Home | Quotations | Misc Notes | Notes 2 | Hair | DemicDiff | Diversity | DNA| Asian IQ | Keita2008 data | BloodDebunk3

Egypt in Africa Black-Greek-DNA links | Notes 3 |Notes 4| Notes 5 | Notes 6 | Notes 7 | Misc news clips | Ethiopians | Nubians
African Tmeline
| Mesopotamia | Egypt- A Tropical Civ || KnolArchiv Notes8| Notes 9 | Notes 10 | Notes 11

Link to research papers and articles: (http://wysinger.homestead.com/keita.html)

Link to current African DNA research: (http://exploring-africa.blogspot.com/) 

Google Search- other data
http://www.nilevalleypeoples.blogspot.com

 

Home page
index.htm

Image gallery
imagegallery.htm

 

Nile valley peopling image gallery  (first 7 rows are new)


Tropical Africans most diverse people in the world- shown by DNA, dental, skeletal, gen. phenotype

Nose shape primarily related to climate
 
Ramses III- 20th Dynasty Pharoah, had sub-Saharan African E1b1a (now called E-M2) DNA new study finds
     
Body mass data shows Egypt populated by topical Africans. Such tropical peoples can vary based on environment - such as temperate climate and diet. Body mass data does not change genesis of Egypt by tropical Africans. Almost 20% of Egypt falls within the tropical zone

Nei race categorization debunk

North Africa includes Sudan, Mali, Niger, Chad etc

PN2 P2 transition DNA

Fallacies of race mongers - Table
 
Kemp dendro reversed


YAP data- African origin

Nazlet Khater of Egypt- cluster with Africans

African M1 - origin in Africa
africanm1a.jpg



misc cro-magnon data

Tishkoff Ethiop clustering 2009
Ethiops overwhelming African


Facial flatness studies cluster Egyptians with other African populations- Hanihara 2000

 


Nerfertiti scans - reconstructions
African similarities 
 

nativeafricanblondism.jpg


redhairedafricankids.jpg

ancientegyptianworkers.jpg

Image galley of dark Egyptians- forgotten native sons of ancient Egypt




European influence or migration to ancient Nile Valley debunked - Keita- Early farmers from El-Badari


Skewed sampling in North African research- Harich 2020, Cherni 2005


more exclusions in purported studies of 'North Africa' fadhlaoui-zid 2011


Limb proportions genetic component


M1 appears mostly in Africa with almost non-existent native frequencies in Europe or the Middle East

Simplistic race mix claims as to East Africans and Ethiopians debunked- Tiskkoff2009

 


defintions of North Africa often exclude Sudan, Mali, Niger Chad although some geographers include them
body mass variation

Kemp 2005 Non-pooled and pooled data show ancient Egyptians not identical to moderns, and clustering ith other Africans

Hanihara 2000 facial flatness shows Egyptians clustering with Kerma or Nubia

Tropical limb proportions of the pharaohs

Recent studies show ancient Egyptians had tropical body plans, closer to tropical Africans than Europeans or Middle Easterners.

Modern studies show the key Badari group quite representative of the ancient Egyptians and cluster more with African groups than Europeans or Middle Easterners

More skewed samples and stacked decks. Abu-Amero uses Arab and Arabized Berber samples from northern Egypt as "representative"

Natufians show affinities not only with sub-Saharans but with older Euro populations who also resembled tropically adapted Sub-Saharan Africans- Pinhasi debunk

DNA analysis of ancient mummies from tomb of nobles finds skin packed with melanin, characteristic of tropical African variants. Mekota 2005

 


mtDNA2008
Today's Arab world Egyptians cluster more with mixed Yemenis and Ethiopians more with Nubians- Amero2008
 

Early Europeans and Middle easterners as late as the Neolithic looked like Africans. Any "backflow" or return to Africa would thus be by people who already looked like Africans

mtDNA info in Egyptians and Egyptian Berbers

2010 DNA study shows foundational African origins of Berbers


North and Northeast African mtDNA

Spencer Wells- The human journey


Egypt in Tropic & Subtropic/Tropic Arid Zone, NOT the cold-climate zones of Europe or Asia. Southern Egypt, from which the genesis of Ancient Egypt sprang, lies in the tropical zone, from the Tropics of Cancer to Capricorn with Tropic of Cancer bisect at 23°26'N 25°0'E. The rest of Egypt lies in the subtropical/Arid tropic zone.



Debunking 1: Greater Mesopotamia (Palestine, Iraq, Syria, southwestern Iran) falls within the Subtropic/Tropic Arid Zone, NOT the cold-climate zones of Europe or Asia. The subtropics are the geographical and climatic zone of the Earth immediately north and south of the tropical zone, at latitudes 23.5°N and 23.5°S. The Greater Mesopotamian area is assigned to the subtropics or the arid tropics by modern climatologists. (See: Troll and Pfaffen, 1964. ‘Seasonal patterns of the earth and Thompson, A. (1997) Applied climatology: pg 179;
Greater Mesopotamia falls within the Subtropic/Tropic Arid Zone, NOT the cold-climate zones of Europe or Asia. The Natufians, and others in the Mesopotamia zonr  do NOT white cold-climate types and do NOT show ‘white Nordic” affinities. 

