b. 25 December 1820 in Knowlton, Sussex (now Warren) County, New Jersey
m.
d. 27 July 1845
buried: Cemetery in Waverly, New York; next to her father, John Ogden Shackelton
b.
m. (2) Anna Allen, with whom he had 2 sons, John and Unknown name of second son.
d.
i. John W., b. 1838; d. 29 April 1851 in Barton, New York; buried next to his mother and grandfather, John Ogden Shackelton
ii. Mary Margaret Jennie, b. 27 December 1843 in Barton, New York; d. 26 February 1915 in Savona, New York; m. Charles Fraley (son of Casper Fraley and Sara E. Frolich), he was b. 4 February 1837 in Pennsylvania; 3 children,
(a) Tracy, b. 30 July 1859 in Pennsylvania; d. 16 May 1945, m. Lucy Ann Sloane, b. in Pennsylvania, d. 5 August 1942, one daughter, Jennie Margaret, d. 23 April 1944, m. Sidney W. Palmer, 2 children, (i)Tracy Sloane, b. 4 June 1916, d. 13 August 1972, m. Kathleen Doris Turner; 3 children, Tracy Sloane, b. 13 February 1945, d. 4 July 1999, Kathleen Ann, Cheryl Elizabeth; (ii) Wilson Sidney, b. 22 July 1926, d. 3 February 1990, m. Florence Unknown, 2 sons, Ned and James Richard
(b) Jessie, b. About 1863 in Pennsylvania, d. 19 February 1895, m. John H. McNanny; one son, Earl
(c) Frances, b. About 1870 in Pennsylvania, d. in Tonawanda, Pennsylvania, m. Ray Fergerson
iii. Charles L., b. 1845 according to Shackleton book or could possibly be 25 December 1839 in Tioga County, New York**, d. 23 February 1917; He moved to Kansas** Mary Shackelton has just recently found that Charles Dutcher was in the Osage Mission-Walnut, Kansas area (they are about 8 miles apart); m. Elizabeth S. Hallenbeck of Hudson, New York; d. 3 January 1908** age 61 years; 1 son, Charles Wesley
1) Charles L. Dutcher family information; (a) email from Mary Shackelton; (b) "The History of Neosho and Wilson Counties, Kansas" by L. Wallace Duncan (page 296); (c) "Annals of St. Paul" by W.W. Graves (p. 246 and p. 408)
*Note* the book by L. Wallace Duncan states that Charles' father was Tracey E. Dutcher
2) Emails from Brandon Palmer
