| 1918 (2005 Record 66-88): PROTECTED: Tony Gwynn, Reggie Jackson, Paul Molitor, Johnny Mize, Ozzie Smith, Ted Williams, Bob Gibson, Warren Spahn Erie (2005 Record 71-83): PROTECTED: Eddie Cicotte, Grover Alexander,Goose Gossage, Willie Mays, Willie McCovey,Bill Dickey, Billy Hamilton, Cupid Childs Sycamore (2005 Record 74-80): PROTECTED: John McGraw, Eddie Collins, Mark McGwire, Stan Musial, Joe Dimaggio, Steve Carlton, Bruce Sutter, Eddie Plank Old Brooklyn (2005 Record 75-79): PROTECTED: Hank Aaron, Mickey Mantle, Tris Speaker, Christy Mathewson, Wade Boggs, Yogi Berra, Lou Brock, Dennis Eckersley Chippewa Falls (2005 Record 76-78): PROTECTED: Goose Goslin, Gabby Hartnett, Joe Jackson, Nap Lajoie, George Sisler, Heinie Manush, Old Hoss Radbourn, Lefty Grove Cleveland (2005 Record 80-74): PROTECTED: Jimmie Foxx, Rogers Hornsby, Honus Wagner, Mike Schmidt, Ed Walsh, Ed Delahanty, Mickey Cochrane, Juan Marichal Athens (2005 Record 85-69): PROTECTED: Roy Campanella, Arky Vaughan, Lou Gehrig, Ralph Kiner, Ty Cobb, Three Finger Brown, Carl Hubbell, Gaylord Perry Brentwood (2005 Record 89-65): PROTECTED: Babe Ruth, Walter Johnson, Hank Greenberg, Brooks Robinson, Ernie Banks, Ryne Sandberg, Nolan Ryan, Rob Nen |
| Round One 1. Lancaster-Jim Kaat 2. Erie-Pete Browning 3. Sycamore-Jim Palmer 4. Old Brooklyn-Sandy Koufax 5. Chippewa Falls-Chief Bender 6. Sycamore (from CFB, from CLE)-Frank Robinson 7. Athens-Jackie Robinson 8. Brentwood-Cy Young Round Two 1. Lancaster-Tommy John 2. Erie-Cap Anson 3. Sycamore-Mickey Welch 4. Old Brooklyn-Bobby Doerr 5. Chippewa Falls-Pie Traynor 6. Cleveland-Bob Lemon 7. Sycamore (from ATH)-King Kelly 8. Brentwood-Johnny Bench Round Three 1. Lancaster-Bobby Grich 2. Erie-John Ward 3. Sycamore-Mickey Lolich 4. Old Brooklyn-Addie Joss 5. Chippewa Falls-Lee Smith 6. Cleveland-Lefty O'Doul 7. Athens-Amos Rusie 8. Brentwood-Bob Feller Round Four 1. Lancaster-Robin Roberts 2. Erie-Hippo Vaughn 3. Chippewa Falls (from SYC)-Harold Baines 4. Old Brooklyn-Dan Brouthers 5. Chippewa Falls-Sam Crawford 6. Sycamore (from CLE)-Johnny Pesky 7. Athens-Eddie Mathews 8. Brentwood-George Van Haltren Round Five 1. Lancaster-Carlton Fisk 2. Erie-Jesse Burkett 3. Sycamore-Red Faber 4. Old Brooklyn-Tommy Bond 5. Cleveland (from CFB)-Mel Ott 6. Cleveland-Buck Ewing 7. Athens-Don Drysdale 8. Brentwood-Willie Stargell Round Six 1. Lancaster-Jeff Reardon 2. Erie-James "Tip" O'Neill 3. Erie (from SYC)-Ed Killian 4. Old Brooklyn-Hughie Jennings 5. Sycamore (from CFB)-Harry Heilmann 6. Cleveland-Jack Pfiester 7. Athens-Hack Wilson 8. Brentwood-Eddie Murray Round Seven 1. Lancaster-Kent Tekulve 2. Erie-Riggs Stephenson 3. Cleveland (from CFB, from SYC)-Joe Wood 4. Old Brooklyn-Catfish Hunter 5. Chippewa Falls-Pud Galvin 6. Cleveland-Joe Morgan 7. Sycamore (from ATH)-Tom Seaver 8. Brentwood-Rollie Fingers |