Ricaut Waelkens debunk - use of late period foreign mixed Egyptian samples as "representative" of the ancients, excluding the previous 3,000 yrs of Egyptian civ.


world climate map


Nefertiti reconstructions show indigenous Egyptian. Famous statutes on display cover original with plaster claim several scientists.

 .

Bogus 'racial' wars claim in 
ancient Egypt flipped on its head

Ethiopians overwhelmingly cluster with other Africans not Europeans, Asiatics or Middle Easterners
Tishkoff 2009

Skewed sampling decks in dental studies of Nubians
Irish 1998

Several key centers of ancient Chinese civilization are in the subtropical not cold climate zone, and China was peopled from the tropical/subtropical South East Asia region, bit cold climate areas.

First Europeans looked like Africans & their color only turned pale recently years ago

Most studies of Egyptian Y-DNA find lineages closer to African populations than Europe or the Middle East. Keita 

New study finds Nubians the closest people ethnically to the Egyptians

Tutsi DNA (E3a) linking with West Africans not alleged 'Caucasoids'

Neo-Nazi claims of white Egypt based on hair debunked.
egyptianhairdebunk75

Nubian - Egyptian links. Debunking "racial conflict" claims about the 2 peoples. Nubians were the closest people ethnically to the ancient  Egyptians, sharing a common culture, intermarrying and having the same pharaonic structure. All this was millennia BEFORE the 25th Dynasty.

Ethiopians versus Europeans. According to conservative Cavalli-Sforza, Europeans are hybrids- mostly Asian. Ethiopians are mostly African. Curiously assorted 'Aryans' want to run away from the Euro hybrid part.

Seveal recent DNA studies including mtDNA Salas, Knight, Petlichkovski etc show Egyptians linking more with West Africans like Mandinka, or other Africans such as Nubians, Somalians, Ethiopians, Sudanics than with admixed groups such as Berbers, or Europeans, Middle Easterners 

Europeans, are not the defining Caucasians or a primary "race" but mere hybrids between Africans and Asians: one-third African, two-thirds Asian per Cavalli-Sforza. Ellen Coffman-Levy shows ancient DNA studies suggesting modern Europeans are little related to 'stone-age' Paleolithics

Rosa et. al (Y chrom in Guinea) shows Egyptian DNA links more with East and Central Africans than with others.

E-M78 origins and weight with Africans not Europeans or Middle East. e-M78 DNA very frequent in Egypt

|
Keita2008 data from Bengston- In Hot Pursuit

Tishkoff 2000 rejects simplistic "racial mix" models - clusters Ethiopians as an indigenous development.

Haplogroup E- uniting numerous African peoples
hapelight

conservative geneticists show Ethiopians cluster primarily with other Africans rather than Europeans or Middle Easterners. CL Brace debunks wandering Caucasoids

Writings of 'Afrocentric 'critic Mary Lefkowitz actually acknowledge Egypt as an African civilization. Lefkowitz's recommended anthropologist Nancy Lovell puts ancient Egyptians as part of a tropical African lineage.

cavalli-sforza 1994 showed Ethiopians cluster more with Africans than others
wilsondebunk.jpg wilsondebunk.jpg
272.45 KB
Assorted 'Nordic Ethiopians' nonsense based on skewed sampling of Wilson 2001 dismissed. The majority Oromo with more Afrian DNA links were under-represented in sampling helping to yield 'Norwegian' matches

East African - Egyptian links
DNA links between Egyptians and sub-Saharan East Africans
upperegyptdebunk.jpg upperegyptdebunk.jpg
172.54 KB
Selective sampling and exclusion of nearby African populations for comparison in study of Upper Egypt-     Ghada Omran, et al 2008. Distant Algeria rather than nearby Sudan or Ethiopia used for example. Despite this, closest African match to Egyptians is with admixed Berbers, closer than Europeans.

Haplogroup "E" - M35, M-78 DNA studies of haplogroup ‘E’ show that the primary peopling of ancient Egypt was by Africans with ‘E” derived lineages, not those of Europe or the Middle East. “E” appears at higher frequencies than other individual haplotypes such as the Near Eastern “J” in some studies of modern Egypt. (Luis 2004)

Aryan 'white Ehiopian' model claims based on Tishkoff 2000 debunked

Brace 2005 debunks wandering Caucasoids- The Questionable contribution


Japanese HLA data


Richards 2003 shows that DNA Haplogroup 'E' links overwhelmingly links Ethiopians, West Africans and South Africans together

cavalli-sforza 1994 showed Ethiopians cluster more with Africans than others


egyptclimatecombo2.jpg


2005 DNA study puts Egyptians closer to Somalians and others with African haplotypes rather than Europeans or Middle easterners (Flores)


Assorted claims of Asian hordes flowing into the Nile Valley debunked

Skewed sampling of Herrera 2004. Samples drawn from tanta nar Cairo of Arabs and Berbers and used s "representative. Southern Egyptians and nearby Sudan, Somalia Ethiopia, etc excluded. Bootstrap analysis finds African clusters however.


