Science and Religion
at the Edge of the Third Millennium
by Robert N.E. Haughton, B.Sc., M.A.Sc., P.Eng. (Corpus-NCR)
The universe is not only stranger than we suppose - it is stranger
than we can suppose!
J.B.S. Haldane, Oxford University, 1920's
Current breakthroughs in science continually influence our knowledge
of who we are and our ever-changing perceptions of the undefinable
power, i.e., God. Great scientists such as Galileo, Newton, Einstein, Bohr,
Heisenberg and Hawking – to name only a few – have forever changed our
understanding of the Universe, from the very small (microcosm) to the very
large (macrocosm).
Studies of cosmology (theory of the Universe) and particle physics
(quantum theory) continue to provide an ever-changing perception
of the underlying mysteries of the cosmos.
The relationship between science and religion rests on two basic
premises: “Science”, the search for truth in all aspects of the physical
universe; and “Religion”, the search for truth in the realm of spirituality.
Here “spirituality” represents “that dimension of living in which we are
aware of the indescribable mystery referred to as God – an ever-present
possibility for
each individual and a reflection of the immediacy of God’s
presence everywhere.”1 The word “religion” is an English translation of
the Latin word “relegare.” Legare means “to bind together”:
thus re-legare is to “re-bind.” Such community rebinding is revealed
in churches, mosques, synagogues, etc. Science can nourish faith, and faith
can deepen our understanding of what science reveals to us. Modern physics
has shown that we are not only deeply connected to the universe
but are an intrinsic part of it. We can
be conceived as children of God who created
all reality, through the continuing dynamism of the laws
of nature. Everything in our bodies is shared with the rest of the universe.
Without the stars and their prior
explosions, over several billion years, there would be no oxygen,
carbon, iron or other minerals that constitute us. We are truly stardust!
Such a realization yields a deeper appreciation of the mystery of
God.
Studies of quantum physics and complexity theory are continually
demonstrating that the universe is more sophisticated and harmonious
than previously believed. Underneath it all, deep patterns of self-organization
continue to emerge. Scientific discoveries since the early 1920's disclosed
that Newtonian physics was incorrect when it claimed we exist in
a deterministic world in which past events foretold the future. Instead,
the universe at the microcosmic level appears to be permeated by intricate
non-deterministic relationships, an holistic totality. The part contains
the whole, but the whole is
greater than the sum of the parts! As we become more open
to new
understandings in science, we must be willing to release traditional
anthropomorphic (humanistic) views of God. The “All-in-All”2 (i.e.,
God) is not to be conceived as a tinkerer who enters creation only
long enough to fix things when they go wrong. Instead, God is continually
operating in reality and relationships. Science, however, does
not explain the ultimate meaning of life. Why isn’t there just nothing?
The question of “existence” will last forever.
In 1987 a remarkable interaction occurred in the realm of Science
and Religion. The occasion was a conference entitled “Our Knowledge
of God and Nature”,convened at Castel Gandolfo, the Pope’s summer residence
south of Rome, to mark the third centenary of the appearance of Isaac
Newton’s famous book Principia Mathematica, the founding work of
modern mechanics. The meeting was organized by the Jesuit astronomers
from the Vatican
Observatory at Castel Gandolfo. The participating scholars
(25) represented various religious backgrounds: Christianity, Judaism,
Hinduism, etc. The resulting documents were published in a book entitled
Physics,
Philosophy and Theology: A Common Quest for Understanding,
edited by Robert J. Russell (Chairperson), The Center for Theology and
the Natural Sciences, Berkeley, CA, William R. Stoeger, S.J.,
and George V. Coyne, S.J. The Foreword of the
book, signed by John Paul II, emphasized the inter-dependence of
science and religion. As quoted by the Pope, “We need each other to be
what we must be, what we are called to be, with each helping to define
the limits of theother so that theology does not profess a pseudoscience
andscience does not become an unconscious theology.”3 The meeting emphasized
that scientists cannot isolate themselves from wider
human concerns for ultimate meaning and value, yet their own methods
are not designed to deal with such concerns. They must, therefore,
look beyond these methods and techniques and devote to this quest something
of the energy and care that they give to their research in science.
