The construction of the flexible octahedra depends on the following lemma illustrated in fig. 2:
LEMMA. Let aba'b' be a 4-gon with equal opposite sides ab=a'b', a'b=ab'. (Assume a,b,a',b' are not all in one line.) Then there is a unique line L meeting the diagonals aa', bb' intheir centers such that rotation by 180� about L leaves the 4-gon invariant by interchanging a with a' and b with b'.
Proof. If the diagonals aa' and bb' coincide, then aba'b' is a parallelogram. And L must be the line through this common midpoint perpendicular to the plane of the 4-gon aba'b'. On the other hand, if the midpoints x,y of aa' and bb' are distinct. Then the line L=xy needs to be perpendicular to both aa' and bb' because only a 180� rotation about L will interchange a with a' and b with b'. This is because aya' is an isoceles triangle with xy the median to the base. So xy is perpendicular to aa'. Similarly L is also perpendicular to bb'. This completes the proof.
Now we can use the above lemma to construct the flexible octahedra by Bricard. Start with a 4-gon aba'b' with opposite sides equal, if we join a point c which is not on the line of symmetry to each vertex of the 4-gon, such "pyramid" will flex in E� (as long as c does not lie outside of the parallelogram if aba'b' coplanar because the edges will intersect.) Flex the "pyramid" and rotate 180� about L, then we can locate c' at exactly the same position as c before rotation. Finally joining c' to each vertices of the 4-gon will yield a flexible octahedron.
The example below showed a planar 4-gon aba'b' with rotation axis L perpendicular to the plane, note that this flexible octahedra will flex if we fixed ba' and twist a into and b' out of the plane but not to the other direction because of the bad intersections of the edges.
fig. 4 Bricard's flexible octahedron made with straws and strings. | |
fig. 5 Bricard's Flexible Octaheron In Motion |
PREV: Rigidity Theories
NEXT: Flexible Connelly Sphere
Illustrated by Jonathan Shum
Center for Intelligent Machines
McGill University, Montreal, Canada.