Yahoo! GeoCities
Some parents choose to do the dairy free version of SCD,thus remaining
GFCF.Other parents give their children goat milk yogurt
to promote healthy gut microorganisms.I have included reports from
both groups I am reporting on all the cases that I know about.Those that
showed improvements and those that need more work to show improvements.
Most of these reports were posted on these yahoo groups:SCDietkids and ElainesChildren.
Patricia ,who started the yahoo group Recovered Kids,said the following
on post 5261 of Recovered Kids.
Yes,The dairy-free version of the SCD diet was a miracle for both my
kids. It recovered my daughter and saved my NT son from wasting away.
Patricia
*******************************************************
Alison Bucci wrote this post,#123, on SCDietkids --- In SCDietkids@y...,
alibucci@a... wrote:
I am Mom to Peter, age 6, ASD/IBD. He went on the GF/CF diet 2 years ago
with very good results both in stools and a lifting of "brain fog". A
month later, the diarrhea returned so we eliminated corn, and the good
stools returned. The next month it was soy and the diarrhea returned.
And so on...
I read Breaking the Vicious Cycle about 3 months ago, and it made alot of
sense to me. Obviously, carbs we're a problem for Peter. He was eating a
TON of potatoes and rice (the addiction thing is always a red flag). Most
importantly, SCD is a diet which has healed thousands of adults with IBD,
and I felt that I had to do something about the GI issues before he
developed full blown Crohns or Colitis or whatever. I was going for
relief from the diarrhea and any improvement in the autism would be a
bonus. Let's face it, Autistic children with chronic diarrhea or
constipation have undiagnosed IBD. It made sense to me to try a diet
which has worked for this condition.
Unfortunately, we couldn't do the intro diet because my son won't eat
soup and I was not willing to introduce yogurt due to caesin. First we
removed potatoes, rice, and sugar. I reworked recipes to use the almond
flour and honey (the baking is a new learning curve for me ). I'm not
sure if we're 100% legal due to the supplements which I haven't checked.
Our results have been great, and he will be on this for a long time. We
immediately saw big improvements in eye contact, initiating language,
and social engagement. No other intervention has helped in these areas.
For the first month, his stools were horrible (yellow and loose), but
this has resolved and we are back to good most of the time. I definitely
think there was a die off of some of the critters and I am really glad
we stuck with it.
Another thing to consider is that SCD is a healthier diet than GF/CF
IMO. I was never comfortable with all that rice. Almond flour is very
healthy. I plan on introducing the yogurt in a few months because I
feel it will aid in the healing of his gut.
Alison
*******************************************************
Jay is the moderator of the yahoo group autism_iron.She has also been a
help to the parents on our list . -- In SCDietkids@y..., "jkrishnaa"
wrote:
I am Jay, mom to 4.7 year old boy in the spectrum. I have been
doing SCD (YES, with the yogurt) since April this year. Elaine was on
the SCDlist at that time and she helped me a lot also. I proposed to
start an SCDgroup for our kids at that time with the help of Elaine and
Jen Young. But didn't think Jen was that interested and I didn't know
any new SCD parent except some who had already been doing the diet.
Anyway, I dropped the idea.
My son has tolerated the yogurt very well and we are vegetarians also and
this had made it even tougher. I could isolate the REAL food allergies
that my son had only on SCD. The very next day after starting SCD, my son
became more alert and everybody could tell the difference. After 3 weeks
on SCD, I also did the GSE/No Fenol combo and I don't know what helped
more but my son's incredible eyecontact is back and here to stay. We did
an OAT test after 4 weeks on SCD and saw that his clostridium level had
gone from 8.5 to 4.2 , 0-0.9 being normal. Our DAN doc DR. Green was
surprised to see the results and started giving me ideas on what culture
I could use to make yogurt. He was the same person who freaked out when I
first told him about yogurt. Also, when I brought SCD up on Phoenixkids
(another group mostly talks about GFCF) not many were enthusiastic
including Dr. Green who said what WILL you feed the kids. Anyway, it was
nice to see that he was recommending this diet to his patients later.
****************************************************
Here is the story of Colin Young as told by his mother,Jen Young.It is
one of over 010 reviews of "Breaking the Vicious Cycle"on Amazon Reviewer:
Jennifer Young from Fairfax, VA USA
How can I find words to describe the miracle that is this diet?
Following it has given me back my son in a way I never dreamed possible.
Elaine's diet has cured my son's autism and his three year struggle with
GI troubles.
