Hazırlayan: Uğur Altunay   E-Posta: ugur.altunay@deu.edu.tr
NO TO
CYANIDE!

Last update
January 6, 2004

Newmont draws outcry in Asia (Heather Draper, July 23, 2003)

Mine in Greece to shut down

As a new high court decision in Greece puts an end to mining underneath the village of Stratoniki, Greek and Turkish anti-mining activists join forces against giant mining companies.

International Arbitration, Sovereignty and Environmental Protection: The Turkish Case (Aykut Çoban, University of Ankara) (pdf format)

Newmont-owned illegal goldmine provokes murder (Ustun B. Reinart, August 24, 2002)

Violence by Normandy workers causes murder in Bergama (Cumhuriyet, August 23, 2002; translation by Emet Değirmenci)

Asterix and the Turkish gold  (July 31, 2002, Olivia Rousette, SBS TV)

Thousands of peasants resist Newmont-owned goldmine in Bergama, Turkey (Ustun Reinart, May 10, 2002)

Fax message sent to Normandy by the director and the information officer of Mineral Policy Institute (April 15, 2002)

The Turkish Government Ignores Courts' Decision (April 4, 2002)

Izmir First Administrative Court also decides the Bergama mine should close (March 8, 2002)

Izmir Third Administrative Court Decides the Bergama Mine Should Close (Emet Değirmenci, March 6, 2001)

THE PAGES IN TURKISH

ARCHIVE

This site can also be accessed at http://environmentalists.educations.net or http://important.as/environment


Newmont draws outcry
in Asia

Indonesians protest the use of protected forests for mining

by Heather Draper, Rocky Mountain News, July 23, 2003

Denver's Newmont Mining Co. again finds itself a target of protest, this time in Southeast Asia.  In the past 10 days, environmentalists, academics and the government officials of some Indonesian provinces have protested the push to allow multinational mining companies onto protected forest lands. [continued]

Mine in Greece to Shut Down

Approximately 100 miners have shut themselves in the undergound Mavres Petres mine in Stratoniki, northern Greece , and are on a hunger stike, protesting against the decision of TVX Hellas to declare bankruptcy.  The Greek subsidiary of TVX Gold, which was recently absorbed by Kinross Gold Corporation, has filed a bankruptcy suit in an Athens court on June 4 and the court’s decision is expected within the month. [continued]


As a new high court decision in Greece puts an end to mining underneath the village of Stratoniki, Greek and Turkish anti-mining activists join forces against giant mining companies.

On December 6, 2002, the Greek State Council officially announced its ruling against the base metals mine belonging to the Canadian TVX Gold Company in the village of Stratoniki, in Northern Greece.  TVX, whose planned goldmine at Olympias was banned by an earlier State Council decision on March 2002, was being touted as the largest foreign investor of the last fifty years in Greece.

The announcement of this high court decision against the base metals mine in Stratoniki has coincided with the visit of Greek anti-mining activists Tolis Papageorgiou and Maria Kadoglou to Bergama, Turkey.

Papageorgiou and Kadoglou visited the villages in the immediate vicinity of the Newmont/Normandy goldmine in Ovacik, Bergama, they met with Oktay Konyar, the spokesperson of the villagers resisting the mine, and with other Turkish anti-mine activists. 

The anti-mining struggles in Greece and Turkey have followed a parallel course.  But while the March ruling of the Greek State Council has put an end to the plans for a TVX gold mine in Olympias, a 1997 State Council ruling in Turkey against the Bergama goldmine was disregarded by the Turkish government, and the mine started full production in April 2002, with a special parliamentary decision that has no legal validity.

Despite the high court rulings, gold mining projects have strong governmental support both in Greece and in Turkey.  In Greece there are proposed gold mine projects in Thrace, in Kilkis (Northern Greece) and on several Aegean islands.  In Turkey, there are close to 600 sites already ear-marked for gold-mining. 

