To
have a valid, complete study of what
is called "The End-Times,"we
need to accurately cover every facet of it.
The files here are from the
manuscript for "After the Great Tribulation,"by James B.
Hartline.
Here,
you can learn the truth
about the Great Tribulation that everyone
should know.
On
the Mount of Olives, Jesus foretold a time of "great tribulation."
It is
important for Christians to understand
what specific events He prophesied, and whether those prophecies have
been fulfilled. We will address the
prophecies one-by-one and will also address something
very important that has been overlooked.
Life
on earth does not end with the "great tribulation." In
fact, life goes on, not just for hundreds, or thousands
of
years, but indefinitely after the tribulation of Matthew 24,
Mark 13 and Luke 21 is
history.
I
am not
referring to a "millenial" kingdom as some people expect, but
life as we normally know it on this earth,
(Luke 21:24) a time after
the "great tribulation." A time when the church continues to
add to its numbers those
who are being saved.
Many
misapplications of
Biblical Scripture have brought forth predictions of sensational
end-time
events, and
much speculation concerning the world and the church. Our beliefs
should always be grounded in truth.
Traditional Teaching
Traditional
teachings say that Jesus will come secretly, just prior to the "great
tribulation," to rapture
all His saints away to heaven, and again openly,
immediately after the tribulation is over, to set up His
millenial
kingdom on the earth. Is that an accurate analysis?
Our aim here is to
focus upon what Jesus said and to determine from His
words exactly what He meant
when He made these predictions. If we
can establish when and where the events He predicted take place, we
can
gain a better understanding of the "great tribulation," so as
to recognize its fulfillment. What was to be
accomplished by the "great
tribulation?" When you get to our "Journalist Approach" page, you
will see.
It is absolutely
necessary to stay out of the area of conjecture concerning this issue.
For this reason, most of
our Scripture references will come from the
Gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke, in the New Testament, and
from
Daniel in the Old Testament. The Gospel of John is silent concerning
these events.
The book of the
Revelation is greatly figurative, and open to too much speculation, and
must always be
balanced by the light of the other parts of the Bible,
so it is not used here as a primary source, but only in a
supportive role to the Gospels. The date when Revelation was written is
also very much in question. The
accepted date of A. D. 90 is
based upon the word of ONE man, and there is great evidence to date it
in A. D. 66 instead.
In the Olivet
discourse of Jesus, found in Matthew 24, Mark 13 and Luke 21, there are
specific predictions
of events which occur prior to and following
the "great tribulation." The sequence of these predictions
gives a time-table which will help us identify the beginning of the "great
tribulation," and some of the
events which come after it.
Most people are not
aware that the Bible says that normal life on earth continues after
the "great tribulation."
Some believe it is followed
immediately by a time called "the millenium." The Bible tells us that
the
"great tribulation" is actually followed by the
appearance of false Christs and false prophets. Luke's
Gospel says that
the "times of the Gentiles" comes after the tribulation.
None of the
Gospels, standing alone, would give us the full story of the "great
tribulation;" they must be
consulted together to open up the full
meaning of the words of our Lord, Jesus.
It is my belief
that Christians should be very well grounded in truth, without
false assumptions, concerning
such important events. If we live our
lives expecting certain things to occur on a prophetic calendar or
chart, drawn up by some evangelist and displayed on TV or in a book,
and we are misinformed, our lives
will not please God. The more
accurately we understand, the more intelligently we can utilize our
God-given
talents for His kingdom. The Bible tells us to study to show
ourselves approved, a workman not to be ashamed,
rightly
dividing the word of truth. (II Timothy 2:15)
Many of us have
spent years under teaching that is not in keeping with what the Bible
has to say on this
subject. We have listened to the traditions of men,
which have made the Word of God of non-effect. The
reason
for this is NOT that our pastors are trying to decieve us, or
keep us in the dark. They have been
taught a wrong premise
upon which to establish "End Time" doctrine. When you build up a
belief on "false"
premises, you can come to almost any
conclusion. Here we hope to lay a proper and accurate foundation
for understanding of these vital truths.
If there are
fulfillments of the predictions of Jesus, which can be clearly
documented, shouldn't we know
about them? Wouldn't they play an
important role in our understanding of the "End-Time?" These things which
we
do not yet know could be life-changing, if they were made a part of our
understanding. Learning more about
the "End Times" should not be an emotional experience.
The fact is, that
there are numerous writings in most libraries, in Bible
commentaries and church history
books which say much of what I will say
here. But you probably have not read them, and chances are, your
pastor
hasn't either. Let's face it, we just do not spend that much time
studying for ourselves.
When I have
mentioned some of the facts which I have learned about the "End Times"
to preachers, they
have told me that they did not have time to study
it. They are too busy pastoring their flock. Some even
said,"What
difference does it make?" That is the name of one of our last pages
of this website.
There are many
prophecies which God gave in the Bible, the fulfillments of which are
recorded history. Have
you ever wondered why so many years have
passed since Jesus made those predictions on the Mount of
Olives,
and yet none of His predictions have been fulfilled. Well, the fact
is, that many of His prophecies
have been fulfilled in
great detail.
Those prophecies
were given so that when they came to pass, they would testify of Jesus.
If none of His
predictions ever occurred, He would be a false prophet,
which we know that He is not. The Jews of today
scoff at Jesus
and use His name as a by-word, because they think He was a false
prophet. It is easy to
prove that He was NOT a false prophet.
As you embark upon
some, perhaps, new discoveries, you will understand the ministry of
Jesus in a new way.
God bless you as you read.
As we entered the
twenty-first century, there were great expectations and many misguided,
predictions of
what was
coming on the earth. Most
are not in the Bible.
It is relatively
consistent, whether found in a
Fundamental church or a Pentecostal one, or almost anywhere
in-between.
It basically goes like this:
Traditional Futurist View
Since the time
that
Jesus lived on the earth,
almost two thousand years have passed in which few of His
predictions
have come true. But, one of these days, the Jews in Israel will rebuild
the temple and reinstitute
animal sacrifices. Then there is all this
talk of a red heifer, and reinstituting the Sacrifice.
At some point
after
that time, there will be
great earthquakes, famine, pestilence and distress all over the
earth,
as never before in the history of the world.
Then one called "the Antichrist"
will appear on the scene, causing many to believe that he is the
Christ.
But before this "antichrist" shows up, the true
believers in Jesus are said to be "secretly" raptured
away to
heaven, en masse, and the only ones left on the earth are the sinners
(those who never accepted
Jesus), and of course, the Jews.
Then the
"Antichrist" performs great signs and
wonders and continues to deceive everyone for
three-and-one-half years,
then he shows his true colors.
He causes the animal sacrifice to cease, and
tries
to force everyone to take the mark of the beast in order to
buy and
sell. Then a more severe tribulation occurs over all the earth.
This continues until Jesus returns from heaven
three-and-one-half years later, with his saints, and sets up
His
millenial kingdom on the earth. Then, for a thousand years, the saints
rule and reign with Christ, over
some other people (no one seems to
know just who).
Such teaching does
not usually go beyond this
point, as to what occurs after the thousand years, although
many teach
that when the thousand years is up, we will all go to heaven and remain
there for eternity.
Some teach that
144,000 converted Jews will go
around evangelizing the world during the
"great tribulation."
And of course, somewhere in there is the "Battle of Armagedon."
Since there are many variations on all this, and
we are interested in true facts, instead of traditions, we
have
not covered every scenario, just enough to show basically what we are
talking about.
Various versions of these doctrines are espoused
by many fine, honest and sincere people, who love the
Lord with all
their hearts. This is not written to hurt or discourage anyone,
but to uplift and encourage
those who love Christ.
If we are open
enough to search for the truth with our whole heart, we will
surely find it, and Jesus
said
the truth would "make us free." John 8:32. Are we really hearing
the truth from those sensationalist
preachers on TV? There are many
ambiguities to most of these
end-time doctrines; as to when the saints
are gathered unto the Lord,
whether pre-trib, mid-trib, or post-trib, all referring to its
relationship with
the "great tribulation," where the "Antichrist"
will come from and where he will reign. Most say
Jerusalem, seating
himself in the rebuilt temple, purporting to be God.
Importance of Prophecy
Prophecy is given
to
us so that we may see the
fulfillment and give glory to God. In the Old Testament, many
times it
is stated by God, Himself, through His prophets, these things will
occur "that they may know that
I am the Lord your God."
The Bible teaches
us
that the proof of a
prophet is that what he predicts comes to pass. The Scripture
says:
"When a prophet speaketh in the name of the Lord, if the thing
follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing
which the Lord
hath not spoken, but the prophet hath spoken resumptuously: thou shalt not be afraid
of him."
Deuteronomy 18:22. So, the sign of a true
prophet of God is that all
of his predictions take place,
just as he said they would.
Jesus, besides all
else that He was, was also
God's greatest
Prophet. He prophesied certain events which, He
said,
would take place in that generation. If those things did not
occur, in that generation, He would
have to be labeled a false
prophet. Therefore, it is vitally important for those fulfillments
to be clearly
understood as a testimony to Jesus.
Realize, that any
Bible prophecy which was
fulfilled after the writing of the Scriptures, is not recorded
in those
Scriptures. How, then, would we know of its occurrence? We
must observe it first hand, hear about it, or read
about it.
Now doesn't it
stand
to reason that, in the
almost two thousand years since the time of Christ, at least some
of His prophecies would have had their fulfillment?
Here, from the
pages
of the Bible, written history, and early church
writings, we will show that the predictions of
Jesus were all true,
and that many of them have already come to pass. Everything, of
course, must be in
harmony with the Word of God.
There
is much to be
learned by the study of
chapter 21 of Luke's Gospel concerning these things, and it is
really the key to understanding most of the prophecies of
Matthew 24. Luke's Gospel gives us the insight to
recognize these
prophesied events as they occur.
If we
want to be
pleasing to the Lord, we must
take a more responsible approach than just taking someone
else's word
for what we believe. We must study it for ourselves. Only then
can we be sure of what we believe,
and have confidence to face the
future. Please begin by reading Luke 21 in your own Bible.
The Bible is not a
book of great mystery, if we
take the time to read more than just selected verses. However,
it does
require diligent study to understand some of the truths to be found
there. When we study enough to dig
out all the facts on any Bible
subject, we will have a good understanding of what God is saying to us.
What specific
facts
about the "great
tribulation" are recorded in the Bible, which will give us the
context of
these Scriptures in Matthew 24?
In the foregoing
Scripture, Jesus was
addressing Jerusalem, and pronouncing a sentence of desolation
upon
the city and the temple (their house of worship).
Luke 21:20-21 is
another "key" to where this "Great
Tribulation" would occur. "And when ye
shall see
Jerusalem
compassed with armies, then know that the
desolation thereof is nigh, then let them which are
in Judea
flee to the mountains; and let them which are in the midst of it
depart out; and let not them that
are in the countries enter thereinto."
Here we see again,
that this "great
tribulation" is to occur in Jerusalem, which is in Judea,
and that those
who are outside Judea (anywhere outside) are not to
enter into it.
Jesus told His
disciples to depart out of it
(Judea) in order to escape the judgment which was about to come
upon
the Jews.
So the answer to our question, Where was the "great tribulation" to occur? is: Judea, specifically Jerusalem.
A very common
misconception about the "Great
Tribulation" is that it is on a worldwide scale.
The
prophecies of Jesus, however, do not indicate this, but confine
it to Judea, as vengeance against the
Jews who killed the
prophets and Jesus. If you disagree with this, study in your Bible and
you will see that it is true.
"But
woe to them that are
with child, and to them that give suck, in those days! for there shall
be great
distress in the land, and wrath upon this people. And they
shall fall by the edge of the sword, and shall
be led away captive into
all nations: and Jerusalem shall be trodden down of the
Gentiles, until the
times of the Gentiles be fulfilled." Luke
21:23-24.
Obviously, "the
land" refers to Judea,
from which the disciples were warned to flee, and "this people"
(on whom the wrath would come) refers to those inhabitants of
Judea, the Jews. They were to fall by
the sword's edge and to
be led captive into all nations. And again, Jerusalem is
named as being trodden
down of the gentiles.
The answer to
Towards whom is the great
tribulation directed? is, the Jews.
Luke 21:23-24,
makes
it clear that the
vengeance is upon the Jews. The reference to the
fulfilling of
"all things written" tells us that the words of Jesus in
Matthew 23:37-38 and all foretold events are
fulfilled during the "great
tribulation period."
The answer to Why
was it to occur? is clearly,
to bring the promised vengeance and wrath of God
upon the unbelieving and wicked Jews in exact
fulfillment of Scriptural prophecy.
God gave these
instructions to Ezekiel, and
it appears that such a principle of a day-for-a-year may also
apply to
some of the prophecies of Daniel.
If it is true, as
many scholars believe,
that the day-for-a-year principle applies to prophecies other than
those of Ezekiel, then the seventy weeks (490
days) of Daniel 9:24
could really be four hundred and ninety
years. The seven weeks (49
days) of Daniel 9:25 would then equal forty-nine years, and the
threescore and
two weeks (434 days) could equal four hundred
and
thirty-four years.
