A View from Box-5 by Kaoru

 The Phantom of the Opera (Her Majesty, London 10/30/97) Dress Circle

I was so looking forward to seeing this production in London. I'd see Phantom holding Christine before she faints, there will be extended version of Raoul singing at the graveyard, etc. Well that night, there were a few accidents, which did not distract my attention too much. But the most damaging thing was that I could not feel any sympathy, compassion, or pity for Phantom. I don't mind "maddening" Phantom, I rather welcome that kind of interpretation. But Phantom still needs to have elegance and seducing atmosphere. Peter lacked both unfortunately, at least at the performance I saw. I saw Zoe's Christine, and she sang pretty well, but I couldn't see deep love towards Raoul nor Phantom. Later I found out that Raoul was an understudy, so maybe the chemistry between Christine and Raoul was lacking. Carlotta did not impress me too much. I saw Brad Little national tour, and Julie Schmit, who is now Carlotta in San Francisco, was much better. I was really disappointed by both managers. Usually Andre has some comic relief, but London Andre was pretty flat, so there was not a good contrast between Andre and Firmin. The surprise was Raoul, I did not know until the show was over that he was the understudy (there was no announcement and I did not get a slip of paper until the end), but during the show, I thought, "Raoul is the only one who is leading the show."

Usually, I'd be moved or even cry at the final liar, but at London production, I did not feel the heartwrenching energy I usually feel from the stage, and the kiss scene and the reaction of Phantom afterward weren't moving either. I have to say, I wasn't judgmental at all, I really tried hard to find some good qualities in this production, but I gave up at the end. Maybe it was only that particular night the cast wasn't in sync, but I felt I was betrayed on the way home. I was thinking about SF POTO cast and how wonderful they are, and I really want to see POTO in SF again. (I think National Tour cast (Brad Little) was better than London cast)

December 20, 1997 Christine Company (San Francisco, Curran Theatre) Orchestra F #114

(Interested in reading a longer version and found out how I managed to get such a great seat? Click here.)

(note: Christopher Carl was the understudy Phantom)

 Music of the Night

He was really sexy in this song. Especially, from "You have come here…." till "my music, my music…" he leaned over the organ as if he'd like to rush up to Christine and touch her and hold her tight, but he can’t. At that point, I felt like his Phantom really adores, loves, and longs for Christine. His Phantom was not a fatherly figure or mad man, but desperately in love with Christine. I could feel his heartache. His voice was really sexy and I loved it even his soar didn’t last too long (darn!). His natural range is baritone, so unless they change the key for him, it must be really challenging.

 Point of No Return

What can I say? Chris was soooo sexy, or should I say the entire scene after he appeared was very sexy and my heart was pumping, felt my body temperature went up. I think Karen was sexy Aminta, too, so both of them excelled in this scene. Once again, I could tell his desperate love towards Christine and when she touched him, it was like his passion exploded and he couldn’t stop caressing. EXCELLENT, BRAVISSIMO! When Christine noticed that he was Phantom and tried to run, the power his showed to pull her back was so overwhelming, it was mixed emotion of passion and anger. I LOVED IT!! After the hood was pulled away, we saw a vulnerable lonely soul that is desperately longing for Christine’s love.

 HOWEVER, I know this is definitely difference of interpretation, but after Chris pulled the ring from his finger, he put it on Christine’s finger instead of handing it to her and let her put it on by herself. I definitely prefer the latter because it totally changes the relationship between two of them. If Phantom puts the ring on her finger, then it’s like he is forcing her to accept him. But if Christine takes it and put it on by herself, then it’s more like, even she is in a state of trance, she accepts Phantom in part of her mind; hence she doesn’t totally reject Phantom subconsciously. To a person who wants to side with Phantom, the latter interpretation suits much better. However, I remember that when I saw Michael Lackely (sp?) as an understudy Phantom in September, he did the same thing he did. Does that mean every understudy Phantom put the ring on Christine where Franc hands it out? I’m very curious. Incidentally, Karen’s Christine showed a bit of disgust when Phantom put the ring on her finger, which is not good, it’s sign that she has already rejected him.