The use of cyanide in the extraction of gold from the ore, and the inevitable activation of the heavy metals that are normally inert in the soil, make gold mining an activity that poses severe environmental risks.  Now, citizens resisting mining projects on both sides of the Aegean Sea have decided to work together to prevent ecological disasters in a region of great beauty and historic importance.

Since Turkey fervently wants to join the European Union, and Greece is already a member,

Greek and Turkish activists have decided to apply together to the European Commission to bring Turkey’s disregard for its own high court ruling to the attention of the Commission, and to ensure that laws are enforced in Turkey, as they are in Greece.

For more information: Maria Kadoglou, [email protected]

                                    Ustun Reinart, [email protected]

International Arbitration, Sovereignty and Environmental Protection: The Turkish Case

by Aykut Çoban
University of Ankara, Turkey. Contact: [email protected]

There have long been debates about the challenges of ‘globalisation’ to state sovereignty. Two dominating perspectives can be identified. The first emphasises that sovereignty is in terminal decline by virtue of the dissolving effects of globalisation on national economic policies and the increasing influence of international organisations and NGOs on governmental decisions (Bauman, 1998: 64-8; Booth, 1991: 542; Taylor, 1999). The second argues in favour of continuity by suggesting that as the international norms concerning sovereignty have guided the development of the state in the sense that each state recognises the others as having sovereignty within their own borders, and as even the biggest multinational company cannot be a rival of states in terms of control of the means of violence, ‘the history of the past two centuries is thus not one of the progressive loss of sovereignty on the part of the nation-state’ (Giddens, 1990: 67; see also James, 1999). Environment–sovereignty relations are also discussed from within the decline–continuity duality (Conca, 1994: 701-2; Litfin, 1998). Global environmental degradation is not merely regarded as testimony to the inefficacy of the sovereign state but as a challenge to the concept of sovereignty. On the other hand, the emergence of international institutions for environmental protection is seen as expanding states’ capacity to deal with the problem, thereby consolidating sovereignty. [continued -HTML format] [continued -pdf format, requiring Adobe Acrobat Reader]

Newmont-owned illegal goldmine provokes murder

by Ustun B. Reinart, August 24, 2002

VIOLENCE BY NORMANDY WORKERS CAUSES MURDER IN BERGAMA

23.08.2002, Izmir
(Cumhuriyet, Aegean Office)

The argument about the illegal gold mine in Bergama, Turkey, caused one person
to be murdered and one to be wounded. [continued]

It is with great sadness that I report to you that the unwanted and illegal Normandy/Newmont goldmine in Bergama, Turkey, has provoked a murder in a village named Pinarkoy near the mine.

    On Wednesday, August 22, a family whose members work at the mine attacked the home of 35-year-old Turan Kilinc, who has been active in the resistance against the mine, and shot him dead.

    During more than ten years of resistance to the mine, the residents of the 17 villages within a 10 km radius of the mine in the fertile northern Aegean region of Bergama have scrupulously avoided violence. They used the Turkish courts (and won at every level of the court system), and they performed creative and determined acts of civil disobedience.

    The Turkish government violated its own laws last spring, by issuing a special permit to the goldmine.  Just last week, I visited the region where most villagers were bitterly complaining that Newmont was buying out powerful villagers to break the resistance.   Now, enraged and grief stricken, they say the mine is destroying not only their lands but also their communities.

    As you know already, Bergama is the site of an ancient Roman city named Pergamon, ironically dedicated to Asclepios, the god of Health. With its olive groves, nut-bearing pines, cotton fields and fig orchards it is - was - a Garden of Eden. Today, the pine-covered hill that rises above the village of Ovacik is a bald wound on the earth.  The greenish tailings dam full of cyanide-contaminated mud grows larger every day.  And now, a family is mourning a man shot dead in the prime of life.

