One's opinion of The Great Mouse Detective
(confusingly released in the UK under the slightly different title
of Basil The Great Mouse Detective) depends upon
what one wants from a movie. If you are seeking a great Disney
classic — a Snow White for the 1980s — then
The Great Mouse Detective is not for you. If, by
contrast, you simply want to see a movie that provides virtually
non-stop rollicking fun, then you would find difficulty in making
a better selection than The Great Mouse Detective.
It is very definitely a movie for those who prefer Star Wars
to 2001 and Sleeper to Annie Hall.
It is not a "Disney classic" in the sense that, perhaps,
Bambi and Pinocchio are; but there is a good case
to be made for its being a classic nevertheless, for it is one of
a kinds: It passes one particular test with flying colours:
In any audience watching The Great Mouse Detective, the
adults and the children laugh at the same jokes.
At a more mundane level, the movie grosses $18 million in the United
States in the first month after its release — an astonishing
feat by any standards.
Needless to say, the reviewers were divided over
the movie. Their reactions ranged from the frankly hostile...
Financial Times
"The supporting cast includes more mice,
and three of the film's four directors have surnames beginning
with M, which suggests to my suspicious mind that they might
be mice too. Certainly they have created a film with somewhat
tiny comic appeal and nothing at all of the pictorial splendour
of old Disney."
...through the "mixed"...
Observer, London
"...the best full-length animated film
the Disney boys have produced since the Master's death.
Yet only in the odd frame do we find that magical spark that
set the great Disney classics of the late 1980s and '40s ablaze."
...to the wildly enthusiastic:
Daily Telegraph
"Basil is intelligent fun, with enough
bite to delight. Do go and enjoy. It is a film the
children can safely take grown-ups to in the confidence that
they will not be bored."
Starburst, Richard Holliss
"...a highly recommended picture...should
not be missed under any circumstances."
David Hancock chose a most inopportune journal
in which to be patronising about the movie:
The Sun, London
"Sherlock Holmes is given the spook treatment
and the little ones will enjoy it."
And at least one reviewer used the movie as an
excuse for an exercise in advanced post-modernistic incomprehensibility:
Independent, London
"Disney cartoons, with their oozy tumescent
contours and their naively filled-in colour, their histrionic
shrieks and gestures...and their cast of goodies (pale, middle-class)
and baddies (swarthy, poor), pretend to wholesomeness and rectitude
while extracting as in Basil, maximum entertainment from the
underlying horror."
"Yes," one aches to ask, "but did
you enjoy the movie?"
It is difficult to list the full strengths of the
movie, but there are a few which should certainly be mentioned.
First, the script. Not only is this exquisitely
plotted, fast-paced, and dramatic, it is also exceptionally funny.
Whether the gags are verbal or visual, they all share a genuine
ingenuity, a love of lateral thinking and skew-logic for their own
sake. A prime example occurs when Dawson and Basil have been
roped to a mousetrap. A record will release a ball down a
chute, and this will (a) set off the mousetrap, (b) fire a revolver
at them, (c) release a crossbow-bolt at them, (d) cause an axe to
chop them in half, (e) let the vast cast-iron anvil drop on top
of them, and (f) cause a camera to take a photograph of their gory
demise so that the vile Ratigan can gloat over it in the years to
come. Basil, however, after feverish calculation realises
that, if he and Dawson set off the mousetrap at exactly the right
time, the ball will stop the bar of the trap, knocking the gun off
target so that its bullet deflects the axe, which falls to cut the
ropes and mousetrap so that the two mice are well clear when the
anvil plummets. Complicated enough...but there is yet more.
Moments later Basil has posed himself, Dawson, and Olivia in seaside-snap
postures just in time for the camera to click and so preserve forever
his proud grin.
The entire complicated sequence takes up only a
few seconds of screen time, yet is meticulously crafted in terms
of both animation and timing. Yet it is the ingenuity of the
sequence of events, which makes the audience burst into applause.
A second major strength of the voice is its characterisation.
