Adverse Drug
Reactions





medical
research




alternatives
to animal experiments?




recommended reading and
book reviews




recommended
websites





news





home





the law





statistics
click on image for other sections
                                            
                                                  
ANIMALS OR BABIES?     



    
It is NOT a choice between animals or people - but between experiments on
  animals (the results of whch cannot be applied to any other species, including
  humans) or research which relevant to humans.





safety testing?
  ANATOMY and PHYSIOLOGY:
   An editorial in `The Lancet! stated "It is notoriously dangerous to apply
   experimental results from animals to the treatment of human beings because
   humans and animal physiology show subtle but important differences"

   HUMAN RESPIRATORY SYSTEM differs from that of RATS, small RODENTS
   - mucus cavity and secretion differs from that of MICE, RATS, HAMSTERS
        CATS, RABBITS, DOGS
   - the lungs differ from those of RATS, AMPHIBIANS, REPTILES, FISH, BIRDS
   - the respiratory rate differs from that of HORSES, SHEEP, GOATS, PIGS, DOGS

   HUMAN AORTA of the HEART differs from that of DOGS
   HUMAN HEART MUSCLE CELLS differ from those of RATS, GUINEA PIGS, CATS,
      RABBITS, PIGS, MONKEYS, CATTLE, FROGS

   HUMAN NERVES CENTRES of the BRAIN differ from those of CATS
  
   HUMAN CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM differs from that of RODENTS, FROGS

   HUMAN EYE differs from that of RABBITS
   - the retina differs from that of CATS, MONKEYS, FROGS, FISH, TORTOISES,
     TURTLES, SNAKES, CHICKENS, PIGEONS

   HUMAN COCHLEA of the EAR differs from that of GUINEA PIGS

   HUMAN NEPHRONS of the KIDNEYS differ from those of RATS, DOGS, BIRDS,
      AMPHIBIANS, REPTILES

   HUMAN LIVER differs from that of MICE, RATS, DOGS, AMPHIBIANS, REPTILES,
      BIRDS

   HUMAN SKIN differs from the skin of MICE, RATS, GUINEA PIGS, RABBITS, FROGS

   HUMAN PANCREAS differs from that of MICE, DOGS

  
DISEASES
  
Less than 2% of all human diseases are ever seen in animals - so experimenters
  
try to create an animal "model" - but such artificially induced diseases in animals
   are not the same as diseases occuring naturally in human beings.

  
ARTHRITIS in HUMANS differs from the "air pouch technique" in RATS, cotton-
      wrapped cartilage implant in MICE; induced oedema swelling in RABBITS

   ASTHMA in HUMANS differs from Ascari-induced bronchospasm in DOGS
    - early response in HUMANS differs from that in RATS, RABBITS, MONKEYS, CATS,
       SHEEP, DOGS, GUINEA PIGS
    - late repsonse in HUMANS differs from that in SHEEP, RABBITS, GUINEA PIGS

   CYSTIC FIBROSIS in HUMANS differs from genetically engineered cf/cf -/- MICE

   DIABETES in HUMANS differs from removal of the pancreas in DOGS, CATS

   EPILEPSY in HUMANS differs from the EEC pattern in MICE, MONKEYS are not
      "chronic models"

   HEART DISEASE
   - atherosclerosis in HUMANS differs from cholersterol-fed RABBITS
   - strokes in HUMANS differ from the "string grasp test" in MICE

   LEPROSY in HUMANS differs from the site of the lesions in ARMADILLOS

   MALARIA in HUMANS is caused by one of four parasites - none of which can
      easily be transmitted to animals

   SPINAL MENINGITIS in HUMANS is not contracted by RATS, GUINEA PIGS, RABBITS,
      MONKEYS

   MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS in HUMANS differs from EAE (experimental autoimmune
     encephalomyelitis) in RATS, GUINEA PIGS, MARMOSETS, RABBITS, MICE

   MUSCULAR DYSTROPHY in HUMANS differs from mdx MICE, which regenerate
     muscles - which humans cannot

   PARKINSON`S DISEASE in HUMANS differs from that induced by MPTP in
     MARMOSETS

   PNEUMONIA in HUMANS has no animal "model" for the pathological mechanisms

   POLIOMYELITIS in HUMANS differs from that in RABBITS, MONKEYS, CHIMPANZEES

   RUBELLA in HUMANS differs from that in MONKEYS

  SMALLPOX in HUMANS is caused by the variola virus - which has never been
     recovered form animals under laboratory conditions

  TUBERCULOSIS in HUMANS differs from that induced in GUINEA PIGS

  ULCERS
   - stomach ulcers in HUMANS differ from that in DOGS
   - peptic ulcers, ulcers of colon, ulcers of rectum in HUMANS do not occur in
    animals.

  
DRUGS and MEDICINES

  
ASPIRIN is an analgesic in HUMANS - causes birth defects in RATS, MICE, CATS,
     GUINEA PIGS, MONKEYS

   PENICILLIN is an antibiotic in HUMANS - kills GUINEA PIGS

   INSULIN is a treatment for diabetes in HUMANS - causes birth defects in MICE,
    RABBITS

   DIGITALIS is a treatment for heart failure in HUMANS - raises blood pressure in
     animals

   CHLOROFORM is an anaesthetic in HUMANS - fatal in DOGS, causes liver damage
     in MICE, causes birth defects in RATS

   AZAURIDINE is a cancer treatment in HUMANS - fatal in DOGS

   PREDNISONE is a treatment for leukaemia in HUMANS - useless against a range
     of animal tumours including two types of leukamia
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1