| Round Eight 1. Lancaster-Joe Torre 2. Erie-Orval Overall 3. Sycamore-Pete Rose 4. Old Brooklyn-Stan Coveleski 5. Chippewa Falls-Joe Sewell 6. Cleveland-Al Simmons 7. Athens-Dave Foutz 8. Brentwood-Rickey Henderson Round Nine 1. Lancaster-Cal Ripken Jr. 2. Erie-Hugh Duffy 3. Sycamore-Ernie Lombardi 4. Old Brooklyn-Fernando Valenzuela 5. Chippewa Falls-Kid Nichols 6. Cleveland-Earl Averill 7. Athens-Kaz Sasaki 8. Brentwood-Albert Belle Round Ten 1. Lancaster-Carl Yastrzemski 2. Erie-Mike Donlin 3. Sycamore-Paul Waner 4. Old Brooklyn-Edgar Martinez 5. Chippewa Falls-Bid McPhee 6. Cleveland-Hoyt Wilhelm 7. Athens-George Brett 8. Brentwood-Bo Jackson Round Eleven 1. Lancaster-Lou Whitaker 2. Erie-Ferris Fain 3. Sycamore-Ron Guidry 4. Old Brooklyn-Robin Yount 5. Chippewa Falls-Jake Stenzel 6. Cleveland-Larry Walker 7. Athens-Andy Messersmith 8. Brentwood-Don Sutton Round Twelve 1. Lancaster-Don Mattingly 2. Erie-Max Bishop 3. Sycamore-Vern Stephens 4. Old Brooklyn-Ray Chapman 5. Chippewa Falls-Hooks Wiltse 6. Cleveland-Rube Waddell 7. Athens-Kirby Puckett 8. Brentwood-Al Spalding Round Thirteen 1. Lancaster-Bill Madlock 2. Erie-Charlie Gehringer 3. Sycamore-Kiki Cuyler 4. Old Brooklyn-Vida Blue 5. Chippewa Falls-Highpockets Kelly 6. Cleveland-Roger Connor 7. Athens-John Clarkson 8. Brentwood-Dwight Gooden Round Fourteen 1. Lancaster-Brian Downing 2. Erie-Homerun Baker 3. Sycamore-Dazzy Vance 4. Old Brooklyn-John Wetteland 5. Chippewa Falls-Tim Keefe 6. Cleveland-Al Rosen 7. Athens-Joe Cronin 8. Brentwood-Al Kaline |
| Round Fifteen 1. Lancaster-Fred Lynn 2. Erie-Denny Lyons 3. Sycamore-Freddie Lindstrom 4. Old Brooklyn-Tim Raines 5. Chippewa Falls-Lave Cross 6. Cleveland-Duke Snider 7. Athens-Bret Saberhagen 8. Brentwood-Ken Williams Round Sixteen 1. Lancaster-Jack Morris 2. Erie-Baby Doll Jacobson 3. Sycamore-Thurmon Munson 4. Old Brooklyn-Dave Winfield 5. Chippewa Falls-Ted Simmons 6. Cleveland-Elston Howard 7. Athens-Roberto Alomar 8. Brentwood-Roberto Clemente Round Seventeen 1. Lancaster-Jim Rice 2. Erie-Doc Crandall 3. Sycamore-Spud Chandler 4. Old Brooklyn-Jose Canseco 5. Chippewa Falls-Noodles Hahn 6. Cleveland-Babe Adams 7. Athens-Andre Dawson 8. Brentwood-David Cone Round Eighteen 1. Lancaster-Ken Caminiti 2. Erie-Ray Schalk 3. Sycamore-Rod Carew 4. Old Brooklyn-Doc White 5. Chippewa Falls-Babe Herman 6. Cleveland-Joe Berry 7. Athens-Mickey Tettleton 8. Brentwood-Fred McGriff Round Nineteen 1. Lancaster-Joe Carter 2. Erie-Stuffy McInnis 3. Sycamore-Jim Bottomley 4. Old Brooklyn-Herb Score 5. Chippewa Falls-Charlie Ferguson 6. Cleveland-Steve Howe 7. Athens-Harmon Killebrew 8. Brentwood-George Foster Round Twenty 1. Lancaster-Jim Barr 2. Erie-Ed Relbauch 3. Sycamore-Jimmy Key 4. Old Brooklyn-Andres Galarraga 5. Chippewa Falls-Jim McCormick 6. Cleveland-Bucky Dent 7. Athens-Will White 8. Brentwood-Sam Thompson Round Twenty-One 1. Lancaster-Jack Clark 2. Erie-Oyster Burns 3. Sycamore-Roger Bresnahan 4. Old Brooklyn-Zack Wheat 5. Chippewa Falls-Tip O'Niell 6. Cleveland-Bill Joyce 7. Athens-Orel Hershiser 8. Brentwood-Rube Foster |
 |