My son Colin, age 4 � , has struggled with GI troubles since 11 months
old. He had the ROTAvirus, chronic diarrhea,and was constantly on
steroids (for asthma) and antibiotics (for ear and lung infections). By
age two-and-a-half he was having night terrors every night. By age three,
he was labeled "failure to thrive" due to his low weight and height.He
was also diagnosed as having developmental delays (Pervasive Development
Disorder, ie Autism). He was behind in speech and motor skills...he
banged his head and stopped looking at me. My son slipped away from me!
Everyone had answers for us...the mainstream doctors (neurologists)
wanted to give him drugs. The GI doctors thought Colin had "autistic"
diarrhea and wouldn't help us. They wouldn't even do a colonoscopy on a
child who had struggle with a GI disorder for years.
The alternative doctors told us to cut out gluten and milk and use high
dosages of vitamins. Stopping gluten stopped his night terrors--but his
chronic diarrhea and delays continued. In fact, as I became a
"gluten-free" cook and branched out to new starches, Colin's symptoms
got worse.
When my son was labeled as having "high functioning autism" at age 3 1/2,
God told me to "put Colin first." So I quit my job to save my son. I
decided that instead of listening to "experts" in autism, I would listen
to my son. I knew he had answers inside him so I studied him.
I always knew Colin had a problem with food. His bizarre food cravings as
a toddler-milk, cheese, and bread-had been replaced with a craving for
gluten free waffles, potatoes, and basically all starches and complex
sugars. Some said he was allergic to these foods. But, I knew it was
impossible for him to have 30+ allergies. I also knew if food was the
problem-somehow it was the answer too.
I concluded that my son was not autistic, but instead a boy with celiac
disease or some other GI disorder. Then,thanks to a former co-worker, who
was a Celiac not cured by gluten-free living, I found Elaine's book.
Within months on Elaine's diet, my son's stools were normal for the first
time in his life! Then, he started doing complex pretend play, looking at
us, and advancing in ALL AREAS OF DEVELOPMENT. He played with toys
appropriately. He voiced his wants, needs, and questions. Oh-the glorious
why questions! He started asking me questions about God,about life, about
the seasons...and about why his tummy had always been sick. His teachers
were amazed. Our family was amazed. We know this diet saved him. We
watched it happen before our eyes. No drugs. No expensive behavioral
therapies. Just diet.
I say don't give up. When Colin couldn't digest the fruits and
veggies, we
cooked them. When he couldn't eat the almond flour-we gave him squash and
banana for carbs until he was ready for the nut flours. We didn't do the
yoghurt described in the book at first-as Colin gets asthma when he
drinks milk. Then, we started using goat's milk yoghurt instead so he
could get the good bacteria he needed to heal. If you truly want to get
well, there is always a way. But you have to have faith and be patient.
Today, my son is the picture of health. He has gained 8 pounds and five
inches in less than a year! He has a healthy glow. He has normal bowel
movements. He has a wonderful appetite too. And now-he has caught up in
almost all areas. He has friends! Next year he will be going to a
regular preschool. Some doctors and others ask us now if we have
"switched" children.
All this through food.
The other day I told my son that I was going to help a friend of his
start this diet. I was explaining about the yoghurt, almond flour, etc.
He said, "Mom, thank you," and threw his arms around me. I said, "For
what?" "For me Mom. Thank you for
IN. Thank you for making my tummy better."
Even Colin knows the power of this diet.
God bless Elaine for fighting for us all and for helping me save my son!
__________________________________________________
Marisol writes about her daughter and SCD inpost#77 of SCDietkids.Marisol
has been a great help to parents on this list
After exactly three weeks
on the diet my daughter's stools normalized completely for the first time
since she was 15 months old; she's now 8. Recently, she's been on the
diet since December, she's made tremendous gains which credit dually to
SCD and chelation. A couple months into the diet she became more
interactive with ther sister and her language expression improved. As far
as implementing the diet goes: Anna, at that point was sooooooo used to
me messing with her eating options that she essentially had a
here-we-go-again attitude about it. And, either she hasn't figured out
how to complain that she can't have what others can have, or she feels
better on the diet so doesn't complain about her restrictions.
**********************************************************************
Linda Carlton is one of the parent representative on the DAN doctors
list.She is also the moderator of autism challenge,a yahoo group.
Some
really wonderful things are beginning to happen here, and since most of
the members don't know about Forrest, he is completely non-verbal. His
autism started suddenly after his HepB vaccination, but he had been on
antibiotics during the time he had that shot. He was only seven months
old at the time, so he was unable to develop language, he even lost the
babbling that he was doing at the time. Over the years we have tried many
therapies, many diets, all kinds of supplements, treatments of all sorts.