Added together, the seven weeks and sixty-two
weeks would equal four hundred and eighty-three "prophetic"
years. The
remaining seven days (or years) of the four hundred and ninety, stated
in Daniel 9:26, will be
discussed as we get further along.
I am not trying to build a case upon an
assumption that the day-for-a-year principle is absolute, but as we
continue, it will be easy to see that the
time-table does indeed match
with the predictions, if we assume that
principle to be valid.
If these figures
are
correct, the Messiah
would come on the scene four hundred and eighty-three years from
457
B.C., which calculates out to A.D. 27 (there is no zero year in going
from B.C. to A.D.) A.D. 27 is about the
date of the baptism of Jesus,
when He began to be about thirty years of age. Luke 3:23.
We are told that
there could be an error in
our present day calendar of as much as seven years or as little
as
three years, depending on who you listen to. Some have stated that
Jesus was probably born between
6 B.C. and 3 B.C. If this is true, then
in A.D. 27, He could have been thirty years of age, the customary age
for the anointing for ministry according to
the tradition.
Let me
substantiate
the dating of the four
hundred and eighty-three years from 457 B.C.
Gabriel, in telling Daniel of the events to
come, gave a reference point for the beginning of the fulfillment of
his prophecy, the decree to rebuild Jerusalem.
In addition to the
decree of Cyrus, already
mentioned, two other decrees followed before the temple
was completely
restored; the decree of Darius in 519 B.C., and the decree of
Artaxerxes in 457 B.C.
Notice that the
decree of Cyrus (538 B.C.)
predates the visit of Gabriel to Daniel (521 B.C.).
The question arises here as to which of these
decrees Gabriel referred in his prediction of the coming of
Messiah. This
dilemma is solved by Ezra 6:14, a
Scripture in which all three decrees are named and said
to be "the
commandment of the God of Israel, and according to the commandment of
Cyrus, and Darius
and Artaxerxes king of Persia."
It appears that
the
three are to be
considered as one. After all, it was the commandment of God(a single
commandment) issued by three kings at
different times. So it appears
that we should date the
commandment at the last instance, or 457 B.C.
As we have already
indicated, four hundred
and eighty-three years after that decree, Jesus, the Messiah,
was
anointed for ministry at His baptism, as the Holy Spirit descended upon
Him and remained, and as
God spoke, saying: "This is My beloved Son in
whom I am well pleased." Matthew 3:17.
Gabriel continued:
"the street shall be
built again, and the wall, even in troublous times." Daniel 9:25.
Nehemiah 4:17 tells us that the men who built
the walls worked with one
hand and defended themselves
with the other. Their enemies were trying
to prevent the reconstruction. Those were "troublous times."
The prophecy,
given
to Daniel by Gabriel,
further states that the Messiah would be cut-off. "And after
threescore
and two weeks, shall Messiah be cut off, but not for himself; and the
people of the prince that
shall come shall destroy the city and the
sanctuary: and the end thereof shall be with a flood, and unto
the end
of the war desolations are determined." Daniel 9:26.
It is imperative
for
us to see that, in
this prophecy in Daniel to rebuild Jerusalem and the temple, following
its first destruction by Nebuchadnezzar, there
is also a
prophecy of a second destruction of Jerusalem
and the temple by
the people of the prince who was to come, after the coming of
Messiah.
It specified that
both the city and
the sanctuary would be destroyed. The reference to a "flood"
(Daniel 9:26) is interesting in light of a
paragraph in the book JERUSALEM,
by Kathleen M. Kenyon,
which we will discuss later. It is
specifically
predicting a sudden war of desolation upon Jerusalem. Similar
language
is used by Daniel in Chapter 11:22, ". . . with the arm of a flood. . .
," and 11:26, ". . . and his
army shall overflow." Both Scriptures
mention water, but speak of war.
Notice that in
Daniel 9:26, Gabriel said
after the threescore and two weeks, Messiah would be cut off.
He
explains this further: "And he [Messiah] shall confirm the
covenant with many for one week: [seven
prophetic years] and in the
midst of the week [halfway through the seven years] he shall cause the
sacrifice and the oblation to cease, and for
the overspreading of
abominations he shall make it [the temple]
desolate, even until the
consummation [a completion], and that determined [the destruction of
Jerusalem]
shall be poured upon the desolate." Daniel
9:27.
A footnote in the
NIV Bible says: "And one
who causes desolation will come upon the pinnacle of the
abominable
temple, until the end that is decreed is poured out on the
desolated city." This "week," which
came after the seven weeks
and threescore and two weeks [a total of sixty-nine weeks] was the
seventieth
week of Daniel 9:24. "Seventy weeks are
determined upon thy
people...." Using the day-for-a-year
principle, we can see in this last
verse, the prediction of a seven year period of time in which the
Messiah
[Jesus] confirms the covenant [salvation by
grace through
faith] with many.
Most
dispensationalists insist that the
seventieth week of Daniel is separated from the other sixty-nine
weeks
by the period of time from the Messiah to the "great tribulation,"
and they say the "great tribulation"
will be a seven year
period, yet future. They believe that Daniel 9:27 describes, not Christ,
but Antichrist,
who they say, will make a covenant with many
and then break it after three and one-half years, and a
worse
tribulation is then said to follow.
I am one of the
many
who disagree with such
doctrine, simply because there is no Scriptural evidence for
such a
separation, none at all.
Notice that in
Daniel 9:27, the one
referred to confirms "the" covenant. It is not the
making of "a"
covenant, but the "confirming" of "the"
covenant. This one also causes the sacrifice to cease. This is exactly
what Jesus did when He became the sacrificed
lamb on the cross at
Golgotha. God confirmed this by tearing
the temple veil from top to
bottom, (Matthew 27:51).
The sacrifices
made
thereafter had no value
whatsoever. The Jews did continue to offer sacrifices until about
forty
years later, when God caused them to cease because of scarcity of
animals. There has been no
reinstitution of animal sacrifice by the
Jews since that time, because there is no temple.
At this point, we
know that Gabriel
predicted the rebuilding of Jerusalem and the temple, then the coming
of
Messiah, followed by the second
destruction of Jerusalem and
the temple, after Messiah is cut off. Add to this
the
prophecy in Daniel 12:11, where Daniel spoke of the "abomination
that maketh desolate." This appears to be
the Scripture to which
Jesus referred when He said: "When ye therefore shall see the
abomination of desolation,
spoken of by Daniel the prophet, standing in
the holy place (whoso readeth, let him understand:) then let them
which
be in Judea flee into the mountains." Matthew 24:15-16.
Daniel also, two
other times (Daniel 8:13
and 11:31), prophesied concerning "transgression of desolation"
and the
"abomination that maketh desolate." If
you examine
these Scriptures very carefully, it becomes obvious that they
are not
the same as Daniel 12:22. For starters, Daniel 8:13-14 specifies a time
of 2300 evenings and mornings, and
seems to be the same as Daniel
11:31, listing a sequence of rulers, culminating in Daniel 11:31.
This continuous
line, as history witnesses,
ends with Antiochus Ephiphanes (Described in various Bible
commentaries). Antiochus profaned the temple,
setting up pagan worship
there and interrupting the daily sacrifice
for 2300 days. These were
literal days, because the prophecy in Daniel 8:13-14 specified evenings
and
mornings as in the days of the creation
in Genesis chapter one.
If you believe that the creation was literal days,
then you have to
accept Daniel 8:13-14 as literal days.
On the other hand, Daniel 12:11-12 speaks of
1290 days (taken literally, three years and seven months) and 1335
days
(literally three years and eight months).
The Hebrew word
used
here was the word for "days,"
not evenings and mornings. These could be literal days, or
prophetic
years. I relate these at this time merely to contrast the number of
days in Daniel 8:13-14 with the
number in Daniel 12:11-12 to show that
they are not the same, and that the "abomination that maketh
desolate"
occurs more than one time.
When Jesus made
His
reference to it, the
desecration by Antiochus Ephiphanes was already long past, so
Jesus
necessarily spoke of the later time of the
"abomination of
desolation" (in Daniel 12:11-12).
A minority of Bible scholars do not accept the
desecration of the temple by Antiochus Ephiphanes as the fulfillment
of
the 2300 days prophecy. Although it seems right to me, that is not the
case in point here.
We can see from
Matthew 24:15, that the "great
tribulation" was to be the fulfilling of the prophecy of Daniel
concerning the "abomination of desolation."
And from Luke
21:20, we know that the desolation would be
administered by armies
surrounding Jerusalem. Because this prophecy in Daniel runs
continuously from the
first desolation, through the
rebuilding
of the temple and the city, the coming of Messiah and on to the second
destruction of Jerusalem and the temple, we
must consider this second
destruction in our quest to find the actual
fulfillment of the "great
tribulation."
Since the time
that
Gabriel visited Daniel,
recorded in Daniel, Chapter 9, and since Jesus prophesied this
desolation,
there has been only one destruction of the
temple and the
city of Jerusalem. That was in A.D. 70. The temple has
not been rebuilt
since that time. As we have already seen, this second desolation of the
temple and city was
prophesied to occur after the cutting off of
the
Messiah.
Jesus was
crucified
in about A.D. 30, after
three and one-half years of His ministry, and the second destruction of
the temple and city followed within that
generation, about
thirty-eight to forty years afterwards, in A.D. 70.
Jesus foretold this
desolation and called it "great tribulation." Matthew
24:21).
At this point, we
will begin to correlate
the prophecies of the Olivet discourse with the actual historical
events
which occurred between the resurrection of
Christ and the
desolation of Jerusalem and the temple in A.D. 70.
We will see if these
events fulfill the predictions Jesus made.
His prophecies had required all these things
to be fulfilled in that generation. A generation is
considered to
be forty years based on the forty years the
children of
Israel wandered in the wilderness until a generation died off.
If we
are to believe Jesus, we must look for fulfillments to come before that
generation passed away. We will
cover, later, what Jesus meant by "This
Generation."
In Matthew
24:1, the disciples had
pointed out the temple buildings to Jesus, and in verse two, He said:
"There shall not be left here one
stone upon another, that shall not be
thrown down." He was speaking of
the destruction of the temple
buildings, and (according to this account) said nothing about anything
else.
In verse
three, they were sitting
upon the Mount of Olives, and the disciples asked Him (concerning His
previous statement): "Tell us, when
shall these things be? And what
shall be the sign of Thy coming, and
the end of the world?"1
Our
problems
at this point are
manifold. This Scripture, in the King James Version, seems to be
speaking
of the second coming of Jesus and the
end of the world as we
know it.
Is this
what
Jesus was saying? Let
us see what we can learn from the Greek text. The Greek word rendered
"coming"
is the word "parousia," which means "presence." That
verse is speaking of the sign of His presence.
The Greek word
rendered "end" is "sunteleia," which means literally: "entire
completion," and the word "aion,"
which the King James
Version rendered "world," literally means "age," and
according to Strong's Concordance,
it further means: specifically
(Jewish), "Messianic period."
The
New American Standard Bible renders the latter part of Matthew 24:3, "end
of the age." The Numeric
English New Testament says: "and
what
the sign of thy presence and consummation of the age?" This is very
close to the Greek meaning. Think
about it. To speak of the
consummation (entire completion) of an age is quite
different from the "end
of the world."
The
parallel Scripture in Mark 13 states it this way: "Tell us, when shall
these things be? and what shall be the sign
when all these things shall
be fulfilled [suntelesthai: to complete entirely]?" Mark 13:4.
What
things? The things which Jesus spoke to them as they left the temple,
concerning the destruction of the temple.
The word "fulfilled" in Mark
13:4 could also be rendered "consummated." So we can see no
contradiction between
Mark and Matthew on this point, just
some
inconsistency in the work of the translators.
Also,
notice
that Mark 13:4 does
not mention the "end of the world," but the fulfillment
of the things Jesus told them.
The same is true of Matthew 24:3 in
the
original language.
What
is the consummation of the age? The book of Hebrews refers to it: "but
now once at the consummation of the
age, hath He [Jesus] been manifest
to put away sin by the sacrifice of Himself." Hebrews 9:26b, NENT.
It
appears that, according to the writer of Hebrews, the "consummation"
of the age was that time period beginning
with and following the
ministry of the Messiah, not the end of the world.
The
King James Version rendered Hebrews 9:26b: "but now once in the end of
the world has he appeared
[past tense] to put away sin by the
sacrifice
of Himself." They translated it as if the end of the world had already
come. We know that the consummation of
that age was not the end of the
world.
Luke
21:7 is very similar to Mark 13:4, "And they asked Him, saying, Master,
but when shall these things be? and
what sign when these things shall
come to pass?
The word
here translated "come to
pass," is the Greek "genesthai," meaning: "begin to be
fulfilled." It is quite
obvious that when the disciples asked "when"
and "what sign," they were simply referring to His previous
remarks
concerning the destruction of the
temple.
The same is true of the question "when shall these things be?" recalling again His earlier statements.
