The Chong Asparagus Plow  1926-1941

[home][1870][1880][1890][1900][1910][1920][1930][1940][Borden][Plow Patents][Patent Case]
 


Isleton Bridge

Steamboat Slough Bridge

Ryde Asparagus Farm, 1940

Rio Vista Bridge

Chong brothers Madera origins

The Chong brothers,  Lee (1889-1952), Jue (1893-1941), Sam (1898-1967), Bing (1900-1979), and Look (1902-1961) were born in Borden, California,.  Borden was located along the main railroad line, a few miles south-west of Madera.  They were American citizens by birth, and attended public "country" schools near Borden and Madera.  The Chong children grew up among white students, as they were the only Chinese-American children in town.  Their parents Leong Yee Chong and Shee Chong had two daughters  Moy (1891-1935) and Lin (1894-1951)

Both sisters married at early ages of15 and 17, both to Chinese businessmen, in exchange for a monetary marriage fee.  Their father was born in 1844 in the Chinese village Luk Yee Tau, Louh Leung, i.e. Leung surname. The village is in Nam Long district.  Around 1860 he had married his first wife in China, and had a son and a daughter.  But economic living conditions were difficult, and he emmigrated from this southern, coastal area of China, to the United States around 1865 to work on Union Pacific railroad construction.  By 1872 the Union Pacific railroad was completed down the Sacramento and San Joaquin Valley to the new town of Borden.  By then he was 28 years old, and Yee Chung, as he was commonly known in the Madera area, quit working on the railroads to seek fortune in gold mining in the foothills.  He discovered enough gold to start a general merchandise store, Yee Chung Company, in bustling downtown of Borden in 1875.  At the time, Madera did not exist; whereas, Borden was a lively place, with hotels, stores, restaurants, stables and so forth.  Many immigrant laborers would hang around Borden on weekends, to party and get away from their boredom of work.  But when a lumber company decided to build a flume from the mountains to start a lumber mill, the Borden landowners made a fatal mistake of asking too much money for the land.  Instead, the mill was built in the present town of Madera, and Borden began a rapid decline of its population and businesses.  However, Yee Chung was able to maintain his store through the 1880's.  In 1887 he traveled to San Francisco, and for an arranged a marriage.  His first four children were born at the store, as the family had lived in the rear of the building.  Yee Chung gamely hung onto his store through 1895, and then finally closed it, since "there was no more business."   Recalling his farming roots in China, he shifted to fruit orchard farming, and began a large fruit orchard business on leased Dorn ranch lands, a mile south-west of Borden and four miles from Madera.

Yee Chung became very successful at farming the fruit orchards, planting most of the early fruit orchard acreage southwest of Madera, and selling the crops to markets up and down the Central Valley.  He was very well-known in Borden and Madera, and assimilated into the community.  He would teach white farmers in the art of operating the fruit orchards.  It was reported he was the "whitest" Chinaman in Madera.  He had learned English over the years, which allowed him to make friends with white farmers and businessmen, to lease the D. S. Dorn ranch from white landowners, and to hire Chinese laborers in the area.  But with success came a sudden death in April 1902, exactly three months before his last son Look was born.  There was a big court fight in the Madera County Courthouse, between the coroner and Yee Chung's family over who would get rights to administer his estate.  A fist fight broke out between the two lawyers, over allegations that Yee Chung had a second family in China, and that therefore his Madera children were "illegitimate".  The family's lawyer won both the fist fight settled at the local gym during the recess, as well as the court case.  The family continued to live in Borden on the Dorn ranch for awhile, before moving to the Emma and Roberts ranches, living off the estate money and money from marriage of their daughter Moy to a merchant, Sun Kow, from Coulterville.  But the estate money ran out by 1910, and the family was forced to take to the train to San Francisco and move into a rooming house in San Francisco.   Life was a struggle while in San Francisco, to keep food on the table with the meager earnings from the oldest sons Lee and Jue.  But they soon realized their low-paid jobs would leave them in poverty, quite apart from the good life they had from the store and farms they lived in Borden.

Oldest sons Lee and Jue begin farming on Grand Island

Upon learning of farming opportunites in the Sacramento river delta, the oldest sons Lee and Jue moved in 1911-12 to the George Beleney ranch on Grand Island, located on Leary Road just of Ryde.  Since most farm laborers could not speak English, the two brothers quickly establish themselves as foreman to manage the immigrant farm laborers.  By December, 1912, the Beleney family trusted Lee and Jue to lease their entire 563-acre ranch for one year for $14,000/year, with rights to five-year extensions upon satisfactory completion of the first year.  The Beleney ranch was one of the larger ranches on Grand Island.  Lee eventually stayed for three five-year extensions until 1928.

