| LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Attitudes and Behaviors Concept
There are many reasons to study attitudes and behaviors. However,
one reason as mentioned in Icek and Fishbein’s Understanding
Attitudes and Predicting Social Behavior is that “social scientists
assume that attitudes could be used to explain human action
since they viewed attitudes as behavioral dispositions” (55).
This reason is based on the idea that “man’s social actions
– whether the actions involve religious behavior, ways of earning
a living, political activity, or buying and selling goods –
are directed by his attitudes” (13). Therefore, the concept
of attitude, defined by Icek and Fishbein, is “a person’s general
feeling for favorableness or unfavorableness for that concept”
(55) and that it is the readiness for response that provokes
behavior which can be in favor or disfavor towards objects (Icek
and Fishbein, 1980).
Besides, Icek and Fishbein relate the idea of attitude
with the behavior by the Theory of Reasoned Action. This theory
is based on the assumption that human beings are usually quite
rational and make systematic use of the information available
to them. Consequently, people consider the implications of their
actions before they decide to or not to engage in such a behavior.
In this case, the intention has two basic determinants, the
individual positive or negative evaluation of performing behavior,
called ‘attitude toward the behavior’ and the social pressure
called ‘the subjective norm’. Therefore, an individual will
intend to perform a behavior when they evaluate it positively
and when they believe that important others think they should
perform it (Icek and Fishbein, 1980).
In his book, Attitude Change: A Critical Analysis of Theoretical
Approaches, Kiesler stated that the concept of attitude comes
from the need of scientists to look for something to explain
consistency in individual behavior and that attitude is a “primary
theoretical function to explain individual difference in reaction
to socially significant objects” (7). According to Kiesler,
attitudes contribute to overt behavior or in other words, individual
difference in behavior should correspond to individual difference
in attitude (Kiesler and others, 1969).
To sum up, an attitude is the person’s feeling toward some
objects or concepts, in favorable or unfavorable way and also
is used to explain the differences of human behaviors. Moreover,
according to the theory of reasoned action, attitude toward
the object results in the individual’s intention to perform,
or not to perform, a certain form of behavior. Therefore, the
concepts of attitude and behavior are related and in order to
understand human behavior, it is necessary to study the human
attitudes.
2.2 Media Culture Concept
An article “What Do the Media Do to us? Media and Society” by
Professor Somkiet Tangnamo, a lecturer of the Fine Arts Faculty,
Chiang Mai University, translated from the book Media and Society
by Michael O’Shaughnessy and Jane Stadler (chapter 3), has mentioned
the relation of media and culture in society by analyzing its
function and how it influences culture and vice versa (ÊÁà¡ÕÂõÔ,
2549).
According to Somkiet, media’s function is the representation
of the world for it tells us how the world should be through
different kinds of media like newspapers, radio and television,
which are the main sources of information we receive everyday.
We know what some places are like though we may have never been
there. Besides, it interprets the information for us and provides
explanations to understand the world by putting emphasis on
some things while ignoring others. It helps us evaluate the
information and teach us how we should perceive the information
in this world. And then we understand the world with relation
to gender, ethnicity and race. We were taught about the distinctions
between men and women, white and not white and so on. In conclusion,
it constructs the pattern for us in seeing the world.
Media does not present the real world. It is rather the
re-presentation of the real world. It constructs reality, values
and norms and re-presents them as if they were real. Moreover,
reality is controlled by certain groups of people; for example,
the producers and the investors are only a small group of people
making media to suit their own purposes. For example, their
purpose is to make the highest profit they can or to set some
ideologies in media. Therefore, what is seen in media may differ
from actual reality.
The theory of media states that it both reflects and affects
society. Media is the mirror that helps people understand society
for it reflects reality, values and norms in a particular society.
When people want to study a society they can look at it through
that society’s media using movies, novels and TV shows. It reflects
how people in that society think, feel or act. And in this way
media is the way to understand society. On the other hand, media
can also affect the attitudes, beliefs and behaviors of people
in the society. It creates values and has influences on its
audiences. Sometimes it does even more than reflecting the events
as it changes and makes them to be ‘media events’. It puts value
on some situations while ignores others. It makes simple things
become extraordinary or make it a part of our lives. For example
Valentine’s Day and Christmas have been emphasized by the media
as if they were very important for people throughout the whole
world.
Moreover, the link and relationship between media and culture
is not clear cut. It is blurred and not obvious which one comes
first. Producers present their ideas and values in the media
and transfer them to their audiences. Then, it expands to larger
groups and becomes about social values, which will in turn,
affect the media producers eventually. In other words, media
produces values, norms and beliefs for people in society to
consume and those social values then, cyclically, return and
have influences on the media once again.
According to Somkiet’s article, it can be concluded that
media and culture are combined together and are inseparable.
Moreover, the media culture or what is presented in the media
are somehow different from reality because it is produced in
the way that someone else wants it to be, which makes media
culture different from the culture that is created in real life
(ÊÁà¡ÕÂõÔ, 2549).
2.3 Feminized Men in Japan
A research done by Shoko Takizawa from SUNY Albany’s Women Studies
Program, “The Cultural Feminization of Men” was recently awarded
the Presidential Scholar’s Award for undergraduate research.
It focused on the phenomena of feminized men in Japan. Her research
presents the transformation of how young Japanese men are feminized
and the way ideal images are presented through media like men’s
magazines, TV dramas, advertisements, commercial ads and cosmetic
products targeted at men. She found that in Japan there is a
redefined concept of the ‘young man’. There is longer a clear
distinction between male and female images. The image of gender
is blurred and has become unisex. The reason for these changes
is that after the collapse of the bubble economy, one that increased
employment opportunities for women, their ability to choose
men and delay marriage also increased. The image of men presented
through the media is androgynous; they do not look like men,
women or even gay men. For example, the idealized images are
hairless bodies and smooth skin and referred to as ‘beautiful
men’. These images are used in marketing strategies especially
in relation to cosmetic products targeted at men by presenting
the image through feminized celebrities and idols. Other media
such as magazines expressed this idea. Some recommendations
for men in those magazines are manicuring, eyebrow waxing, facial
hair removal and many others. What has happened to Japanese
men is becoming what the U.S. has called metrosexualism (Takizawa).
2.4 Japanese Female Adolescents and the Feminized
Male
A study by Mark Mclelland, a Postdoctoral Fellow in The Centre
for Critical and Cultural Studies at the University of Queensland,
“Why are Japanese Girls’ Comics Full of Boys Bonking?” examined
the phenomena of Japanese girls who love to watch male homoeroticism
in comics and fantasize about male homosexuality rather than
heterosexual romance. His research found that these romantic
comics about boys (which are comic strip stories about romantic
love between boys) is a symbol of romanticism and equal love
that Japanese girls cannot have in real life due to the strong
patriarchal society of Japan. They, therefore, identify themselves
with the male character. This implies that this kind of comic
is an escape from reality and is a fantasy among female adolescents
in Japan (Mclelland).
Another research by Mark Mclelland, “Male Homosexuality
and Popular Culture in Modern Japan”, explains the situation
of homosexuals in modern Japanese society and the homosexual
in women’s media. His study states that homosexuality has existed
in girl’s comics for a long time, since the late 70’s with a
wide range of reader groups, and it is a common idea found in
girl’s comic. They are comics written by and for women but the
main characters are male. The male characters in the girl’s
comics are just fantasy for they are not ‘gay men’ and or actually
‘men’ either. They are drawn to suggest an ideal androgynous
image: tall, slender bodies, high cheek bones and pointed chins,
wide eyes and long flowing hair, and they behave with ‘feminine
mannerisms’, expressing emotion and vulnerability like female
characters in male appearance. The homosexual comic has two
levels. The first one is shounen-ai or boy’s love which is more
romantic and another is YAOI which has more sexual scenes. The
YAOI comic is similar to the PWP (Plot, What Plot?) genre of
‘slash’ fiction developed by American women which imagines sexual
scenarios between male heroes of popular TV dramas. However,
while PWP is sold and written privately only in the internet,
the YAOI comic is commercially produced and sold in bookstores
throughout Japan. The beautiful boys in YAOI or shounen-ai are
created by Japanese women as an expression of their dissatisfaction
with current gender stereotypes and the ‘narrow life paths’
which restrict women in the strong patriarchal world of Japan
(Mclelland, 2000).
2.5 Thai Adolescents and Japanese Culture
The study entitled “Foreign Cultural Influence on Thai Adolescent
Identity: A Case Study of Japanese Music” was conducted by Viparat
Panritdam to study adolescent’s behavior as one of the consumer
cultures in society as well as to study the relation between
the consumption behavior of Japanese pop music and Thai’s adolescent’s
identity. The data was collected through observation and in-depth
interview. The interview was divided into two parts: the consumption
behavior of Japanese music which included the interviewees’
interest in becoming Japanese music fans, and their behavior
as Japanese music fans. The second part regarded the consumption
behavior of Japanese music and their sense of identity. The
target group consisted of 17 female adolescent Japanese music
fans from Bangkok aged between 12-22 years old that had access
to Japanese music through media such as radio, television, magazines
and the internet. Another interview was also conducted with
two owners of Japanese music shops and an expert in Japanese
music, because this group is the main information source and
they could introduce some target groups to the researcher. This
way the interviewees would feel more comfortable and familiar
with the researcher too, allowing the researcher to get information
more easily. The result of the study showed that media and peers
play a prominent role in leading adolescents to be influenced
by Japanese music. The music and acoustic technology fulfills
adolescents’ fantasies and make them happy. Adolescent’s behavior
of listening to Japanese music can be explained within two processes,
distinction and imitation process. The first process, distinction,
represents their identity distinctively from their friends who
do not listen to Japanese music. At the same time, the second
process, imitation, leads them to copy the Japanese musician’s
identity, i.e. dressing in the same way as their favorite singers
in concert. Japanese music fan clubs situate their social and
cultural location by participating in such activities as concerts
or parties where they show their identity through dressing up
and acting in a stylized way, as well as creating their own
specific language in groups to indicate individuality and identity
(ÇÔÀÒÃѵ¹ì, 2544).
2.6 Satisfactory Characteristics for Adolescents
Another research completed by Wijit Madsathan entitled “The
Satisfactory Characteristics of Opposite-Sex Adolescents in
Educational Institutions in Khon Kaen” is to find out the satisfactory
characteristics of opposite-sexes among 16-18 year-old adolescents.
The research was done by questionnaire rating the satisfactory
characteristics in three aspects: physique, scholastic and manual
performance, and affective domain. The research found that the
satisfactory characteristics of opposite-sex adolescents as
a whole were arranged in the order from the most to the least:
clean dressing, good appearance, good at studying, honesty,
good-looks and handsomeness respectively. In the physical aspects,
the satisfactory characteristics are good manners, good looks,
handsomeness, clean dressing, good appearance, fine complexion,
and up-to-date dressing from most to least respectively. This
research shows that adolescents regard the personality and outer
appearance as the important things because they are the first
impression to attract the opposite sex (ÇÔ¨ÔµÃ, 2546).
2.7 The Ideal Thai Man
A research done by Kittiwut T., Coleman E. and Pacharin D.,
“The International Encyclopedia of Sexuality: Thailand”, states
that images of Thai men are represented by the notion of chaai
chaatrii, which is an embodiment of the typical masculine features:
authority, courage, self-assurance, physical and emotional strengths,
and sexual prowess. Various expressions for manhood and manliness
also reflect an image of a vigorous and muscular warrior: chaai
chaat tha-haan (bravery and chivalry), chaai ok saam sok (the
muscular chest), chaai chaat acha-nai (the stallion's stamina
and perhaps muscularity), and chaai cha-kan (strength and vigor).
Moreover, the nag leng image, translated to a midway between
“playboy” and “gangster” in English, was simply a paragon of
the traditional Thai male role that manliness has become associated
with the following behavioral patterns: smoking, drinking, gambling,
womanizing, extramarital sexual affairs, public brawls, petty
crimes, and corruption. The ideal secular men who do not participate
in these male vices are therefore often labeled by other men
with negative terms, such as “not a genuine man,” a kathoey
or naa tua mia (the female face) (Kittiwut).
2.8 Background on Japanese Music and Singers among
Thai Adolescents
2.8.1 Japanese singers and fan clubs in Thailand
Japanese music spread to Thailand many years ago and has had
a lot of influences among Thai teens. As mentioned in Viparat’s
research, she has categorized Japanese music into three main
types. The first one is visual rock bands which are heavy metal
music bands placing emphasis on their image, costumes and appearance.
Visual rock bands exhibit their uniqueness of image and appearance
as one gender, one language, and one nationality. The male singers
thus are dressed like females. They are popular among small
groups of people, especially teenagers. The example of popular
bands are X-Japan, Glay, L’arc~en~Ciel, Luna Sea, etc. The second
group is the all female band. They are good at both singing
and dancing. The famous groups are, for instance, Namie Amuro,
SPEED, MAX and Utada Hikaru. And the third group is the all
male band of Johnny’s family that produced all male bands and
idols since the 70th century. The famous groups are SMAP, TOKIO,
Kinki Kids and V6 (ÇÔÀÒÃѵ¹ì, 2544).
In Viparta’s terms, the development of Japanese music in
Thailand can be divided into three steps. It first entered Thailand
as the theme songs and original soundtracks for television drama
or cartoons. The coming of Japanese music through Japanese singers
has just recently happened a few decades ago. And she has summarized
the development of Japanese music in Thailand as below;
1. ‘The Beginning’ took place in 1985 when Japan started
to spread their culture to other countries such as Hong Kong,
Taiwan and Thailand. The popular singers at that time were Shonentai,
Yoko Minamino, Miho Nakayama and Hikaru Genji.
2. ‘The Decline’ was in 1993 due to the fact that American
culture had become more influential in Thailand so that Thai
adolescents did not favor Asian culture but preferred Western
culture instead, especially American.
3. ‘The Return’ of Japanese music in 1996 started from
the coming of X-Japan in Thailand. The trend of X-Japan brought
back the popularity of Japanese music so that many music agencies
in Thailand sold Japanese albums with the copy rights from Japan.
At that time, the Japanese music fan clubs had increased into
wider groups and until this day still have influences among
Thai teens. Many teenagers imitate their favorite singers by
wearing the same clothing, for example, and they would feel
strongly dissatisfied to hear someone talk about their favorite
singers in a bad way (ÇÔÀÒÃѵ¹ì, 2544).
Among the Japanese bands that are famous in Thailand, the
male singers seem to have more fans than the female ones. This
could be due to the fact that fan clubs are more likely to have
more female members than males, and it is quite common that
female fans tend to like male singers more than female singers.
The current famous male singers can be easily separated into
two types which are J-Rock and J-Pop. The J-Rock bands that
are now popular in Thailand are Luna Sea, Lucifer, Dustar-3,
Die~en~gray and so on. The J-Pop bands are basically from the
two big agencies, Johnny’s Jimusho and Pony Canyon. The current
groups from Johnny’s Jimusho that are now popular in Thailand
are Tackey & Tsubasa, NewS, and KAT-TUN for instance. And
the current groups from Pony Canyon are W-inds, Lead and Flame.
These singers have a separated group of fan clubs. The
fans who like J-Rock bands usually think that J-Pop bands are
not good enough in their singing skills, while the J-Pop fans
often found that J-Rock singers are less attractive. It can
often be seen that some groups of fans choose one band to be
their idol and role model and dislike the others. Though they
are a J-Pop fan club, they may not like some bands in the J-Pop
genre and this also happens with J-Rock fans as well. Sometimes,
it can be said that they prefer the images of singers and bands
more than the songs and music itself.
The image of male singers, historically, has gone through
many changes. In the past, the male singer should normally portray
a masculine image to attract female fans, for example they should
be tall and handsome. However, during recent years there are
some changes among male singers. The most prominent are the
visual rock bands with men dressing more like women. Surprisingly
this trend was widely accepted among teenagers, especially female
ones, and the visual rock band of that kind quickly became popular.
For the J-Pop bands and singers, the image of male singers has
become androgynous making it hard to identify whether their
look is male or female. The androgynous image or ‘feminine image’
of male singers is very striking for Thai teenagers. There are
many fan clubs that really admire the feminine male singers
and have many activities to show their identity and their favor
in the singers, for example having parties or concerts to honor
them.
The feminine image of male singers, and its popularity
among fans, brings about the consideration of what happens in
teenager’s culture and their music idol trends. Have the admirable
characteristic of men changed? This is the question that needs
to be answered.
2.8.2 Johnny’s Jimusho: A feminine male idol among Thai
teens
When talking about all male band singers that are very popular
in Thailand, one of the first names that will come to many people’s
mind is ‘Johnny’s Jimusho’ as also mentioned in Viparat’s research.
Sometimes it is known as Johnny’s entertainment or Johnny’s
family. ‘Johnny’s Jimusho’ or ‘Johnny and Associates’ in official
English is the name of a Japanese talent agency, child star
training center, management company, marketing powerhouse and
media conglomerate that has been successful for nearly 40 years.
It was formed by the California-born Japanese-American Johnny
H. Kitakawa in 1963 (Nippop, 2005). The company has been the
top talent agency in Japan for many years and annually making
in excess of 3 billion yen (Metropolis, 2005).
The history of this agency is that it did not begin as
a talent agency but a baseball team instead. The team first
attended a performance of the musical West Side Story and then
was so inspired that they decided to stage their own show. Johnny
Kitakawa then got the idea that he could develop the talents
by himself and establish an artist management company in 1963.
The first singing group he launched was called ‘Johnny’s’. However
the one that was a clear success was the Four Leaves in 1968.
After the Four Leaves, Johnny’s Jimusho produced an endless
number of boy bands and many have had gigantic hits (Nippop,
2005).
The golden age of the idols was in the 1980’s and Johnny’s
created the biggest of all the stars, Tanokin Trio, Ninja, Shibugakitai
and Hikaru Genji. Hikaru Genji became the first group to start
off their career with eight straight No.1’s and in 1988; they
had the three top-selling singles of the year. In the 1990’s
the idol boom had faded and they struggled to achieve real success
as just a singing group. So Johnny’s turned them into multimedia
talents. Within a couple of years, they were simply everywhere,
on TV and radio shows, commercials, best-selling albums, playing
dramatic roles, on magazine covers and in the spotlight at the
top of the popularity rankings. For example, Kimura Takuya,
the member of SMAP, became the dream boy for a whole generation
of school girls and continues to be voted Japan’s sexiest man
(Japanzone, 2005). The technique of Johnny’s is that it is to
tap into whatever the current music is and manufacture a group
which reflects it. For example, Ninja reflected the heavy metal
boom and SMAP were originally intended to be a pseudo-rap group.
With this fact, Johnny’s Jimusho can cover almost all pop music
in the market (Metropolis, 2005).
The Johnny’s production style has often been likened to
a factory. They scout young boys for looks and character, then
putting them through intensive training that includes grooming,
public speaking, dancing, singing, acting, gymnastics and sometimes
more special skills such as skating. The company is always flooded
with letters from youngsters and their parents, hoping to become
the next male super idol. Most of Johnny’s boys sign on in their
early teens, but the age can be as young as nine. Among the
current groups in Johnny’s family are, for example, SMAP, TOKIO,
Kinki Kids, Arashi, V6, NewS, Tackey & Tsubasa, KAT-TUN,
Kanjani8, Johnny’s Junior and others.
TV exposure is an essential part of the Johnny’s formula.
With Johnny’s front line artists always in demand, Johnny’s
uses TV programs as a means for his up and coming groups. Sometimes
their talents appear initially as back dancers or in other non-spotlight
positions. Even before they have their own hit records, they
may have been on TV many times. It can be said that the Johnny’s
artists are more like ‘talents’ than purely musicians or singers
because they perform in a wide range of entertainment categories;
for example live theater, TV drama, movies, commercial ads,
cooking shows and comedy.
The Johnny’s idols will be trained for many years before
they can have their singles or album or what is called ‘debut’
in their terms. For example, Shounentai, the very first group
of Johnny’s, was signed for seven years before they made their
recording debut. After launching their debut single and becoming
popular, the successful group is used to bring up the next generation
of aspiring Johnny’s idols, giving them time in their TV shows
or other productions. However, there is a criticism according
to the high success of its boy bands that the members do not
have to be particularly good singers, dancers or actors, and
that they are “merely famous for being famous”.
The system for bringing up Johnny’s idols has very strict
rules. The members of Johnny’s family are under strict contracts,
and their public images are carefully groomed. The general rule
is members are not allowed to publicly have girlfriends, as
the boys are of greater interest to fans when they are ‘available’.
The evidence to show that their image is of strong concern was
when two members of NewS band, Hiroki Uchi and Kusano Hironori,
were caught drinking whiskey while being under 18, a very strict
law in Japan. For Johnny’s members, public image is the most
important thing, and therefore, as punishment, these two members
were not allowed to work or even be seen in public for an unspecific
amount of time. This situation, caused NewS band to stop their
work as a singers group for the whole year in 2006. This evidence
shows that their image must be clean without any sign of getting
a bad reputation at all.
In Thailand, Johnny’s Jimusho has influence among Thai
teens. Many Thai teens are crazy for their idols. The example
being that Johnny’s singers have had concerts in Thailand many
times, such as at Pattaya Music Festival concert and at J-Asian
Pop concert. A concert held in 2004 was also good evidence to
prove their popularity in Thailand. Hideaki Takizawa and Tsubasa
Imai, the duo of Tackey & Tsubasa group, held a concert
in Thailand entitled “One-To-Call! Freedom Music Festival” which
was their first concert outside Japan after their first single
debut in September 2002. The concert was warmly welcomed by
their fans with more than 10,000 attending their concert. Apart
from these two idols, there are many others such as KAT-TUN
and Johnny’s Junior. During their concert in Thailand, their
CDs were on sale; released nearly at the same time as in Japan
and they were sold in large numbers compared to others foreign
albums in Thailand. They appeared in many Thai variety shows
and magazines and on the day of their arrival in Thailand, more
than 5,000 school girls were waiting for them at the airport
(TSN Life, 2547).
The outstanding character of Johnny idols that is different
from other male Japanese singers is their appearances. Most
of them are boys with beautiful faces and slim figures. The
male idols in Johnny’s family clearly possess feminine characteristics.
Their appearance, as mentioned in the previous chapter, is ‘androgynous’
with eye brow waxing, white complexions, long and dyed hair,
and for them, permed hair is something common. In their TV shows,
they sometimes dress as female characters and act like females.
In concerts, their performances are ambiguous so that audiences
can hardly tell whether it is the posture of a male or female.
Their sexy dances or “ero-dance” looks more like feminine characters
than any stereotype of male behavior.
The Johnny idols, especially the current groups, do not
have the stereotype of ‘manliness’; they can be both masculine
and feminine. It all depends on their costume and concept of
each time they are shown in public. They are not protective
men with muscles and strong bodies that women used to dream
of, but they are a new kind of men that women nowadays, at least
their fan clubs, fantasize about because they are more like
an ideal figure or imaginary character come true to be human.
So, when mentioning about feminine male singers in this research,
it is likely that most of the evidence will be focused on the
idols in Johnny’s singers because they are the most outstanding
example among others.
One interesting issue about Johnny’s Jimusho is the rumors
about Johnny Kitakawa, the boss himself, and his sexual involvement
with the young beautiful boys in his agency. Concerning the
fact that this agency has only boys, this rumor seems to be
convincing. Moreover, in the early days of Johnny’s Jimusho,
there have been accusations that Johnny sometimes enjoys the
boys in his bands more than might be considered appropriate.
In the 1970’s, an idol’s parents charged Johnny with “indecent
behavior” with their son. In 1988, former Four Leaves member
Koji Kita wrote a book about Kitagawa’s sexual harassment of
him. Another idol, Jo Toyokawa also made similar charges to
Johnny. Besides, there are lots of books and magazine articles
that make accusation on a similar topic (Nippop, 2005).
However, though they are widely believed to be true, the
clean image of pretty boy groups has hardly been dented by these
accusations. While there are plenty of rumors and negative reports,
Johnny Kitagawa has not been convicted of any wrong doing and
importantly his business has not been affected at all. Johnny’s
stars remain visible and popular with lots of new bands ready
to replace the old ones, and it will go on this way continuously.
The reason that Johnny’s entertainment has survived amongst
so many bad rumors could be associated to the fact that most
Japanese females are fans of bishounen manga, comic books in
which pretty young boys have romantic encounters (Japanzone,
2005). They are familiar and perhaps, fond of the idea of love
between men, therefore the rumors cannot affect the popularity
or divert the fan club’s positive attention.
2.8.3 Fan Fiction
After participating in many activities with the Japanese music
fan club, one interesting finding was a trend of fan fiction
that was widespread within Thai female adolescents. It is one
of the main activities that almost all of the fans of Japanese
feminine male singers are participating in, having and sharing
some experiences or at least having heard about it. Fan fiction
started originally from the popularity of bishounen comics among
Thai teens which was influenced by Japanese trends. Japanese
comics are very popular among Thai teens and bishounen comics
are part of it. In order to understand what fan fiction is,
it is needed to trace back to the history of bishounen comics
first. The word ‘bishounen’ in Japanese means ‘beautiful boys’,
so the bishounen comic is a comic with romantic scenes between
young beautiful boys. There are two levels of bishounen comics,
shounen-ai and YAOI. The first is more romantic while the second
one has more sexual scenes. With the popularity of bishounen,
came the doshinji, or fan sites in the internet where many writers
wrote boy based love stories. Doshinji has two types; the first
is when a writer creates a plot and characters by themselves.
The second one is when writers use famous characters in former
comics or other idols as main characters. The most interesting
thing of bishounen comics and doshinji is that it is a story
written by and for women only (Doshinji Farm, 2548).
The fan fiction for Japanese music fan clubs is similar
to doshinji. Most of fan fiction can be found on the internet.
The story is created by the writers, and characters in the story
are Japanese male singers. The writers are not professional
writers but they are fans who love reading this kind of story.
They are stories basically about romantic love between male
singers. Sometimes, the plot is inspired by true stories and
events. For example, the story about love between two singers
in the same or different groups sounds more realistic while
some stories are in sci-fi, fantasy, thriller, or comedy depending
on the writer’s imagination. What they focus on using is the
singers’ character, name and physical appearance, to help the
reader to imagine, while the story itself is independently invented.
Fan fiction is available on web boards and on many fan
sites, with many writers posting their stories there and lots
of readers waiting for new stories to appear. And it is not
only on the internet that fan fiction can be found. Sometimes
when a story is famous enough the writer will publish it in
a form of pocket book or novel and put it on sale. Readers can
buy fiction via the internet or at some fairs or meeting parties
between fan clubs. Some writers sell their fiction directly
to their regular customers who know each other prior by telephone,
while some leave the news of their new fictions on web boards
or online diaries, so that if readers are interested they can
call to order. The price of fan fiction, when published, is
around 100 to 400 baht. It is quite expensive, compared to novels
and pocket books sold in book, stores but they are sold in great
numbers among fan clubs.
The popular stories mostly have sexual scenes in a very
obscene way. The story describes sexual scenes so clearly and
the more obscene it is, the more popular it seems to be. The
researcher found that the singers who were chosen to be main
protagonists in fan fiction, and that receive very good feedback,
must possess feminine characteristics. These feminine male singers
will be positioned as female characters in fan fiction, while
some singers who look more masculine will be positioned as male
characters in the fiction.
Although some Japanese music fans who read fan fiction
find it difficult to differentiate between the real world and
the imaginative world in fan fiction, many of the fans state
that fan fiction was just their fantasy, a way-out from stress
and suffering reality and individual entertainment to enjoy
romantic stories about and between men. However, they do not
really wish that their favored singers be gay or homosexual
men. They just feel pleased and happy to read of them.
2.8.4 Web Boards and Fan Clubs
There are a lot of methods to access information about favorite
singers. Thai adolescents can get information about their favorite
singers from TV or radio programs and some magazines specializing
on Japanese celebrities. However, they are quite few in number.
Therefore, in this globalized world, where progressive technology
can be found anywhere, internet is one of the main sources for
Japanese music fan clubs to access information and news. For
a person who does not have any background in regards to Japanese
singers, he or she can easily browse through the website using
many of the search engines available which will at least help
to get some basic information, and in the future, leading to
many more detailed sites to be found. Even the researcher herself
got a lot of information from search engines, such as Google,
so that she could gain access to many websites. From the observation
and searching for information through many websites, the researcher
found that there are quite a lot of fan sites and web boards,
made by Thai fans, which are especially dedicated to Japanese
male singers. In this case, the research will be focused only
on the fan sites of those Japanese male singers that have the
feminine image as mentioned before.
These fan sites and web boards, as the name suggests, are
places for fan clubs and people who like the same singers to
come to share their ideas and opinions, and even exchange updated
news about their favorite singers. It is a community in the
cyber world created by fan clubs as a private place for them
to express their opinions freely without having to worry that
other people will judge them as in the real world. Each web
board has its own characteristics. Usually web boards focus
on each band differently depending on the favor of each group.
For example it could be a web board specially made for fans
of one band, while another board is for another band. Usually,
there are no strict rules that other bands are banned in a specific
web board, but all the fans know it as a manner that they should
not post anything about KAT-TUN band on a web board of W-inds
band, for example. However, some web boards still have some
strict rules to follow, for example selling and buying are not
allowed, or some subjects that are not about the specific singers
are taboo.
The example of fan sites and web boards are, for example;
boardfixxx (fan fiction web board)
jk_secret (all about Japanese and Korean idols)
shounen_ai board (web board for boy’s love
issues and idols)
padawan kkk (web board for fans of KKK – the
old unit which is now NewS band members)
news X kattun (web board for fans of News and
KAT-TUN)
3k_jr_cos (web board for fans of KKK, Johnny’s
Junior and Cosplay band)
koyama’s palace (web board for fans of Koyama)
angelicnews (web board and web site for fans
of News)
yamashita-tomohisa (web board and website for
fans of Yamashita Tomohisa, NewS and other Johnny’s groups)
yamapi-land.com and yamapi.com (web board and
website for fans of Yamshita Tomohisa)
Plus many more that the researcher could not list. These are
just examples because web boards of Thai fans keep increasing
in number all the time, so that it is difficult to calculate
how many of them there are.
Each web board has different rules with webmasters and
moderators to look after their small community, keeping it a
pleasant place to visit and to make members live together in
the cyber world with peace. First of all, before entering the
web site, the fan club has to register to be a member of the
web board. There are some sites that they can browse through
without having to register, but almost all web board requires
a ‘sign-in’ username. The username of the fan club can also
tell their favor in Japanese singers in that they invent new
names. Mostly are the combination between their names and their
favorite singers, such as keaw_yamapee, kame_jin_pui or bo_uchi
for instance. Besides the username, some web boards, usually
the one that comes in the form of web site, allow members to
have their signature and personal picture which will appear
on screen every time members reply and comment on each topic.
The signature and personal picture will tell others about their
identity, profile and their appearance. However, none of them
use their own pictures. They use the picture of their favorite
singers instead in order to tell others who their favorite singers
are. It is the same case with their signatures that appear after
their comment messages. Their signatures and personal pictures
can tell other members directly, that they like the same singers
and that they are in the same fan club. In this way, teenagers
feel more secure and have the sense of belonging to a group.
In the internet world, they can be what they want to be.
They can create a new identity and even a name. It is like a
freedom and world that they create by themselves. It is like
a small community where only similar kinds of people live together.
They are like family and friends that understand each other.
After knowing each other for a period of time, they may have
an appointment to meet in person, or it could be at a meeting
party between members of a web board to do some activities together,
such as a mini concert with a cover band or ‘cosplay’ (a group
of fans dressed up to act and imitate their favorite characters
– for cover bands it is the imitating of singers and relevant
band, for cosplay it is the imitating of characters in movies
or cartoons). In this case they feel more familiar and close
to each other. Many of the fans from the web boards become friends
in the real world and do many activities together like going
to a movie, shopping or having an appointment every weekend.
For some who live in different provinces and could not meet
so often, they could exchange their telephone numbers or write
emails to each other. Therefore, the web board community is
becoming a realm, or small world, of marginal people who find
it difficult to talk with and be understood by people in the
reality of the outside world.
Apart from e-mail addresses, in the web board’s signature,
fans usually leave their link to their blogs or on-line diary.
The web boards sometimes ask them to add this information when
registered. However, some still wrote their links in their signature
anyway no matter if it is required by the webmaster or not.
It could be said that most of them want other members to visit
their blogs or on-line diary because they want to know each
other more. The blogs or on-line diary (called ‘di’ for short
among the fan club) is the spaces for them to write their journal
about their own lives, routines, or it could be something like
an article or poem, pictures or anything they want to share.
Anyway, most of the fan club’s on-line diary is about their
favorite singers and their opinion. For example, they would
write about when the singer plays in new drama, new album and
show the singer’s pictures. They can write what they cannot
say in the real world, what they cannot say to others who are
not in the fan club because nobody would understand. It is different
from writing in an on-line diary because, most of the time,
people who read it are in the same group or fan club and they
understand each other. For the fan club, sometimes an on-line
diary is better than a private diary written in a notebook because
they can receive comments, opinions and feedback from other.
So, they would not feel deserted, as if they were alone. In
this way, the fan clubs feel more familiar with one another,
and some of them talk together by leaving messages in the on-line
diary for a number of years.
Besides talking and exchanging ideas in the web board,
what fan clubs usually do in web boards is share files and pictures.
The pictures could be from Japanese magazines or captured pictures
from a drama, music video or TV program or any picture they
find interesting and worth talking about. When they watch a
drama or TV show and think that the pictures are very interesting,
they will also capture the pictures and post them in a picture
forum. The multimedia files shared in the web board are, for
example, video clips, music video (PV is the technical term),
some dramas or TV programs that are currently on-air in Japan.
Moreover, in the web board, teenagers can access fan fiction
very easily as mentioned before in the previous chapter. There
are a lot of stories and fictions for web board members to read
and share their comments or ideas on what they think about the
story and plot. The last activity in the web board is buying
and selling their collections about their favorite singers such
as singles, CDs, magazines or photos. The most popular products
sold on web boards is CDs which are TV programs, dramas and
concerts from Japanese television. The price is around 15-30
baht per disc. They are TV programs that the sellers download
from the internet and copy on CD. Sometimes, they sell original
CDs and many other products directly imported from Japan. For
example, if their favorite singers are going to release a new
single, they will be some group of people who live in Japan
or will go to Japan to buy it, so there will be lots of orders
from many fans. This is the same when there are concerts in
Japan because they will be a lot of order for concert souvenirs
like posters, pamphlet, clear files and much more. The web board
is, therefore, another place for fans to buy stuffs about their
favorite singers, CDs, pictures or even magazines imported from
Japan. In the past, they might have to rely on some shops that
were in few numbers but these days the market forum in the internet
is a new way for them to buy. It is easier and sometimes cheaper
than buying from shops.
Most of the members of the web boards spend almost half
of the day with a computer, after they come back from school
or during their weekends. Especially in school breaks, they
will be more attached to their computer and the internet – spending
time chatting via MSN, downloading, uploading, reading news,
writing an on-line diary and much more. Some of them spend more
than ten hours a day with a computer, so that some even said
that the first thing they do when waking up to turn it on. Even
when they do other activities, their computer is still turned
on to download so that they do not waste any time. Computer,
internet and web boards accordingly become one of the main activities
for Japanese music fans and at the same time, it is a small
community, escaping from the real world.
|