We have got him to say a few one time words, we figure he said about 20
total words up until the age of eight. Then we started him on the Bodybio
diet, and he started talking for us then, within six months, he could say
some short sentences, or even ask a short question, we lost everything
when we tried to detox him with DMSA for heavy metal toxicity, all the
tests really showed were that he had an increase in aluminum and
antimony, nothing that suggested mercury. The SCDiet sparked my interest,
so much so that I was willing to give it a short term try out, just to
see what would happen. When I learned that I would not have to compromise
the diet that he was on (the bodybio), I became even more interested,
because we were still seeing some progress, despite what the DMSA drug
had done to him. And we had been having so many problems with getting him
to eat the foods on the bodybio diet, that sometimes it just felt
hopeless. However, when we started restricting his potatoes, rice, bread,
and noodles, he started eating lots of bananas, we then started him on a
yogurt it wasn't SCDiet legal, but we were working toward those goals.
Now we have him on a homemade SCDiet legal yogurt, and kefir from the
actual grains made with half and half cow's milk. His supplement list is
of these, bodybio oil, prometol, mastic gum, nat-stim, and cal/mag
butyrate. Last night he said 'Momma', he is going to be 11 years old
soon, and I have only heard him call me Momma four times in those years.
I cannot hardly believe how simple all this has been, and now he is
talking. He was jumping up and down on his bed last night, because I put
him in there early to settle down to sleep, and it was so funny he was
saying bad!, bad! bad! over and over, it is nothing short of a miracle!
It sure feels like one! Now what to feed him!! He picked at the pizza, he
wasn't too happy about that, and mostly he had just yogurt, kefir, and
bananas yesterday, but I can hold out a little longer to see if he can
heal some more. This is so exciting, and it was so simple! Best, Linda
************************************************************************
Ricci is the moderator of ABMD a yahoo group where ASD biomedical issues
are discussed.There are many doctors on that list. --- In abmd@y...,
Ricci wrote:
I can't say with certainty why this diet
works, but my guess is that it is a combination of the fact that so many
of our children lack the enzymes to efficiently digest sugars (supported
by published data), the imbalance of healthy flora in the gut, and
variety of other factors that varies from child to child. The bottom line
for us is that we saw some improvements upon removing gluten and dairy
from Robert's diet, but nothing compared to what other parents reported
for their children. When we implemented the SC Diet, we began to see the
kinds of leaps in progress that we have not seen with anything else other
than secretin and the addition of an air cleaner to our home.
I highly recommend you try the diet and see for yourself if it is right
for your daughter. Having been at this for awhile now, I can tell you
that I am less concerned with the reasons why things work, and I am just
grateful that there are safe, non-invasive interventions that improve the
quality of my son's life, which directly improves the lives of everyone
in my family.
************************************************************************
[from private email with permission]
Yes we did, but after many weeks of terrible diarrhea, crying, tantrums
and irritable behaviour. I posted on this a while back and I am sure that
our problems were because our little boy is sensitive to some of the
foods normally included in the diet (for example eggs). Once we sorted
that aspect out by eliminating the "problem foods" he settled down and is
now doing well. Also when we started the diet we had a candida albicans
problem in his gut rated at a 3+ on a scale on 1-4. So in other words a
fairly bad candida problem. Within a couple of months of starting the
diet, the candida was down to 1, which is rated as normal. I should
qualify this by saying we also used olive leaf extract and probiotics at
the same time so I can't say 100% that the diet was entirely responsible
for our success. Although I am sure it was a big part of the equation. I
am not sure how you are rating success in your survey, but I would say
yes in the longer term the diet was successful and I do believe it is the
best approach to diet for ASD children. We have only been following the
diet for a few months so it is too early to tell what other improvements
we might see. Best Wishes Alison Morrison
- ****************************************************
Susan writes about a relative that is on the diet.The child consumes
forbidden food and has made no progress. I wish so much the parents would
join the list so we could help them.
********************************************************************
My son, James, is 5 and a half, and autistic. Various dietary measures
helped, but it is only since going SCD since last October, that his
stools were finally the right colour, and usually pretty firm and
predictable. We believe his autism was caused by the combo of antibiotics
before and post MMR.
I read a post on recoveredkids about the scd and joined their list to
learn more. Although it was helpful, as was the BTVC book, I had to leave
that list due to volume of mail. I am also on enzymesandautism, and that
is where I read about this new list. The question of probiotics and the
yogurt has remained an issue, as James seems better kept dairy free at
present, and also still has candida, according to a recent test. I keep
wondering if any goat's milk product would be okay, and would like to
hear from other parents regarding this. When James began this diet, he
had been on candida specific transfer factor for a couple of weeks, but
it was within a day or two of removing the last potato that he finally
produced a firm brown stool. Also within two weeks he correctly used the
toilet for this, and also began to understand counting. Also, when
starting the diet, his longest utterances would typically be 3-6 words.