In most Disney animated features, one expects to find two or three
characters powerfully depicted, plus a gaggle of minor zanies to
produce comic relief. In The Great Mouse Detective,
however, all the characters are strong ones — even Queen Moustoria,
who might have been expected to have been a symbol rather than a
fully developed personality, is given a well-rounded character of
her own. (A well-rounded physique, too, but that is by the
by.) If one has to identify a weak link in the chain, it is
probably Mrs. Judson, Basil's housekeeper, but she seems to be two-dimensional
only by contrast with those around her: In most others movies,
she should register as a fully fledged supporting actor.
A third of the movie's strengths one mentions almost
reluctantly: The animation. The climactic scenes of
the chase inside the workings of Big Ben (strictly speaking, the
clock of which Big Ben is the bell) were executed with assistance
of computers — humans did the figures, computers the clock's
gears and cogs — and there were stunning. As the Sunday
Times summed it up, this sequence "couldn't have easily
been done in the old days and must rank as one of the high spots
in the film animation." The point, of course, is that
Disney used the computers to assist the human animators,
not to replace when — for the animation of Basil, Ratigan,
and Olivia in the sequence is magnificent. Has to
be magnificent, in fact, because otherwise it would have looked
appalling when matched to the precision of the computer work.
The reason for the reluctance to praise the animation
too highly has nothing to do with the use of computers, however.
It is that, in some parts of the movie, the animation is not good;
and in other parts the us of static background figures mars some
excellent work in the foreground. An example of the former
flaw occurs early in The Great Mouse Detective, when Dawson
hops down to the pavement from the step of a hansom cab. The
movement is all wrong, and the "illusion of life" is momentarily
destroyed. Examples of the latter defect occur when Basil
and Dawson are in the seedy riverside pub: Behind their animated
figures we see a flat motionless backdrop of the customers —
who are more sketched than fully painted. To add insult to
injury, an attempt is made to give some life to this background
by superimposing upon it the occasional waft of pungent tobacco
smoke.
Still, one has to bear in mind the facts of modern
economics — if facts they are — and, anyway, the quality
of the rest of the film is so high that such blemishes are forgotten
almost as soon as noticed (to be fair, some viewers never notice
them in the first place). This latter fact reflects the time
taken for the two major ingredients involved in the making of The
Great Mouse Detective: The planning of the movie took
four years; the actual making of it took only one.
It is this equation which determines the status
of The Great Mouse Detective as a classic of a different
sort from the other Disney classics. One can pick away at
minor technical blemishes, but this cannot alter the overall effect
of the movie — which is to provide the best entertainment
that there's been in town for many a long year. The Daily
Telegraph, as cited above, recorded the only sensible critical
reaction to The Great Mouse Detective: "Do go
and enjoy."
It is the eve of Queen Moustoria's Diamond Jubilee
and, more importantly, the birthday of young Olivia Flaversham.
Here father, a toymaker, gives her a clockwork dancing-girl as a
present; but almost immediately afterwards he is kidnapped by Fidget,
a one-legged bat who is chief assistant to crime baron Ratigan.
Dr. David Q. Dawson has returned to London after
some years spent in Afghanistan. He is seeking lodgings when
he hears sobbing from within a discarded Wellington boot.
Then he finds Olivia, who has set out in search of Basil, the famous
detective, who lives in the basement of 221B Baker Street.
Dawson does not know Basil, but he does know where Baker Street
is, and so he leads the little child to Basil's home. Basil
is not at home, but his housekeeper/landlady Mrs. Judson lets the
two in out of the rain.
When Basil returns he immediately recognises Fidget
from Olivia's description. Clearly this case involves Basil's
arch-enemy, Ratigan — and we cut to a song-and-enemy, Ratigan
and his cronies, during which we learn that Ratigan plots to overthrow
Queen Moustoria and set himself up as King Ratigan I. He has
kidnapped Flaversham in order to force him to build to robot replica
of the Queen. Back to Basil's flat, and moments later Fidget
appears at the window. He escapes before our friends can catch
him, assisted by a puppyish bloodhound called Toby.