Notice
also
in Luke's account,
there is no mention of the end of the world. The
destruction of the temple was
the subject under discussion, and the
time of its fulfillment. We must be careful to understand this and not
to read
into it something that the Word of God
does not say.
Jesus
warned His disciples, "Take heed lest any man deceive you. For many shall
come in My name saying
I am Christ; and
shall deceive many."
Matthew 24:4-5, Mark 13:3-4, Luke 21:8. "And the time draweth near:
go ye not
therefore after them."
Luke 21:8b. (This is similar to Matthew 24:26 and Mark 13:21).
Did this
happen? Yes there were many who came and pretended to be
the Messiah and each one met death
and came to
naught.
Within one year
of this prophecy, came a
man named Dositheus the Samaritan who boldly claimed to be the
Messiah. A
disciple of Dositheus, Simon Magus claimed to be the "Great
Power of God."
Three years later,
another Samaritan declared the
he would show the people the sacred utensils that he said
were
deposited by Moses on Mt. Gerizim. He amass a great multitude of armed
men, but Pilate defeated them
and killed their
Samaritan leader.
During the reign of
Cuspius Fadus, procurator of
Judea, there arose one named Theudas. He induced a great
number
of men to follow him to the Jordan, saying that the waters would part
on his command. Fadus' army
went after them
on horses and killed
many of them and the Theudas was beheaded.
When Felix was governor,
many rose up, almost
daily, in Judea persuading people to follow them into the
wilderness
where they would show signs and wonders from the ALMIGHTY. Many were
pursued by Felix and
put to death.
About A.D. 55, the
celebrated Egyptian impostor,
Felix, (not to be confused with the governor) assembled thirty
thousand
followers who accompanied him to the Mount of Olives, saying he would
command the walls of Jerusalem
to fall down as
a prelude to the capture
of the Roman garrison and to their obtaining the sovereignty of the
city.
The governor saw
this as a revolt and slew four hundred of
them. The Egyptian impostor escaped.
When Porcius Festus
reigned about A.D. 60,
another impostor promised deliverance from the Roman yoke, if
the
people would follow him into the wilderness. Festus send out
armed force to destroy them and their leader.
You can see
that there was no shortage of false Christs as Jesus had
predicted. "For many will come in My
name saying 'I
am the
Christ' and mislead many." Matthew 24:5.
When Jesus
said "the time draweth
near," He wasn't indicating something that would happen two
thousand
years later. If that were the
case, He would have been
deceiving them, for they would never live to see it. Instead,
He was
warning them of things which would happen in their own generation,
and they did.
Matthew
24:6, "You will hear of wars and rumors of
wars." 7. "Nation will rise against nation
and kingdom
against kingdom."
Next,
Jesus
warned of wars
and tumults, and rumors of wars, and
said, "be not terrified: for these things must
first come to
pass; but the end is not immediately." Matthew 24:6b, Luke 21:9b, NENT.
Notice that the wars and
tumults and rumors of wars occur prior
to the destruction of the temple, as indicated by the word "first."
Were there, in fact, wars, tumults and rumors of wars in the forty years following that prophecy? Indeed there were!
Right
from the pages of History we read: There arose robbers in Jerusalem
called Sicarii.1
They hid daggers in
their clothing and mixed among crowds
at festivals.
They would seek out and kill their victim and then become a
part of the
crowd, and no one knew who was the perpetrator. This caused each man to
be suspicious of even his
closest friends, and to constantly
fear death.
Some
men pretended that God had told them He would show them freedom in a
place in the wilderness and led
many away, but Felix, the procurator,
thought it was a revolt and killed a large number of them.
About three years after
Christ was crucified, war
broke out between Herod and Aretas, king of Arabia Petraea
in which
Herod's army was cut off.
Emperor Caligula ordered
his statue to be placed
in the temple of Jerusalem. The Jews, of course, refused him
and
there were rumors of war, but it never materialized.
Then, a great number of
Jews left Babylon and
went to Seleucia. The Greeks and Syrians destroyed myriads of
them. (Josephus
said this slaughter had no parallel in prior history).
Five years later, the Jews at Perea and the Philadelphians fought over the city limits of Mia and the Jews were slain.
Four years later, when
Cumanus ruled, the Jews
reacted to an act of indignity of a Roman soldier, but when they
saw
the Roman army approaching in large number they panicked and trampled
to death ten thousand Jews in the
streets.
Three years later, the
Samaritans murdered a
Galilean on his way to keep the Passover in Jerusalem. To get
revenge,
the Jews fought against the Samaritans and ravaged their country.
At Caesarea, the Jews
who were mixed with
Syrians raised a tumult over city
government. They argued over
whether the city was Grecian
or Jewish. This led to an armed conflict between Jews and Greeks. The
city was
decreed to the
Syrians. This
brought about the greatest conflict between those two nations. The
Jews beat the
Syrians in one battle, and Felix sent
soldiers out to
slay a great many Jews. About twenty thousand
Jews were
killed.
Wherever Jews and Syrians lived in the same
city, slaughter was a common occurrence. This included
Tyre,
Gadara, Scythopolis, Damascus and Ascalon. At Damascus, ten
thousand Jews were killed in one hour.
At Scythopolis,
thirteen
thousand in a night.
At Alexandria rose up
against the oppressive
Romans. The Romans killed fifty thousand Jews, including infants
to aged.
At Jopata, forty thousand Jews perished.
There were many attacks
of Romans by Jews and
Jews by Romans (even Jews fighting among themselves) in
the years prior
to A. D. 66. This is well recorded in the "Complete Works of
Josephus" to be found in almost any
library.
An
Egyptian false prophet got together thirty thousand Jews and led them
around the wilderness to the Mount of
Olives, and was going to break
into Jerusalem by force, but again, Felix sent Roman soldiers against
them and
many were killed.
Some
deceivers persuaded Jews to revolt and kill other Jews who obeyed the
Roman government. They
plundered the homes of the great men
and slew
them and then set their villages on fire, until Judea was filled
with
their madness.
Festus
succeeded Felix and destroyed many of the seditious. Albinus succeeded
Festus and he was a thief,
burdening the whole nation with taxes,
allowing prisoners to be redeemed for money, and set free. He became
joined to robbers and tyranny was
generally tolerated at that time.
Florus succeeded Albinus and all but legalized robbery, as long as he shared in the spoils.
The
people of Jerusalem (three million of them) gathered around Cestius
Gallus when he visited Jerusalem and
tried to persuade him to put an
end to Florus' exploitation of their country. Florus deluded Gallus and
continued to
incite the Jews to rebel in order to
divert attention from
his own vice.
Florus
had his soldiers bring some of the nonviolent Jews before him, and
chastised them with stripes, then
crucified them. They had done no
wrong. He destroyed about thirty-six hundred men, women and children in
this
way.
In
vain, Bernice, wife of Herod (king of Chalcis) petitioned Florus to
spare the Jews. As often as the rebellion
subsided, Florus would incite
the Jews to rebel again.2
All this is well accepted history from the writings of
Flavius
Josephus, a Jewish historian of the first century. It all obviously
qualifies as fulfillment of the predictions
Jesus made, as recorded in
Matthew 24:4-6
"For
nation shall rise against
nation, kingdom against kingdom: and there shall be famines,
pestilences,
and earthquakes, in divers [various]
places. All these are
the beginning of sorrows." Matthew 24:7-8, Mark 13:8,
Luke 21:10-11.
We have
seen
that nation did
rise against nation, kingdom against kingdom, but what about
famines,
pestilences, and earthquakes?
The fulfillment of prophecy of pestilences and
famines began within about ten years. Look at this Scripture:
"And in
these days came prophets from Jerusalem unto Antioch. And there stood
up one of them named
Agabus, and signified by the Spirit that there
should be great dearth [Greek: Limos, meaning scarcity of food,
as
destitution, famine] throughout all the world [oikoumenen: inhabited
earth or Roman Empire]: which came
to pass in the days of Claudius
Caesar." Acts 11:27-28.3
Claudius Caesar was in power from A.D. 41 to A.D. 54.
So there it is,
right in your own Bible, and if you continue to read a few verses, it
refers to Judea by name.
This
great famine
extended through Greece and into Italy. To alleviate the famine,
Helena, queen of Adiabena,
sent large quantities of
grain from
Alexandria and her son, Izates, gave vast sums to the governors of
Jerusalem
for relief of
sufferers. The Gentile Christians also
sent contributions for relief of the distresses of the Jews:
I
Corinthians 16:2&3. "On the first day of every week let each one of
you put aside and save, as he may prosper,
that no collections be
made
when I come. 3. And when I arrive, whomever you may approve, I shall
send them
with letters to carry
your gift to Jerusalem;"
Dion
Cassius states
that there was a famine at Rome in the first year of
Claudius. In the eleventh year of
Claudius, Eusebius
mentions another
famine.
The book ESSENTIAL
ECCLESIASTICAL
HISTORY by Isaac Boyles, contains the following on page 72,
Chapter
XIX: "Whilst Claudius held the government of the empire [A.D. 41-54],
it happened about the festival
of the passover, that so great a
sedition and disturbance took place at Jerusalem, that thirty thousand
Jews
perished of those alone who were crowded out
of the gate of the
temple, and thus trodden to death by one
another."
Earthquakes
Matthew 24:7b, Earthquakes:
There were numerous earthquakes that are spoken of in the Bible.
Tacitus
records that there was an earthquake at Rome, and a very severe one at
Apamea in Syria, during
the reign of Claudius.
Philostatus
wrote of an earthquake in Crete in his "Life of Apollonius," Which also
occurred in the reign of
Claudius. He also
wrote of quakes in
Miletus, Chios, Smyrna and Samos (all in places where Jews lived).
In
the reign of Nero, Tacitus, Eusebius and Orosius all mentioned an
earthquake in Laodicia.
Eusebius and Orosius
also mentioned that Hieropolis and Colose were overthrown by an
earthquake.
Tacitus
and Seneca both told of quakes in Campania and later at Rome in the
reign of Galba, recorded by
Suetonius.
Josephus
wrote of a heavy storm with violent winds and much rain,
lightning, tremendous thunder and
roarings of earthquakes.
He
said: "It seemed as if the system of the world had been confounded for
the
destruction of man
kind; and one might well conjecture that these
were signs of no common event."
As
you can well see,
history records numerous severe earthquakes in the seven years
preceding A.D. 70, some
associated with Mt. Vesuvius, which eventually
erupted on August 24, A.D. 79, after four hundred years of
dormancy.4
There was an earthquake at the crucifixion of Jesus, and again at His
resurrection. Acts 16:26
records an earthquake when Paul was in jail,
and all the doors were opened and every bond was broken loose.
It says
it was a great earthquake. Most encyclopedias will tell you that there
was a series of earthquakes from
A.D. 63 to A.D. 79. So the prophetic
requirement for earthquakes in various places before the
"great
tribulation," was satisfied.
Review
Now let us
recapitulate a bit. We have the
warning about deception by false prophets, then wars and rumors
of wars
that all came to pass, then the beginning of sorrows (nation rising
against nation, kingdom against
kingdom), pestilences, famine,
earthquakes and trouble. We can see that there were adequate
fulfillments of
all these in the forty years preceding A.D.
70, so we
will continue with the predictions of Jesus, and see if there
are other
fulfillments of His words.
Signs from Heaven
Following
the prediction of
famines, pestilences and trouble, discussed in the previous chapter,
Jesus made
a forecast of fearful sights and great
signs from heaven
(this is only recorded in Luke 21:11). Notice, not in
heaven,
but from heaven.
History
records that many great
signs were given the Jews in the forty years from the crucifixion of
Christ to the
destruction of Jerusalem.
The first
sign was that of a star
like a sword which hung over Jerusalem, then a comet which continued
for a year.
At the feast of unleavened bread, at
the ninth hour of the
night, a great light shone around the altar of the temple
for half an
hour.
At that
same
feast, a cow gave
birth to a lamb in the temple. The eastern gate of the temple,
made of heavy
brass which took twenty men to
shut, was bolted
and barred, and at the sixth hour of the night, it opened on its
own.
All over the area, chariots and armies
were seen fighting in
the clouds, and besieging cities. A voice was heard,
which sounded like
a multitude, saying: "Let us depart hence!"
Four years
before the war, a man
from the country, named Jesus, began (in a time of peace and
prosperity) to cry
out: "A voice from the east! a voice
from the west!
a voice from the four winds! a voice against Jerusalem and the
temple!
a voice against the bridegrooms and the brides! and a voice against all
the people!" "Wo, wo to
Jerusalem," "Wo, wo to the city and to
the
people, and to the temple!"
He did this for years, until he was struck and killed by a stone from a sling or war engine.
Although
he
had received many
stripes from the magistrates, and underwent much punishment, they could
not
restrain him until his prophecy was
completed, and then he died.1
So the signs which were predicted in Luke 21:11 were from heaven, and literally came to pass prior to A.D. 70.
But Before all These
Jesus,
following His description of
signs from heaven, gave a very specific warning to those listening to
Him at that
very moment. He said: "But before all these, they shall lay
their hands on you, and persecute you, delivering you
up to the synagogues [of the Jews], and into prisons, being brought
before kings and rulers for My name's sake.
