[Anyhow Home] [Last Touches Story
Index]
A SAD COMEDY
IT was four
o’clock on a June afternoon in
On the Boulevard Haussmann, at the end nearest the Printemps, there is a print shop; by its side a wide entrance leading to the flats above. The concierge’s little den is on the left. By her door stands a plaister figure holding up a lamp; on the right is the staircase covered with carpet and white druggeting that would be impossible in an English building inhabited by many tenants. Here and there is a corner of the staircase stands a palm, and half way up there is another figure holding a lamp.
On the
fourth floor there lived, five years ago, a woman. All
The woman to whom the place belongs walked up and down quickly, as if she could not bear the agony of her own thoughts; and again slowly, as if the very intensity of the pain half lulled her. She was dark and slender, with a small well-poised head; her black hair dropped low over her forehead, and was gathered into a knot behind; her eyes were soft and dark; her mouth was tender, but it had a scornful curve, and over the whole face anguish and scorn seemed struggling to gain the mastery. She stopped by the window for a moment, but turned away quickly as if the sight of passing people tortured her: kneeling down by one of the wicker chairs she buried her face in the cushion that was tilted across its back. The sleeve of her gown was loose, she pushed it up and bit her arm to keep in the cries that were beating against her heart and struggling to escape from her lips.
“It will kill me,” she said, “it must. If I could have seen him die, it would have been better—sorrow only breaks one’s heart, but scorn like this burns out one’s soul.”
She got up and walked to and fro again.
“He has been so cruel, so brutal,” she cried; “and he is afraid to face me, he has no courage, none—none; yet I love him, him—that man, whom I now see clearly. And oh, my God, how faithful I would have been to him. I could have faced anything in the world; I should have thought it joy to suffer because he loved me. But he, he does not know what courage means—when I die I will leave him my little finger. I cannot bear it, oh, dear God, I cannot—be merciful and do not make me—” the door was opened. She stifled a little cry and turned quickly.
But there entered only a bonne—the traditional French servant, with the white strings of her cap resting flat on her back.
“Madame,”
she said, “I have a letter from my sister at
The woman listened and answered like one in a dream.
“Yes, yes Catherine, you can go. I shall not want any dinner, but you can put it ready and go.”
“Merci, Madame;” and having secured her point, she was adroitly vanishing. The woman called her back.
“Catherine,” she said impatiently, as if she had remembered a necessary duty, and was in haste to perform it, “take the little one some chicken, and there are raspberries and cakes.”
“Merci, merci. Madam is always good to the sick; but Madame is good to all the world,” the bonne said brightly, and waited for an acknowledgment of what was meant to be a pleasant remark. But the woman, trembling with eagerness to be alone, had hardly heard her.
Suddenly there was the little ting of a bell. The woman’s hands locked themselves almost affrighted in each other, and she leant against a cabinet to steady herself.
“Voilà Monsieur,” Catherine exclaimed with a smile and an air of certainly, as she hurried towards the door. “It is a long time since he has been to see Madame,” she muttered, “but that is surely his ring. I always know the manner of it.”
In a moment she returned.
“Monsieur Luard,” she announced, and shut the salon door. The sound of her footsteps grew fainter: the man and woman were alone.
The man too was dark, tall, and fairly slight; young still, two or three and thirty, perhaps, not handsome, though his face arrested attention. Those who came in contact with him felt at once that he was a man worth considering, that he and the world would have much to do with each other, and especially that he would govern his surroundings, rather than he governed by them. A man who knew that he had a history awaiting him, and was impatient to begin it; but it lay outside the room in which he stood: that was as evident as his own consciousness of it. The woman gave a little gasp as he came forward, and passing him stood at the side of the room on which was the doorway, as if to prevent him from going till it pleased her to let him. The empty chairs before the window made, with their cushions, two patches of vivid colour, the stripes in the sunblind showed clearly, the flowers on the balcony beneath it, the sunshine beyond, the drowsy hush that belongs to summer, all seemed to intensify the hour through which the two people, who looked at each other, had to live ere all things between them came to an end.