Fidget's trail leads to a toyshop, where the hideous
little bat is purloining items on a "shopping list" which
Ratigan has given to him: These include toy soldiers' uniforms,
clockwork springs and, most notably, Olivia. Fidget has had
time to gather all the items except Olivia when Basil arrives with
the girl herself and Dr. Dawson. After some minor sleuthing,
Basil and Dawson become separate from Olivia, who goes wandering
off to look at the toys and is captured by Fidget. Basil gives
chase, but eventually Fidget escapes. (One of the toys in
the shop is a bubble-blowing wooden model of Dumbo.)
However, Fidget has accidentally left behind his "shopping
list," and this is found by Dawson. Basil subjects the paper
to chemical analysis, and discovers incontrovertible evidence that
it must have emanated from a riverside pub near where a sever disgorges
itself into the Thames: The only possible candidate is a pub called
"The Rat Trap," and thither Basil and Dawson make their
way, disguised as rough sailors.
They are recognised for what they are by the barmaid
and bartender, and their pints of ale are spiked with soporifics.
Basil is not to be caught out so simply, but before he has time
to tell Dawson not to drink his beer Dawson is to encourage his
lechery, and soon his dancing on stage with a troupe of sexy chorus-mice.
At the end of their song-and-dance number, an enormous fight breaks
out among the pub's patrons. Basil and Dawson escape unscathed,
and follow Fidget, who has made a brief appearance.
In pursuit of the bat they make their way through
a maze of sewage pipes, finally to emerge at Ratigan's lair.
However, the whole thing has been a trap: They are captured,
Basil is humiliated, and the two friends are tied tightly into a
mousetrap: At the end of the playing of gramophone record
the trap with spring — and, simultaneously, they will be shot
by a gun, impaled by a crossbow bolt, chopped in half by an axe,
and flattened by a falling anvil. Oh, yes, and photographed
for Ratigan's later delectation. The arch-criminal sets off
for a grand mouse-hole at Buckingham Palace.
Basil and Dawson escape, of course, and release
Olivia, too, but already Ratigan has captured the Queen and set
in their place his clockwork robot. This pseudo-Moustoria
announces that she has decided to marry Ratigan, and he instantly
proceeds to read out the new laws that he plans to put into effect
forthwith — taxing the poor and crippled, etc. But then Basil
and Dawson arrive, seize the robot's controls, and show Ratigan
up as the impostor he is.
Ratigan and Fidget, with a recaptured Olivia, flee
in their pedal-powered dirigible. Basil swiftly concocts an airship
out of balloons, strings, and a Union flag, and a matchbox, and
he, Dawson, and Flaversham give chase. Eventually Ratigan's
dirigible crashes through the face of the clock stop the Houses
of Parliament. He and Basil do battle among the cogs within,
Fidget having been cast by Ratigan into the Thames some while back
in order to lighten the dirigible's load. Basil and Ratigan
finally fall all the long distance into the fog-enshrouded Thames,
and it seems that our hero has lost his life, à la
Reichenbach Falls, in putting an end to his foe. However,
moments later Basil reappears, pedalling furiously on the remains
of Ratigan's dirigible, and the day is saved.
Inevitable, there is a happy-sad ending.
Olivia and her father must leave (sob), and so too must Dawson (sob)...except
that just then there is a caller, a veiled lovely with a problem
that can be solved only by the acumen of Basil, the great mouse
detective. And Basil introduces Dawson to her as his permanent
assistant. The audience cheers lustily, the titles begin to
run, and an eminently satisfying movie concludes.
BASIL
The received wisdom is that Basil was given his
name as a small memorial to Basil Rathbone, the actor who was the
screen Sherlock Holmes. The truth of this assertion is head
to establish since, of course, the name "Basil" comes
from Eve Titus' 1974 book, and there is especial reason why a book
character show be named for a movie actor. That said, Disney
was obviously aware of the coincidence of names, for in one scene
we see the shadows of Rathbone and his Watson, Laurie Main (who
took over from the one and only Nigel Bruce), cast against Holmes'
study wall, and hear a snatch of conversation between them drawn
from the soundtrack of one of those old movies. (Interestingly,
where we elsewhere see Holmes silhouetted against his window, playing
the inevitable violin, the image is not especially Rathbone-ish.)