By the end of 1923, the four younger Chong brothers decided to start their own farm, and leave their oldest brother Lee to manage the farm workers on the Beleney ranch.  In December 1923, Jue and Bing Chong signed a 10-year lease for $9,000/year for the J. D. McCarthy ranch on Grand Island, just north of the Isleton bridge.   The U.S. Supreme Court had just affirmed California's Asian Land Laws, which restricted Japanese from renting or leasing farm land.  The McCarthy family was cautious, and decided against renewal of their prior lease to a Japanese farmer, to avoid breaking the law.  Instead, they leased their farm to the Chong brothers.  After World War I, prices for farm crops continued to plummet through the 1920's, and the dominance of large canneries in the delta controlled prices.  Making a good living by farming asparagus, pears, and other crops was difficult.  But they used their collective knowledge of farming to realize that the many, old asparagus farms were in dire need of a new, essential service.   In the meantime, the eldest brother Lee moved in 1928 to the huge 880-acre E. L. Shelley ranch on Grand Island near Howard Landing Ferry, later being re-joined by youngest brother Look.  Lee and Look become known as the largest open-land farmers in the area.  In the early 1930's, Lee moved his home base to the Hart Smith Jr ranch west of Isleton, but continued to farm the Shelley ranch.  The Smith ranch had a 4-story mansion, which was the big attraction for Lee to move his family.

Jue, Look, and Sam Chong Invent Asparagus Plow with Tony Miller

As asparagus plants became old and unproductive, farmers have to uproot the plants and start other crops.  But unless the roots could be throughly ridden, the asparagus plants and spears would continue to grow among the new crops.  Prior attempts at developing mechanized plows to chop up the old asparagus roots were not successful.  Jue Chong started a partnership with a friend, Tony Miller, and approached the Bank of Isleton for a loan to develop an asparagus plow.  But they were turned down, as the venture was felt to be too risky.  But they persevered, and developed the first "Miller and Chong" asparagus plow in 1926.  The Miller and Chong plow soon gained local notoriety for its success.  Jue involved his brothers Sam, Bing, and Look in the development and maintenance of the plows they manufactured, and used to plow the old asparagus fields.

Jue Chong never got married, but achieved his greatest success by the plow invention.  Jue and his younger brothers Look and Sam were very good with farm machinery, and mechanically inclined.  Bing was more into accounting and keeping the ledger books, having had some high school education.   Jue Chong had the original idea for the asparagus plow, and with the technical and hands-on help of his brothers, they were able to invent and refine the asparagus plow into the first reliable plow that could churn the old fields without breaking down.  In order to obtain US Patents, they partnered with Tony Miller, since awarding US Patents to Chinese, even American born citizens, would have not been possible.  Tony Miller also became the front-man, for marketing the plow services to major asparagus landowners and corporations, including Del Monte.  All in all, this was a great team.  Tony and the brothers worked together, and hunted together.

In order to buy into the partnership, the Chong brothers loaned Tony Miller the money to buy into the partnership.  Together, they farmed  and crafted, invented the asparagus plow in 1926. This automated plowing of fields previously used for asparagus crops .  The two pictures below show their early plow design in January, 1927.  Miller and the Chong brothers would eventually be awarded seven U.S. Patents for design of the blades and the plow machinery.  They later would manufacture more than 90 asparagus plows, each unit numbered and improving upon the prior design.  Miller and Chong maintained their shop at the McCarthy ranch, where they constantly crafted and sharpened the blades for the plows, and manufactured the machinery.  In 1933, with his brother-in-law Chan Tai Oy's Tong Sun Company facing bankruptcy, and very few people having much income or money for investment, Jue Chong offerred to provide the financial capital for Tai Oy start a new produce company, the General Produce Company.  The old company was allowed to go bankrupt, and the original Tong Sun partners not involved in Genral Produce.  Instead, three of the Chong brothers became equal partners with Tai Oy:  Jue, Bing, and Sam.  The investment would prove to have long-term benefits to the family.   Bing became most involved with the produce company, while his brothers continued to farm and operate the plow business.   When Bing, Sam, and Jue moved to live in Sacramento, the plow business was turned over to Look Chong -- who continued to live on the Wolf ranch.  When Look died in 1960, Donald Leong went to look for the latest plow invention, with its latest refinements in steel blade and drum technology.   They were auctioning off all the old equipment, and remaining plows.  He asked May Chong, who responded, "Knowing the business was coming to an end, Look took a torch to the latest plow investions and destroyed it -- so its inventions would remain secret!" 