And it shall turn to you
for a testimony. Settle it therefore in your hearts, not to
meditate before what ye shall answer.
For I will give you a
mouth and wisdom, which all your adversaries shall not be able
to gainsay [refute] nor resist.
And ye shall be betrayed both by
parents, and brethren, and kinsfolk and friends; and some of you
shall they cause
to be put to death. And ye shall be hated of
all men for My name's sake. But there shall not a hair of your
head perish.
In your patience possess ye your souls."
Luke 21:12-19. NENT
Notice
the
frequent use of the word
"you" in this paragraph. Jesus was explaining to His disciples
what would occur
before all the other things He had just told them, and
it would involve them personally, not some future generation.
History
confirms this, as we read in
the Book of Acts, and in secular history, of persecutions and violent
deaths of many
of His disciples. He said they would be delivered up to
the synagogues, which could hardly happen to us today, but was
a real
threat to the disciples in that age, because of the power of the Jewish
leaders.
He
said they
would be delivered up to
prisons [Paul spent many years in prison and several others had shorter
incarcerations], before kings and rulers [read Acts Chapters 21-28] for
"My name's sake," and it would turn to them
for a testimony.
The book of Acts is full of dissertations of Paul, before various
authorities as a testimony to them.
That
Jesus was
addressing those events
that would occur "before all these," can readily be seen also in Mark
13:9,
"But look to yourselves: [specifying His disciples] for they [the
Jews] shall deliver you up to councils: [sanhedrin] and in
synagogues
shall ye be beaten; and before governors and kings shall ye stand for
My sake, for a witness to
them." Mark 13:9, NENT.
How
clear can
it be? The reason for
their persecution was spelled out plainly, that it was for a
testimony, a witness
to those before whom they would be
taken. Can you think of circumstances under which an unwavering
testimony
of Jesus Christ would be more effective? If they stood strong
before councils and kings and rulers, this made their
witness much more
effective to those looking on. And many of them believed. Even some of
the rulers almost
believed. "Then Agrippa said unto Paul, almost thou
persuadest me to be a Christian. And Paul said, " would to
God that not
only thou, but also all that hear me this day, were both almost and
altogether such as I, except these
bonds." Acts 26:28-29.
So
we can see
that Jesus was pointing
out the events that would befall the disciples prior to the time of
sorrows.
Those words in Luke 21:12-19 were addressed personally to His
disciples. In fact, this whole portion of Scripture
is almost identical
to Matthew 10:16-23, where Jesus sent out the twelve Apostles, telling
them: "Behold, I send
you out as sheep in the midst of wolves;
therefore be shrewd as serpents, and innocent as doves. But beware of
men; for they will deliver you up to the courts, and scourge you in
their synagogues; and you shall be brought
before governors and kings
for My sake, as a testimony to them and to the Gentiles. But
when they deliver you
up, do not become anxious about how or what you
will speak; for it shall be given you in that hour what you are to
speak." Luke 21:12-19, NASB.
Now
there is no
doubt that the above
was addressed to the Apostles, because the text in Matthew 10:5 says
so,
and likewise, Luke 21:12-19, which states it in almost the same
words, was addressed to His disciples.
Mark 13:3 specifically names
Peter, James, John and Andrew as the ones who asked the questions.
Matthew
24:3 tells us that the questions were asked by His disciples,
privately. The very fact of the martyrdom of many
of His disciples
shows that He was speaking of what would befall them, specifically, as
a witness or testimony of
Him.
The
nineteenth
verse of Luke 21
closely parallels Matthew 24:13 and Mark 13:13, "In your patience
possess ye
your souls," or as stated in Matthew and Mark, "But he that
shall endure [have patience] unto the end, the same
shall be saved
[possess his soul or 'person']."
This Gospel of The Kingdom
Only one
thing remained in this
sequence of prophecies before the destruction could come. "And this
gospel of
the kingdom shall be preached into all
the world for a
witness unto all nations; and then shall the end come."
Matthew 24:14.
This may
come as a surprise, but
this Scripture appears to be speaking of the end of the age
contemporary with
Jesus, and not the end of the world
itself.
Mark puts it this way: "And the gospel must first be published among all nations." Mark 13:10.
What is
the
significance of the word
first? Before what? Notice that this statement is located in the
middle of
the warning that Jesus gave His
disciples about what
would happen to them prior to the time of sorrows.
"But take
heed to yourselves: for
they shall deliver you [disciples] up to councils; and in the
synagogues ye shall
be beaten: and ye shall be brought
before kings for
My sake, for a testimony against [Greek text says "to"]
them; and the gospel must first be
published among all nations.
But when they lead you [disciples] and
deliver you up, take no thought
beforehand what ye shall speak..." Mark 13:9-11a.
Notice
that
Matthew 24:14 says
"...into all the world for a witness [marturion: evidence]" and
Mark 13:9 reads:
"...and ye [disciples] shall be
brought before kings
for My sake, for a testimony [marturion: evidence] to them;"
It's the same Greek word for both, witness
and testimony,
but the King James version renders it witness one time
and testimony
the other. Many times, what appear to be discrepancies in our Bibles,
are only inconsistent
rendering of words.
So the
purpose that Jesus gave for first
publishing the Gospel (good news) at that time, was to allow all those,
who could possibly lose their lives in
the upcoming destruction of
Jerusalem, the opportunity to repent and
accept Christ, and to be
warned to flee the wrath to come.
This is a
principle with God, that
He is altogether just and always forewarns His people through His
prophets
before doing anything (Amos 3:7).2
The Jews
were given almost forty
years, after they killed Jesus, to repent and escape the destruction,
but they
would not.3
"He came unto His own and His own received Him not." John 1:11. Had
they received Him, they
would have been spared.
We have
already seen that the Jews
resisted Jesus and the prophets, killing many of them, and putting to
death
the Christ on a cross. This is why it
says "this Gospel must
first be published." Jerusalem was about to be
destroyed.
The Gospel
went first to the
Jews, then after they rejected it, to the gentiles, including all other
nations and even
to the Israelites in the dispersion.
And Paul
and
Barnabas spoke out
boldly and said, "It was necessary that the word of God should be
spoken
to you [Jews] first; since you
repudiate it, and judge
yourselves unworthy of eternal life, behold, we are turning to
the
Gentiles. For thus the Lord has commanded us, 'I have placed you as a
light for the Gentiles, that you should
bring salvation to the end of
the earth.' And when the Gentiles heard this they began rejoicing and
glorifying the
word of the Lord; and as many as had
been appointed to
eternal life believed." Acts 13:46-48, NASB.
Habitable Earth
When
Matthew
24:14 says "This
gospel of the kingdom shall be preached into all the world," the word
for
world is the Greek word oikoumene,
which means:
habitable earth, or specifically, the Roman Empire.
That is
how the word oikoumene was used in those days.4
It did not mean the whole earth.
When the
Bible speaks of the whole
world, the Greek word is kosmos, from which we get our word, cosmos,
that we use now-a-days for "universe."
The following is an example from
Scripture of the use of the word kosmos.
"Verily I say unto
you, wheresoever this gospel shall be preached throughout the whole
world [kosmon], this also
that she hath done shall be spoken of
for a memorial to her." Mark 14:9.
Notice
that world
is kosmon, another form of kosmos. We can see from
this Scripture
that the word kosmos
means the whole world.
Now a very
good example of the use
of oikoumene: And it came to pass in those days a decree went
out from
Caesar Augustus that all the
habitable world [oikoumenen]
should be registered." Luke 2:1, BINT.
This
speaks
of the part of the
world over which Caesar Augustus had authority as all the habitable
world. Any
good Bible atlas will show that the
Roman Empire covered
only a small portion of the whole world.
Oikoumene
means the
habitable earth, or Roman Empire. Kosmos means the
whole world, as far as the New
Testament Greek is concerned.
When in
Matthew 24:14 it says:
"into all the world for a witness unto all nations," the word oikoumene
is used,
meaning all the nations under control
of the Roman Empire.
Matthew 24:14 then says: "and then shall the end come."
It seems
that a more literal
rendering of this Scripture might be: "And there shall be proclaimed
these glad
tidings [gospel] of the kingdom in all
the habitable earth,
for a testimony to all the nations; and then shall come
the end." The
end spoken of here was the end of that age, and of Jerusalem as a
nation, with its inhabitants,
not the end of the world.
In his
book,
"The Search for the
Twelve Apostles," William Steuart McBirnie, Ph.D., Tyndale House
Publishers,
Wheaton, IL., has the following
information:
p. 282, The evidence on the subject,
though ( as we have said) not
copious, is yet conclusive so far as it goes; and this is all one
way.
"The most important
portion of it is supplied by Clement, the
disciple of Paul mentioned in Phil. iv. 3, who was afterward
bishop of Rome.
This author, writing from
Rome to
Corinth, expressly asserts that Paul had preached the gospel 'IN THE
EAST AND IN THE WEST,'
that he 'had
instructed the whole world [i.e. the Roman empire,
which was commonly so called]
in righteousness,' and that he 'had
gone to the extremity
of the west'
before his martyrdom.
"Now, to a Roman
author the extremity of the West could mean nothing short of Spain, and
the expression is often used by Roman
writers to denote
Spain.
Here, then, we have the express testimony of Paul's own disciple that
he fulfilled his original intention
(mentioned Rom. xv.
24-28)
of visiting the Spanish penisula, and consequently that he was
liberated from his first imprisonment at Rome.
p. 290, "Capellus,
in History of the Apostles, writes: "'I know scarcely of one
author from the time of the Fathers downward who does
not maintain that
St. Paul, after his liberation, preached in every country of the West,
in Europe, Britain included.'" (The Drama of the
Lost Disciples, George
F. Jowett, p. 196)
However there is more
solid evidence for an early Christian tradition of Apostolic evangelism
in Britain--possibly that of St. Paul.
TERTULLIAN,
A. D. 155-222, the Early Father, the first great genius after the
Apostles among Christian writers, writing in A. D. 192,
said: "The
extremities of Spain, the various parts of Gaul, the regions of
Britain, which have never been penetrated by the Roman Arms,
have
received the religion of Christ." (Tertullian, Def. Fidei,
p. 179)" (St. Joseph of Arimathea at Glastonbury, Rev. Lionel
Smithett
Lewis, pp. 129, 130)
ORIGEN,
another Early Father (A. D. 185-254), wrote:
"'The divine goodness
of Our Lord and Saviour is equally diffused among the Britons, the
Africans, and other nations of the world." (Ibid)
"ST. CLEMENT
speaks of Paul going to "the extremity of the West, then returning to
Rome and suffering martyrdom before the
sovereigns of mankind."
Gospel Proof
Jesus
said: "This Gospel of the kingdom shall be
preached in all
the world for a witness to all nations,
and then
the end shall come."
Matthew 24:14.
Does the Bible say that this occurred?
The following Scripture shows the preaching of the Gospel to the nations (Gentiles) in progress:
"For thus
the Lord has commanded
us, I HAVE PLACED YOU AS A LIGHT FOR THE GENTILES,
THAT YOU SHOULD
BRING SALVATION TO THE
END OF THE EARTH. And when
the Gentiles heard this, they began rejoicing and
glorifying the word of the Lord; and
as many as had been appointed to
eternal life believed." Acts 13:47-48. NASB.
The Bible,
itself, tells us
that the gospel reached the whole inhabited earth at that time.
"For the Scripture saith,
Whoever believeth on Him shall not be
put to
shame. For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek: for He
is the
same Lord of all, rich unto all that call upon Him: for, Whoever shall
call upon the name of the Lord shall be
saved. How then shall they call
on Him in whom they have not believed? and how shall they believe whom
they have
not heard? and how shall they hear
without a preacher? and
how shall they preach, except they be sent? even as
it is written, How
beautiful the feet of them that bring a gospel of good things! But they
did not hearken to the
gospel. For Isaiah saith,
[prophetically] Lord,
who hath believed our report? The faith therefore is by hearing,
and
hearing by Christ's word. But I say, Did they not hear? Yea, verily,
Their sound when out into all the earth,
and their words unto the
ends of the inhabited earth [oikoumene]." Romans 10:11-18, NENT.
--This
Scripture refers to
preaching of the gospel (glad tidings), saying that Israel is
without excuse, because
the gospel (evangel) had gone out into all
the habitable earth, at that time.
Another
Scripture in the Bible
addresses this spread of the gospel: "because of the hope laid up for
you in
heaven, of which you previously heard
in the word of truth, the
gospel, which has come to you, just as in all
the world..."
"If in deed you continue in the faith firmly established and steadfast,
and not move away from the hope
of the gospel that you have heard,
which was proclaimed in all creation under heaven,
and
which I, Paul, was
made a minister," Colossians 1:5, 6
and 23, NASB.
Yet a
third
Scripture found in
Romans 16:25-27 says: "Now to Him who is able to establish you
according to
my gospel and preaching of
Jesus Christ,
according to the revelation of the mystery which has been kept
secret for
long ages past, but now
is manifested, and by the
Scriptures of the prophets, according to the
commandment of the eternal
God, has been made known to all the nations, leading
to obedience of faith;
to the only wise God, through Jesus
Christ, be
the glory forever. Amen.