Clearly Basil himself is portrayed alone the lines
of the popular conception of Holmes, but to say this is to simply
— for Basil is much more than Holmes in mouse's clothing.
It would be wrong to go do far as the reviewer in Today
who said that "Basil is more lovable mouse than that dreadful
Mickey," but the fact remains that Basil is more of a mouse
that Mickey. To understand Basil's personality we have to
recognise that he is a mouse with many of the attributes of the
great detective whom he emulates rather than being Holmes in fancy
dress.
He is luminously intelligent, and like so many
intelligent individuals he displays a sort of psychological neoteny:
He has never quite grown up so that, despite his adult form, his
mind still exhibits a childlike since of wonder. He is entranced
by his own cleverness (as when he uses a complex chemical experiment
in order to show that Fidget's "shopping list" is saturated
with sodium chloride), and can be thrown into the pits of depression
when that cleverness, so much relied upon, fails to produce the
required results (as when, early in the movie, he discovers from
forensic comparison of two bullets that he has tracked down the
wrong gun). These are characteristics of a precocious child.
When he and Dr. Dawson face death, having been outwitted by Ratigan,
Basil falls headfirst into a slough of despond from which is almost
impossible for his more mature assistant to extract him. This
again is a feature of the youthful mind. However, while immature
personalities may have their drawbacks, they have too their advantages
over their more "grown-up" counterparts and these advantages
Basil has in full measure. The quickness of his movements
reflects the equal quickness of his thinking; and he is capable
of following logical processes that simply would not occur to people
more set in their ways. In the sequence in which he releases
Dawson and himself from Ratigan's "overkill" execution
set-up, for example, Basil — one stimulated by Dawson into
mental activity — realises that their sole hope of escape
is to start out by taking what is apparently the most dangerous
possible course of action, springing the mousetrap. He shows
no fear whatsoever about doing this one he has decided that it is
necessary. One the one hand, this represents the childish
beliefs (a) that everything will be all right no matter how dangerous
actions may seem and (b) that one's own cleverness can be relied
upon 100%; one could add (c), that Basil is so fascinated by the
ingenuity of the plan that, childishly, he completely forgets about
the dire consequences should it fail. But one the other head,
his lack if fear shows the recognition by the intelligent individual
that, if there is indeed only one possible course of action, then
it is silly to be frightened. It is notable that Dawson, who
has been up until then trying to put a brave face on things, who
has been playing the adult to Basil's child, trembles with actually
doing something about their predicament.
There are some similarities to be observed between
Basil and the Disney version of Robin Hood. Both are depicted as
quick-witted, fearless in adversity, pitted against much more powerful
enemies, and so forth. However, the character of Basil has
been much more carefully thought through. One critic had it,
perhaps a little unfairly, that Robin was the most boring character
in Robin Hood, despite his gleeful childish cleverness;
but one certainly could not say the same of Basil, who would be
an outstanding character in any movie. For Basil is more than
just a collection of behaviour patterns: One leaves the cinema
feeling that one knows him as a personality. Every characteristic
rings true. When, for example, Ratigan escapes from the palace
in his bat-powered dirigible, we may be surprised at the nature
of the Heath Robinson-ish vehicle which Basil devises for the purposes
of giving chase, but we are not surprised that Basil should
have been capable of inventing it. This is not simply
because we are confident, as ever, that the goodies will triumph
over the baddies' fellest manoeuvres; it is because the invention
is exactly the type of gadget which we expect Basil — or any
other child — to produce.
Basil's characterisation has many strengths in
itself, but it has in addition an extra one which originates in
the relationship between him and his audience. This is that,
adult or child, we identify with him. If we are not like Basil
we would like to be, and for an hour and a quarter we believe that
we are. This is something of a departure for the Disney features
of the last couple of decades: Many of them have a central
character whose personality is two-dimensional. It is this
character, with we are intended to identify, and the two-dimensionality
is deliberately created so we can graft onto the character sufficient
of our own attributes for the identification to be successful.
In The Rescuers, Penny is "everygirl"; in The
Sword in the Stone, Wart is "everyboy." In
The Great Mouse Detective, however, the character who might
have been expected to take on this role, Olivia, is far from two-dimensional,
and it is Basil with whom we are intended to — and do —
identify.
