GC_ET_AP.html

2021-07-18   11:47:32
2022-08-25   05:27:12


                 All-Pass Circuits

------ This All-Pass Experimental project was started in 2019 -----------
***  Purpose :  
All-Pass Experiments to reduce number of Resonant BandPass
required for Phase-Alignment 

***  Results : Non-Resonant All-Pass stages can produce  Notches usable in the Dual-Notch process.
***  Results : More stages are required, and Notches are not as deep as with AFX, but Very Deep Enough.  

 
 

All-Pass_Schem_01.png   All-Pass_Plots_01.png


First, some Electrical Theory from common Electrical Enginering textbooks :

"All-Pass" defined : 
"The AllPass filter has frequency responses
which must be zero at "w=0" and at "w=pi"  "  


In all researched texts, the traditional academic texts specify
that AllPass filters
CanNot be used for Low-Pass or High-Pass functions ,
nor for Band-Pass functions.


*** However, the author has developed working Dual-Notch Band-Pass circuits
*** which utilize the AllPass Filter in both LoPass and HiPass configurations
*** to perform the BandPass function,
*** and to produce Dual-Notches around f(0) .


( "Working Circuits" Page )

*** Working Circuits  : (GC_ET_APC_F8AFQ.html)   (click)

*** Working Circuits  : (GC_ET_AP_Ckt_A.html)   (click)

*** Working Circuits  : (GC_ET_AP_Ckt_B.html)   (click)

( "Developmental Circuits" Section below


Developmental versions of All-Pass circuits 


*******   Experimental Target  :
*******   Reduce Number of MFB filter stages required to Align Signal Phases
*******       in order to support Dual-Notch Generation around f(0)
*******   Original Target was to attach the AFX Dual-Notch Differential technique.
*******   However,
*******      we found that our circuit could produce Dual-Notch Band-Pass Signals,
ad hoc !
*******   Therefore,
*******     the Target was changed to investigate the quality of the new WaveForms. 

*******************************************************************************


Contributors to this project :

Glen Ellis, E.E., Univ Tennessee, Memphis, TN, USA
Mark Sitkowski, E.E., Design Simulation Systems Ltd, Australia
Joseph Puncochar, E.E. ,VŠB-Technical Univ of Ostrava · Czech
Robert Arnold Orban, Master E.E., Stanford Univ, California, USA,
Dr. Barrie Gilbert, Vp-Eng, Ph.D., Analog Devices., Inc. Beaverton, Or, USA.

 

*******************************************************************************

 Below: All Circuits require new Schem to match the Bode plots. 
Freq are 7Hz and 700 Hz.  Resistors need correction.
###   Lo=7Hz (1M Ohm)     Hi=700Hz (10 K Ohm).
.  

 

*** Simple All-Pass Dual-Notch Circuit , Voltage-Mixer Final 
*******  Simple Developmental ckt , proof of concept.


### AllPass Schematic :  UnBalanced Lo-Pass_parallel_Hi-Pass  and  Combined. 
###   1 AllPass Low Pass   is tuned to 7 Hz.
### 10 AllPass High Pass are tuned to 700 Hz.

 ### The AP LO is Combined with the AP HI to produce the AllPass Output signal. 

 
 

***********************************************************************
### Below is the Revised and Simplified All-Pass Schematic 
###    One AP Lo-Pass combined with 12 AP Hi-Pass stages. 
###   Lo=7Hz (1M Ohm)     Hi=700Hz (10 K Ohm).


AP24-2F-20F-sum-S-413-2-191210-1200-{medg}.jpg

*** Below is the Revised All-Pass Bode Plot for  All-Pass V(out) 
*** showing Notches where "w=0" or "w=p" i. 
*** The tick indicates f(700).
*** The two adjacent notches [ f(515) and f(900) ] 
***    are exactly useful for building a Working Band-Pass Filter. 


AP24-2F-20F-sum-B--413-1-191210-1115-a700-n505-n960-n36dB-wide.jpg

*************************************************************************************************************************************************

*************************************************************************************************************************************************
*************************************************************************************************************************************************
*** In this All-Pass  project, 
***    the authors accidentally tuned all the All-Pass-filter stages to f(0) = 7 Hz  and f(0) = 700 Hz , 
***    which accentuates the "w" notches at each "0" and each "pi" point in the spectrum. 
*** Observing the useful Bode plots, we explored further, along this Accidental Path. 
*** In the fully developed #1 Working Circuit, 
***    we preceeded and followed the All-Pass array 
***    with Multi-FeedBack Band-Pass OpAmp Active Filters 
***    to reduce unwanted side-band signals ( away from f(0) = 700 Hz ). 
*** The authors explored the "UnBalanced" ( 700 Hz and 700 Hz ) approach. 
***    The All-Pass-Lo is tuned to 692 Hz. 
***    The All-Pass-Hi is tuned to 692 Hz. 
***    These frequencies were chosen to utilize standard resistor values.

