THE IGNORED COLLABORATION
by Prof. Dr. Tomasz Strzembosz |
translated by: Mariusz Wesolowski
I did not want to take part in the discussion
caused by the publication of Prof. Jan T. Gross's book "Neighbors" which deals
with the murder of Jews committed in July 1941 in the town of Jedwabne in the
Podlasie area. Primarily because the said discussion, picking up various motifs,
has been so far bypassing the most important fact, i. e., what has happened in
Jedwabne after the entry of the German army into that territory, that is, who,
when and under what circumstances committed the mass murder on the Jewish
inhabitants of Jedwabne.
This is the subject most worthy of discussion, all
the more because Gross's statements, in the light of specific sources, seem to
be not quite true. At the same time, however, the documentation at hand does not
allow me yet to take a public stance in this key question...
Before I come to the main topic, I must begin with
the basic statements. Nothing can justify murders perpetrated on any group of
the civilian population. Nothing can justify killing men, women and children
only because they represent some social class, some nation or some religion, for
any application of justice must have an individual character. Such crimes cannot
be motivated either by one's own convictions, or by superior order, or by
"historical necessity", or by the good of another nation, class, religion and
social group, or by the good of some organization, military or civilian, visible
or secret.
I would like the reader of this article to keep in
mind that such is my basic position. I am also in principle against murdering
the members of any military or police force only because they belong to them,
especially when they are unarmed or in the process of surrendering. Whoever,
then, commits such a murder (the power or reason behind it notwithstanding) is
for me simply a murderer.
GREAT FEAR
Before we try to evaluate the attitudes and
behavior of different social and national groups in the territories occupied by
the Workers' and Peasants'
Red Army (RKKA), it is necessary to recall the fundamental facts, since without learning about the reality of those times we won't be able to understand the people who lived there or who had been brought there by the perturbances of war. The entry of Germans into the Podlasie area was
accompanied by a great fear among the local populace,
who received German armies with undisguised hostility. They gave support to the Polish units being pushed eastward, and many unmoblilized reservists and youths in the pre-conscript age went in large numbers also eastward to find a military body prepared to accept them and give them arms. That's why a number of men from that region (including the unmobilized reservists) took part in the battle of Grodno and the region of Sopockinie - this time already against the Red Army. The population of Podlasie was also giving
support -especially after the battle of Andrzejow (in which took part the 18th
Infantry Division of the Polish Army) - to the locally organized locally
partisan groups which had been active till mid-October [1939] in, among other
places, the vicinity of Czerwony Bor and Bagna Biebrzanskie [the Red Forest and
the Biebrza Swamps], which protected them from destruction. The anti-German
attitude of the inhabitants of Podlasie was monolithic and
unwavering.
The period after the entry of the Red Army into the
eastern territories of the Polish Republic can be divided into three subperiods.
The first, called by Prof. Ryszard Szawlowski (and not only by him!) the
Polish-Soviet War, lasted for two weeks, until the first days of October 1939,
when the organized resistance of the larger combat groups of the Polish Army
ceased, although some smaller units continued the fight as guerrillas. The
second subperiod was the subjugation of the territory, combined with the
implementation of the social "revolution" - political and economic, planned in
advance and realized with the help of the army and special services. That's why
I call it "revolution on a leash". During that time the first arrests had taken
place. This subperiod ended in November 1939 in the official incorporation of
the Polish north-east territories into the Byelorussian Socialist Soviet
Republic, and the south-east territories into the Ukrainian Socialist Soviet
Republic.
Actually it was extended by two months, i.e., until
the Soviet administrative system (a republic, an "oblast'", a region) was
finally introduced in the annexed lands. The third subperiod, from the beginning
of 1940 to June 1941, was characterized on one hand by the unification with the
economic-social system of the Soviet Union (the forceful introduction of
collective farming, strenghtening of the sovkhoz system, finalizing the process
of nationalization of industry, commerce, banks, etc.), while on the other hand
it brought a rapid escalation of repressions, especially in the first half of
1940, which took the form of mass arrests and deportations; the latter lasted in
the so-called Western Byelorussia till the end [of the Soviet rule] and
encompassed about 150,000 people. I would like to discuss this phenomenon in
more depth, as it was - and very few people realize that - an activity based on
the idea of collective responsibility.