Science can purify religion from error and superstition; religion can purify
science from idolatry and false absolutes. Each can draw the other
into a wider world, a world in which both can flourish. Contemporary developments
in science have challenged theology far more deeply than did the introduction
of Aristotelian philosophy into Western Europe in the 13th century. This
challenge also promises resources for new theological development, but
only if there are theologians sufficiently well-versed in the sciences
to make authentic and creative use of the resources the best-established
theories may offer them.
This common quest for understanding requires investigation of a diversity
of sources. Science is not merely a means to technical control or
accurate prediction; religion is not just a matter of moral action or private
converse between the individual and God. Each contributes to our understanding
of the remarkable universe in which we exist. The Science/Religion interaction
is a
collaborative one in which the viewpoints of the participants are
to be respected. In the natural sciences (physics,
biology, etc.) one can discern analogies to this
search for unity through the discovery of natural laws and processes
that unify all aspects of reality and, at the same time, give rise
to the vast diversity of structures and organisms which constitute the
physical, biological, psychological and sociological realms. In physics,
for example,
efforts to unify the microcosmos (quantum theory) with
the macrocosmos (relativity theory) into one Grand Unified Theory have
not yet been accomplished. It is crucial that the dialoguebetween
religion and science remain an open one, each retaining its autonomy. The
conference did not propose that science should become religion or
religion science. Both should support each other as distinct dimensions
of a common human culture. Neither
should assume that it forms a necessary premise for the other. The
unprecedented opportunity is for a common interactive and complementary
relationship in which each discipline retains its integrity and yet is
open to the ever-changing discoveries and insights of the other.
The 1987 conference was the first of a biennial series
of meetings on science and religion alternating between Castel Gandolfo
and the Center for Theology and the Natural Sciences, Berkeley, California.
The resulting documents were compiled in a number of books – e.g., Quantum
Cosmology and the Laws of Nature, 1993; Chaos and Complexity: Scientific
Perspectives on Divine Action, 1995; Quantum Physics and Quantum
Field Theory, 2000. Distribution in the USA and Canada is provided
by the University of Chicago Press. Since the mid-1980's Science/Religion
discussion groups continue to experience a rapid
growth in areas such as North America, South America, Europe and
India, along with a continuing increase in related literature.4
In closing, the following quotations provide a brief reflection on
the interactions between Science and Religion as expressed in the above
biennial conferences.
“Science without religion is lame; religion without science is blind.”
- Albert Einstein.5
“Without any doubt, there is ‘something’ which links material energy
and spiritual energy together and makes them a continuity. In the last
resort there must ‘somehow’ be but one single energy active in the universe!”
- Teilhard de Chardin, S.J.6
REFERENCES
1 GOD was in This PLACE and I, i did not know. Rabbi
Lawrence Kushner.
Longhill Partners, Inc., Woodstock, Vermont, 1991.
p.28.
2 “so that God may be all in all.” 1 Corinthians 15:28.
3 Physics, Philosophy and Theology. Message from the Pope.
Vatican
Observatory, 1988. p.M7.
4 Related textbooks on Science and Religion:
-Quantum Theology. Diarmuid O’Murchu, M.S.C.
(priest and social
psychologist). Crossroad Publishing Co.,
New York, 1997.
-The Mind of God. Paul Davies (physics professor,
University of Adelaide,
Australia). Simon & Schuster, New York, 1992.
5 Ideas and Opinions, Albert Einstein, Crown Publishers,
New York, 1954,
p.46.
6 Hymn of the Universe. Teilhard de Chardin. Harper &
Row, New York.
1965. p.80
|