This, 10 months later, has increased to around 12-13 words, in little
sentences. We did change to a more VB approach in our home program last
September, but even his pronunciation is clearing, and I credit bio-med /
diet for this. James is still low salycilate, virtually no sugar, and low
phenol, so although the SCD has helped, his food list is still very
restricted. We know he has high lead levels, and the candida at present,
but we hope to address both with the help of a DAN doc we are seeing next
month in the USA. We have not found a UK doc who can sufficiently address
his needs yet. We have tried! My little boy is an absolute star, and
works harder than any other 5 year old I know, just to keep up and make
sense of the world, and to communicate the simplest
things....................
I would love to help him get to the stage where he could also enjoy a few
edible 'treats', instead of always just sticking to meat, veg and water!
It would also be easier if his 3 older sisters did not always have to
hide any treats they are enjoying! Enzymes help, but not with sugar, and
the houston enzymes are out for present due to the rice bran
base.............so no-fenol is out, and we have to still restrict
further to avoid phenols. I hope to learn more from this list about how
to help my son. Julie Ross, Scotland.
**********************************************************************
Just wanted to let everyone know that Hunter seems to be finally
overcoming his regression. For those of you who don't know Hunter(almost
5), when we began chelation with DMSA only he had some dramatic
improvements. When we eventually added ALA and TouefF, he had a huge
regression that has lasted close to a year. I've had reports from school
for the last 3 weeks that he's improving again and seems to be getting
back to pre-regression. He's excelling again in his ABA programs and
appears to be able to read since he does amazingly well with matching
words to objects. Although we haven't been strictly SCD, we have done
extremely low carb with him with only the occasional piece of rice bread
or a few french fries. We have started Brainchild vitamins/minerals and
they seem to be really helping although he's a bit hyperactive. I'm going
to go buy some Kefir which was suggested by Linda. I still feel that the
homemade yogurt is very important although I've been chicken to try it.
He's started pointing also which we've been working on for 2 years now.
Let's pray that the improvements continue.
Jo Piker Representative for
Unlocking Autism in South Carolina
www.unlockingautism.org
**********************************************************************
This was posted in the phoenixkids yahoogroup and reposted with permission
This is my first post. I have read your messages and learned so much from
all of you. Thank you. I will make this brief.... My son is Andrew (9,not
sure where he falls on ASD, Crohn's, Profoundly Mentally Retarded) These
are some of the official diagnoses.I have learned not to let the title
dictate his ability. I just call him our wonderboy.
We moved to Oregon(for my husband's new job) from Chicago last June. In
Chicago we saw 2 different GI's MULTIPLE TIMES for his chronic diarrhea
for 4 years.(15-20 Diapers a day) We had every test in the book.
Including a celiac panel where 2/3 tests came back positive. (I was never
informed about these results. I was told that "everything looks fine and
they just couldn't figure out why my little guy stooled so much" I found
out about these test results when I requested my medical records and I
made a "Life Line" for Doc Green. At the age of 8 Drewie weighed 34lbs. I
never knew or heard anything about Gluten. We had tried high fiber diets
and low fiber diets. After our move, we met Keli and another mom and they
hooked us up with Doc Green. They educated us about the diet and the
supplements. I went to FEAT in Sacramento and DAN! in San Diego. Drewie
has been GFCF since Aug 10th. We had GREAT results. After the diet he
only had 8-10 Diapers a day and not so runny. Drewie started to look AT
us instead of at our hair. He slowly started to interact more with us. He
actually turned a radio on! We tried antifungals(for his yeast
problem)but he couldn't tolerate them. He ended up with a "crohn's
flare-up" and was hospitalized.
Doc Green mailed the book Breaking the
Vicious cycle to me. On Oct 10th we started Diet #2. We followed the
book/diet 100%. 2 weeks ago we saw our new GI for an upper and lower
scope(he has developed some fissures and fistulas) He did some biopsies
and found NO YEAST. The other great news was that his ulcers in his
digestive tract are gone. There is only a small area of inflammation. We
are so thankful for Doc Green's advice and the book. Drewie now weighs 40
lbs. He looks so much healthier.His hair is shiny and not brittle. He
plays with toys. He seeks our attention. He gives hugs. He poops 3-6
times a day. We are still working on the poop thing but we are thrilled
with where we are right now. My husband and I agree that Andrew would not
be alive today if we had not started the diets. SO a BIG Thank you to
Keli and Doc Green and all of you who have helped us so much.
