Reaction Paper 5


Pope and Golub suggest that this dilemma is fine when teachers realize they don't have to know

everything and that it is okay for teachers and students to learn from each other. In most areas of

education, this is a "given" but in regards to technology, staff development would appropriately

prepare teachers for some of these situations ahead of time.

Cuban discusses many of the problems teachers face when trying to integrate technology

into teaching and many of those problems are difficult to overcome. It seems natural that in light

of these problems that teachers would not be quick to "jump" into something that takes so much

time, effort, and energy.  His assessment of teachers' lack of use of technology seems accurate

when he says,

           ...historical legacies in school structures and parents' and taxpayers' social beliefs
           about what schools should be doing, I believe, will trump the slow revolution in
           teaching practices. Those fervent advocates who seek to transform teaching and
           learning into more efficient, productive work through active, student-centered
           classrooms will find wholesale access to computers ultimately disappointing
           (Cuban, 2002, p. 196).

He goes on to suggest that the slow revolution will be the vehicle through which change takes

place in how teachers utilize technology in their classrooms.

           It is quite possible that Cuban's theory about technology being oversold and underused

is really a statement embedded with truths about advertising used to promote technology in and

out of schools as well as the lack of total embracing of technology by teachers. It seems logical

that he is suggesting  this situation is no different than any other in the history of education and all

the "hype" done by promoters is just that, "hype."  One thing is certain, teachers have always had

to face stiff criticism from reformers and this situation is no different.

           The blame for not using technology regularly should not be placed wholly on the

shoulders of teachers. Lack of funds, lack of equipment, and training are only of few of the

obstacles teachers face.  Cuban has dealt fairly with teachers when he discussed these in his

book.

           Cuban states in the last chapter, "Yet technology will not go away, and educators have to

come to terms with it as an educational tool" (Cuban, 2002, p. 194).  There is doubt this

transformation won't happen overnight. 

           Cuban's final assessment seems correct when he says on page 196-197, "I predict that

the slow revolution in technology access, fueled by popular suppport and continuing as long as

there is economic prosperity, will eventually yield exactly what promoters have sought...(Cuban,

2002, p. 196-197).

           Education is about change and change is fundamental to life. Technology will find its way

into all classrooms but time is the determining factor.





Click on the link to view page 6: reaction paper6
Click on the link to view page 1: Oversold & Underused
Click on the link to view page 2: reaction paper 2
Click on the link to view page 3: reaction paper 3
Click on the link to view page 4: reaction paper 4
Click on the link to view the reference page: reference
Click on the link to return to my index page: index
Click on the link to view the evidence page: evidence
Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1