One would think that its not just welding steel together, and designing a suitably rugged gearbox, but also the blades and other components had to be heat treated to attain greater toughness in the steel blades, maintaining sharpness, while avoiding excess hardening embittlement that would cause cracking.  When they first developed the plow, the high speed rotating drum and its numerous blades imposed a huge torque on the drum and its drive train.  The brothers Bing and Sam invented an extremely rugged gearbox to withstand the huge forces, while matching the power output of the current tractors.  Catepillar turned them down, when Catepillar was shown their design -- they said Catepillar would have new, stronger gearbox when Catepillar design it themselves.  So the brothers approached another gearbox manufacturer, who helped them with grinding the gears and welding the components into a useful device.  At first, the torque being handled by the gearset was too large, and the case would fail.  To reduce the load, the number of cutter blades on the drum was reduced to avoid breaking the case.
 




 

Because the Paris Brothers crafted a rotary asparagus plow of similar design, Miller and Chong filed a claim for patent infringement against Leon Paris of Rio Vista, and Fred Paris of Berkeley.  The lawsuit focused on the claimed novel cutter blade design, whereby the leading and trailing blade edges were "substantially" equi-distant from the rotation axis.  Both plows used a rotary design, whereby large blades, or claws, were mounted on steel beams to a chain-driven, horizontal axle, which was powered from the tractor engine.  The plow would spin in the forward direction at about 190 rpm.  Tony Miller and the Chong brothers made money by subcontracting plowing of asparagus fields, digging up roots of old asparagus plants no longer productive.   The business was highly profitable, and competitive.  Asparagus harvesting was performed daily by hand.  The Miller and Chong plow was so good that they could guarantee their work; that is, they would warrant that no more than a small fraction of 1% of the asparagus plants would re-grow.  Prior plots by other people could not provide the same guarantee, and their plows were usually scrapped after trials.  In many instances, the farmers would not pay for the work, so Miller and Chong performed the work for no cost.  But in each case, the farmers eventually repaid for the plow services.

From Mary O'Connell on the Asparagus Plow:  Tony Miller and Jue Chong were in the Rio Vista area with their asparagus plow in the 1930's.  Photographs of the Miller & Chong asparagus were taken by Al Avila, copied onto 35 mm slides by Irwin Anderson, then given by Raymond Anderson to Mary B. O'Connell of the Rio Vista Museum

References:  Irwin (b. 1928); Raymond (b. 1921).  The person above standing next to the asparagus plow is likely Tony Miller, who was tall; whereas, Jue Chong was short.  The picture was taken ~1933-37.

From Raymond Anderson, September 2001:    Ray remembers Tony Miller who had farmed in the Ryde area, and recalls Miller partnering with Jue Chong on a ranch  just up river and west of the Isleton Bridge, now Frank Silva's place.  See Jue Chong and Tony Miller at the right at the McCarthy Ranch in 1931.   The Paris Brothers of Rio Vista also designed an asparagus plow, and copied key features of the Miller & Chong plow.  The Paris Brothers manufactured their plow both for resale and for working asparagus fields near the Antioch Bridge until about 1935.  As a result of the Paris Brothers patent infringement, Miller & Chong filed a lawsuit that went on for several years in the 1930's.  Ray in not certain how the lawsuit was settled.  He also recalls a dispute between Miller and Jue Chong, but it did not affect their partnership.  Ray did not recall Sam or Look Chong at the ranch assisting with the plow design and maintenance.

The first tractor to pull the Miller & Chong asparagus plow was a Caterpillar Sixty (2 ), it did not have enough power.   Their original Cat Sixty had a 4-cylinder gasoline engine with 72 horsepower, and 12,360 pounds of pulling power, and three-speed transmission.  For greater pulling power, Miller & Chong switched to the new Caterpillar RD 8 with a big diesel engine, and put in an extra transmission to give it enough torque at the right speed.  Note the massive Cat D-8 with plow in photo below right, ~1931-37 (D-8 introduced 1931).  There is extra room between the seat and back of the hood.  The extra length was necessary to insert the extra transmission for increased gear reduction and pulling power.  The plow was driven at high-speed ~200 rpm via a chain-drive off the tractor engine.  The plow created quite a dust storm and tremendous amount of noise.  Until the Cat RD-8 was manufactured, most tractors were underpowered, which required the novel invention of the asparagus plow to pulverize the ground.