The script of the documentary by Olivia Rousette (SBS TV)

Asterix  and the Turkish Gold

July 31, 2002

To western Turkey, where thousands of villagers are doing battle against an Australian-built gold mine. Their champion is a charismatic former bank manager dubbed ‘Asterix’ by the Turkish media. It is Turkey`s longest-running environmental dispute, and it has pitted the indomitable peasants against the forces of globalisation, and some heavily armed Turkish police.  Despite numerous court victories, the backing of prominent scientists and a wonderful flair for publicity, the villagers look like losing out to a government desperate for foreign investment. Olivia Rousset reports on Asterix and the Turkish gold.
[Click to read the fulltext]

Thousands of peasants resist Newmont-owned goldmine in Bergama, Turkey

Ustun Reinart, May 10, 2002

The Newmont goldmine threatens the villagers’ livelihood. The villagers who are independent, and who today produce fruits, olives, vegetables and cheese will no longer be able to feed themselves.  They have nowhere to go – except to the squatter neighbourhoods of big cities. [Full text of the article]

Turkish Government Ignores Courts' Decision

Uğur Altunay, April 4, 2002

The Turkish government sent an official letter to Normandy, the Mining Corp. operating in Bergama, reading that the corporation was allowed to continue its gold mining operations on the site.  The 3rd and 1st Administrative Courts have recently made decisions one after another to stop the mining operations.  However, the government simply ignored the courts' decision and warning about the hazards of cyanide and let cyanide be used in the gold mine.

Ministry of Health Decides Bergama Mine Be Closed

Uğur Altunay, March 31, 2002

The Ministry of Health has been reported to send a letter to Normandy, the Mining Corp. operating in Bergama, to stop the mining operations.  Sefa Taskin, the former mayor of Bergama said, "Now is the time to close either the mine in Bergama or the courts in Turkey."  Oktay Konyar, the spokesperson for the villagers in the Bergama region, said, "Now we have the right to ask this question to those who have accused us of having connections with German foundations: 'What kind of connections do you have with multinational corporations?'"  The mine is expected to have closed permanently by April 2, 2002.

Izmir 3rd Administrative Court Decides the Bergama Mine Should Close

Emet Değirmenci
March 6, 2002

Izmir Third Administrative Court has recently decided that the gold mine in Bergama should be closed immediately or otherwise the consequences likely to arise due to the hazards of  mining cannot be compensated later.
[Click to read the fulltext]

Izmir 1st Administrative Court Also Decides the Bergama Mine Should Close

March 8, 2002

No sooner had Izmir Third Administrative Court decided that the gold mine in Bergama should be closed than the First Administrative Court made another decision in line with that of the Third.

A new mine to open in Antalya

February 26, 2002

It is reported that a new gold mine is to be opened in Antalya, major  touristic city in the south of Turkey.

The Peasants of Bergama Form a Union

by Oktay Konyar, the spokesman of the peasants of Bergama
December 24, 2001

For a long time now, there have been discussions about the future of the peasant’s movement in Bergama. The peasants have accomplished a great deal. Now, it is time for them to enter the political arena in a more organized fashion. We have considered joining a political party but the peasants have traditional party loyalties. Even if a political party has never supported them, they don’t abandon the political party supported by their fathers. It’s important to respect their freedom. It would not be right to call on them to join a particular party.
[Click to read the fulltext]

Life Against Gold

by Ustun Reinart

More than eleven thousand visitors in two years!

This site, set up in 2000, has been visited by more than eleven thousand visitors ever since.  The number of those visiting the English pages exceeded  4 thousand and those visiting the Turkish pages 7 thousand.  Thanks to all who enabled us to reach such figures either by promoting our site or by visiting our site.  We are also indebted to the sites linking to us and to those who contributed by writing for our site.  This site would not have survived so long without those invaluable contributions.

On a rainy December afternoon, we drive past the Normandy gold-mine at Ovacik, in the Bergama Valley of the Northern Aegean region of Anatolia. Olive groves suddenly give way to barren land, dug up and surrounded by rolls of barbed wire -- a wound on the land. Further up, the tanks and pipes of the mine tower above the huge pit where mud contaminated with cyanide will collect and remain forever toxic.

