by Larry Pedrie
Head Coach of the Chicago Chill
Former Head Coach of the University of Illinois Flames
Having been in athletics my entire life, both as a player and a coach, I often find myself confronted with the high degree of emphasis placed
upon winning. As a player I have always had a deep desire to win and a hatred for losing. I don't like to admit it, but I remember as a
3rd grader punching a classmate for his failure to hit the ball over the net in a gym class volleyball game. I have carried this desire to
win and hatred toward losing my entire life... and it's still there.
As I began coaching, losing became even more personal. I no longer had the opportunity to physically participate and directly affect the
game's outcome. My first and most lengthy coaching experience lasted 15 years and was at the Division I NCAA College hockey level. I am now
beginning my second year of coaching at the youth level, as the coach of the Chicago Chill AAA Bantam team. Having had a chance to look back
at my college coaching experience, and the opportunity to see the current direction of youth hockey, I find myself with a different attitude
toward winning. Although striving to win is extremely important, how you accomplish winning is far more important.
I believe at the youth level in all sports * (and possibly at the high school level as well) that winning should be a secondary priority, not the ultimate and only goal, as is too often the case. The primary emphasis should be placed upon the development of each and every athlete both on and off the ice. If the cost of winning a game does damage to one player's self confidence, desire or interest in the sport then ultimately as coaches we have failed. I cannot accept the thought of sitting a weaker player(s) on the bench in an effort to win a game. The amount of humiliation and embarrassment that players feel and take from that game is far more significant than any positive that may have come from "winning" the game.
The decision as to how much playing time a child receives should not be based upon that child's ability or lack thereof. Instead, we should
be teaching and rewarding the values of effort, discipline, coachability and team play. We should be instilling confidence, encouraging
success, identifying mistakes, and providing the opportunity to correct mistakes. Penalize a player because of laziness and selfishness, but
not for lack of ability.
Youth sports are not about the "strong surviving". We are here to create the "strong" from all of our participants. Each and every child deserves the opportunity to compete, feel a valuable part of the team, and be provided the opportunity to develop as a player and person. If people, especially young people, do not feel good about themselves, development will stagnate.
Coaches must realize that they may be destroying the possibility of any future development by limiting the opportunity to play. If a child
feels like a failure at hockey, his/her self-confidence toward everything he/she does may be diminished. None of us can predict when
development in any individual will begin, accelerate or decline. If provided the opportunity to develop, a weak player in a year's time may
become the best player. However, none can develop if not given the incentive and opportunity to do so.
As coaches, we must decide why we are involved and what motivates our decisions. If winning is our ultimate goal, the damage caused may far
outweigh the positive experiences. If coaches can simply understand that their main reason for involvement is the kids, then all of us will
be winners.
* Note: The Palmyra Ice Hockey Association fully endorses the philosophy in this
article for our developmental teams at the Junior High and JV levels. On
these teams, learning individual skills and positional play (teamwork)
is stressed, and their practices are designed to focus on the development
of these skills. We strive to keep ice time during games as equal as possible
based on attitude, effort and willingness to learn, not ability. Our older and higher-skilled players are often assigned
to lines with our younger players. They are encouraged to develop their
leadership qualities and help our younger players develop their skills
in game situations.
By design, the CPIHL is intended to be as competitive as possible at the
Varsity level. Individual skills and commitment to teamwork are assumed
at this level of play, and as an organization we focus more on developing
the playmaking skills and on-ice "vision" required to win games.
Since we consider competition to be an important part of player development
at this level, positions on the Varsity team are earned at the coaching staff's discretion. They base their selections on player ability and the number of open bench
slots available - by position.
Ice time during Varsity games is earned, based solely on the skills players demonstrate through their performance in practice as well as in games. Playing with a "short bench" in competitive games or on special teams (power plays and penalty kills) is a normal occurrence at this level; it rewards those players who excel in their positions.