More Heroic Then Your Average Superhero
Batman is certainly not to be classified as an ordinary superhero. So how does he measure up? We'll find out by comparing him to Superman, who pretty perfectly fits the definition of the 'typical superhero'. In that, he is usually the first name that comes to mind when someone even mentions the word 'superhero'. He's got amazing superpowers and is seemingly infallible. Also, he's the perfect do-gooder and is always there when you need him (DC Comics Secret Files: Superman). Still when comparing the two greatest and most popular heroes in the comic book medium, it is more than just a simple comparison. As the Green Arrow says to Batman in TDKR, "I always knew it'd get down to you and the big blue school boy. Planet's too big for the two of you" (Miller and Janson, Part. 4, p. 34). This is more than a comparison. This is battle.
Alfred: I sense a certain tension between you and Superman, sir. Do you question his capabilities?
Bruce: No. Just his judgement. He doesn't grasp the limits of brute strength against a mind as warped as the Joker's. (Dini and Staton, p. 26)
Superman, though a smart man, is no match for Batman in the detective skills department. This is mainly because he usually gets by using his strength to solve things, not his brains. So, Batman may easily outsmart him without having to get into a fistfight.
Still, Batman has his weaknesses too. In TDKR, Superman says, "Bruce-this is idiotic. You're just bone and meat like all the rest" (Miller and Janson, Part. 4, p. 39). Bruce is only human and no match for Superman when it comes to brawn. It wouldn't take much for Superman to overpower him.
Also in consideration is how the American public views the heroes. I think this statement sums it up, "Superman is the American dream. Batman is the American truth" (Hill).
The verdict? Batman announces:
You're beginning to get the idea, Clark. This is the end for both of us. We could have changed the world...now look at us. I've become a political liability...and you...you're a joke. I want you to remember, Clark�in all the years to come...in your most private moments�I want you to remember my hand at your throat. I want you to remember the one man who beat you." (Miller and Janson, Part. 4,
p. 42-43)