“Well,” he asked, “what is it?” She hardly seemed to hear him. She gave a long sigh, and said breathlessly, as if to herself:
“You have come—” She was evidently struggling to control herself, and he saw it.
“You insisted,” and he shrugged his shoulders after the fashion of the Englishman abroad.
“Why did you not write? I sent you so many letters. A man usually answers—”
“I had nothing to say.”
“And silence is so valorous,” she said in a low voice. He pressed his lips together.
“Did you send for me to have a final quarrel? It was hardly worth while.”
“Oh, no,”
she echoed, with a note of sadness, “hardly worth while. When do you go to
“To-night by the 9·50.”
“And to
“In a month’s time.”
She hesitated, then in the same low voice she asked:
“Did you mean all the things you said the other night?” He nodded.
“It is time it ended,” he said, “what would come of it if we went on?”
“The future keeps its own counsel and we could wait on it.” But he was silent. “And the other things?” she asked.
“What other things?”
“The cruel,
wicked ones—” she broke off and went on abruptly. “Ah, I remember when I saw
you first—that day at
“Perfectly. It was a pity you did not betray your feelings at the time. You disguised them well.”
“They were not feelings. It was a sudden impression flashed upon me and forgotten till the other night. Then, as I looked at your face again, I understood and stood aghast. It was like a revelation.”
“And did you wish to tell me this? I am curious to know the reason of the interview. I suppose we shall arrive at it soon?” He was calm enough, but his face was white and hard.
“No; but
you force it from me. You are so speechless: you do not seem to care at all.
You treat the past eight years—eight whole years,
“I do,” he answered doggedly. “It may be pleasanter than this one.” She clasped her hands in despair—white hands on which there was just one little ring, a gold circle with a moonstone in it.
“Oh, my God,” she cried, “that I should have cared for you—that I should care still, and not loathe you. I could kill myself for the criminal deed of loving you.”
“But why?” he asked. His tone had changed, but it had no effect upon her. “I have loved you, Madeline.”
“You,” she
said; “what you call love is not fit to stamp under my feet. Oh go, go—I cannot
endure even the sight of you, it maddens me. Go to the women you are fit
for—the women who will make you once of a series; as you, perhaps, have made
me. Is there some one waiting for you in
“I shall mean them,” he said, slowly.
“Mean them,” she echoed scornfully, “oh yes, mean them if you can. Say them to some Englishwoman—they will satisfy her, no doubt.”
“I am going to marry one,” he answered, and silence fell. Her lips turned white, her hands trembled, but still she struggled to be composed.
“Ah,” she gasped, “at last you have found courage to tell the truth. It was very difficult, was it not? And soon? Is it to be soon?”
“Yes.” He watched her critically, and half in fear; but even as he did so he was sensible of the sweetness of her voice, the perfect contour of her head.
“That is
why you are going to
“Yes.”
“Is it to the one you told me of—your cousin, Mademoiselle Isabel?” He nodded.
“I
understand. You were always ambitious. You think she will be admired, that she
will make a sensation at the Embassy. You are living already through your
triumphant arrival at
“I have tasted success, and am like a tiger that has tasted blood. All things pall beside it. Now, may I be permitted to depart? There is nothing to be gained by prolonging this visit, I imagine?”
She was silent for a moment. Then she went nearer and a little nearer till she was within a yard of him. Her voice softened, an entreaty seemed to be in the movement of her hands.
“Don’t do it,” she said, as if the words were forced from her against her will, as words are forced from prisoners on the rack. “She will not love you as I have.”
“It is too late—”
“Ah, no!” she cried. It was like a cry of pain.
It seemed to smite him. He looked almost afraid, as if he were at her mercy.
“I wanted to marry you once,” he said, “and you refused.”