Beth Hauser!
**********************************************************************
--- In [email protected], "brianangela2001" wrote:
I have
been lurking on this board for over a year, posting only a couple of
times. I've noticed several comments about the GFCF folks and just felt
the need to post, but not be inflammatory. I hope our story will
encourage a spirit of understanding.
My 4yo daughter was born screaming and didn't stop until she was two. She
NEVER slept and had rashes and diahrea. We started dietary interventions
for her and nursing mommy (me) at three months. By the time she was 10
mos, we were GFCF. We noticed some improvement, but not a lot, but we
continued thinking we needed more time. When she was 26 mos, we discoverd
Feingold. I immediately removed all significant salicylates, phenols, and
benzoates. Two nights later, she slept through the night. Finally, my
little girl became manageable, but the diahrrea and rashes continued.
Over the next two years, we continued to remove more and more from her
diet. Additionally, on her third birthday, we added enzymes. We started
slow, staying GFCF, and worked our way up. Eventually, we were up to 3
capsules of Zyme, 3 of Pep, and 1 of NF with a pizza. We saw no behavior
regression, but the bowel and skin issues got worse, not better. We went
back to GFCF for our main diet, with some infractions. Still nothing.
Through all of this, my daughter's behavior was "okay," but not great.
She was still hyper, unable to make good eye contact, and didn't always
sleep well. She was also high-strung and temper tantrums were common. We
also took other supplements. No vaccines after a bad reaction at two
months.
Anyway, I found out about the Specific Carbohydrate diet two
months ago (www.breakingtheviciouscycle.org) and recognized my daughter's
symptoms. We started and the results have been wonderful. It seems her
bowels have been damaged to the point they needed an easy to digest diet
to heal. Skin and bowels are clearing up, behavior and sleep are great.
I'm discovering a new little girl!
My one-year-old is also responding well to this diet. She was on the same
track as big sister.
This is not an advertisment for the diet we are on. Nor is it a slam
against the enzymes, because we use them daily (sometimes hourly) and are
soooo thankful for them. We are able to eat goat yogurt, broccoli,
squash, and more because of the enzymes. I wouldn't be without them. I
just wanted to present another viewpoint about diets. We all have to do
what works best for our children. For us, a regular diet with enzymes
wasn't it, and neither was GFCF. Hope this is beneficial to someone.
Thanks for listening.
--- In [email protected], JULIETARABOCHIA@A...
wrote:
Elaine,
My 4 yr old ASD
son was born with thrush, and both the boys' first yrs of life consisted
of back to back ear and respiratory infections, and very poor health.
Both of their gut dysbiosis show high yeast and c difficile markers, and
the microbiology showed almost no good bacteria, the "bad guys" and
yeast. We've been through every kind of antifungal/ antiparasite med on
the market, everytime to get to a worse place after the treatment
concludes. I have to say since starting the diet, they have been so
healthy, and have gotten over their first 2 colds rather quickly &
without the nebulizer breathing treatments, yeah. They have nice flat
tummy's most of the time, I don't hear the loud tummy rumbles, and D has
subsided for the most part, and we're going poo on the potty after 1
year of training!!! woo hoo! We've made such awesome social gains, and
is much more able to concentrate when his tummy is feeling better. Yeast
is the only challenge we still have (itchy bottoms after having honey or
too many pears or bananas in a day).
Thanks Elaine for all you've done for our boys, and the wellness of our
family. You are doing a great thing that's helping many young and old
have a better way of life.
Bless you, Julie
To: [email protected] From: "Patrick I. Lecky"
Date: Sun, 22
Dec 2002 17:54:55 -0500 Subject: Re: [ElainesChildren] Autistic boy
Hi Allison:
Thanks for responding. YES! we've noticed the same improvements in
Cammy's speech within a week! He's much clearer, he repeats words after
hearing them only once, etc.
His stools are also now formed and not mushy and not smelly as before.
It's amazing.
The yogurt seems to be doing the most good. What foods do you believe
really helped.
Patrick
From: Allison Houston To:
[email protected] Sent: Sunday, December 22, 2002 5:50 PM
Hi Patrick,
My autistic son has only been on the diet for 2 months,
so I cannot say that he is "recovered". However, when we started SCD
Malcolm's only words were "please, thank you, cookie". Within 3 weeks
Malcolm had developed functional speech. "I want a cookie, It's time to
go home, "Let's go brush teeth, I want to stay here" kinds of sentences.
This last couple of weeks his diction has improved immensely, and he can
now repeat new words and phrases after hearing it just once or twice,
with good ennunciation. So, I can't give you a long term story - yet.
However, we have seen very significant improvement in a very short time.