TIME OF DEPORTATIONS
The first deportation, on the 9/10 February 1940,
included the military and civilian settlers and foresters with their families.
The second, on 13 April 1940, encompassed everybody whose relative(s) had been
captured as Polish soldiers, policemen, etc., escaped abroad or went into
hiding, or had been arrested as conspirators or "enemies of the people", that
is, the socially dangerous element (SOE). The third, on 29 June 1940, which
affected especially the cities, included the so-called "bezhentsy" [refugees],
among them many Jews, particularly those among them who had registered with the
authorities for voluntary return to the German zone of occupation. This fact
partly demolishes the myth about the joyful welcome given to the Red Army by
Polish Jews exclusively because of their fear of Nazis. The last deportation,
started in the Wilno region (which had been snatched by the Soviets at the time
of the liquidation of the Lithuanian Republic in June 1940) on 14 June 1941, and
on the territory of the Byelorussian Republic on 20 June 1941, was interrupted
by the German invasion.
All of them, as we can see, were acts of violence
undertaken on the basis of collective responsibility.
For the father, who was a soldier, the whole family was held responsible; for a brother, who was a refugee - his close relatives; for a forester - those who lived with him. The strike was aimed at the "nest". On the other hand, for example, in Warsaw the Germans in revenge for an armed action of the underground executed people from the nearest appartment building, prisoners from the Pawiak gaol, or the inhabitants of a village near which a military train had been blown up; in short, people completely unrelated to the perpetrators. This collective responsibility included children, women and old people. It was most often the weakest ones who paid with their lives on the way and in exile - in Siberia or in the "hungry steppes" of Kazakhstan. TREASON IN THE DAYS OF DEFEAT
Who was the executor of the [Red] terror? The NKVD
and, in the first period, also the Red Army (RKKA) which supervised the
"chekhist operational groups", a relationship similar to that between the
Einsatzgruppen and the Wehrmacht. And the militia? Very few people know that in
the years 1939-1941 there were three different kinds of militia.
The first kind was the various "red guards" and
"red militias", composed of the locals armed with clubs, cut-down rifles, axes
and revolvers, although sporadically they even had automatic weapons, who gave
support to the Red Army in its "liberation march" and who performed the acts of
"class anger" in the name of social groups oppressed by the "lordly Poland". As
a rule, these groups surfaced immediately after 17 September 1939 (or even on
that very day, which is telling) and operated, usually in a very bloody fashion,
not only behind the lines of the Polish Army, but also after the entry of the
Red Army, which gave the local "revolutionary elements" a few "free" days to
settle personal accounts and exercise class revenge.
Later on those "militias" would be replaced by the
Workers' Guard, organized on the occupied territories under the order of the
Byelorussian Front Commander of 16 September 1939, as well as by the Citizens'
Militia, formed on the basis of a similar order of 21 September 1939. Next,
after the incorporation of "Western Byelorussia" into the Byelorussian Socialist
Soviet Republic, these two were replaced by the closely connected to the NKVD
Workers' and Peasants' Militia (RKM), at first composed solely of newcomers
(so-called "vostochniks", "easterners"), later on absorbing also the
locals.
The Polish population, apart from a small group of
city communists and an even smaller one of village communists, received the
Soviet aggression and the system brought by it in the same way as they had
received the German invasion. This is confirmed by literally thousands of
various testimonies. The participation of Polish peasants in the so-called
selsoviets (village councils) does not mean anything, because these were purely
"decorative" bodies. The real power rested with the executive committees, and
especially with their supervisory party and police apparatus.