Al Avila and his brother worked for Miller and Chong, driving their tractors to plow the asparagus fields.  One time, while Al's brother was raising the plow, the hoist mechanism didn't work.  While trying to get it up one evening, he lost an arm or leg.   Ray doesn't remember which; but from the patent drawing, he probably got an arm or leg and clothing caught in the chain mechanisms.  The crew did not find him until the next morning, in much pain.   He survived the accident.  Ouch.  Shown standing alongside the Cat RD-8 with Miller & Chong plow is probably Al Avila's brother (picture below taken in the 1930's); Al was born 1929.   Irwin and Raymond's father, Holger Anderson, had a sheep and grain farm in the Montezuma Hills above Rio Vista.

Ray recalls 1937, when he and his dad Holger Anderson had their Cat 60 hauled on a contracted cliber truck with a tag axle trailer from their Montezuma Hills ranch to Sherman Island, where they had a small farm with asparagus and other crops.   They took the Cat 60, since it was the biggest, meanest tractor they had, and would surely get the job done quickly.  While they were there, the Miller & Chong Cat RD-8 with plow was working the fields on the Barofaldi Land next door and got stuck.  The crew said the land was so soft they were constantly getting stuck, and their tractor had insufficient power to pull the plow in the soft ground.  So the Andersons used their Cat 60 to pull it out.  Irwin was just 8 at the time.  Holger decided against paying to have their tractor hauled back to their farm above Rio Vista, and decided to drive the Cat 60 back.  For their return, they had only a half set of tractor street shoes, meaning one street shoe on every other location.  Ray vividly and humorously recalls driving the monster Cat 60 across the Three Mile Island Bridge and breaking loose some cement on the bridge supports, caused by the tractor inducing high vibrations in the old bridge.  At the time, the Three Mile Island Bridge was a rotating design like the Sacramento I Street Bridge.  They finished crossing the bridge and proceeded to the east end of the Rio Vista Bridge.  To avoid damaging the Rio Vista Bridge, they left the tractor at McKinnon Ranch, and went looking for more shoes.  They went to the Catepillar dealer, which informed them that Jue Chong probably had an extra set in their shop.  So they went up to the Miller & Chong ranch just north and west of the Isleton Bridge on Grand Island.  When Jue Chong saw and recognized Holger Anderson, Jue gave them a half set of street shoes.  Jue said to keep them, since he no longer needed them.  But the incident cost Holger $500 for the bridge repairs.  The Miller & Chong later became the Silva Brothers Ranch, where Silva's wife still lives.

Ray said they planted the 'grass roots very deep; as the 'grass grew older it was nearer the surface, so the plow only went as deep as was necessary.  They used the plow to dig up old roots from asparagus plants no longer useful for production.  So the plow did not have to plow deeply for this operation.  The asparagus plow would grind up the ground and roots about one foot deep, leaving finely pulverized soil in its wake, ready for planting other crops.  Donald Leong said the plow was so effective, that if you walked onto the plowed field you could sink into the soft ground up to your knees!  Perhaps, the chopped asparagus roots and dirt made a fluffy, lightweight mixture.

During 1935-37, the Andersons dug up their last asparagus plants from their Sherman Island ranch.  Italians and Portugese ran most of the asparagus farms, which moved on to the Stockton area in the late 30's.  Subsequent attempts to replant asparagus on the same fields did not produce lasting yields, having depleted the ground.

Ray recalls another interesting incident for those familiar with striped bass fishing under the "towers" south of Rio Vista.  The towers refers to the two huge towers that allow the main power lines to traverse the Sacramento River.  One tower was on Sherman Island, and the other on Montezuma Hill.   Their crew had been working on a 12 foot high windmill tower under the Montezuma hills end of the electric lines, when a large ship was steaming up the channel.  The ship forgot to lower its boom, and caught one of the power lines.  His crew heard a very loud snap, as the line broke.  They scurried down from the windmill as fast as they could, and ran for cover.  Luckily, no one was hurt.

Another possible source of information is August Coreia of Isleton, who attended Isleton Schools, and was friends with Al Avila.  His association with Avila, who worked for Miller & Chong, may offer further insight.  August Coreia referred to Dayly Lee of Walnut Grove for more information.  Dayly is living in Sacramento, but still farming on Ryer Island.   Mabel Rogers of Isleton recalls her brother drove the tractors for the Miller and Chong plow.

Sam Chong's step-grandson Mike Lim had heard that Jue and Sam Chong's plow design had been stolen, and perhaps patented.  He heard his grandfather had to modify their plow design. because of another plow design that had copied the Miller and Chong plow features.  Miller and Chong were granted seven U.S. Patents on the plow and implements from 1929-1933, and the Paris brothers at least five U.S. Patents from 1933-1937.   In reality, Tony Miller and the Chong brothers sued the Paris brothers for patent infringement on their blade design for the asparagus plow.  The Miller and Chong vs Paris Brothers lawsuit in the U.S. District Court ran from 1934 to1936, shortly after both groups were granted plow patents in 1933.  The long running patent dispute was eventually settled unfavorably to Miller and Chong, having focused on one patent involving the blade geometries.  The patent was deemed to be "not a valid invention," and Miller and Chong had to pay court costs of $160.  This could have led to Jue Chong getting ulcers, and may have led to his early death at 48.  Jue Chong worried a lot, perhaps over the patent disputes.

