| TO
WELCOME
TO CONTENTS |
defining terms, the "meaning" of rage |
Part of a long and comprehensive
article entitled
Perimenopause: The Complex Endocrinology of the Menopausal Transition
by Jerilynn C. Prior at
http://edrv.endojournals.org/cgi/content/full/19/4/397#sec9
addresses the question of the effects of hormones on psychosocial and
emotional expereinces. It concludes:
Finally, given the associations of emotional symptoms with high estradiol levels, it is not surprising that cycling perimenopausal women whose estrogen levels are at least intermittently extremely high would experience unwanted emotional symptoms. The term "mood swings" used commonly by women may be literally true and linked to wide fluctuations in estrogen levels. Thus the perimenopause and its resulting loss of fertility and social status are coupled with erratic and high estrogen levels which, in addition to causing breast tenderness, fluid retention, and troublesome menstrual cycle bleeding, also increase the physiological responses to stress.Endocrine Reviews 19 (4): 397-428 Copyright © 1998 by The Endocrine Society |
I suppose I am mainly concerned about the irritability. It is so bad sometimes, I think it could get out of control. Does the irritability go away closer to menopause?I think it probably depends a lot on how much you have to be irritated about. No, really: While I do feel that some of my own "moodiness" during peri - including phases of wanting to bite people's heads off for things I would have ignored earlier in life - has had a hormonal component. But inn almost every specific case I can think of, the irritability didn't come out of thin air. There's always been something - word or deed, someone else's or my own - that truly bugged me. The hormonal element just sort of cranked up the volume of my reaction. Personally, I've found this useful; it spurred me to finally resolve some things that had been bothering me, in a minor irritant way, for decades. That might mean sitting down with a loved one and saying, "You know, it's always bugged the hell out of me when you do/say X, and I've reached an age where I just don't want to put up with it any more. So what can we do about that?" Or detaching myself from some longstanding "volunteer" commitments that I'd taken on when I didn't really want to, because I felt obligated or guilty or whatever. I sometimes think that the heightened emotional state that sometimes accompanies peri is an opportunity for us to clear the decks for old age, to look closely at our lives and how we live them - and sometimes, who we're living them with - and decide if this is how we want to spend the rest of our lives. Personally, I've found that most of the irritability has gone away once I've dealt with the source of what's irritating me. 8 or 10 years into peri, I have very few crabby days any more, although I still have moments of heightened emotion (weeping at sappy TV commercials is a favorite.) Your mileage may vary, but it's worth considering. - -Pat Kight [email protected] |
Hi Everyone.. I'm exactly your age and have been experiencing mood swings of the kind you describe for three or four years now. In my case, the easily triggered frustration and irritability alternates with a mood of depression, passivity and insecurity (charming, huh?). It might help to keep a journal of some kind, tracking which are your worst "frustration days" and correlating them to your menstrual cycle. In my case, I get irritable for a week or two before my period, then I'm fine during my period, then I hit a depression/passivity phase right after my period. (There's one week in there where things are mostly fine :/ ). A great deal of emotional turmoil may be related to quitting smoking. Depression is frequent in people who have quit smoking, as is irritability, difficulty with concentration and memory, and over-reaction to minor annoyances. I know whereof I speak - I quit 2+ years ago. Although you may welll be perimenopausal at 43, you may also just be suffering the side effects of quitting smoking -the ones the doctors don't tell you about. This is most emphatically NOT a suggestion that you should go back to smoking, but give yourself a break and realize that it will pass as time goes on. You might try to get a prescription for an antidepressant if you think you're depressed - there are theories suggesting that smokers, either by nature or as result of the use of nicotine, are prone to depression and smoke to alleviate it - sort of self-medication. Please feel free to email me if you want to discuss my own personal experience. I don't sell anything, nor do I have any connection with anyone who does. Well, I certainly wouldn't call it depression, although there is a kind of clinical depression that can manifest in extreme irritability and nervousness, but it could still have to do with hormones. I started getting this when I was around your age (I'm 45 now), and it seemed to me that the feelings were similar to what women with PMS described. If PMS is a reaction to changing hormone status, and perimenopause (which I was pretty sure I was in because of other symptoms, very heavy and irregular periods among them), I thought maybe treating the difficulty as if it were PMS might help. I tried evening primrose oil, and it did help. Recommendations for dosage vary and you'll want to read up on it and what it does, but I did find it very helpful. You might want to look at other suggested remedies for PMS too, or at least for that portion of it. I did also get bloating sometimes and migraines and clumsiness and foggy thinking, but they weren't well correlated with the irritability.Does this sound familiar to any of you? Are my hormones making a change? or do I just sound like I'm going nuts? This is pretty common in perimenopause; and, as I said, some women have a version of it every month with their PMS. I don't think you are going nuts. This didn't always work, depending on how mad I was, but sometimes I could just tell myself, Look, this really is not such a problem, you're not mad, it's just chemicals racing around. So is ordinary irritation, of course, but at least then I feel like some operation of the mind started the chemicals going. |
