"It was more exciting to
find than the Titanic because to me the Titanic is just a shipwreck," Thomas
Dettweiler, who led the search teams for both vessels, told Agence France-Presse aboard
his boat. "With the Titanic most people have died who had any connection with it, but
with the Dakar it's still living."
On Sunday, 31 years after the ship was lost at sea, Israel officially went into
mourning. Newspapers printed pictures of each downed naval crewman and officer, pictures
frozen in time. Israel Radio played somber music, and, repeatedly, a recording of the
final transmission from the ship -- a musical tribute to the ship sung by its new crew.
In a place where the ritual of burial is a national obsession, many urged the
government to try to raise the submarine from the deep to retrieve whatever human remains
might exist after all this time.
"I pray that they will pull the submarine from the sea and bring the boys to
burial in Israel so we will have somewhere to go and cry," Shmuel Shenfer, whose son
Reuven was aboard, told Itim, the Israeli news agency.
In a disturbing coda to the Dakar saga, a former navy commander, Adm. Michael Barkai,
killed himself hours after hearing that the submarine had been located. His brother, Maj.
Avraham Barkai, had been the ship's deputy commander.
The admiral, whose decorated navy career ended abruptly 20 years ago after he stood
trial and was acquitted on sexual assault charges, had been sick with cancer.
In January 1968, an Israeli crew set out from Portsmouth, England, to introduce the new
submarine into the Israeli naval fleet. Purchased from the British, the World War II-era
vessel had been refurbished and proudly inaugurated before the journey.
Just off Crete, the ship sent what would be its final message to shore, including the
group warbling of a giddy, prideful tribute to the new craft, written by Avraham Barkai:
"The Dakar is in the depths in full strength," they sang.
Then the ship disappeared. For two weeks, the Israeli navy searched, with help from
other navies. In mid-February, Moshe Dayan, then the defense minister, and senior military
officials pronounced the hunt futile.
"The day the Dakar was declared sunk with all hands aboard has remained indelibly
etched on my soul," Zeev Schiff, the military editor of Haaretz, wrote Sunday. Schiff
described how a crowd of the crew's relatives, gathered at a naval base, was stunned into
silence after officials proclaimed the search to be over.
Schiff continued: "Then, one voice started wailing, and the floodgate of tears was
let loose as an untamed cry of bereavement arose from the hundreds of voices in unison.
The mood swung from grief to pandemonium, as everyone stormed the podium."
Dayan, he said, sneaked out the back door.
About a year after the initial search was called off, the submarine's emergency buoy
washed up on the coast off the Gaza Strip. The navy made the assumption that the boat had
veered from its course to go down in relatively shallow waters off Egypt. That assumption
governed a new round of searches for the Dakar, which were made easier after Israel signed
a peace treaty with Egypt.
Two years ago, under continuing pressure from the relatives of the crew, the navy asked
for help from the United States, which assisted with further explorations. A few months
ago, American Nauticus Corp., which discovered the remains of the Titanic, was hired by
Israel to use its advanced technology to sweep the ocean floor. With sonar gear and
robot-guided deep-sea cameras, the Dakar was found about 300 miles west of Israel --
precisely on its original course.
The submarine had vanished, though, during an era when delicately balanced superpower
rivalries were being fought out beneath the seas, when Israel and Egypt were still enemies
and when Soviet and Egyptian fleets dotted the Mediterranean.
Its mysterious disappearance inevitably spawned any number of theories, and the mystery
will not be resolved for some time, if ever. An initial examination of the submarine
suggested that it did not sink because of an enemy attack, but more likely because of a
technical malfunction, human error or a collision.
Brig. Gen. Gideon Raz, a former deputy commander in the Israeli navy, visited the site
of the wreck Sunday and observed the submarine through an underwater camera. He said that
the front section was whole, the middle section damaged and the rear section separated
from the main body. Parts were spread about the ocean floor.
"I think we can say that it was not caused by a large explosion, or explosives, or
ammunition," he said. "One thing is clear, given that the pieces did not spread
over a large radius: It fell almost whole until the end of its fall.'