Again,
Paul
wrote in Romans 15:18,
"For I will not presume to speak of anything except what Christ has
accomplished through me, resulting in
the obedience of the Gentiles by
word and deed, 19 in the power of signs
and wonders, in the power of
the Spirit; so that from Jersualem and round about as far as
Illyricum I have fully
preached the gospel of
Christ.
20 And thus I aspired to preach the gospel, not where Christ was already
named,
that I might not build upon another
man's foundation; 21 but as
it is written, "They who had no news of Him
shall see, And they who
have not heard shall understand."
22 For this reason I have often been
hindered from coming to you; 23 but now, with no further
place for me in
these regions, and since
I have had for many
years a longing to come to you 24 whenever I go to Spain -- for I
hope
to see you in passing, and to be helped on my way there by you, when I
have first enjoyed your company
for a while -- 25 but now I am going
to
Jerusalem serving the saints."
What did
Paul mean when he said
there was no further place for him in those regions?
He meant that he had
covered them thoroughly with the
gospel and it was
time to continue on to somewhere else. He was now planning
to go
to Spain.
In Acts
19:10 it says that all
in Asia heard.
In Acts 13:49 It says that the . .
.word. . .spread through the whole region. . .
Romans 1:8, "Your faith is being
proclaimed throughout the whole world."
Cities and countries where the Book of Acts specifically says the Gospel was preached.
Antioch, Syria,
Cilicia, Cypress,
Pamphylia, Derbe, Lystra, Iconium, Phrygia, Galatian region, Asia,
Mysia,
Bithynia, Troos, Macedonia, Samotrace,
Neopolis, Phillipi,
Thyatira, Amphipolis, Appollonia, Thessalonica, Berea,
Corinth, Cenchrea, Ephesus, Caesarea,
Alexandria, Achaia, Athens,
Greece, Assos, Mitylene, Chios, Samos,
Miletus, Cos, Rhodes, Patara,
Phoenicia, Tyre, Ptolemais, Mnason, Tarsus, Damascus, Nazareth,
Jerusalem,
Antipatris, Rome, Italy, Myra in Lycia,
Cnidus, Crete,
Salmone, Rheguim, Puteoli, Azotus, Galilee, Judea,
Samaria, Parthians,
Medes, Elamites, residents of Mesopotamia, Judea, Cappadocia, Pontus,
Egypt, Libya,
Cyrene, Arabia, Lydda, Joppa, Seleucia,
Salamis, Paphos,
Perga, Pesidian, Lycaonia, Attalia, Three Taverns.
Ethiopian
Eunuch. A total of over 80 cities and countries.
Most of the above
list was the work of one
man, Paul. Phillip preached to all the cities from Azotus to
Caesarea.
Note that Rome and Italy are listed in
separate
scriptures and the same is true of Athens and Greece. This
indicates
that the country as well as specific cities were taught the
Gospel. The other apostles were also busy
preaching the
Gospel to the Jews and some gentiles.
Remember,
that Jesus sent them in
to all the habitable earth (oikoumene) for a witness, not into all the
world
(kosmos). Look up the word
"world," as used in Luke 21, in
your concordance and you'll see the truth.
Was the Gospel preached into all the world (oikoumene) for a witness?
It is hard to argue with the Scriptures. The Gospel was taken into all the world for a witness at that time.
Eusebius
Eusebius,
described as the
Christian Church's greatest historian, writing in the fourth century,
had this to say:
"Thus, then, under a celestial
influence and
cooperation, the doctrine of the Savior, like the rays of the sun,
quickly irradiated the whole world.
Presently, in accordance with
divine prophecy, the sound of his inspired
evangelists and apostles had
gone throughout all the earth, and their words to the end of the world."
Writing of
a
time prior to A.D. 70,
Eusebius said: 'And it was at this time that "over all the land there
went forth
the voice" of His holy apostles and
"their words over all
the earth."'5
Further,
speaking of the apostles,
Eusebius said: 'They were driven from the land of Judea and they
traveled to
all the nations, bringing the message
of the Gospel. They
did so by the power of Christ, for He had said to them:
"Go and teach
all nations in My name."'6
So the church's greatest historian agrees, that the gospel had already
been preached into all the world
for a witness, prior to the
desolation of the city and the temple in A.D. 70.
At another
place, Eusebius said:
"As for the holy apostles, and disciples of our Savior, they had spread
over all
the inhabited world."7
Again, we
quote Eusebius, "But the
members of the church in Jerusalem were instructed by a prophecy,
revealed
to the leaders, to abandon the city
before the war and to take
up residence in one of the cities of Perea which was
named Pella. From
Jerusalem the followers of Christ migrated to Pella, and thus the royal
Capital of the Jews and
the whole land of Judea were all
abandoned by
holy men. The justice of God could now at last come upon the Jews
for
all their crimes against Christ and his apostles. This race of impious
men could at last be blotted from the world."8
As we saw
in
Acts 13:46-48, the
Jews rejected the gospel, and following its proclamation, the end did
come,
indeed, in the fall of Jerusalem in
A.D. 70.
It is also
easy to see that the
early church historians did not know about many of the inhabited areas
of the earth.
They spoke of the area that they knew
as the whole
inhabited earth.
The Great Commission
Just
because
the gospel was
preached into all the world (habitable earth) for a witness at that
time does
not mean that we should stop
evangelizing the world today. As
long as there is a person on the earth who
does not know Jesus Christ
as his Lord and Savior, we must continue to freely share the good news
of the
gospel.
Matthew
26:13 says: "Wheresoever
this gospel shall be preached through the whole world (kosmon)..."
This
indicates that it would reach beyond the Roman Empire at some point in
time, which we know it has.
The "great
commission" in Matthew
28 tells us to make disciples of all nations, teaching them to observe
the commandments of Jesus.
It is
sufficient evidence that we
should continue to share the gospel, that God honors our efforts by
bringing
into His kingdom many converts by
means of the Gospel. If
there were no such results from our efforts, only
then would we be
justified in questioning its continuance.
But, the
prophecy of preaching
the gospel to all the world for a witness was literally fulfilled
before the
destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70.
The second
destruction was after
all the Bible had been written, therefore it is not recorded there.
But
there is a very good record of it in the writings of Flavius Josephus.
Josephus was a Jew
who was carried out of
Jerusalem in a coffin, while it was under siege by Titus'
Roman
Army. The Jews considered him a traitor, however, if he had
remained in Jerusalem as the
others did, we would not have his very
detailed and very conscienciously written history of that time period.
Even though the
Jews
do not recognize
Josephus, their history of that time very closely parallels his on most
events. The history by Josephus is well
accepted and highly acclaimed
by the rest of the world.
I will relate to
you
the significant events
that have to do with our discussion of the Great Tribulation. As you
read through this, notice how it lines up with
the prophecies of Jesus
on the Mount of Olives (Luke 21).
Because many people have never heard of the
events which occurred in Jerusalem between A.D. 66
and A.D. 73,
it is essential to include here some history of that period.
The actual
destruction of Jerusalem, which
began in the spring of A.D. 70, was the culmination of years
of
conflict and provocation between the Jews and Romans.1
Jerusalem first
fell
to Roman control in 63
B.C., and remained under Roman domination until four years
before its
destruction. The Jews seized control of the city in A.D. 66. About May
of that year, the Jews
attacked the Romans that were at Masada, and
slew them. Then Eleazar, the son of Ananias the High
Priest, persuaded
the officiating priests to receive no gift or sacrifice for any
foreigner. This eventually led
to the refusal of Caesar's sacrifice,
and ultimately started the war.2
Eleazar's men
killed
a group of Roman
soldiers on the Sabbath day. The people of Cesarea killed the Jews
among them on the same day and hour when the
soldiers were slain. In
one hour, twenty thousand Jews
lay dead.
At Alexandria,
Tiberius Alexander sent two
Roman Legions plus five thousand other soldiers to destroy
the
seditious Jews. These soldiers rushed violently into the Delta, and
destroyed unmercifully, catching
Jews in open fields as well as some in
their homes. No mercy was shown, regardless of age. They slaughtered
until the place overflowed with blood, and
fifty thousand lay dead upon
heaps.
Cestius Gallus
took
part of his forces and
marched into Zebulon of Galilee, finding it deserted by its men, the
multitude having fled to the mountains, they
plundered the city.3
Cestius also besieged Jerusalem in A.D. 66,
and then retreated without
apparent cause.4
He was severely attacked in his retreat and suffered great
casualties.
Was the presence
of
the Roman army of
Cestius Gallus actually the "abomination of desolation"? The
Roman army
was considered an abomination by the Jews, because of the Roman's
ensigns and images
which they worshipped and to which they
sacrificed.
Where is the holy
place in which the
abomination of desolation was to appear? Was it the temple proper?
This
is what many believe, but Ezekiel 43:12 indicates differently. "This is
the law of the house; upon the
top of the mountain the whole limit
thereof round about shall be holy. Behold this is the law of
the house."
Ezekiel 43:12. [emphasis mine].
So the mere presence of the Roman army in the "holy city" was an abomination, standing where it ought not.
If we read only
Matthew and Mark, we have
difficulty fully comprehending the reference to the "abomination
of
desolation," but let us now look at Luke's account of these same
prophecies and we will see why the
Christians believed this to be what
Jesus had foretold: "And when ye shall see Jerusalem compassed with
armies, then know that the desolation thereof
is nigh. Then let them
which are in Judea flee to the mountains;
and let them which are in the
midst of it depart out; and let not them that are in the countries
enter thereinto.
For these be the days of vengeance, that all
things
which are written may be fulfilled. But woe unto them
that are with
child, and to them that give suck, in those days! for there shall be
great distress in the land,
and wrath upon this people." Luke 21:20-23.
Notice again, that
this prophecy is not for
the whole world, but for those in Judea only. Actually, the
siege
of the city under Cestius Gallus did not
materialize into the
destruction of the city. That was to come later,
but it served the
Christians well, in that it afforded them time to escape before the
actual desolation came.
This vengeance
which
Jesus prophesied had
to come upon the Jews in order to fulfill the Scriptures. There
was to
be distress in the land, and wrath upon this people.
"This people" refers to the Jews, who both
killed Jesus and the
prophets (1 Thessalonians 2:15), and said, "His blood be on us, and
on our
children." Matthew 27:25. The
desolation was not intended to
ensnare the Christians, for they had the
words of Jesus warning them to
flee when certain events began to occur.
Eusebius, in his
history, reports that an
oracle of the Lord directed them to flee from Jerusalem. They fled
across the Jordan river to Pella. It is said
by Eusebius that not one
Christian was killed in the destruction
of Jerusalem.5
By A.D. 69, the Jerusalem church was gone entirely,6
gathered out of the tribulation by the
Lord's word.
Although the A.D.
66
attack by Cestius
Gallus was not the destruction of Jerusalem, it did signal the
beginning of what is called the "great
tribulation."
There followed, continuous attacks of Jews upon
Romans, and Romans upon
Jews.
The people of
Damascus slew the Jews that
lived with them. A short time later, Vespasian was sent into
Syria by
Nero to make war with the Jews there. He slew ten thousand Jews and two
Jewish generals, John
and Silas.
Vespasian took
Gadara, Jotapata, Joppa, and
Taricheae, and helped his son Titus in taking Gamala. Great
was the
slaughter of the Jews by Vespasian.
Titus then took
Gischala and John of
Gischala fled to Jerusalem. As there was preparation for war with
Rome,
there were, inside, various factions fighting each other.
The Zealots who
had
sent for the Idumeans,
slew a great many more of the citizens, themselves.7
Vespasian
persuaded the Romans to not proceed in the war
at that time.
At one point,
Vespasian made preparation
for the siege of Jerusalem, but because of Nero's suicide, he
changed
his mind. All these events, and many more, too numerous to recount
here, occurred prior to the
actual destruction of Jerusalem and the
temple. So the Jews, not only in Jerusalem, but throughout the land,
had suffered great loss of life.
Then in the spring
of A.D. 70, Titus, heir
to the throne of Rome, went to take a look at Jerusalem. He was
surrounded there by such a large group of
Judean citizens that he
barely escaped with his life.
A short time later, eighty thousand men with
battering rams surrounded Jerusalem. Jesus had said: "And
when ye shall
see Jerusalem compassed with armies, then know that the
desolation thereof is nigh." Luke 21:20.
Right before the
Passover festival, large
numbers of men came into Jerusalem to defend it. Jesus had said
"Let
not them that are in the countries enter therein." Luke 21:21c. The
walls were more strongly fortified, as
Titus formed his huge army all
around Jerusalem. Then he sent word to the inhabitants to surrender,
demanding submission, taxes and recognition of
Roman rule. Titus
desired to spare the destruction of the
temple and the city, but the
Jews refused all negotiations, swearing to defend their city with their
lives. As
the Roman army attacked, the first encounter
was successful
for the Jews, as they caught the 10th Legion by
surprise on the Mount
of Olives.
During the Passover of A.D. 70, Titus came
with his battering rams, but the Jews quickly destroyed them.