Skewed mtDNA sampling- gonzalez-perez


Gravestone of the Nubian solider Nenu, circa 2250 B.C. depicting him and his weapons and Egyptian wife. Marriages between Nubians and Egyptians were common, and both peoples shared a common culture.


Neo-nazi appropriation of Egyptian heritage based on blood groups debunked. (bloodwrap.jpg)

blood types


Racial blood grouping on Egyptians. Africans closer than others
bloodgroupdebunk.jpg

King Tut A2 blood type quite within African range. (A2debunk.jpg)

Aryan Egypt' Racial claims on King Tut's blood debunked. Africans actually closer. Reputed A2 blood marker a trivial one worldwide, adn also found in Africa. (tutdebunk2.jpg)
raxterrufftrinkhauscombo.jpg raxterrufftrinkhauscombo.jpg
150.03 KB
Limb studies show Egyptians, ancient or modern, cluster closer to other tropically adapted peoples like Black Americans than white Europeans- Raxter and Ruff 2008
limbstudies2-small.jpg limbstudies2-small.jpg
26.08 KB
Limb studies show ancient  Egyptians cluster closer to other tropically adapted peoples like Black Americans than white Europeans- Zakrewski 2003
brace2005a.jpg brace2005a.jpg
177.11 KB
Study of C. Loring Brace 2005 showing early Europeans looked like Africans, not today's whites, hence matching some African data
truenegromodel.jpg truenegromodel.jpg
212.56 KB
Weaknesses of C. Loring Brace's 
1993 Clines and Clusters study critiqued such as exclusion of the 
key Badarian group
africanracepercentmodel1.jpg africanracepercentmodel1.jpg
161.43 KB
Bogus "white Nubians" debunked- Fox 1997
aryanracepercentmodel.jpg aryanracepercentmodel.jpg
112.10 KB
Bogus "Aryan" model of African genetics debunked
blockdebunkbig.jpg blockdebunkbig.jpg
255.79 KB
Bogus use of late Dynasty data as 'representative' of Egypt debunked - Kemp dendrogram
duhrabhammerdebunk.jpg duhrabhammerdebunk.jpg
180.25 KB
Bogus 'white Mediterranean' model of Egypt debunked
haniharadebunk1.jpg haniharadebunk1.jpg
200.53 KB
Bogus 'Aryan' or 'Mediterranean' Egypt models debunked along with 'white Nubians' - Hanihara 2003
poloniboschdebunk.jpg poloniboschdebunk.jpg
173.88 KB
Selective sampling in Poloni, Bosch, Hammer or Cavalli-Sforza. Assorted racist 'Aryan' nonsense debunked
HANHIARA2003CLUSTER.gif HANHIARA2003CLUSTER.gif
79.22 KB
Clustering of Egyptians with other Africans like Nubians before Europeans or Middle Easterners- Hanihara 2003
lagoasantoplotsm.jpg
lagoasantoplotsm.jpg
182.47 KB
Clustering of Egyptians with Africans when individual craniometric traits used rather than series aggregation- Lagoa Santos
duhrabtishkoff.jpg duhrabtishkoff.jpg
181.06 KB
Assorted racist 'Aryan' and 'Medit' nonsense about African genetics debunked
kempdebunk2.jpg kempdebunk2.jpg
169.02 KB
Assorted racist 'Aryan' and 'Medit' nonsense based on Barry Kemp's dendrogram dismissed
poloni1997group.jpg poloni1997group.jpg
36.25 KB
Poloni 1997 groups Egyptians closer to other Africans than Europeans or Middle Easterners despite samples drawn from far north
raxterruffsamples.jpg
raxterruffsamples.jpg
41.63 KB
2008 Limb proportion study  of 
Raxter and Ruff groups Egyptians with other tropically adapted peoples 
like Black Americans rather than white Europeans despite use of 
northern samples
duhrabmeditdebunkbig.jpg duhrabmeditdebunkbig.jpg
213.31 KB
Assorted racist 'Aryan' and 'white Mediterranean' Ethiopians' nonsense debunked
duhrabhammerdebunk-hit.jpg duhrabhammerdebunk-hit.jpg
172.43 KB

