That night after some deliberation amongst the Bronx Tribe, Seth and Danielle S. grabbed their torches and led the rest of the Tribe down the streets to the warehouse for the fourth Tribal Council of the season. Seth and Danielle S. grabbed a seat, while Nick told Danielle P., Micha, Jerroth, Jacob, and January to grab a torch and get it lit with fire. As they placed their torches in the proper places and took their seats, Nick addressed the Bronx Tribe with a few questions. The first was the January. He asked her about how much pressure was placed on her as the last surviving player on the Bronx Tribe during the challenge. She said it was very unnerving and stressful to be the only one left to answer questions for her tribe. She was scared that she would screw up badly. Jacob jumped in and told Nick that the tribe was proud of how well she did on her own with all that pressure riding on her and she overshot the number by just a little bit. Nick then addressed Jerroth about tribe morale. He answered proudly saying that the tribe was really stoked for being as dominant as they have been in challenges and added that Roy was lucky today. Nick said it should be an interesting vote and asked Jacob to start the voting. Jacob, Seth, Danielle P., Micha, January, Jerroth, and Danielle S. all wrote down their vote, placed it in the tea kettle, and walked back to their seats as Nick went to retrieve the votes. He sat the kettle on the pedestal and began reading the votes aloud one-by-one:
DANIELLE S.
DANIELLE S.
DANIELLE P.
MICHA
MICHA
MICHA
The last vote...
DANIELLE S.
It was a tie as Nick explained that the tribe will revote for either Danielle S. or Micha (who can't vote) The tribe revoted as a teary eyed Seth spent a minute at the voting booth crying before casting his vote. Nick tallied the votes again:
2 votes for DANIELLE S. and two votes for MICHA as the fourth person voted out of Roughin' It: New York City was...DANIELLE S.
A few tears rolled down her face as she grabbed her torch and approached Nick. He snuffed her torch out as she quietly sobbed on her way out of the warehouse. Jerroth and Danielle P. looked wide-eyed at each other as their plan failed. Nick told the highly emotional tribe to grab their torches and head back to camp.