I have found I've needed to learn to manage my anger. Since I have been in menopause I find I am more willing to express my anger and since I am kind of 'powerful' in my expression of things generally--the anger seemed to grow and grow. I find thinking about things and having conversations with my boyfriend when I am not 'feeling' angry has been a big help. When I 'feel' that rage coming on I try and stay away from people and think it through. It's like I am learning to process it AND express it rationally -FINALLY- after years and years of putting it aside for someone else's priorities or blowing up. Oh and here is something else. I finally managed to broach the subject that marriage is very important to me and found my boyfriend's main reluctance stems from my anger. We have been together 5 years (since right about when I started perimenopause) and he said he was hoping that I would become less angry when perimenopause passed because he is afraid that someday I will 'start yelling and not stop.' Well I thought about that. I HAVE been expressing my anger -- well, if they had an Academy Award I think my name might show up on the short list. . . .So I said we need to figure this out and I wanted to spend the next 6 months really looking at the relationship to see if it's going to work or not and make some decisions. Then I came up with the idea that on any day when I 'yell', we will put a 'Y' on the calendar and at the end of six months we will have hard numbers.(I think he is REMEMBERING more yelling than there actually IS right now. Well lo and behold--it's been about 3 weeks with no 'Y's' yet. Two reasons --1) I really am not yelling as much 2)Knowiing I have to write it down actually makes me 'think before I explode.' Kind of like writing down the food you eat on a diet. |
When I first used to get "mood swings" I didn't have a clue it was happening to me. I'd get into all sorts of arguments with my husband and I *always* thought I was in the right and he was being unreasonable .... and it was always only afterwards that I knew I'd been literally out of control. But this began to happen so often and the things I was saying and doing were sooo horrible that I'd feel tremendous guilt afterwards :-( Poor man really didn't deserve it and, quite frankly, my marriage was at stake. |
| The
need to define one's terms
Responses springing from a post containing the statements There are few reasons for individuals to vent rage --anger perhaps, but not rage. I say that because rage is usually unproductive.Hmmmm, rage is N.O.K, but "outrage" is well deserved? ;-) You highlight a similar discussion we had many months ago about each of the different definitions we were all putting on the same words. Anger versus rage and how they are different. I hear you about the difference between productive and unproductive releases, but I use the words in just the opposite way. Deep rage to me is the morally okay stuff, like your "outrage." Anger is the petty stuff directed at someone else, usually as a projection of something about themselves that they want to blame on someone else. But whatever, since I am a lay Californian Jungian thinker, I am a big fan of the "shadow" and not discarding any of our darker emotions or putting overly judgmental overlays on them as not okay feelings. The feelings just are. They are one of the coequal four parts of the Jungian concept of wholeness. (Intellect; emotions; intuition; sensation) All of them need to get brought forth from the darkness, not just the "nice" ones. I do believe one has responsibility for their expression, but not their existence. Otherwise, I see them getting projected and scapegoated. For me my life awareness changed from outer to inner in trying to heal my way out of panic attacks. I had to go into the fear rather than fight or deny it. I had to find a way to let it speak to me. I guess I feel the same way about any of our "negative" feelings. The anger/rage, like my debilitating panic, comes from a deep source. I do believe that both it and its context needs to be honored somehow. I think the stories about deep rage at menopause have had a common theme of a personal power assertion "that was so unlike" the person feeling it. This response of detachment from these feelings has become almost predictable. "It wasn't like me. My family (friends) (workers) (sales person) were shocked and they want my old self back. They don't want me to be like that. This, I believe, is one of the many meno turning points on this issue. Does the deep meno rage that is perhaps a nascent power assertion bubbling up get discarded and drugged back into non-existence, or is a choice made to see where this source of new energy is coming from? This seems to be a common meno happening and a lot of us recognize it and wryly chuckle at our own outbursts during our early meno days. So how can we ritualize and channel this "rage" as productive new energy rather than retreating from it in shock and terror, or using it as the first of many excuses to take drugs to make us "feel good." Does this symptom define whether we are going to let ourselves feel like a victim to our own bodies? Or do we find a way to integrate the energy and review our new sense of meno boundaries? And how do we do this once we decide to ride with it - if we do? Broad sweeping generalizations and observations, I know. But I am intrigued with writing a meno tale that ritualizes the commonality of the meno experience, a vessel to hold the loose ends that a lot of us seem to share in one a way or another. Like .....what is the
BIG picture of meno. Besides a cruel joke by nature? Nope, I personally
am not buying into that image. No point. It is all raw material at this
point. We are the first generation to be speaking up and together on this
whole subject. Do we inherit and accept a negative image of it or do we
re-write a better one for the next generation of women who will be experiencing
the same darn things? What will be our legacy for the time we have all
spent here on asm? (Joan L.)