Assorted racist 'Aryan Ethiopians' claims dismissed. Cavalli-Sforza et al 2002 show Ethiopians clustering more closely with Africans, including the ancient San/Khosian than white Europeans or Middle Easterners

tishkoffoutofafricageneticflow.jpg tishkoffoutofafricageneticflow.jpg
152.29 KB
Out of Africa genetic flow model - Tishkoff
ethiopiandna.jpg ethiopiandna.jpg
304.00 KB
Sampling bias in the study of Ethiopians- Lovell and Passarino. Despite this Passarino found Ethiopians cluster much more with African groups than Europeans or Middle Easterners
Assorted racist 'Aryan' and 'white Ethiopians' nonsense dismissed
sanchezethiopsomaliplot2.jpg sanchezethiopsomaliplot2.jpg
47.54 KB
Sanchez 2004 showing Somalis clustering more with other Africans than Europeans or Middle Easterners. Assorted 'Aryan Somalid' nonsense dismissed.
somalidnabig.jpg somalidnabig.jpg
123.57 KB
2 studies (Sanchez, Comas) showing
Somalis clustering more with other Africans than Europeans or Middle Easterners. Assorted 'Aryan' nonsense dismissed
somalidnacomas1.jpg somalidnacomas1.jpg
39.63 KB
 Comas study showing Somalis clustering more with other Africans than Europeans or Middle Easterners. Assorted 'Aryan' nonsense dismissed
somalidnatreecomas.jpg somalidnatreecomas.jpg
87.93 KB
Comas study showing Somalis clustering more with other Africans than Europeans or Middle Easterners. Assorted 'Aryan' nonsense dismissed
wardDentalmet2debunk2big.jpg wardDentalmet2debunk2big.jpg
135.41 KB
Assorted 'Aryan' nonsense based on dental data debunked

Sumerians race
warddebunkb1.jpg warddebunkb1.jpg
167.81 KB

More 'Aryan' nonsense based on dental data dismissed

subsaharanpropmap4.jpg subsaharanpropmap4.jpg
127.82 KB
Selective double-standards in the definition of 'sub-Saharan' critiqued. Ethiopia and Somalia are below the Sahara but are often classified as not. Huge parts of Chad, Nigeria, Mali etc abve the Sahara but are curiously classified as "sub-Saharan'
greeknegroidaffinities.jpg greeknegroidaffinities.jpg
69.30 KB
Greek - African DNA links. Cystic fibrosis mutation
hlafreq2.jpg hlafreq2.jpg
88.86 KB
Greek- African DNA links.
Arnaiz Villena data on Greeks, not Palestinians as alleged by assorted 'Aryans'
egyptianmandenka.jpg egyptianmandenka.jpg
31.50 KB
Egyptian - West African DNA links
westasianafrican.jpg westasianafrican.jpg
122.33 KB

Early Midle Easterners looked like Africans. Hanihara 1996 study show Ir. Bronze Age closer to Africans than Europeans or West Asians. Assorted Carleton Coons and 'Aryan' piffle dismissed.

egyotinafrica1.jpg egyotinafrica1.jpg
127.55 KB
Numerous cultural and material links of Egypt and Africa based on mainstream scholarship: Bard, Lovell, Zakrewski, Vogel, Yurco, etc
forgottenoriginals1.jpg forgottenoriginals1.jpg
146.79 KB
Mainstream data on Southern Egyptians
nilevalleytimeline2.jpg nilevalleytimeline2.jpg
209.15 KB
Timeline of Nile Valley developments. Conquest or absorption by Southern hegemons near the Sudan and Sahara not the north
niloticcommunity3.jpg niloticcommunity3.jpg
77.38 KB
The Nilotic peoples as one continuity, 
not artificial 'Aryan' race splitting. 
- Frank Yurco
ychromoegypt1.jpg ychromoegypt1.jpg
92.74 KB
Y-chromosome data in Egypt, linking more with African groups than Europeans or Middle Easterners
pn2clade2A.jpg pn2clade2A.jpg
47.97 KB
The PN2 DNA clade- linking together numerous African peoples regardless of how they look
haplotypesmap.jpg haplotypesmap.jpg
132.72 KB
Haplotype E, the most prevalent in Africa
hape.jpg haplotype E.jpg


Afro-Asiatic languages originated in Africa. Semitic did not involve much gene flow from Arabian penisula but diffused thru African populations (Kitchens 2009)

researchproblems3.jpg researchproblems3.jpg
31.03 KB
4 research problems in Nile Valley studies- true negro model, sampling bias, misleading labels and the exclusion of African data to maintain certain 'race' models
em78wadihalfa.jpg em78wadihalfa.jpg
74.13 KB
E-M78 data in the Sudan
eastafricadna1.jpg eastafricadna1.jpg
48.27 KB
egyptychromodistrib.jpg egyptychromodistrib.jpg
29.45 KB

Egypt Y-chromo data

blackdefinition.jpg blackdefinition.jpg
65.97 KB
Dictionary definition of black 
people or Negroes
hiernaux75.jpg hiernaux75.jpg
66.08 KB
Hiernaux on African genetic and physical diversity.
northafrica.jpg northafrica.jpg
16.43 KB
Double standards in how 'North Africa' is defined