As a final note, it should be added that the voicing
of Basil, performed by Barrie Ingham, could not been bettered.
It complements and enhances Basil's screen personality perfectly.
If one heard it on the radio, one would conjure up one's mind's
eye a figure very much like the screen Basil. There were rumours
before the release of The Great Mouse Detective that Disney,
scared by the poor reception given a few months earlier to Steven
Spielberg's The Young Sherlock Holmes, had plans to dub
American voices onto the soundtrack for the movie's North American
release. Fortunately, these were rumours, and Ingham's marvellous
performance has been preserved.
DR. DAWSON
If Basil is himself, rather than a mouse version
of any human actor, Dr. David Q. Dawson, late of Her Majesty's 66th
Regiment in Afghanistan, is modelled to a great extent on that doyen
of screen Watsons, Nigel Bruce. Indeed, were it not for his
ears and tail, Dawson would display none of the attributes of a
mouse at all.
It is argued above that Basil is essentially a
childlike character: While possessed of great intelligence,
he has a multitude of childlike traits. Dawson, by contrast, represents
the voice of adulthood, common sense, and sensibleness...which all
means that he is of little use in the mental duel against an intellectual
criminal such as Ratigan. Indeed, it is hard to think of any
reason why Basil should be so keen, at the end of the movie, to
enlist Dawson's assistance in future cases — except, perhaps,
that Basil may have been finding life as a solo operator a trifle
lonely. Dawson's only contribution to the fight against evil
in this adventure is to keep talking to Basil after the latter's
humiliation by Ratigan: Left to himself, Basil would have
perished on the mousetrap.
Like Nigel Bruce's version of Watson, Dawson cannot
be relied upon: He is well-meaning blunderer. When the
companions are in the toyshop, Basil entrusts Olivia to Dawson's
care; yet the good doctor succeeds in losing the little girl almost
at once. Similarly, in the seedy riverside pub, "The
Rat Trap," Dawson forgets his freshly adopted persona sufficiently
to try to order a dry sheet; while Basil nips this motion in the
bud, he is not swift enough to stop Dawson from swilling down his
pint of drugged ale post haste. Thereafter, in a scene reminiscent
of the gently parodic movie The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes,
Dawson allows the temptations of the flesh lure him into an intimate
dance with the pub's seductive chorus girls. All of these
faux pas not only embarrass Basil, they hinder his chase
after Ratigan.
It is perhaps a pity that Dawson should be modelled on the Nigel
Bruce representation. In Conan Doyle's books, Watson was by no means
a buffoon; the same is true of Eve Titus' Dawson in Basil of Baker
Street. Still, an intelligent Dawson might have drawn one's attention
away from Basil, which would have been a bad thing in terms of the
overall structure.
One the positive side, it would be unfair not to
mention Dawson's essential goodness. Not only does he good-heartedly
take Olivia from her dank misery in the gumboot to the sanctuary
of Basil's flat, he also perseveres in pressing her case when Basil
is all too keen to forget about her. In this respect, Dawson
is like one's favourite uncle: Always ready to help out in
times of trouble, but not the ideal person upon whom to rely, or
with whom to discuss theoretical physics.
OLIVIA FLAVERSHAM
In many other Disney features the "token child
lead" is not is really a character at all, merely a symbol
of "everychild." Delightfully, in The Great
Mouse Detective the lead child is a fully-rounded personality.
Olivia Flaversham, the toymaker's daughter, is definitely no cipher.
Also, she does not fall into the other possible trap — that
of being nauseatingly cute. Although somewhat mouse-like in
appearance, she is a very realistic little girl.
The Scots accent helps, of course. This was
supplied by eight-year-old Glaswegian Susanne Pollatschek:
It is comparatively rare for a US movie-maker to use a genuine Scot
to provide a Scots voice but, to judge by this performance, US movie-makes
ought to do it more often.
Olivia is a stubborn wee girl: She usually
gets her way. Consider the dialogue we hear when she suggests
to Basil that she ought to accompany himself and Dawson on the perilous
journey to the toyshop:
OLIVIA: Wait for me! I'm coming too!