(response to above post) Deep rage to me is the morally okay stuff, like your "outrage." Anger is the petty stuff directed at someone else, usually as a projection of something about them selves that they want to blame on someone else.So how are we to ensure that in philosophical (especially - practical stuff too) we are talking about the same thing? Joan has sensibly started out by pointing out how her definition differs from what she interprets X's to be, but if I were to say that rage is not OK and never will be and is to be abhorred in all circumstances, what would anybody think I meant? Would it be Joan, or would it be X who would attempt to persuade me of the error of my ways? My definition of "anger" is not necessarily +"petty" so there's a difference for a start! Do you mean feelings that others think are not Ok? The feelings just are.Yes they are and I believe they are all OK -what is problematical is what one does as a result of them which can well be notOK. During my meno cogitation days, I had a big breakthrough emotionally when I read a book which took pains to point out that emotion is e-MOTION and provided that they are _allowed_ the motion - to flow through and dissipate they are usually shortlived and harmless. It is the damming up of feeling which increases the intensity and the damage when the dam finally bursts - as it must, whether inward or outward. They are one of the coequal four parts of the Jungian concept of wholeness. (Intellect; emotions; intuition; sensation) All of them need to get brought forth from the darkness, not just the "nice" ones. I do believe one has responsibility for their expression, but not their existence. Otherwise, I see them getting projected and scapegoated.I understand the projection -the blaming of others for a fault within thhe blamer that the blamer is unwilling to admit to, but how do you scapegoat a feeling? My understanding of a scapegoat is a person who get picked on to take all the blame for all the faults of all those doing the scapegoating, so that these others can feel superior and guilt free. Oh...maybe in this case the problem could just be blamed on the rage for instance? The anger/rage, like my debilitating panic, comes from a deep source. I do believe it and its context needs to be honored some how. I think the stories about deep rage at menopause have had a common theme of a personal power assertion "that was so unlike" the person feeling it.While this may be so in the majority of cases, it wasn’t for me. I didn't need any more power. But then once again according to somebody's definition maybe my outbursts didn't qualify as "rage within the meaning of the act" "It wasn't like me." My family (friends) (workers) (sales person) were shocked and they want my old self back. They don't want me to be like that.And neither did *I* This seems to be a common meno happening. A lot of us recognize it and wryly chuckle at our own outbursts from our early meno days.And that's very telling I think -we recognize it in hindsight as we do so maany things in life. Until they are experienced they cannot be known, only known about. And what do we recognize it as? Childish temper tantrums with no satisfying result? Nascent self confidence overcorrecting from previous doormatness? Purely physiological response to hormonal instability which becomes re-balanced by their excretion in the resultant sweat, tears and increased respiration? So how can we ritualize and channel this as productive new energy rather than retreating from it in shock and terror?My rage by definition is not retreatable from. It is overwhelming and carries all before it. Does this symptom define whether we are going to let ourselves feel like a victim to our own bodies? Or do we find a way to integrate the energy and review our new sense of meno boundaries? And how do we do this once we decide to ride with it?I think this has to be totally individual as usual but the first necessity is to accept what you are saying above because without it there is no incentive, no need to put forth any effort to achieve it. There has to be faith in its possibility - and few people in the early stages of meno have any sense of meno boundaries whatever they are. The more I read this group the more aware I become that it is only after the fact that people can realize the "gift" aspect of the symptoms they have experienced. My peri was pretty horrendous for a time and I only wanted to escape, but it was in my efforts to escape (drugfree other than alcohol since I thought I should be able to do it myself) that I found "enlightenment" if you will and made great spiritual progress. I most certainly would not have chosen to go through that time but now I'm glad I did. Like .....what is the BIG picture of meno. Besides a cruel joke by nature? Nope, I personally am not buying into that image.Nor me. (Pat(Crone)) |