Asian advantages in IQ, commerce etc per conservative scholars
(asian_advanage.jpg)
trinkhauslimbproportion.jpg trinkhauslimbproportion.jpg
55.31 KB
Trinkhaus limb studies show modern Egyptians closer to dark-skinned African tropical peoples like Black Americans, Pygmies, and others like dark-skinned Melanesians than white Europeans or Middle Easterners
eurohybridization.jpg eurohybridization.jpg
10.25 KB
Europeans are not a race, nor the defining Caucasoids but a hybrid of African and Asian variants according to Cavalli-Sforza
beninsicklecell.gif beninsicklecell.gif
41.98 KB
Distribution of Benin sickle cell - in Africa and into Europe
humanvariationdiagram.jpg humanvariationdiagram.jpg
94.64 KB
tishstructure.jpg tishstructure.jpg
110.32 KB
Tishkoff 2008 structure of African DNA- limited Saharan sampling
westasianafrican.jpg
hanihara96small.jpg
Hanihara98 small. Early Midle Easterners looked like Africans. Hanihara 1996 study show Ir. Bronze Age closer to Africans than Europeans or West Asians. Assorted Carleton Coons and 'Aryan' piffle dismissed.

cannibalism in Europe.jpg
Cannibalism in Europe

African climate patterns- Egypt

israel.jpg
civ timelines
AEEgyptiandancers.jpg AEEgyptiandancers.jpg
23.61 KB
africanpeoples1.jpg africanpeoples1.jpg
18.34 KB
   
saharaninvaders.jpg saharaninvaders.jpg
27.63 KB
africattleherder.jpg africattleherder.jpg
8.51 KB
amen1.jpg amen1.jpg
13.59 KB
Ancient_Egyptian_woman_with_wig-orinil.jpg Ancient_Egyptian_woman_with_wig-orinil.jpg
67.75 KB
ancientegyptianworkers.jpg ancientegyptianworkers.jpg
15.42 KB
anukemet.jpg anukemet.jpg
52.62 KB
arsinoe.jpg arsinoe.jpg
7.45 KB
wwomanChildOldGouma500.jpg wwomanChildOldGouma500.jpg
20.41 KB
bushman.jpg bushman.jpg
2.56 KB
dental.jpg dental.jpg
3.08 KB
egargi.jpg egargi.jpg aartegy.jpg aartegy.jpg
7.55 KB

Hitler debunked 16k

Gay Fuherer

3.79 KB

egyboat.jpg egyboat.jpg
15.33 KB
ethiopianchildwithblondism.jpg ethiopianchildwithblondism.jpg
19.27 KB
egypthairwoman2.jpg egypthairwoman2.jpg
59.43 KB
egypthairwoman3.jpg egypthairwoman3.jpg
47.88 KB
egypthairwoman4.jpg egypthairwoman4.jpg
85.01 KB
egyptianagriculture.jpg egyptianagriculture.jpg
18.03 KB
ethkids.jpg ethkids.jpg
15.01 KB
firsteuro.jpg firsteuro.jpg
17.86 KB
iceman.jpg iceman.jpg
8.19 KB
israel.jpg israel.jpg
4.44 KB
xraymum1.jpg xraymum1.jpg
3.90 KB
tutfa.jpg tutfa.jpg
2.50 KB
lang.jpg lang.jpg
3.48 KB
nimrud.jpg nimrud.jpg
6.27 KB
menes.jpg menes.jpg
9.78 KB
nilevalleymap.jpg nilevalleymap.jpg
22.71 KB
pyr.jpg pyr.jpg
5.52 KB
quotes.jpg quotes.jpg
6.65 KB
r1bhassan.jpg r1bhassan.jpg
18.53 KB
ramesses.jpg ramesses.jpg
27.22 KB
saharans.jpg saharans.jpg
30.44 KB


Afrocentric critic Howe maintains that ancient Egyptians were indigenous Africans

skullmum.jpg skullmum.jpg
8.98 KB
somalibeauty.jpg somalibeauty.jpg
24.08 KB
tjuya.jpg tjuya.jpg
8.59 KB

raxterrufftrinkhauscombo.jpg


ancient Egyptian dancers1

ancient Egyptian dancers 2

yurco 

Natufians, precursors of the Neolithic Revolution show strong links to sub-saharan Africa (Brace 2005)

Tropical limb proportions definition
  pepiseneb.jpg
pepi - Notes 9
.
iceman.jpg
cold climate debunkery
   
Sowell-African geography

'Race' in DNA debunked1


'Race' in DNA debunked2
Templeton

 

 

 

 

