TV  video Camcorder DigiCam Media Audio Theater Help companies  
  Home : Models : Formats : Media : Help : How to choose : Top ten things to check
  Columbia ISA
Consumer Camcorders in 2004:

A visit to your local electronics store will be a good start towards making a final decision on which camcorder to buy. You can usually see, touch and try out all the current models and last year's models as well. New models appear at least once a year. The old models then are reduced in price. Sometimes you can save 50% off the original price of a model that is being discontinued. 

There is a wide selection from which to choose. What you will see includes models from Sony, Panasonic, JVC, Hitachi, Canon, and a few others.

Sony has a rather wide selection, crossing all formats except VHS-C, with Panasonic, JVC, and Canon following with mostly MiniDV models. Hitachi offers their MiniDVD models as they were the first to release the optical disc format models. Sony has since captured the lead in the MiniDVD format with last year's (dcr-dvd100,200,300) and this year's (dcr-dvd101,201,301) MiniDVD models.

You will find an array of different formats including the following: VHS-C, 8mm, Digital8, MiniDV and MiniDVD. Sony's MicroMV format seems to have all but disappeared in 2004. The analog 8mm camcorder from Sony and the VHS-C camcorder from Panasonic are at the bottom of the scale both in price and technology. The MiniDVD and the 3 CCD models are at the top of the consumer category technology scale currently.

The size of camcorders keeps shrinking from 8mm down to MiniDV and now miniDVD. The 8mm and VHS-C models are bulky compared to MiniDV and miniDVD. The new MiniDV and miniDVD models from Sony fit in the palm of your hand compared to the giant 8mm and VHS-C models.

The trend today in camcorders is smaller rather than larger in consumer models and digital rather than analog, so a computer can process the video, and also in media, most likely away from tape and towards optical disc. Tape can get jammed in the mechanisms and tape models have more moving parts to break. This in part because the tape transport has to load and wind the cassette tape where a disc just has to turn on the spindle and is read by a laser. Disc media also is not degraded each time you play it like a tape is, so recordings are viewed the same, time after time with disc, while tape is dragged over the read/write heads, each time losing some quality.

Future trends look like a move towards HD or High Definition video using optical disc media. HD is a whole new ballgame. Video resolution will move from 500 to 720 and 1080 quality images. This means even sharper video and possibly superior audio as well.

The comparison chart below shows your choices in 2004 for various camcorders. The ratings are: Size Factor 1=smallest,  4=largest and Overall Technology, 10=new (best) and 7=old. MiniDVD is the only disc based format. All others use tape. MiniDV is the smallest tape, (MicroMV is smaller but not considered here) then 8mm and then VHS-C is the largest (same tape width as VHS).

 



Panasonic VDRM-50 MiniDVD



JVC GR-D200 MiniDV



Canon zr-90 MiniDV




SONY DCR-DVD101 MiniDVD




Canon Elura 70 MiniDV
   
Camcorder Approx. 
Price
Size 
Factor
Format Age Technology
Sony DCR-DVD201 $900 1 Mini-DVD current 9.9
Panasonic PV-GS200 $850 2 MiniDV current 9.8
Hitachi dz-mv580A $800 2 Mini-DVD current 9.6
Panasonic vdrm50 $800 2 Mini-DVD current 9.6
Sony DCR-HC30 $600 1 MiniDV current 9
Canon Elura 70  $700 1 MiniDV current 9
JVC GR-D93US $650 1 MiniDV current 9
Sony DCR-TRV22 $500 2 MiniDV last year 9
Canon Elura 50 $500 1 MiniDV last year 9
Sony DCR-TRV460 $380 3 Digital8 current 8
Sony DCR-TRV128 $270 3 8mm last year 7.5
Panasonic PVL-453 $250 4 VHS-C last year 7
           
   
What you want to test out and question with today's camcorders: (Top ten things to check when buying a camcorder)

For each camcorder you look at, go over the following: 

• Look at the overall appearance of your potential camcorder. Do you like the way it looks? You better be satisfied here because you'll be spending a lot of time "behind the wheel". 

• Does the camera body appear to be made of quality materials? 

• How does the camcorder  feel in your hands? Too big? Too small? 

• Does it have a shoulder strap and hand strap? 

• How about the menus, touch screen or dedicated buttons, where are they located? Try setting up the different menu options and see the results. Check to see what features and options are available. Can you setup the camera with ease?

• Try out the zoom control. Too sensitive or not sensitive enough? Is the image stable? 

• What connections are available? TV hookup , computer linkup, VCR or DVD recorder hookup, audio? Which computer operating systems are compatible with the camcorder?

• Is the viewfinder to your liking? You may have to use it if bright sunlight washes out your LCD screen.

• How does the LCD screen look, too small? What does the video look like on the screen? 

• How do you manually focus? Try a close-up shot, is it in focus?  

• Where is the record start/stop button? 

• How do you power on the camcorder? 

• Where do you load the media? 

• Can the camcorder accept a tripod?

• Is there a video light capability for indoor shooting? 

• What about a lens cover and case to protect your camcorder? 

• Does the camcorder have a battery charger and AC adaptor? 

• How much does an extra battery cost? 

• How long will the battery last on a full charge? 

• How much does media cost? 

• What is the warranty? 

• And of course, what is the price? Is it a budget buster? Does the store offer financing? Comparison shop online for a good price. Consider sales tax and shipping costs in the total price. 

• What is the return policy?

• Does the manufacturer have customer support available online and/or by phone?

• Search online for a discussion group relevant to your camcorder to see if other buyers have experienced problems with the model. You will be amazed at how much you can learn by reading reviews.

• Consider downloading the manufacturer's owners manual if available online. Again, you may find information which will make or break a particular model. Sony for one offers manuals online in PDF format for most of their models.

 



SONY dcr-dvd201 MiniDVD





SONY dcr-trv22 MiniDV

  Contact: [email protected]

::

 

1