Hope that helps,
Allison
----- Original Message ----- Flag Message - Mark as Unread ] To:
[email protected] From: "sharon_atyh "
Date: Mon,
16 Dec 2002 15:02:40 -0000 Subject: [SCDietkids] Re: Digest Number 134
Hi Julie
I'm glad to be here too, thanks. And glad Owen has started the SCD.
We've see some interesting things so far. He's been alert, it's hard to
explain....sort of wide awake, but not giggly. The best thing though is
he's toilet trained himself - day and night - something we've been
struggling with forever. Hooray!
All I keep wondering is why I delayed so long in removing those carbs....
The coconut lollies sound good
BW Sharon (in Guildford, UK)
----- Original Message ----- From: Alane Martinuzzi To:
[email protected] Sent: Thursday, November 21, 2002 10:35
PM Subject: [ElainesChildren] help with kid-friendly foods
To all of the experienced cooks and SCD experts, please help. I would
appreciate any ideas on getting going on this diet. We started on
Saturday. I tried the intro, but he wouldn't touch the chicken soup, or
the yogurt, or any stewed fruit. I made hot wheels cars with the juice
and gelatin, he wouldn't touch it either (except to drive them around the
table). I cook chicken, which he usually loves, no go. He won't eat
eggs, no matter how they are cooked. He hates honey, and the saccharin
tastes horrible. I've tried the pancakes, no go. I made "pizza" with
the crust in the book, homemade sauce and bacon, nope. I tried spagetti
squash with homemade sauce, and little meatballs, nope. I've deep fried
squash, zucchini, turnip (rutabaga?) and carrots into chips, nope. I've
made 2 kinds of bread, 3 kinds of cookies, muffins, he won't touch any of
it, except the peanut butter ones. I even rolled pretzels with the pizza
crust recipe. The bread crumbles with or without toasting, and doesn't
really have a bread taste, so he won't eat it. I've tried the yogurt
plain, with honey, with stewed fruit, in smoothies. I've dripped it and
added cinnamon, also tried it with garlic, as a sort of cream cheese, and
mixed it with homemade ketchup as a dip, no way. All he has eaten in the
last 6 days is bananas, apple slices, hamburgers, and peanut butter
cookies. I'm getting desperate, here, and running out of ideas.
On the plus side, I had my bi-monthly meeting with the school, and they
say a different child walked in on Monday, and they are so impressed with
his progress since, they can't believe it is the same child. He is
talkative, friendly, almost no aggression, smiling, hugging, happy and
participating. I want to stick with this, but not at the risk of having
him malnourished. His energy level is dropping fast. Any ideas you have
would be most appreciated.
Thanks in advance,
Alane
Mimi:Alane's son had a yeast die off rection and the diet was
temporarily discontinued.Alane hopes to try it again
To: [email protected] From: "Allison Houston"
Date: Tue, 12 Nov 2002 15:04:22 -0500
Subject: Re: [ElainesChildren] brand new and desperately need
helpful hints
Hi Janet,
We have only been SCD for about a month, and I've only been
using yogurt for a couple weeks. My 4 year old is autistic too, and yes,
carbs were very big. What I did was to start intorducing the SCD baking
and backing off on rice and potatoes while I was busy reading and
researching. I had gone GFCF cold tyurkey back in the summer, and didn't
want to do that again. Malcolm LOVES the muffins and cookies. He's
slowing down on them now that I've introduced the yogurt. I'm using cow
and haven't seen any bad reactions yet. (I'm just about through the
third batch).
To me, SCD makes more sense than GFCF. If bowel issues are part of
the problem, giving them the simplest foods possible are the way to
go, I figure. Malcolm's language has come on a lot - some with
removing the potatoes, rice and sugar, and even more so with adding
the yogurt. One of these days I'll make a batch of goat just to
compare, but so far I haven't seen any problems. Malcolm won't eat
it from a bowl, so I mix in a little honey with the yogurt and give
it to him in syringes. I'm up to 3 servings a day. His BM's
changed colour immediately, and the texture is changing too. It's
still mostly pasty, but I do get an occasional "trophy" as they say
on this list.
My suggestion would be to go for it. It's a great diet. I am
feeling wonderful on it too. i've got much more energy. I now find
that if I eat sugar - I get ANGRY!
Good luck,
Allison
To: [email protected] From:
"carolinemcgilluk" Add to
Address Book Date: Thu, 17 Oct 2002 13:48:14 -0000 Subject: [SCDietkids]
Re: SCD versus GFCF
Karen
I wanted to answer your post even though I don't think we fall into
your category of "tried the GFCF and it didn't work". We have been gfcf
for nearly 3 years now. Removing gluten was like a miracle for us
because James literally began to talk and "woke up".