Oxford encyclopedia of ancient Egypt Encyclopedia of the Archaeology of Ancient Egypt and Ancient Egypt: Anatomy of a Civilization Limb proportion studies The Egyptians: (n introduction 2005) textbook
Quotes:
[i]"The evidence also points to linkages to
other northeast African peoples, not
coincidentally approximating the modern
range of languages closely related to
Egyptian in the Afro-Asiatic group
(formerly called Hamito-Semetic). These
linguistic similarities place ancient
Egyptian in a close relationship with
languages spoken today as far west as
Chad, and as far south as Somalia.
Archaeological evidence also strongly
supports an African origin. A widespread
northeastern African cultural assemblage,
including distinctive multiple barbed
harpoons and pottery decorated with
dotted wavy line patterns, appears during
the early Neolithic (also known as the
Aqualithic, a reference to the mild
climate of the Sahara at this time).
Saharan and Sudanese rock art from this
time resembles early Egyptian
iconography. Strong connections
between Nubian (Sudanese) and
Egyptian material culture continue in
later Neolithic Badarian culture of Upper
Egypt. Similarities include black-topped
wares, vessels with characteristic
ripple-burnished surfaces, a special
tulip-shaped vessel with incised and
white-filled decoration, palettes, and
harpoons...

Other ancient Egyptian practices show
strong similarities to modern African
cultures including divine kingship, the
use of headrests, body art, circumcision,
and male coming-of-age rituals, all
suggesting an African substratum or
foundation for Egyptian civilization.."[/i]

Source: Donald Redford (2001) The
Oxford encyclopedia of ancient Egypt,
Volume 3. Oxford University Press. p.
28
Quotes:
There is now a sufficient body of evidence from modern studies of skeletal remains to indicate that the ancient Egyptians, especially southern Egyptians, exhibited physical characteristics that are within the range of variation for ancient and modern indigenous peoples of the Sahara and tropical Africa.. In general, the inhabitants of Upper Egypt and Nubia had the greatest biological affinity to people of the Sahara and more southerly areas."
(Nancy C. Lovell, " Egyptians, physical anthropology of," in Encyclopedia of the Archaeology of Ancient Egypt, ed. Kathryn A. Bard and Steven Blake Shubert, ( London and New York: Routledge, 1999) pp 328-332)

and

"must be placed in the context of hypotheses informed by archaeological, linguistic, geographic and other data. In such contexts, the physical anthropological evidence indicates that early Nile Valley populations can be identified as part of an African lineage, but exhibiting local variation. This variation represents the short and long term effects of evolutionary forces, such as gene flow, genetic drift, and natural selection, influenced by culture and geography." ("Nancy C. Lovell, " Egyptians, physical anthropology of," in Encyclopedia of the Archaeology of Ancient Egypt, ed. Kathryn A. Bard and Steven Blake Shubert, ( London and New York: Routledge, 1999). pp 328-332)
Quotes:
"The raw values in Table 6 suggest that Egyptians had the “super-Negroid” body plan described by Robins (1983).. This pattern is supported by Figure 7 (a plot of population mean femoral and tibial lengths; data from Ruff, 1994), which indicates that the Egyptians generally have tropical body plans. Of the Egyptian samples, only the Badarian and Early Dynastic period populations have shorter tibiae than predicted from femoral length. Despite these differences, all samples lie relatively clustered together as compared to the other populations." (Zakrzewski, S.R. (2003). "Variation in ancient Egyptian stature and body proportions". AJPA 121 (3): 219-229.

Quote:

"Intralimb (crural and brachial) indices are significantly higher in ancient Egyptians than in American Whites (except crural index among females), i.e., Egyptians have relatively longer distal segments (Table 4). Intralimb indices are not significantly different between Egyptians and American Blacks... Many of those who have studied ancient Egyptians have commented on their characteristically ‘‘tropical’’ or ‘‘African’’ body plan (Warren, 1897; Masali, 1972; Robins, 1983; Robins and Shute, 1983, 1984, 1986; Zakrzewski, 2003). Egyptians also fall within the range of modern African populations (Ruff and Walker, 1993), but close to the upper limit of modern Europeans as well, at least for the crural index (brachial indices are definitely more ‘‘African’’).. In terms of femoral and tibial length to total skeletal height proportions, we found that ancient Egyptians are significantly different from US Blacks, although still closer to Blacks than to Whites."


("Stature estimation in ancient Egyptians..' Raxter and Ruff et al.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2008, Jun;136(2):147-55


Quotes:
"Ancient Egyptian civilization was, in ways and to an extent usually not recognized, fundamentally African. The evidence of both language and culture reveals these African roots. The origins of Egyptian ethnicity lay in the areas south of Egypt. The ancient Egyptian language belonged to the Afrasian family (also called Afroasiatic or, formerly, Hamito-Semitic). The speakers of the earliest Afrasian languages, according to recent studies, were a set of peoples whose lands between 15,000 and 13,000 B.C. stretched from Nubia in the west to far northern Somalia in the east. They supported themselves by gathering wild grains. The first elements of Egyptian culture were laid down two thousand years later, between 12,000 and 10,000 B.C., when some of these Afrasian communities expanded northward into Egypt, bringing with them a language directly ancestral to ancient Egyptian. They also introduced to Egypt the idea of using wild grains as food." (Christopher Ehret (1996) "Ancient Egyptian as an African Language, Egypt as an African Culture." in: Egypt in Africa, Theodore Celenko (ed), Indiana University Press)