[Click here to read the full text of the article]

Cyanide mining hazards endanger community, environment

Community groups and NGOs in Europe and the United States today issued a report exposing the danger of unregulated cyanide compound releases from mines around the world.  Decoding Cyanide: an Assessment of Gaps in Cyanide Regulation at Mines reveals that current government and industry regulations and procedures fail to test for many of these potentially toxic agents. They also fail to address the issues that are of most concern to the public - protecting communities, human rights, and land and water resources.  The report was provided to the European Union (EU) Commission as input for its February 22nd Brussels meeting on cyanide leach mining.  [Click here to read the full text of the article]


Photo by Gazi Yüksel

Come and See...

Those who claim that cyanide is not harmful to the environment and to human beings are requested to come to Lefke and see what cyanide has done here. No living creatures exist here around the mining area today.

For more information, please visit the site about the Lefke case.

(by Enver Bıldır)

a request from a reader
To whom it may concern,
My name is Samuel Mayer.  I am making a research project on cyanide contamination for an OAC class in School. This project involves me going out to the field and doing experiment with a cyanide testing kit. My only problem is finding a sight in Canada to perform my experiments. And any information and pointers would be very useful.

Thanks beforehand.
Samuel Mayer

"Cyanide was the poison used in Nazi concentration camps. Now an Australian company has unleashed it on the rivers of Europe and their inhabitants."

Project Underground

Cyanide Leaching in Gold Mining Across the World and Some Facts

Cyanidation process in gold mining has led to environmental disasters in many countries across the world such as the United States1, China2, 7, Canada3, Guyana4, Bolivia, Philippines, Zimbabwe5 and Ghana6.

The harmful effects of cyanide leaching range from the release of other toxic chemicals, such as arsenic, lead, cadmium and mercury, permanent damage to some species of animals, deforestation, soil erosion, land slides, to the contamination of underground water. As the effects of cyanide are getting more obvious, the opposition to cyanide leaching in gold mining is also rising. Many organizations in such countries as the United States, Canada and Turkey to start a movement towards banning cyanide leaching in mining have been lalready formed. As a result of such movements, the use of cyanide has recently been banned in Czech Republic. Other countries are expected to follow the same path.

Why Should Cyanide Leaching in Gold Mining Be Banned?

When the related sites on the right column are checked, detailed answers to this question can be found. However, a short summary is given below:

Cyanide leaching in gold mining should be banned because
- Cyanide is deadly for human beings and for nature.
- During the cyanide leaching process, such extremely poisonous chemicals as arsenic are released.
- Due to such factors as human error and earthquakes, gold mines are never secure. As for Turkey, there is a fault line only 1.5 kilometers away from the gold mine in Bergama, Izmir.
- There is already more than enough gold in the world, most of which are kept in banks and safes.
- As for the situation in Bergama, Izmir, Turkey, the courts have prohitited cyanide leaching in the mine. Moreover, the people living around the mine are against cyanide leaching in gold mining.
- The use of cyanide in mines contradicts with the items of Human Rights Declaration. Concerning Turkey, it also contradicts with the constitution and the laws.
- Turkey will not benefit from the gold mines within its borders.
References

Life, land, clean water
and clean air are
more precious than gold.

All peoples depend
on nature for life.

It is our responsibility
to protect all of nature
for present and
future generations.

GoldBusters

1 Cyanidation process in gold mining has led to environmental disasters in the United States
2 Gold mining in China: Taming the wild west
3 Report to the Workers' Compensation Board on the Ontario Gold Mining Industry
4 Guyana, Colorado and The Black Foot River have all been contaminated by cyanide
5 Small-scale Gold Mining: Examples from Bolivia, Philippines & Zimbabwe
6 Cyanide Spill Ghana's Worst Environmental Disaster
7 Eleven tonnes of cyanide spills into Chinese river

If you have articles you would like us to include in this site or any ideas you would like to share with us, please write to [email protected]  

Siyanürle Altın Madenciliği ve Gerçekler Anasayfası'na gitmek için burayı tıklatın. (Click here to go to the page in Turkish.)

© 2000, Uğur Altunay

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1