Orwell's view of a true communist state cannot exist. Animal
farm starts a communist state, but ending in a totalitarian
state. A totalitarian state means the government total
control over people. However, a true communist state works
without a government because everybody is equal.
Communism cannot succeed because everyone is selfish, lazy
and greedy!
My personal view of human nature is that human nature
is that humans are generally selfish and greedy. I believe
that pure communism is impossible to accomplish and cannot
exist. Because the essence of being humans is not perfect,
everybody will become selfish and lazy. For example, if one
works hard and produces more products than others, but he
gets the same pay as others, I believe he will become lazy
with time. Why should one want to share his labor and
achievement with lazy people? Therefore, the instinct of
depravation is deeply hidden in every human’s personality.
When circumstance changes, the bad qualities rise to the
surface. When people work without profits to motivate them,
the economy will eventually collapse causing the government
to fall apart: look at Russia’s government to overnight
collapse. Because capitalism is a private economy, people
work for themselves. One can freely pursue profit and earn
money for themselves. When everybody works hard for their
money and devotes himself or herself to society, the society
becomes more prosperous and affluent.
(Teacher's
comment: Overall, very good ! See
comments 93% )
Back