"Ancient Egypt belongs to a language group known as 'Afroasiatic' (formerly called Hamito-Semitic) and its closest relatives are other north-east African languages from Somalia to Chad. Egypt's cultural features, both material and ideological and particularly in the earliest phases, show clear connections with that same broad area. In sum, ancient Egypt was an African culture, developed by African peoples, who had wide ranging contacts in north Africa and western Asia." (Morkot, Robert (2005) The Egyptians: An Introduction. Routledge. p. 10)


"Populations and cultures now found south of the desert roamed far to the north. The culture of Upper Egypt, which became dynastic Egyptian civilization, could fairly be called a Sudanese transplant."
(Egypt and Sub-Saharan Africa: Their Interaction. Encyclopedia of Precolonial Africa, by Joseph O. Vogel, AltaMira Press, Walnut Creek, California (1997), pp. 465-472 )

"..sample populations available from northern Egypt from before the 1st Dynasty (Merimda, Maadi and Wadi Digla) turn out to be significantly different from sample populations from early Palestine and Byblos, suggesting a lack of common ancestors over a long time. If there was a south-north cline variation along the Nile valley it did not, from this limited evidence, continue smoothly on into southern Palestine. The limb-length proportions of males from the Egyptian sites group them with Africans rather than with Europeans."
(Barry Kemp, "Ancient Egypt Anatomy of a Civilisation. (2005) Routledge. p. 52-60)
"Using primarily linguistic evidence, and taking into account recent archaeology at sites such as Hierakonpolis/Nekhen, as well as the symbolic meaning of objects such as sceptres and headrests in Ancient Egyptian and contemporary African cultures, this paper traces the geographical location and movements of early peoples in and around the Nile Valley. It is possible from this overview of the data to conclude that the limited conceptual vocabulary shared by the ancestors of contemporary Chadic-speakers (therefore also contemporary Cushitic-speakers), contemporary Nilotic-speakers and Ancient Egyptian-speakers suggests that the earliest speakers of the Egyptian language could be located to the south of Upper Egypt or, earlier, in the Sahara. The marked grammatical and lexicographic affinities of Ancient Egyptian with Chadic are well-known, and consistent Nilotic cultural, religious and political patterns are detectable in the formation of the first Egyptian kingships. The question these data raise is the articulation between the languages and the cultural patterns of this pool of ancient African societies from which emerged Predynastic Egypt."

--Anselin, A (2011) Some notes about an early African pool of cultures from which emerged Egyptian civilization.
In: Egypt in its African Context. 2009. Proceedings-  Museum, University of Manchester, England. Karen Exell (ed). BAR International Series 2204 2011
Archaeopress Publishers of British Archaeological Reports

Limb proportions group ancient Egyptians closer to tropical Africans and African-Americans
"Limb length proportions in males from Maadi and Merimde group them with African rather than European populations. Mean femur length in males from Maadi was similar to that recorded at Byblos and the early Bronze Age male from Kabri, but mean tibia length in Maadi males was 6.9cm longer than that at Byblos. At Merimde both bones were longer than at the other sites shown, but again, the tibia was longer proportionate to femurs than at Byblos (Fig 6.2), reinforcing the impression of an African rather than Levantine affinity."
-- Smith, P. (2002) The palaeo-biological evidence for admixture between populations in the southern Levant and Egypt in the fourth to third millennia BCE. in E.C.M van den Brink and TE Levy, eds. Egypt and the Levant: interrelations from the 4th through the 3rd millenium, BCE. Leicester Univ Press: 2002, 118-28
Modern Egyptians cluster with Sub-Saharan Africans on several counts
QUOTE:

"The biological characteristics of modern
Egyptians show a north-south cline, reflecting
their geographic location between sub-Saharan
Africa and the Levant. This is expressed in DNA,
blood groups, serum proteins and genetic
disorders (Filon 1996; Hammer et al. 1998; Krings
et al. 1999). They can also be expressed in
phenotypic characteristics that can be identified
in teeth and bones (Crichton 1966; Froment 1992;
Keita 1996). These characteristics include head
form, facial and nasal characteristics, jaw
relationships, tooth size, morphology and
upper/lower limb proportions. In all these
features, Modern Egyptians resemble Sub-Saharan Africans (Howells 1989, Keita 1995)."