The Jews
fought the Romans with their own weapons. They also threw stones upon
them and poured boiling
oil on their heads from the walls. But the
Romans repaired the rams and finally forced the Jews back and
took the
outer wall. They also seized the nearby town of Bezetha.
After fighting for
seventeen days, the
Romans reached the Antonine Tower and the Jews at last realized that
it
would be a fight to the death.
The army of Titus
crucified five hundred
prisoners in one day. They also cut off the hands of some of the Jews
and sent them back into the city to instill
fear in the people.
Titus held a
council
of war, and listened
to suggestions from various parties as to how he should proceed.
He
felt the only way to prevent the Jews from getting new supplies and
continuing to resist was to
completely cut them off, so he had his
soldiers build a siege wall, totally encompassing the city. The
wall
was four and a half miles around, with
thirteen large forts
outside, and the huge Roman army completed
it in just three days.
It is said that
the
building of the siege
wall, forts, and platform for their rams, necessitated the clearing of
woodlands over sixty square miles, leaving it
as a desert.8
The siege wall was
an exact fulfillment of
the prophecy of Jesus, "For the days shall come upon thee, that
thine
enemies shall cast a trench about thee, and compass thee round, and
keep in on every side, and shall
lay thee even with the ground, and thy
children within thee; and they shall not leave in thee one stone upon
another: because thou knewest not the time of
thy visitation." Luke
19:43-44, KJV. 9
As we have seen,
that enemy, Rome, did
throw a bank up before them. They did encircle the entire city with
a
wall, hemming them in on all sides, so that no one could go in or out
of the city. And we will see, as we
continue, that they did level them
to the ground, they and their children within, and did not leave one
stone
upon another that was not thrown down (Luke
21:24).
The destruction
was
so complete, that a man
named Turnus (Terentius) Rufus actually plowed up the land
on which the
temple had stood,10
so completely that it appeared as though it had never been inhabited.
According to the
book JERUSALEM, by
Kathleen M. Kenyon,11
page 185, "The final structures were
regularly planned houses, beneath
which was a well-built drain, a layout that culminated in the period of
Herod Agrippa." "In the destruction of these
buildings, walls were
razed, paving stones torn up, and the
drain clogged with material
firmly dated to the last part of the century by the pottery. In the
drain were
human skulls and other bones, washed down from
the ruined
city higher up the slope." Continuing on page
186, . . . "with the
drains and retaining walls which controlled the forces of nature, was
destroyed, the central
valley reverted to its natural function.
Torrents of water from winter rains swept down the valley. The
stratification of Site N showed how these
torrents had churned up the
debris resulting from the destruction
by Titus." This may explain the
reference in Daniel 9:26 to a flood related to the second destruction
of Jerusalem.
After twenty-one
days, the wall surrounding
Antonine Tower fell to the battering rams, but the Jews had
built a
second wall behind it.
The famine was so
intense in Jerusalem that
money was worthless and could not purchase food. ('He then
said to me,
"Son of man, I will cut off the supply of food in Jerusalem. The people
will eat rationed food in
anxiety and drink rationed water in despair,
for food and water will be scarce. They will be appalled at the
sight
of each other and will waste away because of their sin. Ezekiel
4:16-17, NIV.)
The High Priest's
wife Martha roamed the
streets looking for a mere morsel of food. A woman, Miriam,
actually
killed, roasted and devoured her own child which was still of nursing
age, a gruesome sight.
("Therefore in your midst fathers will eat
their
children, and children will eat their fathers." "A third of your
people
will die of the plague or perish by famine inside you; a third will
fall by the sword outside your walls;
and a third I will scatter to the
winds and pursue with drawn sword." "I will send famine and wild beasts
against you and they will leave you childless.
Plague and bloodshed
will sweep through you and I will bring the
sword against you. I the
Lord have spoken." Ezekiel 5:10,12&17, NIV.) Was not this "great
tribulation?"
"For these be the
days of vengeance, that
all things which are written may be fulfilled. But woe unto them that
are with child, and to them that give suck, in
those days! for there
shall be great distress in the land, and wrath
upon this people. And
they shall fall by the edge of the sword, and shall be led away captive
into all nations: and
Jerusalem shall be trodden down of the
Gentiles,
until the times of the Gentiles be fulfilled." Luke 21:22-23.
There were many
people hiding out in the
Sanctuary, and those who could not stand the thought of living
without
their beloved temple threw themselves into the burning mass. Many
others hid in the inner court.
They had been promised by the smooth
words of the false prophets, the priests (Matthew 24:11), that God
would save them by a miracle at the very
moment of destruction. Of
course, that did not happen.
The Romans slew
about six thousand on the
spot. The temple was totally burned, and only smoldering rubble
remained along with the western wall. Those
priests who did escape to
the wall went without food for days,
and finally had to surrender, and
Titus ordered them killed. He said, "Priests must fall with their
Temple."
The Roman standard was raised in the ruins, and they sacrificed to their pagan gods in the Holy Place.
Speaking of A.D.
70,
Eusebius said: "at
last the abomination of desolation spoken of by the prophets was
implanted in the very temple of God...."13
Flavius Josephus
in WARS
OF THE JEWS, chapter VII, section 7, states that the Romans
themselves never took
the Jews for their enemies until they revolted
from them in A.D. 66. Regarding their state of affairs, he
wrote,
"however, the circumstances we are now in, ought to be an inducement to
us to bear such calamity
courageously, since it is by the will of God,
and by necessity that we are to die: for it now appears that God
hath
made such a decree against the whole Jewish nation, that we are to be
deprived of this life which
(He knew) we would not make a due use of;"
Even Titus, who
conquered the Jews, stated
that God had fought with his army and given the Jews over
to him.15
What did Jesus
mean
by "this
generation?"
Some say that the word generation
should be rendered race, meaning the Jewish race. Others say
that
He meant the generation alive when the
signs begin to occur,
not the generation when Jesus spoke these
words.
The word
translated generation
is the Greek word "genea," which Strong's Exhaustive Concordance
defines as "a generation" or by
implication, an age. Berry's
Interlinear defines it "the people of any given
time," "an age of the
world's duration." It is quite safe to render it generation,
meaning the age
contemporary with Jesus and those who
lived at
that time.
While it is true
that the "great
tribulation" was to come only upon the Jews (not the
whole world),
the word, genea, in this instance does
not mean race, as some would claim who do not hold to this
view.
If this
generation is understood to
be the one to whom Jesus spoke these predictions, it makes
absolutely
perfect sense. This is also fully
consistent with all
other renderings of the same Greek phrase used
elsewhere in the Bible.
This is a very important fact if we want the truth concerning this
matter.
Examples: This
wicked generation,
Matthew 12:45. This generation seeks a sign, Mark 8:12.
"This
untoward generation," Acts 2:40. But first must He suffer many
things and be rejected of "this
generation," Luke 17:25.
Whereunto then shall I liken the men of this generation?
Luke 7:31.
Not one of us
would
try to say that these
phrases were spoken of any generation other than the one in
which they
were uttered. It is obvious, beyond question, that all refer to the generation
of people
contemporary with Jesus. Yet, our
Scriptures under
examination reflect the exact same meaning,
and many,
who are learned Bible scholars, suppose it to mean some later
generation. Why? Because it
fits the "futurist" doctrine. But
it is not true. There is nothing in the Scriptures
preceding His statements
that would transfer it to some future
generation. He said THIS
generation.
In Luke 11:29
Jesus
said of that
generation: "This generation is a wicked generation;
it seeks for a
sign, and yet no sign shall be given
to it but
the sign of Jonah."
Then in Luke 11,
verse 49, Jesus said: "For
this reason also the wisdom of God said, 'I will send to them
prophets
and apostles, and some of them they will kill andsome
they will persecute, 50 in order that the
blood of all the prophets,
shed since the foundation of the world, may be charged against
this
generation, 51 from the blood of
Abel to the blood of
Zechariah, who perished between the alter and
the house of God;
yes, I tell you, it shall be charged against this generation.'"
NASB.
Now doesn't it
make
perfect sense that He
would fulfill His prophecy of destruction of the generation that
was charged
with the guilt of destroying the prophets and apostles and even Jesus
Himself?
Jesus said:
"Verily,
I say unto you, this
generation [genea] shall not pass, till all these things
be fulfilled."
(Luke 21:32 and Matthew 24:34)
If it could be
interpreted "this generation
(which is alive when these signs begin to occur) shall not pass
until
all be fulfilled," then we must again conclude that the
fulfillments of those prophecies came about
prior to A.D. 70. The
record so dictates. All the signs did come at that time.
Donald G. Miller,
in
his Commentary on the
Gospel of St. Luke, p. 148, THE LAYMAN'S BIBLE
COMMENTARY, Vol. 18, had
this to say about Luke 21:32: "If verse 32 can be referred to the
destruction
of Jerusalem, it presents no problem, for that
took place
within the lifetime of many to whom Jesus was
speaking. If it does not
relate to that, it presents us with an almost insoluble problem, for
Jesus did not
make guesses about the date of the end."
R.V.G. Tasker, in
his GOSPEL OF ST. MARK,
p. 205, said this of Mark 13:30: "This generation must surely
be the
generation of the Lord's ministry, who would indeed have lived to see
the awful days of the siege
of Jerusalem."
Jesus identified
the
generation that He was
to destroy in His wrath when in Luke 17:25 He said: "But first
He must
suffer many things and be rejected by this generation."
Referring again to
Matthew 24:34, notice
that the text says this generation shall not "pass." Some
translations
render it shall not "pass away," but a careful study of the Greek shows
that it should be, as
the King James Version has it, simply "pass,"
from the Greek word parelthe.
In Matthew 24:35,
Jesus used a different
word, pareleuontai, when He said "Heaven and earth shall pass
away, but my words shall not pass
away. The Greek word for pass
away, in both instances in this verse
is the same. Although it has
the same root as parelthe, it has a slightly different meaning.
So, the Greek text
in Matthew 24:34 says:
"Verily I say to you, in no wise will have passed this generation
until all these things shall have taken
place," [My rendering]. Jesus
seems to have used the word generation
more to indicate the
passing of the time period of a generation than the passing of the
people of that time
period or generation. For those who had ears
to
hear, He told them that the promised wrath of God upon the
Jews,
including the destruction of their temple, would come in that
generation. There seems to be no
authority in the Bible
at all to apply this statement to a later time.
Why did God wait
so
long after the
crucifixion of Jesus before bringing the destruction of those people
and
the Temple? In the wilderness, God
caused the children of
Israel to wander for forty years, until that
generation
died off. In this instance, God allowed the Jews forty years
to repent, before He brought
destruction upon them through the
instrument of the Roman Army in A. D. 70. Some believe that was
not
the end of that generation, but all Jesus said
was "This generation
shall not pass until all be fulfilled, so it could
have gone beyond
A.D. 70. Actually, I believe that it did go several years beyond
that time to encompass
additional events which wrapped up the
predictions of Jesus.
There are various
indicators in the Bible
as to how long a generation is. The first people on the earth
before the flood lived hundreds of years, to
almost 1000. Then,
after the flood, man's years were shortened,
so the length of the
generations probably changed. The length of the life-span of a man is
not what is totally in
place here. Many of the people who were
listening to him had already lived a great part of their lives.
But it
would happen before they all died off.
The A.D. 70
desolation of Jerusalem
and the temple is the only"great
tribulation" prophesied in the Bible,
so if there is to be
another, you have to get it from some other than Biblical source.
I challenge you to
prove me wrong on this.
The fact is, there
can be only one
fulfillment of the "great tribulation" which Jesus
predicted. The Bible
contains two Scriptures which absolutely
preclude
a dual fulfillment.
Matthew 24:21
speaks
of this "great
tribulation," using the Greek word "thlipsis," and Mark
13:19 calls it
"Affliction," from the exact same Greek
word.
Both instances state that it will be unparalleled in the
past
or
future. This means that it can only
happen one time.
These Scriptures make this very clear:
"For this shall be
great tribulation
[thlipsis] such as was not since the beginning of the world to this
time, nor
ever shall be." Matthew 24:21. "for in those
days shall be
affliction [thlipsis] such as was not from the beginning
of the
creation which God created unto this time, neither shall be." Mark
13:19.
"Such as was
not
since the beginning"
indicates that it had never happened to that degree before, and "nor
ever
shall be" states that this "great
tribulation"
foretold by Jesus will never happen again.
You cannot expect
a
repeat of something
that Jesus said could only happen once. And this is the only "great
tribulation" that He foretold, "days
of vengeance" upon
the Jews, in fulfillment of Prophecy.
Similar language
was
used concerning the
wisdom of Solomon, in 1 Kings 2:12. God said, "I will give you a wise
and discerning heart, so that there will
never have been anyone
like you, nor will there ever be." We know
that Solomon is
accepted as the wisest man that ever lived.
Recall that,
earlier, we wrote of the
destruction of Jerusalem and the temple by Nebuchadnezzar beginning in
605 B.C. when he took the city, and ending
when he destroyed the temple
in 587 B.C. Although this was a similar
destruction to the one in A.D.