On the other hand, the Jewish population, and
especially Jewish youths and the city poor, participated en masse in giving
welcome to the invading army and in introducing the new order, also by violent
means. This is confirmed as well by thousands of Polish, Jewish and Soviet
testimonies; there are official reports of the C-in-C of the Association for
Armed Struggle [ZWZ,later the Home Army],General Stefan Grot-Rowecki, there is
the [famous] report of the emissary Jan Karski, there are accounts written
during and after the war. After all, even the [earlier] works of Jan T. Gross
speak about these facts; Gross based his clear and undisputable conclusions on
the materials preserved in the Hoover Institution in the States.
The Soviet Army was welcomed with enthusiasm not
only in the territories occupied formerly by the Wehrmacht, but also in the
Eastern Borderlands, where the Germans never arrived. What's more, those
"guards" and "militias", growing like mushrooms right after the Soviet
aggression, consisted in the main part of Jews. And not only that. Jews
undertook acts of rebellion against the Polish state by taking over towns,
organizing there revolutionary committees, arresting and executing the
representatives of the Polish state authority, and attacking smaller or,
sometimes, quite large (like in Grodno) units of the Polish Army.
Dr. Marek Wierzbicki (who for the last few years
has been researching Polish-Byelorussian relations in the so-called Western
Byelorussia in 1939-1941, and therefore also recording facts related to
Polish-Jewish relations) in his large, still unpublished, article speaks of a
3-day-long battle between the rebellious Jews of Grodno and the Polish army and
police (starting on 18 September 1939, before the arrival of the Red Army), of
the two-day struggle for the nearby Skidel, about Jewish revolts in Jeziory,
Lunna, Wiercieliszki, Wielka Brzostowica, Ostryna, Dubno, Dereczyn, Zelwa,
Motol, Wolpa, Janow Poleski, Wolkowysk, Horodec and Drohiczyn Poleski. In these
localities nobody had seen a single German - the attacks were directed against
the Polish state.
It was [nothing else but] armed collaboration,
going over to the enemy, treason in the days of defeat. How numerous was the
group of [Jews] who had participated in all this? The specific number will be
probably never known. In any case such incidents took place everywhere in the
zone of operations of the Red Army's Byelorussian Front.
NEW ORDER IN ADMINISTRATION
The second question concerns the collaboration with
the terror apparatus, especially the NKVD. It was undertaken first by
"militias","red guards" and revolutionary committees, later on by the already
mentioned workers' guards and citizens' militias. In the cities they were
composed mostly of Polish Jews.
Later still, when the situation was taken firmly in hand by the Workers' and Peasants' Militia (RKM), the Jews - according to Soviet documents - were substantially overrepresented in that body as well. Polish Jews in civilian clothes, wearing red armbands and armed with rifles, in large numbers took part in the mass arrests and deportations. This was the most drastic sight, but equally galling for the Polish society was the massive presence of Jews in all the offices and institutions, especially since these had been dominated before the war by the Poles. On 20 September 1940, during a conference in Minsk
..., the chief of the NKVD City Department stated: "We have been following this
practice: Since the Jews have given us their support, one could see them -
and only them - everywhere. It became fashionable that every director of an
institution or a company boasted about the fact that he didn't employ a single
Pole. Many of us were simply afraid of Poles."
At the same time the minutes of communist party meetings in the Bialystok "oblast'" record numerous "complaints" about hearing only Russian and Yiddish in the Soviet institutions [and] about the Poles' feelings of being discriminated against... It was both true and in accordance with the current "party line" because at that time the highest Soviet authorities had introduced a "new policy" in regard to the Poles. Marek Wierzbicki in his article sums up that
situation as follows: "The extensively developed structures of Soviet
administration gave the masses of unemployed Jews a chance to find a job, which
- in borderland towns with no industry and a very limited job market - was to
them of great importance. The Jewish population, representing on the whole a
much higher level of education than the Byelorussian society, provided numerous
clerks, teachers and security police functionaries, which had a definite impact
on Polish-Jewish relations because the Jews most often took over the positions
of Polish clerks and teachers... Moreover, in September-December 1939, there
took place numerous arrests of those representatives of the Polish population
who had held before the war higher positions in the administrative and political
hierarchy of the Polish state, or who had been involved into social activities.
