Beginning

1

Developing

2

Accomplished

3

Exemplary

4

Score

Group Cooperation

No cooperation while working in the group.

Some efforts to cooperate in group, but had difficulty.

Worked in group well. Had very few problems with cooperation.

Did an excellent job cooperating in the group. Contributed.

Peer Critiques

Didn�t critique summary.

Made efforts to critique, but missed some major mistakes.

Completed summary critique, didn�t offer any suggestions or recommendations.

Complete summary critique fairly and was helpful in suggestions.

Article Summary

Summary is too short, no personal evaluation, more than five grammar or spelling errors.

Summary is correct length, has no personal evaluation, has less than five grammar or spelling errors.

Summary is correct length, includes personal evaluation, has less than five grammar or spelling errors.

Summary is correct length, includes personal evaluation, has only one grammar or spelling error.

Class Presentation

Had a minimal presentation or not at all. Turned in copy of article.

Made an effort to complete the presentation but had great difficulty, didn�t have a copy of article.

Completed presentation proficiently and did a good job delivering it to the class, had copy of article.

Completed presentation proficiently with pictures to show. Did an excellent job delivering it to the class, had copy of article.