BASIL: What! Certainly not! This is no business
for children!
OLIVIA: Are we going to take a cab?
BASIL: My dear, I don't think you understand. It
will be quite dangerous. [Distractedly sits on his violin,
smashing it. Continues angrily:] Young lady!
You are most definitely not accompanying us, and that is final!
The next shot we see is of Olivia accompanying
Basil...
It is one of Basil's little failings that he is
not good with children. Throughout most of movie he regards
Olivia as little more than an unavoidable pest — which, in
many respects, she is. However, she has a great many good
qualities, notably her courage in adversity (she struggles stoutly
to escape from the bottle in which she has been imprisoned, hoping
to release Basil and Dawson from Ratigan's trap), and by the end
of The Great Mouse Detective even Basil's ascetic heart
has warmed to her — to the extent that he is almost tearful
when she and her father say farewell. Even then, however,
he proves incapable of getting Olivia's name right — a running
gag throughout the film. His final attempt at "Flaversham"
is his most ornate:
OLIVIA: Goodbye, Basil, I'll never forget
you.
BASIL: Not I you, Miss...Miss...Flangerhanger.
It is to be hoped that future Disney animated features
will continue the practice of The Great Mouse Detective
and have strong, realistic children in the leading roles.
HIRAM FLAVERSHAM
Olivia's father, the kind old toymaker, is a pleasing
character voiced in Scots tones by Alan Young, who did such a fine
job as Scrooge in the featurette Mickey's Christmas Carol.
His part in The Great Mouse Detective is not a major one, yet his
personality has been carefully created. On the one hand, he
is every child's favourite grandfather, mild, gentle, fond of the
little ones; but on the other, he has a certain steel concealed
beneath the soft exterior. He is prepared to die rather than
assist Ratigan's diabolical scheme, and it is only when the "large
mouse" threatens instead to torment Olivia that Hiram concedes
defeat.
RATIGAN
Chris Peachment, writing in Time Out,
put into words what many audiences must have felt on watching The
Great Mouse Detective:
"As usual with film noir, however, it
is the villain who steals the heart. Who could resist
a crime baron in a top hat, and crimson-lined cape, who speaks
in a voice which emanates from somewhere at the back of Ligeia's
tomb? In the final breathtaking showdown, high up in the
cogs and ratchets of Big Ben, which looks like one of Piranesi's
prisons, I know who I was rooting for. The final splashdown
in the Thames leaves the way open for a possible sequel and
I'll be at that one too, shouting 'Let's hear it for Ratigan.'"
Well, we all know what Piranesi's prisons look
like, don't we?
In voicing the arch-villain Vincent Price plays
the part of Vincent Price with gusto, and it is to the animators'
credit that they did not simply model the character on the actor.
To be sure, Ratigan has some of the pretensions to culture displayed
by Price's usual screen persona — represented physically by
a three-piece suit, a foot-long cigarette-holder, etc. — but
aside from these (and Price's eyebrows) he is a new creation, modelled
on no one but himself — and Conan Doyle's Moriarty.
It has to be said: Ratigan is a sewer rat.
However, it should not be said whenever he is within earshot, because
he is ashamed of his species: You may remark upon the fact that
he is exceptionally large for a mouse, but to go any further is
to invite doom at the jaws of Ratigan's voracious cat Felicia.
It is, in fact, essential that Ratigan be generally accepted as
a mouse, for one suspects that he would not cut much of a figure
among other rats: He has opted to be a big guy among small
ones.
He is, of course, the Moriarty to Basil's Holmes;
and like Moriarty he is not simply some numbskulled crook:
He is as much of a genius as Basil. That his genius has concentrated
on crime is another item of fidelity to Doyle's original creation,
as is his somewhat gratuitous cruelty. His flamboyant personality
is matched only by the grandiosity of his plans — this, like
his pleasure in bullying, is a very childlike characteristic, and
indeed all that arguments in favour of Basil being essentially a
child work equally well when considering Ratigan. One can
take this much further (although perhaps not as far as some Sherlockian
scholars, who claim that Moriarty actually is Holmes in disguise)
by noting the many similarities between the personalities of Basil
and Ratigan. For example, both have the same love of ingenuity
for its own sake — overingenuity, even. While we applaud
Basil for the complexity of his escape from the fiendish set of
death-dealing gadgets, we must remember that it was Ratigan's mind
which originally assembled the collection. And, like Basil,
Ratigan is vain; he likes nothing better than to surround himself
with cronies eagerly (and literally) singing his praises.