Local Jews - members of the provisional administration or militia - had been at
that time actively helping the Soviets in hunting down and arresting such
persons."
He goes on, referring to none other than Jan T.
Gross:
"It was also a frequent occurrence that some
representatives of the Jewish population jeered at the Poles, pointing out the
sudden reversal of fortunes of the two nations. The Poles often heard vicious
remarks along the lines of "You wanted Poland without Jews, now you have Jews
without Poland", or "It's all over for you.""
Thus we can see that the Jewish participation in
the Soviet power structures is unequivocally attested to in Polish testimonies
(especially those on the basis of which Jan T. Gross has been for the last
quarter of the century constructing his books and articles) which have been
recorded already during the war, and which are preserved - among other places -
in the Hoover Institution in the United States; the same applies to
the Soviet state and party archives recently made accessible, as well as to
the reports of the Polish underground command [from the period in
question]...
It seems, then, that the following statement
expressed by Prof. Gross in his "Neighbors" does not have much justification [in
facts]:
"Frankly, the enthusiasm of the Jews at the sight
of the entering Red Army was not a common phenomenon, and it is not clear why
the collaboration of the Jews with the Soviets in 1939-1941 should be considered
exceptional."
FALSE EQUATION
The second part of the quoted paragraph, which
refers to the Poles, goes thus: "On the other hand there can be no possible
doubt that the local population (with the exception of the Jews)
enthusiastically welcomed the Wehrmacht units in 1941, and collaborated with the
Germans, also in the extermination of Jews. The earlier quoted segment of
Finkelsztejn's testimony about Radzilow - confirmed also by the quoted
reminiscences of peasants from nearby villages - forms a precise negation of the
common tales about Jewish behavior in the Eastern Borderlands in 1939 at
the sight of the coming Bolsheviks."
Before analyzing the contents, I would like to take
note of the style of Gross's approach. Hundreds of extant testimonies and
numerous reports of the Polish underground authorities (including the report of
the pro-Jewish Jan Karski) do not offer sufficient grounds for drawing any
conclusions. This may be correct - after all, we should try to investigate the
situation in various specific localities without relying too much on widespread
but general opinions. But, at the same time, a [single] testimony of
Finkelsztejn's plus a few accounts of neighborhood peasants suffice [for Gross]
to pronounce a sweeping judgment not about specific individuals but about the
entire local population (except the Jews.)
The same applies to the thesis that it was the
Polish inhabitants of the small town of Jedwabne who murdered their Jewish
neighbors - based on the testimonies of a few Jewish escapees who managed to
survive, and on the materials of the Security Office originating from the
(undoubtedly sadistic) investigations of 1949 and 1953, during the period when
Polish bishops had been sentenced for treason against the Polish nation and
espionage on behalf of "imperialists".
Let's talk now about that Polish collaboration. It
has been discussed by Andrzej Zbikowski... It consisted, among other things, in
murdering the Jews by Polish "bands" composed mainly of ex-Soviet prisoners
(recently liberated by the Germans), and in attacks on "the retreating smaller
groups of the Soviet Army" by the same "bands". A simple equation between 1939
and 1941...
But, for God's sake, a joyful welcome given to the
Germans, who arrived in the middle of a horrible deportation and released
hundreds of people from Soviet abattoirs (in Brzesc, Lomza, Bialystok and
Jedwabne, among many other places) is different from attacks on the Red Army
soldiers (our yesterday's occupiers), and these are different still from the
murder of soldiers of the Polish Army. True, Jews didn't have an easy life in
Poland, there were undoubtedly "accounts of injustices", to quote a line from
the poet Broniewski, but they weren't deported to Siberia, or shot, or sent to
concentration camps, or killed by hunger and overwork. Even if they didn't
consider Poland their homeland, they did not have to treat her as an alien power
and join her mortal enemy in killing Polish soldiers and murdering Polish
civilians escaping to the east. They did not have to take part either in
selecting their neighbors for deportations, these terrible acts of collective
responsibility.