“I know,” she answered, sadly, standing before him with her head bent. “I wanted to be famous; as you did, too. I thought some day, perhaps, you might be proud of me, and then—but it is our ambition that has divided us. My fame would only be a hindrance to you, and yours is not yet great enough to give me shelter.”
“It is better, wiser, to part.”
“No, no, that cannot be—it cannot be better to let life go for the cold reflection of it—” she swayed, as if from weakness, and, mechanically, as if to prevent her from falling, he put his arm round her.
“Poetical, as usual, Madeline,” he said, half tenderly.
“No,” she answered, and a little restfulness seemed to steal over her; “no, not that. Do you think,” she asked, “that any woman will ever love you as I have done?”
“No, no woman will ever love me half so well.”
“Other women’s love—”
“There will be no other women. You do not comprehend, I am going to marry.” He spoke as though he had only to impress this fact upon her to make her see its reasonableness.
“A lukewarm woman with grey eyes and fair hair?”
“I love her,” he said, doggedly.
“Love her,” she answered, in a low, scornful voice; “go on loving her, try your best: you will find that I have for ever raked the fire out of any love that is left in your heart to give.” She had raised herself and stood with her head thrown back looking at him while she spoke.
“Madeline,” he urged, “be sensible. Nothing could come of this, it is better to end it. I would have married you once, as you know. I entreated you, and you refused. Now I am going to marry elsewhere. You said just now that one ambition had parted us. It has. We have both a chance of a career—yours is made already; but we should only wreck each other. There are many things in the world besides love. You used to protest that an intellectual life was so much to you.”
“Oh yes. It has been much—”
“Dreams and ideals and the rest of it.”
“And from dreams one awakens; and ideals are often but commonplaces wrapt round with a cloud.”
“You are getting better; this is like the old talk,” he said, with a sigh of relief. “Now, let me go, dear; it is better to get it over.”
“No, I
cannot. Oh,
“I hoe it will last longer,” he said grimly. “Money and success and reputation are the things men try for and value.”
“When you are dying”—and her voice was low again— “it is my love that you will remember, my kisses you will linger over—not success or reputation or the money at your bank.”
“You have been eager enough to gain your own success.”
“Only that it might strengthen your love for me—might make my love seem more precious to you. When they have crowded to see me, and the place has rung with applause—you have been there and known”—and for a moment there was a ghost of triumph in her voice. “It has all seemed only like a wild accompaniment to a little secret song in my heart, that only you and I understood in all the world. And when I heard their shouts I only cared because I knew that you heard them too.” For a moment he was silent.
“I have been an awful brute to you,” he said; “but, Madeline, I know what is best for us both.”
“You said I should die on your shoulder,” and she touched it with her cheek. “If you had but kept that promise—”
“One promise so much when one is in love.”
“Now another woman will die there. I pray that Heaven may shut its gate on her.”
He raised himself angrily, “You are going too far,” he said.
“No,” she
entreated, “forgive me, forgive me: remember that we shall never meet again.
“It is impossible.” She put her head once more on his shoulder with a long sigh of content, though she knew that the contentment was but for a moment.
“My dear place,” she said, “my dear home. Come and dine with me this last night,” she whispered again. “Let us forget that it is the last—and then I will let you go.”
“I cannot.”
“Yes, just once more, for the last time in the world.”
“It is impossible,” he repeated.
“No, no, not impossible,” she said, quickly and eagerly. “I will not be cruel or cross; I will be your Madeline who has love you, and grown famous only for love of you. Will any other woman do that for you, dear life? No, no I think not. We will have a cosy dinner. I will wear my cream-coloured gown that you like, the one with the wide sleeves that fall back like these. I will do my hair up in a great loose knot. You said it suited me. I will put red roses at my waist and look my best, and we will talk of poetry and ideals”—and a little scoffing came into her voice as she said it—“and we will forget that it is the last time we may ever meet at all.”
“I can’t. I
have asked
“When—at what time?”
