DiamondCutters - Justin Upton, SS, Ari
Playalistics - Howie Kendrick, 2B, LAA
Pirates - Carlos Quentin, OF, Ari
Mudslingers - Chad Billingsley, P, LAD
Goofballs - Joel Guzman, SS, LAD
Yellowfin Tuna - Ian Stewart, 3B, Col
Monkeys - Dustin Pedroia, 2B, Bos
Mystery Hill - Jared Wells, P, SD
BarleyMalts - Daric Barton, 1B, Oak
Chiliheads - Stephen Drew, SS, Ari
Clones - Jeremy Hermida, OF, Fla
Disastros - Alex Gordon, 3B, KC
Round 2
Disastros - Brandon Wood, SS, Ari
Clones - Andy LaRoche, 3B, LAD
Chiliheads - Chuck James, P, Atl
BarleyMalts - Adam Miller, P, Cle
Mystery Hill - Nick Markakis, OF, Bal
Monkeys - Jon Papelbon, P, Bos
Yellowfin Tuna - Hanley Ramirez, SS, Bos
Goofballs - Chris Nelson, SS, Col
Mudslingers - Josh Barfield, 2B, SD
Pirates - Ian Kinsler, 2B, Tex
Playalistics - Miguel Montero, C, Ari
DiamondCutters - Mitch Jones, 1B, NYY
Round 3
DiamondCutters - Jered Weaver, P, LAA
Playalistics - Billy Butler, OF, KC
Pirates - Randy Ruiz, 1B, Phi
Mudslingers - Kendry Morales, 1B, LAA
Goofballs - Ryan Garko, C, Cle
Yellowfin Tuna - Conor Jackson, 1B, Ari
Monkeys - Omar Quintanilla, SS, Col
Mystery Hill - Francisco Liriano, P, Min
BarleyMalts - Delwyn Young, 2B, LAD
Chiliheads - Eric Young, 3B, NYY
Clones - Felix Pie, OF, ChC
Disastros - Thomas Diamond, P, Tex
Round 4
Disastros - Fernando Nieve, P, Hou
Clones - Lastings Milledge, OF, NYM
Chiliheads - John Danks, P, Tex
BarleyMalts - Wilfredo Pujols, OF, StL
Mystery Hill - Charles F. Smith, DH, Dah
Monkeys - Danny Sandoval, 2B, Phi
Yellowfin Tuna - Joel Zumaya, P, Det
Goofballs - Jeff Clement, C, Sea
Mudslingers - Anibal Sanchez, P, Bos
Pirates - J. Brent Cox, P, NYY
Playalistics - Ryan Sweeney, OF, ChW
DiamondCutters - Leo Daigle, 1B, ChW