THERE WERE NO RED FLAGS ONLY ON THREE
HOUSES
Let's move now away from general issues to the
situation in the town and district of Jedwabne. Jan Gross is correct in stating
that there are not too many testimonies related directly to this place, but
their number is not minuscule, either, and, in any case, there are many more in
existence than the small selection utilized by Gross in his narrative on the
events on 10 July 1941. "The new approach to sources", postulated by Gross in
relation to the Jewish depositions, could be used also in this case. After all,
these are testimonies by persecuted people, who were saved from annihilation
only thanks to the Sikorski-Mayski agreement of July 1941. The survivors speak
here as witnesses to a crime, and they touch upon the "Jewish problem" without
any prompting, spontaneously, "from the fullness of their hearts."
Did the Jews of Jedwabne, like so many others,
offer a warm welcome to the Red Army? Various depositions taken both during the
war and by myself at the beginning of the 1990s, give a positive answer to that
question.
Let's first have a look at the accounts deposited
with the Polish Army of Gen. Anders and archived in the Hoover Institution,
which are now also available in the Eastern Archive (Archiwum Wschodnie) in
Warsaw.
Acount no. 8356, by Jozef Rybicki, a cartwright
from the town of Jedwabne: "The Red Army was received by the Jews who put up
[triumphal] gates. They changed the old government and introduced a new one from
among the local inhabitants (Jews and communists). Policemen and teachers got
arrested (...)."
Account no. 10708, by Tadeusz Kielczewski, a local
government worker in Jedwabne: "Immediately after the entry of the Soviet Army
there was spontaneously organized a municipal committee composed of Polish
communists (the president, Czeslaw Krytowski, was a Pole, the members were all
Jews). The militia was also composed of Jewish communists. At first there were
no repressions because they [i.e., the Soviets] did not know the [local]
populace, only after a series of denunciations by the local communists the
arrests began. House searches had been conducted by the local militia among the
people who were thought to possibly possess arms. The main wave of arrests by
the Soviets started only after the first elections."
Account no. 8455, by Marian Lojewski, a
locksmith-mechanic from Jedwabne: "After the entry of the Red Army into our town
an order was published to surrender all the weapons in the hands of the local
population. For keeping any arms the penalty was death. Later on many house
searches were conducted because of denunciations by Jewish merchants who accused
the Poles of stealing various items during their absence. Numerous arrests were
made among people against whom the local Jews had a grudge for persecuting them
by the Polish state."
Account no. 2675, by Aleksander Kotowski, a wood
sorter from Jedwabne: "During the entry of the Red Army I was absent, [later on]
the power was given to Jews and Polish communists, who had been imprisoned
before for Communism. They led the NKVD to appartments and houses and denounced
Polish citizens-patriots."
Finally the account of Lucja Chojnowska, nee
Cholowinska, deposited on 9 May 1991. Mrs. Cholowinska, the sister of Jadwiga
Laudanska, in the spring of 1940 found herself in the partisan camp at Uroczysko
Kobielne situated deep within the Biebrza swamps and - after a battle between
the Poles and the Soviet army there on 23 June 1940 - was taken prisoner. Our
conversation, conducted in Jedwabne, was concerned with that battle and not with
the relations in the town where both ladies used to live. Nevertheless, at some
point Lucja Cholowinska-Chojnowska stated: "In Jedwabne, inhabited mostly by the
Jews, there were only three houses without a red flag during the entry of the
Soviets. One of them was our house. Before the first deportation a Jewish woman,
our neighbor, came running to us (we always had excellent relations with the
Jews), and warned us that our names were on the deportation list. Then I, with
my sister Jadwiga and her 4-year-old daughter, run away to Orlikow, taking with
us just a few clothes." Note well: the Jewish neighbor knew who was on the
deportation list, and that was the most strictly guarded secret. So much about
the beginnings.