“At 7·30, and then he is to see me off.” She was silent for a moment.
“Come to me after your dinner. 7·30, and the train goes at 9·50. Tell him to meet you at the station, and come to me at 9, or soon after, and we will have a last few minutes. We will sit on those chairs in the twilight, as we have sat so often, and drink our coffee, and look at the flowers, and the lights as they come in the windows opposite. Yes, yes,” she went on, swiftly, “and then you shall go. I could not bear to part like this. You say I am poetic, let our parting be so—in the twilight, with the scent of the flowers, and the coffee on the little table just as in the old days, and I in a white dress. We will not say a single word to let ourselves know it is the last time—and you shall go before half-past nine. Oh! I swear to you, I will not say a single word that shall betray that you are not coming again to-morrow and to-morrow.”
“You will really let me go?” he asked, relenting. “You will be sensible and calm?”
“I will
really let you go,” she repeated eagerly, “and he sensible and calm. Oh, I will
be the wisest woman in
He looked down at her face for a moment and then answered slowly:
“I will come, I will trust you—”
“And you will take me in your arms for just one moment before you go, and kiss me and say ‘ I love you.’ Yes, yes; you have said it so often in years gone by and never will again in years to come.”
“But—”
“Only for this last time—you
need not say good-bye—it shall be that instead, and then,” she added, with a
sigh, “I will let you go and be content.”
“Then it shall be so;” he answered,
gently.
“You will not fail me?” he answered,
gently.
“No. Look beautiful and let us
forget that it is the end.”
“I will;” she looked up at him with
a smile, and spoke in the sweet voice that all
“Well?” he asked inquiringly.
She answered slowly, “May the woman
you will hold dearest in your life, when mine is severed from it, be false and
fail you in the hour you love her best if you fail me to-night.”
“I will not fail you. I will come
and trust to you to keep your word.”
“I will keep it,” she answered. “Now
go, and good-bye, since we are not to say it to-night. There shall not be one
single parting word, I promise you; but you must say that you love me,
remember. Adieu, adieu,” and she opened the door. “Stay, I forgot that
Catherine is going to
“No,” he said, with a strange fear,
“not finished?”
“Finished as far as love is life,
and it is all; what does the rest matter? But, there, go—go,
it is better. Here is the key.” And she was calm again. “It was only for
one moment, just for one moment that I forgot,” she explained, breathlessly:
“now, see, I am quite brave, and will be so. I will sit and listen for your footsteps
to-night. Adieu, adieu.”
“I am so far out of it,” he said, as
he stepped on to the boulevard. “Probably she will keep her word. She is a
consummate actress, but I believe she loves me.” He walked on till, he hardly
knew how, he found himself at the Rue Royale. He went along it, stood looking
for a moment at the Place de la Concorde, and then turned up the Rue de Rivoli, just for a last time to see the familiar shops and
faces, and the gold lines on the rails of the
Madeline Debray
loved him, and had trusted him as none beside in the world ever would. His cousin Isabel? Her feeling for him, and he knew it
perfectly, was as yet an unanswered question. He loved her—curiously, as a
mother does her unborn child, wondering how the world will seem when the new
life awakes in it. She would awake when he had set out life before her, and had
given her all things. He liked to think that he had the whole shaping of her
future; he resented the power of a woman who could make a career
unaided—unconsciously he resented Madeline’s having done so, as well as the
manner in which she had done it.
He hurried on, to make the last
arrangement for his journey. There would be only just time to catch the train,
after his interview with Madeline.
“Have you finished packing,
Charles?” he asked, as he entered his rooms.
“Oui,
Monsieur, but see this little silver box was nearly left; it had fallen behind
the escritoire in the Monsieur’s room.” Luard looked
at it almost angrily. Madeline had given it him three years ago. They had gone
to St. Germain-en-Laye, and whiled away half-an-hour
at one of the curiosity shops. He had bought her a quaint old fan—he remembered
the skirts of the little Watteau dancers painted on it, and the pattern of the
inlaid ivory sticks.