70, it was not as severe in terms of the horrors of it and it occurred
long before
Jesus made His pronouncements concerning the "great
tribulation."
Later in this
writing, we will speak of a
destruction of the city of Jerusalem, but not the temple which occurred
in A.D. 135. Again it was not as severe, and
since there was no
temple to be destroyed, it could not qualify as
the "great
tribulation."
Warburton
is
quoted as having said:
"One of the most awful eras in God's economy of grace, and the most
awful revolution in all God's religious
dispensations." Orelli said: "A
greater catastrophe than the mortal combat
of the Jewish people with
the Roman world-power, and the destruction of the holy city, is unknown
to the
history of the world."
Farrar called it "the most awful in history.1
Adam Clarke wrote: "No history can furnish us with a parallel to the calamities and miseries of the Jews.2
Eusebius
wrote: "Such was the
punishment of the Jews for their iniquity against the Christ of God,
and for
their impiety. But one should add to this the
prophecy of our
Savior, a prophecy in which there was no lie, and
by which He foretold
these very things: Woe to those who are with child and give suck in
those days. Pray that
your flight be not in winter nor on a Sabbath
day. [The Sabbath means almost nothing to most Christians
today]. For
there shall then be a great affliction such as never happened from the
beginning of the world until
now, nor ever shall happen."3
"These things happened in the second year of Vespasian [A.D. 68-79] and
in
accordance with the prophetic utterances of
our Lord and Savior,
Jesus Christ, Who by divine power foresaw
the events as though they
were already happening. He shed tears at them and lamented, for so it
is set down
in the writings of the holy evangelists who
also gave His
words.4
Josephus,
speaking of the A.D. 70
destruction of Jerusalem said this: "I cannot refrain from saying what
my
emotion bids me. It seems to me that if the
Romans had proven
powerless against the sinner, the city
[Jerusalem] would have been
engulfed by an earthquake or flood, or it would have shared the
thunderbolts
of Sodom, for it had brought forth a
generation more
ungodly than these. Because of the folly of these men,
the entire
nation perished."5
In Acts 2:40, Peter called it a perverse [untoward] generation.
In the preface of
"The Wars of the Jews" or
"the History of the Destruction of Jerusalem," COMPLETE
WORKS OF
JOSEPHUS, p.427, Josephus wrote: "Whereas the war which the Jews made
with the Romans
hath been the greatest of all, not only that
have been
in our times, but, in a manner, of those that ever were
heard of; both
of those wherein cities have fought against cities or nations against
nations...."
Josephus described
it in a similar way to
that of Jesus, when He said: "such as was not from the beginning of
the
creation which God created unto this time, neither shall be." Mark
13:19.
This destruction
was
so complete that every
synagogue and every tombstone with a Jewish inscription was
destroyed,
leaving no sign that a single Jew had ever lived in Palestine.
"And except those
days should be shortened,
there should no flesh be saved: but for the elect's sake those
days
shall be shortened." Matthew 24:22, Mark 13:20.
Jesus prophesied
of
the destruction of
Jerusalem, in that generation, Matthew 23:36 and that the
temple
would not be left one stone upon another that
would not be
thrown down, and that God's people were to flee
when they saw the city
surrounded with armies, and that if the days were not shortened, no
flesh would be
saved, but for the elect's sake, those days
were
shortened.
Luke continued,
"And
they shall fall by the
edge of the sword, and shall be led away captive into all nations:
[notice, they, not you] and Jerusalem shall be
trodden down of the
Gentiles, until the times of the Gentiles
be fulfilled." Luke 21:24.
Let me pose a
question. What race of
people on this earth has been led away captive and scattered into all
nations? Only the Jews have been so
completely dispersed, yet
retained their identity. This was not true of
the house of Israel (ten
northern tribes dispersed about 721, B.C. who melted into other
civilizations).
The first part of
Luke 21:24 was exactly
fulfilled between A.D. 66 and A.D. 73, as attested to by Josephus.
The
Romans completely destroyed Jerusalem and the temple and an estimated
1,100,000 Jews died by the
edge of the sword, or by starvation, and
many were led away captive into all nations. Of the latter group,
some
of the recorded figures are: 2,130 at Joppa, 1200 at Jotapata, 6000
young men at Tarichea who were
sent to Nero, over 30,000 others sold or
given to Agrippa. Of the Gadarenes, 2200, Idumea, 1000, and
Josephus
says the total was about 97,000 who were taken captive.
Why Such Desolation?
We can readily see
that the prophesied
desolation of Jerusalem, which Jesus called "great tribulation,"
was completely fulfilled in explicit
detail through the events
which occurred in the forty years following His
ministry. But why would
God bring such desolation upon a nation which He had chosen to be
His own?
Luke 19:44 tells us why this desolation occurred: "because you did not recognize the time of your visitation." NASB.
Just what does
that
mean? The Lord, God, in
order to redeem fallen man, sent His only begotten son to bring
the way
of salvation. After the prophets had prophesied of Jesus, the Jews,
instead of receiving Him, crucified
Him. He was too much of a threat to
them.
Jesus spoke before the multitudes and His disciples, saying: "woe to you scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites!"
Then, as recorded
in
Matthew 23, to the Jews,
He said: "Therefore, behold I am sending you prophets and
wise
men and scribes; some of them you will kill, and some of
them you will scourge in your synagogues, and
persecute from
city to city that upon you may fall the guilt of all the
righteous blood shed on earth, from the
blood of righteous Abel to the
blood of Zechariah, the son of Berechiah, whom you murdered between the
temple and the altar. Truly I say to you, all
these things shall come
upon this generation.
"O Jerusalem,
Jerusalem, who kills
the prophets and stones those who are sent to her! How often I
wanted
to gather your children together, the way a hen gathers her
chicks under her wings, and you
were unwilling. Behold your
house is being left to you desolate!" Matthew 23:34-38, NASB.1
R. V. G. Tasker,
in THE
TYNDALE NEW
TESTAMENT COMMENTARIES, 1st Ed., 1961, Matthew,
pp. 218-219, makes
this statement about the desolation of Jerusalem: "This terrible
prophecy of Jesus
[Matthew 23:37-39] was uttered in no spirit of
vindictiveness, but, as the most moving lament over
Jerusalem bears
eloquent testimony, was truth spoken in love . . . and He recalled the
numerous occasions
when He would have sheltered them, if only
they had
been willing, from the wrath that was coming upon
them in the onslaught
of the Roman legions . . ." On page 222 we read: "The blood of innocent
men that is
to be unjustly shed by the death of the
Messiah and His
servants will make it possible for the destruction of
Jerusalem in A.D.
70 to be in effect a judgment upon the murderers of all God's servants
whose deaths are
recorded in the canonical Scriptures."
The exceeding
wickedness of the Jews
is shown through the historical and Biblical records of the lives and
deaths of the followers of Jesus. Among those
who were brutally
murdered were Stephen, James, Andrew,
Peter, Paul, Simon the Canaanite,
James son of Zebedee, Bartholomew, Thomas, Matthew, James son of
Alphaeus, Jude Thaddeus, John Mark, Barnabus,
Matthias, Luke and Jesus.
The Bible records the stoning of Stephen Acts Chapters 6 & 7.
Acts 6:8, "And
Stephen, full of grace and
power, was performing great wonders and signs among the people.
9. But some men from what was called the Synagogue
of the Freedmen, including both Cyrenians and
Alexandrians, and some
from Cilicia and Asia, rose up and argued with Stephen.
10. And yet they were unable to cope with the
wisdom and the Spirit with which he was speaking. 11. Then
they
secretly induced men to say, "We have heard him speak blasphemous
words against Moses and God."
12. And they stirred up the people,
the elders and the scribes, and they came upon him and dragged
him
away, and brought him before the
Council.
13. And they put forward FALSE witnesses
who said, "This man incessantly speaks against this holy place,
and the
Law;
14. for we have heard him say that this
Nazarene, Jesus, will destroy this place and alter the customs which
Moses handed down to us."
Acts 7:58. And
when
they had driven him out
of the city, they began stoning him, and the witnesses laid
aside their robes at the feet of a young man
named Saul.
59. And they went on stoning Stephen
as he called upon the Lord and said, "Lord Jesus, receive my spirit!"
60. And falling on his knees, he cried out
with a loud voice, "Lord, do not hold this sin against them!" And
having said this, he fell asleep.
History
tells
us that James, the just, was thrown down from the pinnacle of the temple,
and it did not kill
him, so they finished him off with a fuller's
club.2
In Luke 21:12,
Jesus
warned His disciples
that the Jews would persecute and scourge them
in their
synagogues. You can also see this in Matthew
24:9.
The Jews
persecuted
many followers of
Jesus, including Peter and Paul, from city to city (1 Thessalonians
2:15).3
All this, Jesus said, would occur that the guilt of all the blood of
the righteous from Abel to that day
would fall upon those Jews, and it
would all come upon that generation. And indeed, it did.
That generation of Jews, Josephus said, was the "most ungodly generation to live on the earth."
Paul said, "For
you,
brethren, became
imitators of the churches of God in Christ Jesus that are in Judea,
for
you also endured the same sufferingsat the hands of your
own countrymen, even as they did from
the Jews, who both
killed the Lord and the prophets, and drove us out. They are
not pleasing to
God, but hostile to all men, hindering
us from
speaking to the Gentiles that they might be saved; with the
result that
they always fill up the measure of their sins. But wrath has come upon
them to the uttermost."
1 Thessalonians 2:14-16, NASB.
It is also
interesting that Paul credited
the Jews with the death of Jesus, when most people
today are
persuaded that the Romans were
responsible for
killing Him. Perhaps the Roman soldiers nailed Him to
the cross, but it
was at the insistence of the Jews who shouted "crucify Him!"
The prophecy
of
Jesus that the Jews
would kill the prophets, scourge some of them in their synagogues
and
persecute some of them from city to city was fulfilled over and over in
the book of Acts. Let's look at
some of those scriptures:
Acts 9:29, "And he
was talking and arguing
with the Hellenistic Jews; but they were attempting to put
him to death."
Acts 10:39, "And
we
are witnesses of all
the things He did both in the land of the Jews and in Jersalem,
And they also put Him to death by
hanging Him on a cross."
Acts 14:2, "But
the Jews
who
disbelieved stirred up the minds of the Gentiles, and embittered
them
against the brethren." 19. But Jews
came from Antioch
and Iconium, and having won over the multitudes,
they stoned Paul
and dragged him out of the city, supposing him to be dead."
Acts 17:1, "Now
when
they had traveled
through Amphipolis and Apollonia, they came to Thessalonica,
where
there was a synagogue of the Jews. 2. And according to Paul's
custom, he went to them, and for
three Sabbaths reasoned with them from
the Scriptures."
5. But the Jews, becoming jealous
and taking along some wicked men from the market place, formed
a
mob and set the city in an uproar; and
coming upon the house of
Jason, they were seeking to bring them
out to the people.
13. But when the Jews of Thessalonica
found out that the word of God had been proclaimed by Paul in
Berea
also, they came there likewise, agitating and stirring up the crowds.
Acts 20:3, "And
there he spent three
months, and when a plot was formed against him by the Jews
as
he was about to set sail for Syria, he
determined to return through
Macedonia."
19. "serving the Lord with all humility and
with tears and with trials which came upon me through the
plots of
the Jews.
Acts 21:27, "And
when the seven days were
almost over, the Jews from Asia, upon seeing him in the
temple, began to stir up all the multitude
and laid hands on him,
28. crying out, "Men of Israel, come to
our aid! This is the man who
preaches to all men everywhere against our people, and the Law , and
this
place; and besides he has even brought Greeks
into the temple and
has defiled this holy place."
Acts 23:12, "And
when it was day, the Jewsformed
a conspiracy and bound themselves under an oath,
saying that they
would neither eat nor drink until they had killed Paul."
Acts 24:9, "And the Jews also joined in the attack asserting that these things were so."
Acts 25:2,"And the
chief priests and the
leading men of the Jewsbrought charges against Paul; and
they
were urging him, 3. requesting a concession
against Paul. . ."15.
"and when I was at Jerusalem, the chief
priests and the elders of the Jewsbrought
charges agains him, asking for a sentence of condemnationupon
him."
24. "And Festus said, "King Agrippa, and all you gentlemen here present
with us, you behold this
man about whom all the people of the Jews
appealed to me, both a Jerusalem and here, loudly declaring
that he
ought not to live any longer."
Acts 26:2, "In
regard to all the things of
which I am accused by the Jews. . ."21. "For this
reason some
Jews seized me in the temple and
tried to put me
to death."
Is it any wonder that God destroyed those wretches?
No Great Surprise
It should come as
no
great surprise that
God spent His wrath on the Jews of that time. He had foretold it
through His prophets, and Jesus had made it
perfectly clear as well.
The prophet
Jeremiah
wrote numerous times
of the coming of the first desolation of Jerusalem: "For thus
hath the
Lord said, The whole land shall be desolate; yet I will not make a full
end.. For this shall the earth
mourn, and the heavens above be black:
because I have spoken it, I have purposed, and will not repent
neither will I turn back from it." Jeremiah
4:27-28.
