9
                                                       We  had  more  than enough  of  those to consider for the awards, so much so that it
                                                        took  us  a  long  time  to  debate  over  our  choices,  championing our favorites and
dismissing  those  that  raised  our  hackles. Judging the stories made me realize how  limited my own taste can be, and how
keen  my  women  co-judges  were  to  certain  nuances  that  I  overlooked  in  some  stories.  It  was  only  later, after the
deliberations,  that  we  learned  some of the eminent names of the authors in our shortlists�Azucena Grajo Uranza, Rosario
Cruz  Lucero,  Charlson  Ong,  Angelo �Sarge� Lacuesta�proof that the magazine continues to attract established writers as
well  as the hot new ones emerging from creative writing classes and workshops.  Proof again that, contrary to some critics
who say literary writing in English is moribund or is a dying tradition, our literature in English continues to flourish.

Paolo Manalo, the literary editor disqualified six stories, and that left us 32 short stories to read over the Christmas break.

It so happens that there are no old fogeys in this year�s crop of judges, and so our choices reflect our age. We chose stories
that  were  well-written,  narratively  compelling,  and  ones  that chose risks or were even risqu�. And it was also only later,
after the deliberation, that we realized all our winning authors happened to be gay.

The  first  prize  went  to 
Bobby  Flores Villasis for �Elegies From Another Book,� a story that perfectly captures (through
fiction)  the  decadent  ethos  of  Negros.  Told in an elegant prose style, it teems with characters, achieving the density of a
novel yet retaining the control of a short story. The story is about Jake, a college professor who tries to turn his back on the
aristocratic  Hispanic  culture  he  came  from,  withall its preoccupation with social status and propriety. Resolutely gay and
bohemian,  Jake defies his background by teaching in a Protestant university and having an affair with Wayne, the Caucasian
husband of one of his cousins. The story is a strange brew of social satire, gothic violence, and, yes, hot sex. But in the end,
the  story  still  manages  to  achieve tragic pathos. After his father dies, Jake goes back to the old house with two of his gay
students.  The  last  sentence  reads:  �We plan to make love until the sun streams in through the windows and all the ghosts
have  gone.�  The  story  is  a  triumph of the art of story-telling;  the sensory details wash over the reader as he gets sucked
into  the  steamy,  sweltering world depicted in the story and even smell and taste the sweat of lovemaking. I understand that
this  is  not the first time that Bobby Villasis has won the award, and he has been writing about the same milieu in his fiction.
If  one  tries  to  understand  Negros  from  Bobby�s  stories,  one  will see a world more sinister and sensual than the South
created by Tennessee Williams. In him, Renato Madrid has become a pagan.

You  will  either love or hate the 2nd prize-winning story �Higher Orders� by
John Bengan. It is the kind of story that elicits
extreme  reactions  from readers. One judge said she was �stunned� by it and wanted it to win 1st prize, while another judge
found  a  lot  of objectionable elements in it. The story is narrated by a rookie assassin, a young member of the Davao Death
Squad,  the  group  allegedly  responsible  for the extrajudicial killings of notorious drug pushers and drug lords in Mindanao.
For  sheer  suspense  and  handling  of  action, the story was the most compelling to read in this year�s batch of stories. The
assassination  scene  alone  is as vivid as any action movie, but the moral resonances of the story cannot be captured by that
medium. Andrea Pasion, one of the judges, commented:  �[  �   ]�

The  3rd  prize-winning  story  went  to 
Danton  Remoto for the coruscatingly hot story �The Heart of Summer.�  For its
delicateness  and  lyricism,  the story is reminiscent of some coming of age stories by Kerima Polotan and Estrella Alfon, but
this  story  becomes  doubly poignant because the narrator is gay. Menchu Aquino, who found the story really cute, had this
to say about it: �[�]�

We  do  not  claim  that these three stories were �the best� ones published this year. Eight other stories were shortlisted, and
many  of  them were  just as good and effective, with memorable characters and originality of vision. There was the strange
story  of  the  female  �electric  man�  who  tampered  with  the electric meter of houses at night; there was the story of the
appearance of  the Virgin Mary�s apparition in the market of Pagadian; and there was the story of a woman who almost gets
tempted  to  abscond with a signature leather bag in Paris. Stories and stories and stories, so well-written, so deserving to be
read.  Our country is a babel of stories, so much chismis from showbiz to the love affairs of politicians, but few of them get
written down as fiction worth publishing in the pages of
Free Press.

If  there  was  anything  we  learned  from  the  passionate debates we had as judges, it was the confirmation of the fact that
some  tastes  are shared, and some are not. Contests are just as good as the tastes of its judges, and we abide by our choices
as a reflection of our tastes and prejudices. 

On  behalf  of  my  co-judges  Menchu  and  Andrea,  we would like to thank Free Press and the sponsors of the contest for
making  us  experience  the joy of reading some of the best stories that will mold the landscape of our country�s imagination.
As  practicing  writers,  we  have  been  quickened  and  inspired  by  the thought that we are in good company, and we will
continue  to  write  with  the notion that we are not alone, that stories beget stories, and that
Free Press is the best venue for
publishing them.



An Introduction to the Prize-Winning Stories
By Timothy Montes
Ah, the stories.
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1