“Stay,” she had said, “I will give
you something too; this little antique box, it is the shape of a heart—of my
heart that loves you,” she whispered. “You must keep your stamps in it. When
you go to
He could see the long terrace, and
the forest, and the Château at its gates.
He could hear Madeline’s talk again,
of James II. who had died there, and Madame de Montespan, who had danced; of Marie Antoinette who had
driven through the stony streets. While he listened he had dropped the box.
“Ah, do not tread it under foot,” she had said, “remember it is my heart.”
He hated sentiment, and women, and
all things that appertained to them.
“Give it to me, Charles,” and he
went downstairs. “Madame,” he said to the manageress of the hotel, “accept my thanks for all your attentions. You have a little
son; allow me to present him with this box. When he is a man you will have the
wisdom of experience; endeavour to let my gift be a
symbol of his heart,” and he opened it to show that it was hollow, “that is, so
far as your charming sex is concerned—then his success in the world will be
assured.”
The friend invited to dine arrived
punctually. He was a tall, fair young Englishman, who looked upon loafing, especially
in
“There are lots of people in
“No, I shall be glad to get off.”
Two people got up from the next table and went.
“Rather a handsome woman,”
“Yes,” Luard
answered, absently, watching the waiter put down the chicken and the salad.
Suddenly he turned round, almost savagely.
“
“Badly hit?” he asked.
“I have been. It ends in being badly
bothered. There is no worry worse than a woman; she drags at you so.”
“Well, you are going in for one on an a long lease.”
“A wife—that’s different. A time
comes when a man must marry. It’s part of his business.”
“Not a great love affair then?”
“Oh, yes, I am devoted to her; she
is my cousin; I have known her all my life, and so on.”
“Excellent reason for not being
devoted, having known her all your life, I should have thought. But, all the
same, I congratulate you. She is very beautiful.” Luard
closed his lips with satisfaction.
“I wish the journey to
“The journey to
“That’s why it exists, so far as I
am concerned.”
“You appear to have gone in for
success with both hands and feet.”
“It’s the only thing worth living
for; everything else wears out—come to an end.”
“I daresay. I never had any
myself—never tried for it—don’t want it—it would bother me. But I like to look
at others while they struggle after it.”
“It comes, and is not struggled
after.”
“To you.
But don’t you find things in general pretty played out,—or do you want to go
on?”
“I want to go on, don’t you?”
“Well, yes, in a leisurely sort of
way. Then, you see, I am not a player: I am a spectator.”
“How do you mean?”
“Some men play the game of life and
some look on. You play, I look on. Don’t want to be bothered to do more. Life
is best taken easily.”
“I wish women would recognize that.”
“Women again; you have been badly
hit somewhere.”
“Don’t let us talk of it. By the
way—” he put his hand in his pocket, but he drew it back with a start. He had
touched Madeline’s door-key.
“What’s the matter?”
He took no notice of the question.
“What did you do on Wednesday after
I left you?” he said, abruptly.
“Went to the last
night of Sardou’s play. Madeline Debray was
superb. She is beaten at the end, you know, but gives in like an empress.”
“Ah!” And Luard
filled his glass with red wine, and looked at the people out of doors. “She is
a good actress.”
“I heard something curious about her
the other day: that she goes in for nursing the poor, and all sorts of rum
things.”
Luard
answered almost savagely again. “Mere thirst for emotion; women long for it,
and will have it, of one sort if they can’t get another. The mere sight of pain
is in a certain sense attractive to some women.”
“I don’t like that notion, it seems rough on
them,”
“Usually for evil,” Luard muttered, as they got up to leave the place.
The clock pointed to ten minutes to
nine.
“Look here,
Five minutes past nine.
He was at the corner of the
Boulevard Haussmann. The lights had not yet been put into the kiosks, for the
long summer day seemed hardly at an end, though the first fold of twilight had
fallen. He walked with lagging steps, which he vainly tried to make resolute.
