Here are some of the comments that I have received:
"The plots are very well crafted & I realized immediately that you managed
to do what too many others have not--keep not only to the era but also to
the tone, cadence & vocabulary of the original without being either hampered
by, or obsessed with, its peculiarities & sometimes obscure cultural/historical/scientific references.
As a student of the Victorian era & a fan of pastiches (not something,
as we know, that certain Sherlockians will admit in themselves or even
accept in others) I am always appreciative of accurate historical &
cultural details such as those you use. I have found that authors
(including at least 2 or 3 "professionals") who lack the benefit of
expert editors & fact checkers publish grievous, embarrassing errors.
So far, my critical eye hasn't caught a single gaff of that sort in
your work."
"Thank you very much for putting on-line the manuscripts which fortune
placed in your hands. They provided me with much enjoyment. Thank you for
sharing. They seemed to be authentic stories of the good Doctor Watson."
"These stories are by and large excellent, and this is coming from a published
author and now english teacher."
"Thank you very much. These stories were a joy to read."
"The Armchair Holmes stories are really splendid. They have the flavor of the
original Conan Doyle works. I look forward to more of them."
"Thank you very much for your stories and for your time. I love
this kind of story."
"I just went through two of your stories involving the great Sherlock Holmes. I must say that you have done proper justice to the character. I am writing this mail just to congratulate you."
"I'm a big fan of SH and found your pastiches excellent. While reading them, I couldn't help forgetting that they were not ACD
originals. I wish you both success and hope you continue writing!"
About the Seance: "cool story."
About the Invisible Marks: "Great read"
About Baker's Bread: "I enjoyed reading your story."
"Just read your 'bakers bread', and its pretty good, quite in line with the real thing."