But the following 3 years has been like a roller coaster, mostly moving
forward but with significant periods of regression. We have realised
that his regression is almost always due to flare-ups in yeast or - more
particularly for us - clostridia. And the periods of greatest gains have
been when we have taken measures to deal with the gut bugs. For example
we had an amazing positive response to enzymes when we started them and
this I'm convinced was because they were helping keep yeast/bugs at bay.
Now we are following the SCD with the exception that we are using
quinoa flour to make pancakes because James always regresses when we
try using the nut flours instead. We are continuing to see slow but
steady improvements. James is now 4 1/2, started full-time regular
school in September, and is doing extremely well (without needing a
classroom aide).
So for us, the SCD is helping because it is the only dietary regime
that tackles the gut bugs on an on-going basis. My personal feeling,
FWIW, is that any autistic child with on-going gut bug problems, would
be helped by either trying the SCD or, at a minimum, restricting the
carbs and absolutely no sugar. By on-going gut bugs I mean that you
treat them (maybe with diet, antifungals, probiotics etc) and they
improve temporarily but always come back. This is the category that
James falls into. I think this diet offers the only hope of keeping
them away for good.
I'd be interested to know what was said on the other board - please let
us know! I'd be especially interested to know if you do see a "yeast
kids" pattern.
HTH
Caroline
Message 1571 of 1777
Msg # From: [email protected] Date: Mon Jan 13, 2003 11:57 am
Subject: Re: [ElainesChildren] are you sure there's no 3 month flare?
I am new to this list, so I was unaware that ASD kids did not have a
flare up. I have an exception though. I started my son, who was seven
at the time, on the SCD on Nov. 1. He immediately started eating the new
foods and loving everything. I could not fill him up, and am still
having a problem getting him full! However, we were concerned that
perhaps he was getting sick when we started seeing regressive behavior
less than a week after starting the diet. For 2 months it was horrible.
He lost all of his spontaneous requests, became completely prompt
dependent for dressing, eating, in his aba programs, etc. Very weak
sounding verbals. He would cry whenever his therapists, who he loves,
would come to the house. Worst of all, he became severly impacted. The
doctors actually thought we might have to resort to manual disimpaction.
He was only going by means of an enema. However, I am thrilled to report
that 2 months later we have him back and better than ever. He is so much
more connected than he ever was before. We still have a long way to go
with him, but I can only believe that this was due to the diet.
Julie A
Message 1576 of 1777
Msg # From: "[email protected]" Date:
Mon Jan 13, 2003 3:03 pm Subject: Yoghurt and Progress Report
Hi to everyone,
I had a couple of yogurt questions but I did want you to know we have
been<
on the diet now 12 days and things in the last couple of days are
starting
to look really good. This week-end we had one emotional moment and that
was it.Miles wanted to try to ride his bike (something that he hasn't
wanted to do in over a year!) and he was throwing a football with his
brother (again, a rather small but remarkable event. So so far so good.
And I feel better knowing that he is not eating 5 bowls of rice/cereal a
day. I am wondering how quickly anyone noticed the hand flapping
reducing/resolving. Still a big problem of ours.(My son is Non-verb= al
learning disorder not austistic/PDD)
Message 1600 of 1777
Msg # From: [email protected] Date: Tue Jan 14, 2003 10:30 am
Subject: my son's 2 wk report
Hi everyone!
Well, tomorrow will be 2 weeks on the diet and I just wanted to share
with you how my son is doing, some questions I have, and a request for
comments please. (Reminder - my son is ASD, 3yrs, possible celiac-and
prior to SCD was GFCF for about 2.5 mo)
After about day 6 my son started having perfect poops everytime! yippee!
He did have one mushy one after eating some papaya (accidentally) and
this morning, part of it was mushy. I'm just expecting this to happen
from time to time - am I right? Afterall, Rome wasn't built in a day -
so I'm not expecting instant gratification.
I am noticing an increase in urination and a slight odor to it. What
does this mean? He is eating more meats since starting this diet (not
excessive though) and a little bit more phenol foods. Is the increase in
urination just a temporary readjustment period for his body?
Also - his cheeks are a little bit redder. It comes and goes. His right
cheek had "red flashes" even before we started the diet. I have a few
thoughts on why his cheeks are redder now (and the patches, at times, are
bigger than they were before):
1) Obvious thought - it's winter, heater is on - chapped skin. This past
week was our first really cold week in Tennessee - that's when the
cheeks got redder
2) I temporarily stopped all those supplements when I started the diet.