THE ARRESTS BEGIN
Now some more questions. Of whom did the Jedwabne
militia consist and what was its attitude toward those of the locals who had
been considered too closely attached to the Polish state, the malcontents, the
enemies? How (if at all) did the red terror manifest itself there, and had it
been implemented only by the transplanted Soviet citizens, the "vostochniks", or
also by the "old" Polish citizens, the permanent residents of the town and
district of Jedwabne? Let's look for the answers in the same (in historians'
parlance) "personal documents", deposited still during the war and
later.
Account no. 1559, by Kazimierz Sokolowski, a worker
from Jedwabne: "The Soviet authorities created a militia, mostly from among
Jewish communists, and the arrests began of farmers and workers who had been
denounced by the militiamen. The populace had to pay high taxes, churches were
also taxed, the priest was arrested. Mass house searches had been conducted
among the people unfriendly toward the regime, the "enemies of the people"...
The majority of the local populace tried to avoid taking part in the elections
(on 22 October 1939, T.S.). All day long the militia was dragging them at
gunpoint to the polling station. The sick were also carried there by force.
Shortly after the elections they carried out a night roundup, arrested entire
families and deported them to the Soviet Union."
Account no. 1394, by Stanislaw Gruba, a worker from
Jedwabne: "House searches were conducted in order to find weapons,
anti-communist literature, etc. The suspects had been immediately arrested, just
like the families of Catholic priests, and put in prison for further
investigation."
Account no. 2589, by Jozef Karwowski, a farmer from
the Jedwabne district: "In October 1939 the NKVD announced pre-election
meetings. The NKVD and militia assembled the audiences by force. If someone
protested, he was immediately arrested and he afterwards disappeared without
trace."
Account no. 2545, by Jozef Makowski, a farmer from
the Jedwabne district: "They arrested people, threw them into cellars and
pigsties, starved them, didn't give them any water to drink, beat them bestially
and in this way they tried to make them confess to their membership in Polish
organizations. I myself was beaten unconscious during NKVD interrogations in
Jedwabne, Lomza and Minsk."
Account no. 8356, by Jozef Rybicki of
Jedwabne, already know to us: "House searches were conducted among the wealthier
farmers, they took away furniture, clothing and precious objects, and after a
few days they came at night and arrested them. They dragged people by force to
various meetings - whoever tried to oppose them, he was denounced as a
"vreditel" (saboteur) and then arrested. The village elder was preparing lists,
going from house to house and writing down the names and dates of birth. The
electoral commission was composed of professional soldiers and Jews and local
communists. The candidates had been chosen in advance, mostly Jews and
communists from the Soviet Union."
THEY PUT ON RED ARMBANDS
Let's move now to the postwar accounts collected by
myself in the context of my inquiries about the battle at Uroczysko
Kobielne.
Jerzy Tarnacki, a partisan from Kobielne, wrote in
a letter of 24 October 1991: "A patrol consisting of Kurpiewski, a Pole, and
Czapnik, a Jew, came to arrest me and my brother Antek. We managed to escape
from our own backyard. I went into hiding in the village of Kajetanowo, at the
house of my friend Waclaw Mierzejewski. I learned from him that there was a
Polish partisan unit behind the river Biebrza. I stayed in hiding until
mid-April 1940."
Stefan Boczkowski from Jedwabne observes in a
letter of 14 January 1995: "The local Jews in Jedwabne put on red armbands and
were helping the militia in arresting "the enemies of the people", "spies",
etc."
Kazimierz Odyniec, M.D., the son of Sergeant Antoni
Odyniec (killed in the battle of Kobielno on 23 June 1940), wrote in his letter
of 20 June 1991: "By the end of April 1940 a local Jew in the uniform of the
Soviet militia came to our appartment and ordered Father to report to the NKVD
office... Father bid us goodbye, first sending out Mother to follow that
militiaman to see where else would he go, because the list [he had noticed]
contained a score of names. Later on it turned out that Father didn't go to the
NKVD. The next day the NKVD arrested Mother, trying to force her to reveal
Father's hiding place."
