For
advert-free site go to
www.palad.org.uk
PALAD believes that policy on all non-medicinal
drugs should be integrated so that both legal and
illegal drugs are included. All drugs can cause harm.
Instead of discriminating between legal and illegal
drugs, policy should discriminate between reasonably
safe use and harmful use for each and every drug. It
should encourage any healthy use, tolerate reasonably
safe use, educate against use harmful to the user and
legislate only against use harmful to others. A crime
must involve someone harming another, not only
themselves. People have a greater right to risk
harming themselves than they do to risk harming
others. There is no health justification for the
restriction of free trade in illegal drugs within
nations and internationally. We believe all tax
revenue from the legal drugs trade, £20 billion a
year, should be ring-fenced to fund drug education
for all, treatment for users harming themselves and
enforcement against users harming others.
All drugs can be used harmfully, not just illegal
drugs. Alcohol Concern and ASH both feel that the
prohibition of illegal drugs gives the false
impression, especially to young people, that legal
drugs are safer than illegal ones. The Home Affairs
Select Committee report Government Drugs Policy:
Is it Working? states that "legal drugs,
such as tobacco and alcohol, are responsible for far
greater damage both to individual health and to the
social fabric in general than illegal ones". We
agree with the Home Office guidance "we need to
continue referring to alcohol, tobacco and caffeine
as drugs" and the Government's 10 Year
Strategy for Tackling Drug Misuse when it says
"legally obtainable substances such as alcohol,
tobacco ... should ... be addressed ... within the
strategy". The Welsh Assembly's Tackling
Substance Misuse in Wales states that
"Substance misuse ... involves both illegal and
legal substances" and that "This strategy
covers the full range of substances that are misused
in Wales".
The reality of drug use is that:
- All drugs can cause harm.
- Most drugs can be used relatively safely
[tobacco seems to be the exception].
- All drugs can cause harm to the user if used
excessively.
- All drugs can cause harm to others if used
without consideration for others
(drug-driving, passive smoking).
A fair and rational drugs policy that reflects
this reality would:
- INTEGRATE illegal and legal drug policies
since all drug use may cause harm.
- DISCRIMINATE instead between reasonably safe
use, use harmful to user and use harmful to
others.
- TOLERATE reasonably safe use.
- EDUCATE against harm to users.
- LEGISLATE only against harm to others.
- ELIMINATE unjustifiable barriers to fair
trade.
Prohibitionists fear the legal introduction of
more drugs into society believing this would increase
the harmful use of drugs. Anti-prohibitionists
support the rights of illegal drug users to take
their drugs reasonably safely or only risking harm to
themselves - equal rights with legal drug users.
PALAD's focus attempts to resolve this conflict by
defining and tackling drug harm alone for each and
every drug while supporting the rights of all,
especially users of legal drugs and young people, to
take all non-medicinal drugs safely. It is vital that
education, not legislation, is used to minimise
self-harm through drug use. Only then can people take
responsibility for their own health and exercise
informed choice.
We believe mentioning the phrase 'drug legalisation'
sends the wrong message to prohibitionists who may be
genuinely concerned about limiting drug misuse; we
prefer the phrases 'reformed drug policy' or 'proper
regulation of illegal drugs'.
We believe that the integration of legal and
illegal drug policy is the single most vital issue.
Once that occurs then the subsequent policy steps
above become inevitable.
NEXT PAGE: