| 1B - Jason Giambi 2B - Alfonso Soriano 3B - Shea Hillenbrand SS - Alex Rodriguez C - Jorge Posada OF - Ichiro Torii Hunter Manny Ramirez P - Derek Lowe RESERVES Paul Konerko MIke Sweeney Robin Ventura Tony Batista Derek Jeter Nomar Garciaparra Omar Vizquel Miguel Tejada AJ Pierzynski Garret Anderson Johnny Damon Robert Fick Randy Winn PITCHERS Mark Buerhle Freddy Garcia Eddie Guardado Roy Halladay Mariano Rivera Kazuhiro Sasaki Ugueth Urbina Barry Zito |
| 1B - Todd Helton 2B - Jose Vidro 3B - Scott Rolen SS - Jimmy Rollins C - Mike Piazza OF - Barry Bonds Sammy Sosa Vladimir Guerrero P - Curt Schilling RESERVES Damian Miller Benito Santiago Richie Sexson Luis Castillo Junior Spivey Mike Lowell Jose Hernandez Lance Berkman Shawn Green Luis Gonzalez Adam Dunn Andruw Jones PITCHERS Robb Nen Mike Remlinger Vicente Padilla Odalis Perez Mike Williams Trevor Hoffman John Smoltz Eric Gagne Byung-Hyun Kim |
| Managers: NL - Bob Brenly AL - Joe Torre |