-- Smith, P. (2002) The palaeo-biological 
evidence for admixture between populations in the
southern Levant and Egypt in the fourth to third 
millennia BCE. in E.C.M van den Brink and TE Levy, eds.  Egypt and the Levant: interrelations from the 4th through the 3rd millenium, BCE. Leicester Univ Press: 2002, 118-28
Limb proportions:

"These same log shape variables were subjected to two forms of cluster analysis: neighbor-joining (NJ) and unweighted pair-group method using averages (UPGMA) tree analysis. Figure 8 is the NJ tree. It has two main branches—a long and linear body build branch that includes the Egyptians, Sub-Saharan Africans (except for the Pygmies), and African-Americans and a second, less linear body form branch that includes the Inuit, Europeans, Euro-Americans, Puebloans, Nubians, and Pygmies. Note that the Nubians used in this study are thought by some to represent an immigrant population from Europe or Western Asia [see Holliday (1995)]."
--Holiday, T. (2010) Body proportions of circumpolar peoples as evidenced from skeletal data. AmerJrPhyAntrho, 142: 2. 287-302

 
Affinities of Egyptians and sub-Saharan Africans detailed in mainstream scientific studies. [quotes]:

"From the Mesolithic to the early Neolithic period different lines of evidence support an out-of-Africa Mesolithic migration to the Levant by northeastern African groups that had biological affinities with sub-Saharan populations. From a genetic point of view, several recent genetic studies have shown that subSanaran genetic lineages (affiliated with the Y-chromosome PN2 clade; Underhill et al. 2001) have spread through Egypt into the Near East, the Mediterranean area, and, for some lineages, as far north as Turkey (E3b-M35 Y lineage; Cinniogclu et al. 2004; Luis et al. 2004), probably during several dispersal episodes since the Mesolithic (Cinniogelu et al. 2004; King et al. 2008; Lucotte and Mercier 2003; Luis et al. 2004; Quintana-Murci et al. 1999; Semino et al. 2004; Underhill et al. 2001). This finding is in agreement with morphological data that suggest that populations with sub-Saharan morphological elements were present in northeastern Africa, from the Paleolithic to at least the early Holocene, and diffused northward to the Levant and Anatolia beginning in the Mesolithic. 

Indeed, the rare and incomplete Paleolithic to early Neolithic skeletal specimens found in Egypt - such as the 33,000-year-old Nazlet Khater specimen (Pinhasi and Semai 2000), the Wadi Kubbaniya skeleton from the late Paleolithic site in the upper Nile valley (Wendorf et al. 1986), the Qarunian (Faiyum) early Neolithic crania (Henneberg et al. 1989; Midant-Reynes 2000), and the Nabta specimen from the Neolithic Nabta Playa site in the western desert of Egypt (Henneberg et al. 1980) - show, with regard to the great African biological diversity, similarities with some of the sub-Saharan middle Paleolithic and modern sub-Saharan specimens. 


This affinity pattern between ancient Egyptians and sub-Saharans has also been noticed by several other investigators (Angel 1972; Berry and Berry 1967, 1972; Keita 1995) and has been recently reinforced by the study of Brace et al. (2005), which clearly shows that the cranial morphology of prehistoric and recent northeast African populations is linked to sub-Saharan populations (Niger-Congo populations). These results support the hypothesis that some of the Paleolithic-early Holocene populations from northeast Africa were probably descendents of sub-Saharan ancestral populations...... This northward migration of northeastern African populations carrying sub-Saharan biological elements is concordant with the morphological homogeneity of the Natufian populations (Bocquentin 2003), which present morphological affinity with sub-Saharan populations (Angel 1972; Brace et al. 2005). 

In addition, the Neolithic revolution was assumed to arise in the late Pleistocene Natufians and subsequently spread into Anatolia and Europe (Bar-Yosef 2002), and the first Anatolian farmers, Neolithic to Bronze Age Mediterraneans and to some degree other Neolithic-Bronze Age Europeans, show morphological affinities with the Natufians (and indirectly with sub-Saharan populations; Angel 1972; Brace et al. 2005), in concordance with a process of demie diffusion accompanying the 
extension of the Neolithic revolution (Cavalli-Sforza et al. 1994)."


---Cranial Discrete Traits in a Byzantine Population and Eastern Mediterranean Population Movements
F. X. Ricaut, M. Waelkens. Human Biology, Volume 80, Number 5, October 2008, pp. 535-564

 

Compiled Archives of the Nile Valley Study Group
2003-2010

Home | Quotations | Misc Notes | Notes 2 | Hair | DemicDiff | Diversity | DNA| Asian IQ | Keita2008 data | BloodDebunk3

Egypt in Africa Black-Greek-DNA links | Notes 3 |Notes 4| Notes 5 | Notes 6 | Notes 7 | Misc news clips | Ethiopians | Nubians
African Tmeline
| Mesopotamia | Egypt- A Tropical Civ | Notes8| Notes 9 | Notes 10 | Notes 11

Link to research papers and articles: (wysinger.homestead.com/keita.html) 

Link to current African DNA research: (http://exploring-africa.blogspot.com/) 

Google Search- other data
www.nilevalleypeoples.blogspot.com/2010/09/blog-post_06.html

Home page
index.htm

Image gallery
imagegallery.htm

 

2007<