*** Presented above is a Simplified Proof-of-Concept All-Pass Filter 
*** showing the array of notches,  
*** two of which are +/- f(700) and exactly useful. 

 

 

 

*********************************************************
*** Below are the Developmental All-Pass Circuits:

 

*** Right-Click Schematics and Plots for larger image ***

*****************************************************************
 

*******  Simple Developmental ckt , proof of concept.

*******  24 AllPass stages designed as  12 LP and 12 HP 
*** an error was inserted in the tuned f(LowPass)
*** and un-expected results were observed. 


### 24 AllPass Schematic :  UnBalanced Hi-Pass_parallel_Lo-Pass  and  Combined.
### 12 AllPass Low Pass are tuned to 7 Hz w 1M Ohm.
### 12 AllPass High Pass are tuned to 700 Hz w 10K Ohm.
### The AP LO is Combined with the AP HI to produce the AllPass Output signal.

( AP24-Notch-S-Hi-Lo-319-13-191113-1303-d.jpg )

### Below is the Original RAW All-Pass V(out) showing Notches where "w=0" or "w=pi" .
*** this observation lead to further experimental designs.

AP24-Notch-M-Hi-Lo-401-056_No-Flt_007-700_0191114-0845-sml-b.png )



*************************************************************************

*************************************************************************
*************************************************************************

*** Addendum **********************************************************

*************************************************************************

*** "No Notch" failed schematic : 
....... Balanced Design LO=700 Hz  /  HI=700 Hz
.......  combined by Voltage-Mixing . 
*** This type of topology is frequently employed to produce audio phase shifting,
***   with each stage staggered at 1/10 f(0) to cover the entire audio spectrum.
*** Band-Pass aligned with w=0 and w=pi. 
*** produces NO DUAL-NOTCHES
.


AP24-Dev-401-balanced-S-NoNotch-191117-1835.png




*************************************************************************************************************************************************
*************************************************************************************************************************************************
*************************************************************************************************************************************************
*** In this #1  project,
***    the authors accidentally tuned all the All-Pass-filter stages to
f(0) = 7 Hz  w 1M Ohm
(0) = 700 Hz  w 10K Ohm 
***    which
***    accentuates the "w" notches at each "0" point
***    accentuates  each "pi" point 
*
*** Observing the useful Bode plots, we explored further, along this accidental path.
*** In the fully developed #1 working circuit,
***    we preceeded and followed the All-Pass array
***    with Multi-FeedBack Band-Pass OpAmp filters
***    to reduce unwanted side-band signals ( away from f(0) = 700 Hz ).
*** The authors explored the "UnBalanced" ( 7 Hz and 700 Hz ) approach.
***    The All-Pass-Lo is tuned to 6.20 Hz.
***    The All-Pass-Hi is tuned to 692 Hz.
***    These frequencies were chosen to utilize standard resistor values.
*** Further #2  development will be done using the"UnBalanced" design
***    with f(0) at 650 Hz and 750 Hz to observe the effect.




*** DUAL-NOTCH Band-Pass schematic : 

*** Un-Balanced design :  LO=007 Hz and HI=700 Hz, Hi/Lo  Voltge-Mixed , 

*** Band-Pass aligned with w=0 and w=pi. 
*** DUAL-NOTCHES
  down to -50 dB .


AP24-Dev-S-401-sum-04-191124-1100.png

*** DUAL-NOTCH Bode Plot,     Scale : 700mV = -3dB ; 500mV = -6dB.

AP24-Dev-B-401-sum-04-191124-1100--.png







 

****************************************************************************************
****************************************************************************************
****************************************************************************************

*** No-Notch Failed schematic

*** Un-Balanced
LO=007 Hz and HI=700 Hz, Hi/Lo Differentiated 

*** Band-Pass aligned with w=0 and w=pi. 
*** NO Notches.
*** Differential method of combining the Hi/Lo signals does not produce a Dual-Notch effect.

AP24-Dev-S-401-dif-04-191124-1100.png

*** Bode of NO-Notch ;  Scale : 700mV = -3dB ; 500mV = -6dB

AP24-Dev-B-401-dif-04-191124-1100--.png

 

*********************************************************************
*********************************************************************
*********************************************************************