Goodfellas - Billy Butler, KC, OF
Tuna - Ian Stewart, Col, 3B
Pirates - Carlos Quentin, Ari, OF
Monkeys - Dustin Pedroia, Bos, 2B
Chiliheads - Stephen Drew, Ari, SS
Disastros - Alex Gordon, KC, 3B
Mystery Hill - Jered Wells, SD, P
BarleyMalts - Daric Barton, Oak, 1B
Mudslingers - Phillip Hughes, NYY, P
Strippers - Justin Upton, Ari, SS
Hokies - Chris Nelson, Col, SS
Clones - Daisuke Matsuzaka, Japan, P
Round 2
Clones - Andy LaRoche, LAD, 3B
Hokies - Jeff Clement, Sea, C
Strippers - Mitch Jones, NYY, 1B
Mudslingers - Troy Tulowitzki, Col, SS
BarleyMalts - Adam Miller, Cle, P
Mystery Hill - Jason Hirsh, Hou, P
Disastros - Brandon Wood, LAA, SS
Chiliheads - John Danks, Tex, P
Monkeys - Humberto Sanchez, Det, P
Pirates - Matt Garza, Min, P
Tuna - Homer Bailey, Cin, P
Goodfellas - Ryan Sweeney, CWS, OF
Round 3
Goodfellas - Gio Gonzalez, Phi, P
Tuna - Chris Young, Ari, OF
Pirates - Jay Bruce, Cin, OF
Monkeys - Chris Iannetta, Col, C
Chiliheads - Carlos Gonzalez, Ari, OF
Disastros - Andrew Miller, Det, P
Mystery Hill - Joe Koshanski, Col, 1B
BarleyMalts - Troy Patton, Hou, P
Mudslingers - Felix Pie, ChC, OF
Strippers - Shane Youmann, Pit, P
Hokies - George Kottaras, SD, C
Clones - Jose Tabata, NYY, OF
Round 4
Clones - Josh Fields, CWS, 3B
Hokies - Joaquin Arias, Tex, SS
Strippers - John Baker, Oak, C
Mudslingers - Cameron Maybin, Det, OF
BarleyMalts - Ryan Braun, Mil, 3B
Mystery Hill - Luke Hochavar, KC, P
Disastros - Jason Windsor, Oak, P
Chiliheads - Eric Patterson,ChC, 2B
Monkeys - Joey Votto, Cin, 1B
Pirates - Yovanni Gallardo, Mil, P
Tuna - Hunter Pence, Hou, OF
Goodfellas - Neil Walker, Pit, C