Voting
* did not vote, so a vote is cast against themselves
**-As incentive to drop out of the game, Travis V. received three jury votes.
***-Sam put back in game as a red team member in place of Travis
****-Adam was the only member of the danger zone in Cycle 14, so he automatically got voted out
| Name | Cycle 1 | Cycle 2 | Cycle 3 | Cycle 4 | Cycle 5 | Cycle 6 | Cycle 7 | Cycle 8 | Cycle 9 | Cycle 10 | Cycle 11 | Cycle 12 | Cycle 13 | Cycle 14 | Cycle 15 |
| Nick | ---- (3rd) | ---- (5th) | ---- (5) | ---- (3) | ---- (3) | ---- (1) | ---- (1) | ---- (6) | ---- (5) | ---- (4) | ---- (3) | ---- (1) | ---- (1) | ---- (2) | Winner |
| Katie | Annie (11th) | ---- (9th) | ---- (2) | ---- (1) | ---- (2) | ---- (4) | ---- (2) | ---- (2) | ---- (3) | ---- (3) | ---- (2) | ---- (2) | Robb (2) | ---- (1) | Runner Up |
| Adam | ---- (5th) | ---- (2nd) | ---- (1) | ---- (2) | ---- (1) | ---- (3) | ---- (3) | ---- (4) | ---- (1) | ---- (1) | ---- (1) | Annie (3) | Robb (3) | **** (3) | Katie |
| Robb | ---- (4th) | ---- (4th) | ---- (4) | Travis V. (9) | ----(8) | ----(7) | ----(7) | Josh B. (7) | Sean (6) | Josh (7) | Sam (5) | Adam (5) | Robb* (4) | | Nick |
| Annie | C.J. (13th) | ---- (10th) | ---- (8) | ---- (8) | ---- (4) | ---- (6) | ---- (5) | ---- (3) | ---- (2) | Robb (6) | Annie* (6) | Annie* (4) | | | Nick |
| Sam | ---- (7th) | ---- (6th) | ---- (7) | ---- (5) | ---- (5) | Travis V. (8) | Josh B. (8) | ***, Josh B. (8) | Sean (8) | ---- (2) | Sam* (4) | | | | Katie |
| Josh | C.J. (12th) | Travis V. (11th) | ---- (9) | ---- (6) | ---- (5) | ---- (5) | ---- (4) | ---- (1) | ---- (4) | Josh* (5) | | | | | Nick |
| Sean | ---- (1st) | ---- (1st) | ---- (3) | ---- (4) | ---- (7) | ---- (2) | ---- (6) | ---- (5) | Sam (7) | | | | | | Katie |
| Josh B. | ---- (10th) | ---- (7th) | Kyle (10) | Robb (11) | Eviana (11) | Maggie (10) | Sam (9) | Sam (9) | | | | | | | Nick |
| Travis V. | Travis (15th) | Bob (15th) | Kyle (12) | Robb (10) | Maggie (10) | Maggie (9) | Sam (10) | ** (10) | | | | | | | Nick*** |
| Maggie | ---- (8th) | ---- (8th) | Kyle (11) | Travis (12) | Travis V. (12) | Travis V. (11) | | | | | | | | | Katie |
| Eviana | ---- (2nd) | ---- (3rd) | ---- (6) | ---- (7) | Eviana* (9) | | | | | | | | | | Did Not Vote |
| Travis | Travis* (14th) | Travis* (14th) | Travis* (13) |
Travis* (13) | | | | | | | | | | | Did Not Vote |
| Kyle | ---- (9th) | Kyle* (12th) | Kyle* (14) | | | | | | | | | | | | Katie |
| Bob | ---- (6th) | Bob* (13th) | | | | | | | | | | | | | Did Not Vote |
| C.J. | C.J.* | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Katie |