Dr. Odyniec, in a letter sent to me after the
publication of Jan Gross's book, stated: "Gross stresses the cruelty of the
Polish side without mentioning the behavior of a large group of Jews who had
openly collaborated with the Soviets and who denounced the Poles deserving
arrest or deportation. I'll give you an example of my own family (here comes a
repetition of the description quoted above, T.S.). I also remember that the
bodies of partisans killed at Kobielno were carried away by a Jew named Calko, a
neighbor of my uncle Wladyslaw Lojewski" (letter of 25 October
2000).
Roman Sadowski, an officer of the Home Army, the
husband of Halina (sister of Kazimierz Odyniec, deported on 20 June 1941 to the
Soviet Union), wrote to me on 10 November 2000: "During the Soviet occupation
the Jews were "rulers" of those territories. They totally collaborated with the
Soviet authorities. According to the statements of my wife's cousins, it was the
Jews together with the NKVD who were preparing deportation lists."
As we can see, although I did not undertake a
systematic search for this kind of information, a substantial collection
of spontaneous and unsolicited testimonies about the Jewish behavior practically
"gathered itself." Therefore, I cannot agree with Gross's statement that
"I have found only one account specifically concerned with the welcome given to
the Soviets in the town [of Jedwabne] in September 1939 - as we know, that was
the moment which fixed for many Poles the memory of Jewish disloyalty - and even
this account is not very reliable, having been written down more than 50 years
after the events." And then Gross talks about the bit of information collected
by Agnieszka Arnold during her preparations of the documentary film about
Jedwabne.
Not being an expert in this specific field, I have
quoted above five testimonies, for the most part written down before 1945, which
talk about the attitudes of the Jews from Jedwabne toward the new Soviet
authorities, and nine relations about the activities of the militia (composed
predominantly of the Jedwabne Jews, although its commandant was a Pole, Czeslaw
Kurpiewski, a known prewar communist.)
Let's also add a very characteristic information,
repeated in two independent sources: Apart from the Jewish militiamen in
uniform, Jews in civilian clothes also participated in the arrests, just with
red armbands on their sleeves and armed with rifles.
A CHARACTERISTIC INCIDENT: TRZCIANNE
The very same documents from the Hoover
Institution, supposedly so well known to Jan Gross, mention a whole list of
cities and towns where the Jews enthusiastically welcomed the Red Army, and
later on filled the ranks of militias: Zambrow, Lomza, Stawiski, Wizna, Szumowo
(with the Jewish militia commandant by the name of Jablonka), Rakowo-Boginie,
Bredki, Zabiele, Wadolki Stare, Drozdowo.
In the Red Forest [Czerwony Bor] the fighting still continued. It wasn't the Soviets but a group of 10-15 Polish cavalrymen who were crossing that neutral zone. They came upon the triumphal arch, the rabbi with bread and salt on a platter... The uhlans charged into the crowd, destroyed the arch, laid about with the flats of their swords, trashed a few Jewish stores, they even wanted to burn the town but it didn't come to pass. The rabbi's daughter died of a heart attack. The cavalry went away. The Jews in Trzcianne were armed..." This account, recorded by myself almost 50 years
after the event, has been confirmed by Soviet sources. They state that, by the
end of September 1939, a "band of Polish soldiers", under the command of two
local landowners, Henryk Klimaszewski and Jozef Nieczecki, attacked the town and
conducted a "robbery and a pogrom among the Jewish population." During this
action Henryk Klimaszewski supposedly kept calling for a showdown with
Bolsheviks and Jews by saying, "Get the Jews for Grodno and Skidel, it is time
to settle the score with them, away with the Communists, we will kill all the
Jews."
GERMANS SAVED HUNDREDS OF INHABITANTS
Apart from the Hoover Institution collection, known
to Prof. Gross, and the accounts in my possession, there are other testimonies
about the behavior of the Jedwabne Jews in the years 1939-1941. Danuta and
Aleksander Wroniszewski in an article "Aby zyc" ("Just to survive"), published
in the "Kontakty" magazine on 19 July 1988, reproduced an account of an
inhabitant of Jedwabne: "I remember when they were deporting Poles to Siberia,
on each and every wagon there sat a Jew with a rifle. Mothers, wives, children
knelt in front of them, begging for mercy. The last time it happened on 20 June
1941."