Do what he would he could not help thinking, not of
Madeline, but of Isabel, with her blue eyes and soft fair hair, and he grimly
hated the task before him. “Perhaps I am a fool to do it,” he muttered; “she
may stab me or shoot me.” A little nearer, and he was before the house. In the
print-shop window was a large glass magnifying a bunch of flowers; he stopped
to look through it. Suddenly he raised his head, and turned quickly in at the
entrance leading to the flats. the concierge did not
see him; the lamp held up by the plaister figure was
not yet lighted. He went up the white covered stairs, past the palms and the
closed doors beneath Madeline’s.
“It’s the last time,” he thought;
“how odd it is to know that I shall never come up these stairs again.” He
hesitated for a moment when he reached the fourth floor, and felt for the key.
It turned easily, and he entered. Everything was absolutely silent; some
undefined fear of trickery made him keenly alive. He stood still for a minute,
looked round, and listened. Nothing. The salon door
was opposite; he walked towards it; a second’s hesitation,
and he turned the handle. The twilight had deepened in the last few minutes.
“Madeline,” he said. There was a
scent of flowers, a faint odour of coffee. The
familiar objects of the room were growing indistinct with the coming night.
“Madeline,”
and he went forward. She was sitting by the window just as she had said, but
she did not speak a word.
“There is no time to lose. I have
only ten minutes.” The window was wide open as usual, the flowers massed, the
sunblind stretched over them, deepening the dimness of the room. Here and there
the lights twinkled in the windows opposite. Her face was towards the balcony,
her back towards him. She was leaning her head against the chair,
her arms were thrown up over it. He could see plainly, even in the twilight,
the whiteness of her clasped hands against the red cushion. He could see, too,
that she wore the cream-coloured gown, the soft silk
trailed round the side of the chair; he knew that her hair was coiled in the
loose knot he had loved, that there were red flowers fastened at her waist.
“Am I to sit down on the other side,
and finish out our comedy?” he asked. The table was between the chairs, the
bowl of roses stood on it still. He noticed a little heap of petals that had
dropped, and the yellowness of the brass coffee-pot. He moved the chair a
little aside to sit on it, and then for the first time he saw her face. Her
eyes were staring with a startled look in them at the houses opposite,
her mouth was a little open as if to give a cry of pain.
“Madeline,”
and he stepped over the white skin rug, round to the other side of her. “Are
you ill—what is the matter?”
There was no answer.
“Madeline,”
and he touched her shoulder; but there was no response. The latch-key dropped
from his hand on to her lap. “For God’s sake speak, I am here, dear.” He said
the last word as though he would bribe her back to life with it. But still she
stared out at the windows opposite, and no cry of pain or word of joy came from
her lips.
“Madeline,” he said once more. “Good
heavens, is she dead?” He knelt by her side, and looking at her face, gently
put down her arms; her head fell sideways almost on to his shoulder. The memory
of the promise that she should die on his shoulder flashed through him The movement had closed the mouth; he fancied that there was
a little gasp—had the promise been kept? A half moment of thankfulness if it
were so, and with a felling of superstitious horror he held back, so that he
might not touch her face, and putting her head on the cushion again, stood up.
Then as though the dumb lips had said them again, and say, ‘I love you;’ and
may the woman you will hold dearest in your life when mine is severed from you
be false and fail you in the hour you love her best, if you fail me.” He stood
and listened to them; they seemed to be swept into his heart, to fasten round
it. Shrinking and hesitating, he waited for a moment. He saw the mass of
flowers on the balcony and the lights in the windows beyond; he heard the sound
of wheels beneath; but before him and between them all sat the dead woman. A
short breath—and slowly he stooped, and took her in his arms, and kissed her,
and said, “I love you.” Then he drew back. As he did so, for a moment, all
things seemed to vanish, and he thought of the day on which he saw her first,
eight years before at