PS\XcT ]X]Vd]P \dSP]iP ST [P _aTcT]bX ] [P RdP[ bT T]
RdT]caP ST[X\XcPSP ]^ b [^ R^] T[ _TSX\T]c^ bX]^ cP\QX|] R^] [^b PR^]cTRX\XT]c^b T] `dT bT Ud]SP 4[ Pdc^a
R^]cX]ŠP bd aPi^]P\XT]c^ Tg_aTbP]S^ `dT RP\QXPa [P RP[XUXRPRX ] Yda€SXRP ST [P aTb_^]bPQX[XSPS X]e^RPSP
X\_[XRP d]P ed[]TaPRX ] P[ _aX]RX_X^ ST STUT]bP [^ `dT bT caPSdRT T] d] UP[[^ X]R^]VadT]cT RP_Pi ST PcPRPa
[^b Ud]SP\T]c^b \Xb\^b ST[ _aX]RX_X^ P TbcdSX^ Tb STRXa T[ _aX]RX_X^ SXb_^bXcXe^ [P QX[PcTaP[XSPS XVdP[SPS
h [TVP[XSPS T]caT ^ca^b
'$
4] RdP]c^ P [^b [€\XcTb ST[ YdiVPS^a _PaP RP[XUXRPa Yda€SXRP\T]cT [P bT]cT]RXP T[ CaXQd]P[ ST 0_T[PRX^]Tb
T] [^ 2XeX[ R^]bXSTaP) °;cRO` ZO \Obc`OZShO RS ZO OQQW„\ ^`][]dWRO O c\O `S^O`Ob]`WO RS ROƒ]a ] S\`W_cSQW[WS\b]
W\RSPWR] SfQSRS SZ t[PWb] RSZ Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO g aWU\WTWQO W\U`SaO` S\ SZ t[PWb] RSZ ^`W\QW^W] RS Q]\U`cS\QWO S\ QcO\b]
ac^]\S W\b`]RcQW` Oa^SQb]a RS VSQV]a _cS \] TcS`]\ O`bWQcZOR]a ^]` SZ RS[O\RO\bS g \] a„Z] []RWTWQO` S\ S\T]_cS Xc`RWQ]
&$
RS Z]a VSQV]a OZSUOR]a ±
?^a Š[cX\^ RPQT aTUTaXa P [P TgcT]bX ] ST[ _aX]RX_X^ Wc`O \]dWb Qc`WO OZ `SQc`a] RS QOaOQW„\ BTVŠ] bT WP SXRW^
T] [Pb X]bcP]RXPb _a^RTbP[Tb bd_TaX^aTb T[ _aX]RX_X^ ST R^]VadT]RXP bT P]V^bcP T] aT[PRX ] P [^b PVaPeX^b P
[^ `dT bT PVaTVP [^ _aTeXbc^ T] T[ Pac€Rd[^ !&" ! ST[ 26? T] RdP]c^ P [P \T]RX ] ST [Pb ]^a\Pb ST STaTRW^
X]UaX]VXSPb ^ Taa ]TP\T]cT P_[XRPSPb

&' 34 74643DB ^_ RXc _uV $ (
&( E4B2>E8 2>;01>A03>A4B ^_ RXc c E8 _uV (
' 34 74643DB ^_ RXc _uV $!
' 34 74643DB ^_ RXc _uV $ !
'! 34 74643DB ^_ RXc _uV $!%
'" BT]cT]RXP '' ! # ST [P Bd_aT\P 2^acT ST 9dbcXRXP T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c # ! $ 4S 52D 2Pb^
!%! _uV ('"
'# BT]cT]RXP "$ ! $ C02 & C 1]cb] ` 0SZZ] :„^Sh T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c ! ! % 4S 52D 2Pb^
"& _uV #!(
'$ 6D4AA0 ±4[ ?aX]RX_X^ 7c`O <]dWb 1c`WO g SZ >`W\QW^W] RS 1]\U`cS\QWO S\ SZ >`]QSa] 1WdWZ± X]) 00 EE) F777 8]`\OROa <OQW]
\OZSa RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ _uVb !'% !'&
'% BT]cT]RXP $! ! $ C02 C 1Oab`] ` AOZd] Dth_cSh T] @SdWabO C`cUcOgO RS 2S`SQV] >`]QSaOZ c ! ! % 4S 52D
2Pb^ ! _uV #!$