Finally, he shares with Basil the quality of courage: Although
it could be argued that his fearlessness during the fight in and
on Big Ben is a result of his hatred having taken him over, nonetheless
such fearlessness does not spring from nowhere. Somewhere
deep inside him Ratigan must have a strong strain of genuine article.
Ratigan's presumed demise, plunging into the Thames,
is very reminiscent of Basil and Holmes surviving the escapes.
However, Doyle never resurrected Moriarty. Perhaps, though,
Disney will bring Ratigan back to the screen — although this
seems, at the time of writing, to be unlikely.
TOBY
Whose dog is Toby? Basil seems to
imply that he is Toby's owner, but this seems a little improbably
— although certainly Basil has trained the dog for his own
purposes. Actually, as we discover, Toby is really Holmes'
dog. Well, mostly...
In fact, Toby is really not so much a dog as a
puppy. The Disney animators seems to have incorporated into
his physical appearance and his behaviour every puppyish characteristic
there could think of: Eager, panting, lolling tongue, soft
yet mischievous eyes, general rotundity of form...and clumsiness.
Indeed, the finest strictly visual gag in the movie comes when Basil
commands the hound to set off on Fidget's trail. From the
top of the screen descends a vast, brown and very determined puppy-paw
to flatten the little detective.
Toby obeys Basil, much of the time. For some
reason he detests Dawson, and greets him with a growl on all occasions.
Olivia, however, is another matter. From the instant that
she meets him and gives him a cheese crumpet, he is her slave.
For example, when he is being left outside the toyshop, we have
the following:
BASIL: Now, Toby, sit! [Toby fails
to sit.] Toby, sit! [No reaction.]
OLIVIA: Sit, Toby! [Toby sits instantly.]
BASIL: Good boy.
FELICIA
Ratigan may be Basil's criminal alter ego,
but the parallels are not carried as far as the two characters'
pet animals, for Felicia is nothing at all like Toby. She
is a huge, far, spoiled, cowardly pink cat, whose main contribution
to Ratigan's schemes is to gobble up those of his cronies who have
hurt his feeling. Summoned by his little bell, she lurches
plumply into his presence and devours whatever miserable offender
he places before her; afterwards she licks her lips with a loathsomely
smug little smile of satisfaction. But she is a coward.
She is content to consume small animals that go unprotestingly to
their doom, but should one of them fight back — as Fidget
does, most determinedly — she has no comprehension of how
to respond. She would be an idle lap-cat if only Ratigan's
lap were large enough. Similarly, towards the end of the movie,
she is enthusiastic about the prospect of devouring a defenceless
Queen Moustoria, but as soon as Toby — who is more her size
— appears on the scene she is off like a shot.
This chase culminates in a superb gag. Felicia comes to a
high wall and leaps up on top of it, leaving a thwarted Toby down
at ground level. Mockingly Felicia shimmies her ample bottom
at the yapping puppy, and then she calmly jumps down on the far
side of the wall. After a minuscule pause, all hell breaks
loose. We discover why when the camera pans slowly across to reveal
the sign: ROYAL GUARD DOGS.
FIDGET
If you feel that you've met Fidget somewhere before,
then this is probably because you've seem The Black Cauldron,
whose character Creeper is astonishingly similar. The likeness
extends even the voice, although in fact two different voice-actors
played the parts (Creeper was Phil Fondacaro, Fidget Candy Candido).
Fidget — whose name is given in some Disney
documents as "Fidgit" — is a peg-legged bat of evil
countenance. He is the most recent representative of a long
line of dim-witted, bumbling assistant villains; indeed, it is hard
to see why such an intellectual criminal as Ratigan should have
chosen him as a sidekick. Mind you, Fidget is not quite such
a lame-brain as Ratigan makes him out to be: The bat sole
error is to leave behind in the toyshop his "shopping list"
of items to be appropriated to help Ratigan's scheme. This
is something that anyone might have done. Ratigan, of course,
does not see things quite that way, and Fidget is destined for death
at the teeth of Felicia before Ratigan suddenly realises that he
still has a use for the small incompetent.