I wanted to give the good food a chance and then re-evaluate all the
supps and see which ones I felt like he really needs. It could be
since he's off the cod liver oil.....
3) Are the cheeks red from detoxing?
4) It could be a food (maybe peanut butter or the watered down pineapple
juice) - although, I've never noticed the cheeks getting red instantly
after eating
Thanks in advance! And we (the whole family!) are really enjoying this
diet. To me it really seems easier - just simple cooking and back to the
basics!
Tanya in Nashville, TN
From: "allison_lillies" Date: Fri Nov 15,
2002 6:11 pm Subject: Autism and SCD
I am a new member of the group and would appreciate some advice. My son
is almost 3 and was diagnosed with autism a year ago. He has been gluten
and casein free for the entire year with little benefit. I started him on
SCD 2 weeks ago. During these 2 weeks his autistic symptoms have
regressed and he is displaying behaviors that we haven't seen for at
least 6 months. Have other autistic children regressed at the start of
the diet? I don't know whether to wait it out or take him off the diet. I
am very worried to see disturbing behaviors return. Any advice is
welcome, Thank you, Allison.
Mimii:Was this a temporary yeast die off?Or is this situation one of the
few cases where SCD is not the right diet?I tried to contact the
parents and got no email reply.
From: [email protected] Date: Mon Dec 23, 2002 6:01 pm
Subject: 1 year old need help
Ok all, I have taken my son off formula a few days ago and
he was already gfcf. Btw he was on Neocate. Anyway I put him on scd
diet and he has had NON STOP diarrhea for DAYS. I dont know if it is the
diet or the fact that he has had so much malabsorption problems from day
one and needed special formula but the only way i can firm up his stools
and slow them down is to put starch back in his diet, like rice and
potatoes. EVERYTHING else goes right threw him, he is not gaining
weight. He looks terrible. Dr wants me to put him back on formula until
we can figure out what is going on.
Crystal
Mimi:When Crystal asked for help we were short on help.It was Christmas
and we were unable to give her the help she needed.I hope to
contact her again.
I recently did an internet search for more reports about SCD and autism
and found these reports.
From this website:
http://www.scdiet.org/6research/autism.htm
The following highlights some dialog between Elaine Gottschall and
Dawn's regarding Dawn's success with the SCD and the success of her
autistic daughter, Allie.
Dear Elaine,
Oh and I ate a ton of delicious food last night! We started with dry
white wine, then Butternut Squash Soup w/ Pears, followed by a spinach
salad (spinach, tomato, cheddar cheese, mushrooms, oil & lemon
dressing), free range Cornish game hens stuffed with celery, raisins,
apples, & carrots, and glazed with an apple sauce, then finally the
peanut butter cake. Yum! Am I really the same person who was whining
about missing my favorite foods 7 months ago? *grin*
[responding to Elaine's question about how Allie came to feel so much
better]
I had written in about this before. She has been on SCD for 4 months
now and has been declassified from her autism diagnosis. She is still
a very spirited little girl, but all her autistic behaviors have
disappeared. I am using the yogurt and cheeses with her. Her favorite
treat is the orange juice/yogurt creamscicles! She has a couple of
those a day. She alo loves the half & half yogurt mixed with apple
butter.
Dawn UC 11 yrs, SCD 7 months - no meds
Allie cured autistic, SCD 4 months
*****************************************************************
I found another message from Patricia,the founder of the list
RecoveredKids.Patricia was mentioned in part 1 of the parents
report.Here she mentions another boy who did SCD.
Message 5451 of the yahoogroup RecoveredKids
From: MMous12905@a..
.
Date: Wed Oct 3, 2001 1:40 pm
Subject: SCD - Colleen
Colleen,
I don't know if you will hear of many more success stories with this diet
because hardly anyone is doing it. I only know of one other Mom, besides
myself, and her son is recovered. Between the two of us, we've told
hundreds
of parents about this diet. It took a giant leap of faith to do this. I
doubted myself big time.
Patricia
Aw, shucks, and here I thought I had a great idea. Of course, if Amazon
would hurry up and send me my book....I just got a shipping confirmation
email from them. In the meantime, I'm not sorry I started without it. Seth
(5) is starting to use connecting words like "to" and "go", Tommy (2) is
regaining words, and Gabby (4) is picking up one phrase a day. Yesterday she
noticed that I was sad (her daddy has gone to Tenn. for six weeks with the
Air Guard). She said, "What's wrong? It's okay, mommy," and patted my head.
Wow! She also brings her little brother a tissue and says, "Wipe your nose,"
when he cries. All this in a week! She's never noticed how anyone else was
acting around her, was too hyped up to respond, poor girl.
Autumn