Did the Polish inhabitants of Jedwabne and
neighboring villages welcome the Germans with enthusiasm and as their saviors?
Yes! They did! If someone drags me out of a burning house, where I could die any
second, I will embrace him and give him my gratitude. Even if tomorrow I have to
consider him my next mortal enemy. In those days the Germans saved hundreds of
the locals (maybe also from Jedwabne?), who had been hiding for several days in
the cornfields and among the bushes on the banks of the Biebrza river. They
saved them from a deportation to death, somewhere in the deserts of Kazakhstan
or the Siberian taiga. And it was already commonly known what such a deportation
meant: Letters and other messages had been arriving from the "special
settlements". Parallel to the deportations there were taking place mass arrests
of the suspects, which often led to prolonged and deadly terms in the gulag
or prison.
We shouldn't be surprised, then, by those signs of
joy or by those (in Zbikowski's words) "bands" attacking the reatreating groups
of Soviet soldiers. Attacking their yesterday's tormentors, representatives of
one of the most cruel political systems ever suffered by humanity.
THE MOST TERRIBLE DAY FOR THE POLES
Recently there has been published a new, specific
and trustworthy, source, namely, "The Chronicle of the Abbey of
the Congregation of the Benedictine Sisters in Lomza (1939-1954)", edited
by Sister Alojza Piesiewiczowna (Lomza 1995). Let's quote the fragment
describing the events of 22 June 1941:
"June 20. The Feast of the Sacred Heart of Jesus.
The most terrible day for the Poles under the Soviet occupation. Mass
deportations to Russia. From the early morning wagons carrying Polish families
drove across the town toward the railroad station. Deported were the wealthier
Polish families, families of nationalists, Polish patriots, the intelligentsia,
families of prisoners in Soviet gaols; it was even difficult to understand
exactly what categories had been deported. Wailing, moaning and terrible despair
ruled in Polish souls. On the other hand, the Jews and the Soviets are jubilant.
It is impossible to describe what the Poles are going through. A completely
hopeless situation. And the Jews and Soviets loudly rejoice and threaten that
soon they will deport all the Poles. This may as well turn out to be true
because for the whole day of 20 June and the next day, June 21, they dragged
people to the train station without interruption...
June 22. Very early in the morning there was heard
the rumbling of plane engines, and from time to time the explosions of bombs
over the town... A few German bombs fell on more important Soviet posts. A
terrible panic overtook the Soviets. They started running away in complete
chaos. The Poles were very happy. Every bomb explosion filled our souls with
indescribable joy. After several hours there was not a single Soviet in town,
the Jews hid in cellars and basements. Just before noon the prisoners broke out
of their cells. People were embracing each other in the streets and cried for
joy. The Soviets were retreating without weapons, they did not return a single
shot.
In the evening of that day no Soviets remained in
Lomza. The situation was yet far from clear - the Soviets run away, the Germans
still didn't arrive. On the next day, June 23, the town was still unoccupied.
The civilian population started breaking into, and pillaging, all the Soviet
magazines, warehouses and shops. In the evening of 23 June a few Germans entered
- the people were relieved."
No other reaction could possibly take place in
those days. A few weeks later, the Union of Armed Struggle (ZWZ) was hastily
restoring the Soviet-damaged conspiratorial structures and collecting masses of
weapons abandoned by the Red Army; this "interregnum" was used to prepare for
the struggle with the next occupier. There are as many testimonies in support of
this, as there are for the incidents of robbery, revenge and pogroms. As always,
the reality turns out to be more complicated than we can ever
imagine.
Tomasz Strzembosz (born in 1930), a historian, is a
professor at the Catholic University of Lublin and in the Institute of
Political Studies of the Polish Academy of Sciences. Author of numerous books,
he recently published "Rzeczpospolita podziemna".
|