Chisholm2k 25/07/04
Home * contact me

Privatisation and PPP

New Labour New Value(s)

More posters
Contact me

Our new page on Spin

It should be self-evident that if public services are being provided by a private supplier, they must compete against the best that the public sector can provide.

In a free society, there can nothing wrong with a private service - provided that the consent of all concerned has been obtained, provider, customer and workers. Under laisser-faire or 'economic liberalism' only the consent of the shareholder and the protecting establishment matters.

If the best that the public sector can provide is not on offer, can this consent of all concerned - provider, customer and workers - be a meaningful consent?
STOP PRESS...But has New Labour the political will to 'deliver on competent provision of public services' ('zonky', GU Talk)?
See Alexis Akwagyiram, Guardian 16 Dec 2002.

Ongoing Reports
PPP
Railtrack on brink of collapse



Ongoing Reports
Sources
Guardian PPP (+ other websites)
Special Report: Transport in Britain (other reports)
Independent Transport index
FT Special reports

Catalyst Forum Hattersley fights back
Catalyst is a "new campaigning think tank for the labour movement and the left, committed to developing and promoting practical policies for the redistribution of wealth, power and opportunity".
For activities
see events
(previous events, publications).

London Mayor PPP
Guardian Special Report: Livingstone's London
IPPR Institute for Public Policy Research
(Links to UK Politics)

UK Labour Party Sleaze Millenium Edition Website
"Welcome to the website devoted entirely to Labour party sleaze!! At present there are around forty more articles to be added. This site is non-partisan, hence if the Tories had been in power they would have got the same treatment!"

Campaigns against PPP
Lib Dems
...contact me re other campaigns



PPP

2003
Dec 29th
The Guardian Revealed: tube crisis as firms fined £32m
Andrew Clark, transport correspondent
Travellers on the London Underground have endured a dramatic collapse in the network's reliability since its part privatisation a year ago, with private contractors being forced to pay heavy fines for failing to deliver on their commitments.
Aug 20th
The Guardian Private passion
Washington's fondness for privatisation and deregulation is creating dangerous problems at home and abroad, says Julian Borger.
February 26th
The Guardian Germany sells off the silver
In desperate need of cash, German local authorities are using byzantine and dubious arrangements to lease their assets to America, writes John Hooper.
2002
Dec 16th
The Guardian Rail spending review raises fears of big cuts in jobs and services
"Senior MPs and transport groups reacted angrily to reports yesterday that huge cuts are planned in rail services and safety maintenance in a bid to slash spending", writes Alexis Akwagyiram.

May 9th
The Guardian 'Privatise NHS' ads scorned by unions
"Alan Milburn, the health secretary, provoked the scorn of Labour traditionalists yesterday when he placed adverts in national newspapers inviting the private sector to run failing NHS hospitals. ", write John Carvel and Terry Macalister. Guardian on
Public-private partnerships,
The NHS Plan

April 21st
The Guardian Legal brake could stop Tube plans
"Government plans ... could be thrown into turmoil by a new legal row centring on the independence of consultants used by Labour to validate the Public Private Partnership", writes Nick Mathiason.

March 18th
BBC

The Moscow Metro - "The Best Underground System in the World Bar None"

For fuller details see our 'metro' page.


March 8th
The Guardian

In-house teams 'better' than private contractors

(Society Guardian) "Handing too many services to the private sector can leave a local authority "hollowed out" and at the mercy of an "imperfect" marketplace, says the report. This can destroy local government's ability to respond to changing targets and priorities", according to a new report from the Cardiff Business School. (author Tom Entwistle)

Other papers from Contract Line, on-line journal of Public Services Network (PSNet).

Also from Society Guardian
Public-private partnerships,
The future for public services

Jan 22nd
The Guardian

Very British corruption

"The private finance initiative is rigged - and now we have a chance to stop it", writes George Monbiot, "...[it] can be implemented only with the help of an anti-competitive process which leads inexorably to corruption. If it were cleaned up so that it offered fair competition and value for public money, the big corporations would desert it. Public services would, once more, be controlled by the public."

2001
Nov 25th
Observer

Fury over Blair ally's NHS cash

A private healthcare company headed by one of Tony Blair's closest allies is making millions of pounds from acute NHS staff shortages, The Observer has discovered.


Oct 19th
this is London

PPP - Pathetic, Pathetic, Pathetic, by Tony Travers.


Aug 26th
Observer

Accountants' words that shame a whole strategy
What the accountants Deloitte and Touche have done in their confidential report on London's Public Private Partnership is to expose a mendacious gerrymander that sets out unfairly to rig the rules so that whatever LU does it can be depicted always as less efficient than the private sector....There are four dodges....

View Report (.pdf)
Transport for London comment
Aug 7th
this is London

Blair versus the people of London, by Max Hastings.


July 30th
Guardian

Mayor loses bid to block PPP for tube

Has a list of links and further articles

July 12th
Guardian No private company is prepared to take on Brixton prison
Our schools need gowns, not suits
Two elections now have shown some distaste by the electorate for this rabid pro-private sector prejudice, Hutton

Filthy, gloomy and chaotic
Beneath the gleaming façade lurks a catalogue of horrors that nurses, doctors and unions insist prove the Government's much loved private finance initiative is not just bad in theory: they have lived with it, and it does not work in practice. Also more on health.
July 7th
Guardian

Ken vs New Labour round 2?
Ken writes

June 25th
Guardian Institute for Public Policy Research (qv) and their critique of PPP
(Story * Comment)



Railtrack on brink of collapse
Guardian Talk
May 13th
Guardian Roy Hattersley: A nation derailed by privatisation
"... what we all hate about the men who run the railways is their preoccupation with profit. That is why the Byers scheme for the almost nationalisation of Railtrack was greeted with such general enthusiasm. ..."

Guardian
Special report:
Potters Bar crash

2001
Oct 15th
Guardian Roy Hattersley: The decision on Railtrack was correct
"I begin with the admission that I am irredeemably biased against Stephen Byers. The secretary of state ... was the first New Labour minister to announce that increasing inequality is not a phenomenon that should trouble us. The size of the cake is, he said, more important than the way in which it is cut."
Oct 14th
Guardian How not to run a railway
"... The alternative of using more public, not private, money is attractive because government can borrow much more cheaply. The catch is it would count as government borrowing and so be opposed by the Treasury."
Oct 9th
Guardian Faults in the privatized structure
"Railtrack sees the operation of the railway as a bit of a hindrance to its role, which is more being a substantial property company." (Railtrack signaller)
NB blame allocation
Independent 'Investors cannot claim they were not warned'

Oct 7th
Observer Will Hutton sets out the debate inside government
No longer available check here
...
BBC Railtrack on brink of collapse DoT, SRA


New Labour New Conmen?

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1