Final liar

This is such an emotional scene every time I see the show, and difficult scene, too. (At the same time an actor can push his envelop a lot here) Because I prefer to see the desperation turning to maddening anger, but not too angry at the same time. I liked his reaction when Christine said "The tears I might have shed for your dark fate grow cold, and turn to tears of hate!" It was as if Erik finally realized what happened to the relationship between him and Christine. So when Phantom said, "Make your choice!" I felt like that he already knew the choice she would make (choosing Raoul). I was moved by his reaction after the kiss, I could clearly see his state of shock and heartbreaking choice he had to make for Christine. After Christine and Raoul had gone, and he picked up the veil and murmured "Christine, I love you" over and over again, he showed one last time his genuine love towards Christine, and it was very touching.

January 22, 1998 Christine Company (San Francisco, Curran Theatre) Orchestra H #111

 I saw SF POTO on 1/22 in the full house (at least on the orchestra level) in the 7th row, and it was GREAT!! I saw Lisa as Christine and she convinced me that she is the best Christine currently performing in the world in the overall rating (singing, acting, physique etc). Chris as Raoul was strong, as ever, he is the only Raoul that makes Christine torn between Raoul and Phantom. And I can tell Raoul loves Christine so much by the number of times he kisses Christine. He kissed Christine at least three times or more during Masquerade! (I saw national tour POTO in L.A. last weekend and there, Raoul did NOT kiss Christine at all during Masquerade)

But what I want to talk about is Franc. Oh, he took Erik to another level on Thursday night. He was beyond excellent. I noticed he was portraying Erik a bit different on that night from the beginning. His singing was a bit heavy, shall I say? Each note was pronounced slightly longer but clearer and stronger. There are many points he performed slightly different from previous ones but the most noticeable one was the Angel scene. He usually mummers "Christine.... Christine...." after "he was bound to love you...." but on Thursday, he almost shouted like "Christieeeeeeeeeeene!" which shook my soul like nobody else did, I almost groaned. Then when he heard Christine and Raoul's love song in the back ground, he turned back a bit and tried to hide in his cape, and even said "pul-eeeeeeeeeeease" in moaning way. Since his movement was much larger than usual, so the Angel swung a bit but he did not care, and neither did I. I thought that performance itself was worth the price of admission. I was so moved I felt like I want to give him a standing ovation right there (at the end of the first act).

I wanted to stay after the show to tell Franc how much I enjoyed and appreciated his performance that night but it was really late, so I didn't. I'm going to see the show again on 1/31 so hopefully I will tell him about it on that day.

January 31, 1998 Christine Company (San Francisco, Curran Theatre) Lower box #1

This was the first time I saw in the box seat. I could not see the rear stage of the left side (like Manager's desk) but other than that, I could see everything so close!! When Franc came towards Christine to get his mask back after "Damn you!" I could almost see his eye color. I love this seating! Franc got better and better as the story progressed. And the very end, when he sang "You alone can take my song take flight... it's over now the Music of the Night!" I got goosebumps, so did the rest of the audience because before the song was ended, everybody started applausing! Of course, there was a standing ovation for Franc too. Great performance as usual.

POTO backstage tour

I am pretty lucky that I became acquainted with a sweet girl through a Phantom Board. She is a friend with Franc D'Ambrisio and knows many actors in the Christine Company. So I dared and asked her if it's possible for her to arrange a backstage tour for me, and she was such a sweet person, and said YES. SO after the matinee, which was another superb production, we met at the stagedoor, and her friend, Mike took us on the stage.

Most of the sets are hang in the air, and I was surprised that the stairs that they use in Masquerade are collapsed and shot up in the air. There was the table they use in Point of No Return in the wing with lots of plops on it. I took one of the goblets in my hand and.... no, I put it back. As much as I wanted to have it as a memento, I don't want to be banned from SF POTO. (BTW, if it was Javert's ribbon, I don't think I can guarantee keeping my hands away from it!)

The stage itself was not that big, and when you look at the orchestra section from the stage, it did not look huge either. The chandelier was in the mid air, and a guy was working on the cleaning up the hole where these fires shoot up. He said after every performance he has to clean it and refill the gun powder. Mike showed me the death trap that Phantom disappears into after Masquerade, the hole Raoul jumps into to find Christine (the actor jumps in from 15 ft high!) There was the Phantom chair where he disappears into at the end. We were told not to touch anything so I stuck my head in the chair to see how it works. I think I know how now but of course it's a secret. ;)

Then we went down under the stage to see all the ensemble's costumes (they don't dry clean often, they clean the liners, oh, stinky!). Every time Mike explained in which scene they used the costume or wig etc, I sang a phrase a bit and he said "This woman really knows Phantom." Well of course, I should be the understudy of understudy. I can immediately become Christine if they need one!