Fidget is designed to be two apparently contradictory
things simultaneously: First he must be funny, and second
he must be scary. Funny he most certainly is, but Disney had
to devote a little more effort to making him frightening.
The usual solution is to introduce his repulsive face very suddenly
onto the screen, to accompaniment of appropriate music. This effect
is slightly corny, but it works well.
Fidget is one of Disney's best comic sidekick-villains.
As with several others of them, one cannot help but wonder why on
earth Fidget sticks with Ratigan: He is bullied and abused,
and goes in constant fear of being fed to Felicia. He seems
to gain nothing from the liaison. Surely he could fly off
to pastures new?
QUEEN MOUSTORIA
The queen of the mice is obviously based on Queen
Victoria, her human counterpart. She is rounded and small,
with pear-shaped pendulous cheeks and a double chin. Cosmetics
have painted two stark pink blush-ellipses on her cheek, and on
her head perches an undersized crown.
Her role in the movie is a very minor one, yet
she is given some of the best lines. For example, in conversation
with Fidget, who is disguised as one of her guards but remains as
revolting as ever: "Have you been with us long?"
The movie is set at the time of her Diamond Jubilee — an anniversary
about which she is delighted: "Oh, I just love jubilees!"
The clockwork model of her produced by Hiram Flaversham
bears many of her physical characteristics. However, it fails
to move with her regal grace (a sort of upper-class waddle):
Instead, it jumps and jerks uncontrollably. It is astonishing
that Moustoria's loving subjects are fooled by it for a moment.
MRS. JUDSON
Basil's landlady, based on Holmes' Mrs. Hudson,
plays much the same sort of part in The Great Mouse Detective
as Mrs. Hudson played in Doyle's books: Basically, she is
just part of the scenery. She is keen to preserve the tidiness
of the house, Basil's privacy, and a dimple in her chin; but she
is at the same time kind-hearted: At first she refuses ingress
to Dawson and Olivia but then, as soon as she sees the little girl's
damp clothing and drowned-rat expression (no joke intended), she
transforms herself into a fussing maternal figure, eager to dry
clothes and supply cheese crumpets. In short, she is much
the same as Mrs. Hudson.
BARTHOLOMEW
A delightful little cameo part is played by a drunken
mouse called Bartholomew. While the other thugs are singing
of "Ratigan — the world's greatest criminal mind,"
Bartholomew unfortunately forgets himself so far as to sing of "Ratigan
— the world's greatest rat." Fortunately
Bartholomew is too intoxicated to know what is going on when Ratigan
rings his little bell to summon Felicia to polish off the perpetrator
of such a howler.
Bartholomew, incidentally, shared Barrie Ingham's
voice with Basil.
MINOR CHARACTERS
Among the noteworthy minor characters are the individuals
found in the seedy waterside pub where Basil and Dawson seek clues
as to Olivia's whereabouts. These include a very sexy Dancing
Girl-Mouse, whose act provokes Dawson into the most ungentlemanlike
behaviour; the Barmaid and the Bartender who, clearly in cahoots
with Ratigan, spike the drinks of our heroes; the Pianist whose
attempt to retaliate against an intrusive Dawson starts the gigantic
fight; and a Juggling Octopus, whose sad performance has to bee
seen to be believed.
Elsewhere, a number of Ratigan's thugs have speaking parts.
Of interest is a thug who does not look like a mouse at all.
He is bog-green, and has a face less like a mouse's than like that
of Bill the Lizard or one of the little tortoises/turtles —
e.g., Toby Turtle — to be found in so many Disney movies.
Why this should be the case is something of a mystery. Fidget.
One can accept him as part of the crew, he being a "flying
mouse," after all; but mice and tortoises are not known to
crossbreed.
And, of course, right at the end there is the beautiful Lady Mouse
who persuades Basil and Dawson to take on their next case.