Fred F. Paris  (1891-1964) of Berkeley was a Stanford graduate, working as an excavation contractor.  His experience with rotary trench plows lent to design of an asparagus plow for his brother Leon A. Paris (1892-1967).  Americo Vernon Avila, 1929-1993, born CA, died Solano Co, Al was about 65 when died per August Coreia's wife.  Tony Stephen Miller, 1897-1985, died Sacramento Co.  Holger Walter Anderson (1883-1941):  immigrated from Denmark, and died in Solano County.

The following picture are from the Bing Chong family picture albums and archives, currently maintained by Bing's wife Jane Chong (2001).
 

Eddie Chan of Sacramento (1913-2001):  Jue lived on a ranch, but he died pretty young in 1941, just 48.  The asparagus plow quite famous, indeed.  They made a lot of money.   Because patents are granted only for 17 years, Tony Miller and Jue Chong's patent would have expired by the late 1940's.  Now a lot of people have asparagus plows.  Jue made a lot of money, when money was scarce in those days.  Jue's savings was instrumental in providing the necessary capital to help start General Produce in 1933.  What about Sam?  He maintained the asparagus plow, lived on the ranch, then married Rose Chong and he moved up to the corner house at 13th and W Streets in Sacramento.  Then Look got married to Dan Yee's sister May.  Look died when he was 59 years old.  Look spent his life farming a big ranch, across the river and just north of Isleton.  Jue Chong told him, "Don't farm that ranch, it's too big for you.  You're gonna lose your butt."  And sure enough, he put the money into the ranch and lost everything.  He made the mistake of going into partnership with a white accountant, who embezzled all the money from Look's share of the plow business.  Being an accountant, his partner manipulated the books, and took Look for a bundle of money.  When they caught up with the accountant, he committed suicide.

Ed Jow of Sacramento (1927-2001):   Ed remembered Jue Chong as being a nice guy.  He said he was aced out of the money for the asparagus plow.  Whether it was his partner or someone else, he didn't know since he was a teenager at the time.  Ed said the Chong brothers, Sam, Look and Jue always bought them ice cream ...  as for LE Chong, he said the guy was always grumpy.  Ed past away just one month at end of September, shortly after being interviewed.

Connie King of Locke (2001:  Connie King knew Jue Chong from when she was a waitress in Isleton.  He used to come in for lunch.  In one of their first encounters, he paid 15 cents for a meal, then left 10 cents on the counter.  She gave  him back the 10 cents, but then he told her it was for a tip.  She didn't know what a tip was, and that was her first one. Jue was a quiet, soft-spoken gentleman.   She thought Jue Chong was a very nice person.  She made $25 a month at the restaurant.  In those days you were expected to leave the family at 15 or 16 and go out on your own, she said.  She remembers when Lois died, that it was especially hard on Grandpa Di Hong Jow, that he would go out in the yard every night crying out for her.  She believes it was Steamboat Slough that her father used to rowboat across to visit the Jows.  In Isleton, grandma Jow and her mother used to get together a lot and talk about everything.  Unfortunately they used a different dialect which she was unable to understand.  Yes, she remembers them talking about the two Jow sons, but that they left town.


Asparagus (Asparagus officinalis var. altilis L.) is a hardy perennial vegetable native to the seacoasts of Europe and eastern Asia, where it has been cultivated for over 2,000 years. It was a well known and valued vegetable to both the Greeks and Romans. Early settlers brought asparagus to North America, where it has been grown in home gardens since colonial times. Commercial asparagus production began in this country in the middle of the nineteenth century.  The word asparagus comes from the Greek asparagus, meaning shoot or sprout. 

Tips for growing asparagus.  Be sure soils are at a high fertility level prior to planting new asparagus. It is a good practice to plow under a green manure crop such as alfalfa or vetch, or to plow under 10 or more tons per acre of barnyard manure. Plow under deeply all fertilizer materials.  The asparagus roots can grow 10 feet deep, thereby taking advantage of deeply plowed manure.

Two years are required to establish an asparagus field, but once into production plantings endure from 10 to 20 years.  Average yields in California and Washington are between 2,500-3,000 pounds per acre. 

Continued
____________________________________
 Send comments or materials to Feedback


Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1