I really appreciate Ms. S.L. and Mike for their kindness, I had such a wonderful theatre experience I will treasure for a long time.

February 19, 1998 Christine Company (San Francisco, Curran Theatre) Orchestra K #7

I went to SF POTO last night through the storm and hails, anything for Franc, of course --- only to find out that Phantom was understudy!! Aaaaaaaggggggrrrrr! I knew that Lisa was on vacation in advance, so it would be Karen last night, but when I opened the playbill, there were another white paper saying "in today's performance, Phantom will be played by Norman Lange" !! Okay, so what happened to Franc? Did he get sick or his place was flooded out?? I had a mixed feeling because I was so looking forward to see both Lisa and Franc again, and when I found out that Lisa would be on vacation, I thought "well, at least I can see Franc's performance which is worth price of the admission," then that hope was shattered when I sat in the seat. However, I have never seen Norman's Phantom so I thought, "okay, he may surprise me." Still, had I known that I'd be seeing an understudy Phantom like when I saw Chris in December, I didn't have a panic attack right before the performance. (Of course, Franc wasn't planning to be sick so I'm NOT blaming anybody here)

The theatre was packed (at least the orchestra section) and the audience was very warm and responsive. Norman performed quite well for being an understudy at the last minutes, but his first note "Insolent Fool! The slave of fashion, basking your glory!" was not as angry as Franc's. I love Franc's the entrance scene so much. I should not compare with Norman and Franc since Franc has been performing Erik for four years. I only wished Norman's body movements were a bit more smooth and relaxed. He looked so stiff at "I have brought you..." and movement was somewhat choppy and sudden.

Still, I liked his "Point of No Return," it was sincere and at the same time very sexy too. (I told him after the show and he was a bit embarrassed) Also when he was kissed by Christine, he made a sound like "aahhh" showing how surprised and moved he was, I thought that was original. Also when Christine returned to return the ring, he acted like she came back to him, and he again expressed an audible joy, which quickly turned to realization of the disappointment. Very nice touch.

Norman seemed very friendly after the show (must be very happy with his performance) and signed his autographed on my ticket tab (I have Chris' autograph on my ticket when he was Phantom). BTW, Martin Lewis was the understudy Andre and he was quite funny. He portray Andre as a gay-ish manager, in my opinion, and it worked well. I wanted to ask him and confirm if my observation was correct, but alas, he walked away ever so quickly.

January 3, 1999 Christine Company (San Francisco, Curran Theatre) Mezzanine row G #106

Yap, as some of you suspected, I attended the final POTO performance at San Francisco. In the sold out theatre, I sat in the center Mezzanine to have a great view for the last time.

The performance was nearly perfect. Franc D'Ambrosio (Phantom) has been sick since November, and has missed most of the matinee shows, so I could tell he was not 100%, but he was pouring everything he had, and I was very satisfied. His weep and cry, "Christineeeeen!" in the Angel statues totally tore your heart. Lisa Vrohman (Christine) is a seasoned Christine yet her vocal clarity hasn't changed a bit. It seemed her singing was powerful as ever too. My friend met Lisa before the show and she said she would stay in the Bay Area for a while. I heard that there is her solo CD possibility near future. Christopher Carl performed Raoul stunningly and it looks like he is looking forward to returning to NYC. He will appear in 1776 in Santa Barbara from Feb. to March.

Even though there were many Phans who have seen the show hundreds of times, the audience laughed at every cue. There were prolonged applause after every song, especially, after Music of the Night, the applause kept going and the blackout remained for a while.

I truely enjoyed the performance by Patricia Hurd (new Carlotta), boy, she can sing AND act! Her timing was impeccable. I have never laughed at Carlotta's scenes so much. Too bad this was the last time I saw her in POTO (unless she goes to the tour). Bravo, Ms. Hurd!

Finally the inevidable time has come. When Phantom sang "It's over now Music of the Night...," to us, the lyric was too close to the heart. The final curtain came down and it was the end of SF POTO Christine Company. Franc, Lisa, and Christopher made a speech and there were lots of laughter, so it wasn't too bad. Franc never said "good bye," he kept saying "thank you, thank you," and I yelled back "Thank YOU, Franc!"



Go back to the Cream of the Crop page

Go back to the Home page


This page hosted by GeoCities Get your own Free Home Page



 

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1