Although this
prophecy concerned the first
destruction of the temple and the city, the fact of its fulfillment
indicates that God would do that which He
foretold. Therefore, we
should not be surprised that He did it
again. God caused the temple and
city to be destroyed twice because of the wickedness of the people. The
second destruction was prophesied in Daniel
9:26. Many people have
overlooked this prophecy.
Warning
Jesus gave
the Jews plenty
of warning about the impending doom of Jerusalem and the temple.
It was
the subject of several
of His parables.
Luke 19:12-28, He
said therefore, "A
certain nobleman went to a distant country to receive a kingdom for
himself, and then return. 13. "And he
called ten of his slaves,
and gave them ten minas, and said to them,
'Do business with this
until I come back.' 14. "But his citizens hated him, and sent a
delegation after him,
saying, 'We do not want this man to
reign
over us.' 15. "And it came about that when he returned,
after
receiving the kingdom, he ordered that these slaves, to whom he had
given the money, be called to
him in order that he might know what
business they had done. 16. "And the first appeared, saying,
"Master,
your mina has made ten minas more.' 17. "And he said to him, 'Well
done, good slave, because you
have been faithful in a very little
thing, be in authority over ten cities.' 18. "And the second came,
saying,
'Your mina, master, has made five minas.' 19.
"And he said to
him also, 'And you are to be over five cities.'
20. "And another fame,
saying, 'Master, behold your mina, which I kept put away in a
handkerchief; 12 for
I was afraid of you, because you are an
exacting
man; you take up what you did not lay down, and reap
what you did not
sow.' 22. He said to him, 'By your own words I will judge you, you
worthless slave. Did
you know that I am an exacting man, taking up
what
I did not lay down, and reaping what I did not sow?
23. 'Then why did
you not put the money in the bank, and having come, I would have
collected it with
interest?' 24. "And he said to the bystanders,
'Take
the mina away from him, and give it to the one who
has the ten minas."
25. "And they said to him, 'Master, he has ten minas already."
26. "I tell you, that
to everyone who has shall more be given, but
from
the one who does not have, even what he does have
shall be taken away.
27. "But these enemies of mine, who did not want me to reign over
them,
bring them here, and slay them in my
presence."
Matthew
21:33-45 "Listen to another
parable. There was a landowner who planted a vineyard.and put
a
wall around it and dug a wine press in it, and built a tower, and
rented it out to vine-growers, and went
on a journey. 34. "And when the
harvest time approached, he sent his slaves to the vine-growers to
receive
his produce. 35. "And the vine-growers took
his slaves and beat
one, and killed another, and stoned a third.
36. "Again he sent another
group of slaves larger than the first; and they did the same thing to
them. 37.
"But afterward he sent his son
to them,
saying, 'They will respect my son.' 38. "But when the vine-growers
saw
the son, they said among themselves, 'This is the heir; come, let us
kill him, and seize his inheritance.'
39. "And they took him, and cast
him out of the vineyard, and killed him. 40.
"Therefore when the owner
of the vineyard comes, what will he do to
those vine-growers?" 41. They said to Him, "He will bring those
wretches to a wretched end, and
will rent out the vineyard to
other vine-growers, who will pay him the
proceeds at the proper
seasons." (Luke 20:16, "He will come and destroy
these vine-growers. . .")
42. Jesus said to them, "Did you never
read in the Scriptures,
'THE STONE
WHICH THE BUILDERS REJECTED,
THIS BECAME
THE CHIEF CORNERSTONE;
THIS CAME
ABOUT FROM THE LORD,
AND IT IS
MARVELOUS IN OUR EYES'?
43. "Therefore I say to you, the kingdom
of God will be taken away from you, and be given to a nation
producing
the fruit of it. 44. "And he who falls on this stone whill be
broken to pieces; but on whomever it
falls, it will scatter him like
dust." 45. And when the chief priests and the Pharisees heard
His parables,
they understood that He was speaking
about them.
46. And when they sought to seize Him, they
became afraid of the
mulitudes, because they held Him to be a prophet.
Matthew 22:1-7
"And
Jesus answered and
spoke to them again in parables, saying, 2. "The kingdom of
heaven
may be compared to a king, who gave a wedding feast for his son.
3. "And he sent out his slaves
to call those who had been invited to
the wedding feast, and they were unwilling to come. 4.
"Again he
sent out other slaves saying, 'Tell those who
have been
invited, "Behold, I have prepared my dinner; my
oxen and my fattened
livestock are all butchered and everything is ready; come to
the wedding feast."'
5. "But they paid no attention and went
their
way, one to his own farm, another to his business, 6. and the
rest
seized his servants [the prophets] and mistreated them and killed
them. 7. "But the king was
enraged and sent his armies,
and destroyed those murderers, and set their city on fire."
Luke 19:41-44, And
when He approached, He
saw the city and wept over it., 42. saying, "If you had known
in this
day, even you, the things which make for peace! But now they have been
hidden from your eyes.
43. "For the days shall come upon you when your
enemies will throw up a bankbefore you, and surround
you, and
hem you in on every side. 44."and will level you to the
ground and your children within you, and
they will not leave in you one
stone upon another, because you did not recognize the time of
your visitation."
Clay in the Potter's Hand
In Jeremiah,
chapter
18, there is a
principle which God gave through the prophet, which enlightens us as to
how God deals with mankind. "O house of
Israel, cannot I do with you as
this potter? saith the LORD.
Behold, as the clay is in the potter's
hand, so are ye in mine hand, o house of Israel. At what instant I
shall
speak concerning a nation, and concerning a
kingdom, to pluck up,
and to pull down, and to destroy it; If that
nation, against whom I
have pronounced, turn from their evil, I will repent of the evil that I
thought to do
unto them. And at what instant I shall speak
concerning a
nation, and concerning a kingdom, to build and to
plant it; If it do
evil in my sight, that it obey not my voice, then I will repent of the
good, wherewith I said I
would benefit them. Now therefore go to, speak
to the men of Judah, and to the inhabitants of Jerusalem,
saying thus
saith the LORD; Behold, I frame evil against you, and devise a device
against you: return ye now
every one from his evil way, and make your
ways and your doings good. And they said, There is no hope: but
we will
walk after our own devices, and we will every one do the imagination of
his evil heart." Jeremiah 18:6-12.
God made it very
clear, through Jeremiah,
exactly what Israel could expect from Him. In Jeremiah 18:17,
God said
that He would scatter Israel before their enemy. "Because my people
hath forgotten me..."
Jeremiah 18:15.
So if Israel had
followed God, He would
have preserved and blessed them, but because they chose their own
way,
He destroyed and scattered them.
This, of course,
again spoke of the first
destruction of Jerusalem, but it shows the principle by which God dealt
with the Jews in the latter desolation as well.
In the forty years
from the death of Jesus
to the desolation of Jerusalem and the temple, God gave the Jews
ample
opportunity to receive the gospel, repent and accept Jesus, the
Messiah, but they refused (except for
a few who believed and repented).
So God was not free to change His mind concerning the calamity that He
had pronounced upon them through Jesus and the
prophets.
Because of the
principle in Jeremiah
chapter 18, in which God responds according to man's obedience to
Him,
many of the prophecies made in the Old Testament, concerning God's
promises to natural Israel, have
not, and will never come to pass. They
were conditional upon Israel's obedience. God has shown us through
their example that He will bring calamity upon
disobedient people when
they continually refuse to be
corrected and to repent and turn from
their evil ways. He will also bring blessing upon those who walk
according to His statutes.
As we have gone, verse by verse, through the Olivet discourse, we can now see the fulfillments more clearly.
The exactness of
these predictions of our
Lord Jesus confirm again in our hearts that He was indeed the
Christ,
the Son of God. Every word which He spoke has been, or shall be,
literally fulfilled. Jesus said:
"Heaven and earth will pass away, but
My words will not pass away." Mark 13:31.
Since the time
when
Jesus spoke the
prophesies recorded in Matthew 24, Mark 13 and Luke 21, the only
period of tribulation in recorded history,
which dealt with the Jews,
that could possibly be the fulfillment
of Luke 21:20-24, was that
destruction of Jerusalem in A. D. 70. No other such period has included
all the
specific predictions of time-table, location,
severity, exact
sequence, etc., as did that desolation.
After the A. D. 70
destruction, the city of
Jerusalem was not under Jewish control again until A. D. 132.
This was
only for a brief period of about three years, during the reign of Roman
emperor Hadrian.
At that time,
there
was a man named Simon,
called Bar-Cocheba (Bar-Kochba), whom the Jews proclaimed
and supported
as their long-awaited "Messiah."
Simon led the
insurrection, achieving
independence for Jerusalem, which apparently lasted until A. D.
135
(history is not complete concerning this).
The finds near the
Dead Sea in 1951-52
included two letters from a "Simon ben Koseba" who could have
been one
and the same as "Simon Bar Cocheba" (a name given him by a Scribe,
based on Numbers 14:17,
believing that he was the Messiah). Bar
Cocheba
means: "son of the star."
Simon ruled at
Jerusalem for three years,
as indicated by the so called "insurrection coins" minted with
Hebrew
inscriptions. These numbered "year 1" and "year 2," and dated from the
"liberation" of Israel.
This numbering shows that the Jews thought it
the beginning of a new era under their "Messiah." The
coins proclaimed
him "Simon, the Prince of Israel."
This movement was
finally crushed by Roman
general Julius Severus, governor of Britannia, and Simon
Bar-Cocheba
was killed about A. D. 135. The spelling of his name was then perverted
by the Rabbis to
"Simon Bar-Kosiba" (son of lies).
After this time,
the
area known as Judea,
now called "Palestine," (land of Philistines) became a Roman
Province.
Jews were forbidden to enter on pain of death. Its population was by
then heathen.4
Since the A. D. 70
destruction, the temple
in Jerusalem has never been rebuilt. It, therefore, could not
be destroyed again. For this reason, the
destruction of A. D. 132-135
must be totally ruled out as a
possible fulfillment of the "great
tribulation" prophesied by Jesus. The temple destruction was to
be a major part of that fulfillment.
From the
crucifixion
of Christ, to this
day, the Jews have been visited by calamity and persecution.
They had
invoked upon their race the most far-reaching indictment that man could
ever conceive.
They said of the Christ, "Let His blood be
upon our
heads and upon our children." Matthew 27:25.
There is only one
hope for the Jew, and
that is the same hope that exists for any man; to call upon the
name of
the Lord Jesus Christ, accepting His forgiveness and salvation, and
being taken from under
this self-appointed curse.
Sufficient Evidence
If we stopped at
this point, we would have
given sufficient evidence to establish that the "great
tribulation" of Matthew 24 is
past history; that the events of
A. D. 70 did, indeed, fulfill all that
Jesus prophesied concerning the "great
tribulation."
At this point, we
press into some other
areas of events which were to happen after the tribulation
of
those days. They do not make or break our case for the already past
fulfillment of the "great
tribulation," but do, by the very
fact of their occurrence, support our belief that the "great
tribulation" is past.
These chapters
will
help us to better
understand Bible prophecy. The possibility of more than one
fulfillment
of some of them is not precluded by Scripture, however, only one
fulfillment is necessary to
establish the authenticity of a prophecy.
Now let us talk about what happens after
the tribulation.
There seems to be
a
period of time, during
and possibly after the "great tribulation," which transpires between
verses 24 and 25 of Luke 21. This we will talk
about in the Chapter on
"The Times of the Gentiles."
For the time immediately after the "great tribulation," Jesus gave the following warning:
"Then if any man
shall say unto you, Lo,
here is Christ, or there: believe it not. For there shall arise false
Christs, and false prophets and shall show
great signs and wonders;
insomuch that, if it were possible, they
shall deceive the very elect.
Behold I have told you [disciples] before. Wherefore if they say unto
you, Behold,
He is in the desert; go not forth: Behold, He
is in the
secret chambers; believe it not. For as the lightning
cometh out of the
east; and shineth even unto the west; so shall the coming [presence] of
the Son of man be.
For wheresoever the carcase is, there will the
eagles be gathered together." Matthew 24:23-28, Mark 13:21-23.1
It is important to
understand that these
false Christs and false prophets arise after that "great
tribulation." What implication does
this have for those who hold
the pre-tribulational rapture theory?
If the elect are raptured to
heaven as they believe, how can they be on earth to be deceived?
In the Olivet
discourse, Jesus specifically warned His disciples to not believe
these false Christs and false
prophets. He was speaking of
events that would occur in the years following A. D. 70.
History records numerous examples of false gods and false Christs. Justin, the martyr, wrote:
'One Samaritan,
Simon, from a village
called Gitthon, performed wonders of magic by the art of the demons
who
possessed him. He did this in your imperial city of Rome during the
reign of Claudius Caesar. He was looked
upon as a god, and like a god
was honored among you by a statue placed on the Tiber River between the
two
bridges and bearing this Latin inscription:
simoni deo sancto,
which means, "to Simon the holy god."'2
According to
Eusebius, Hegesippus, in a
letter, wrote: "The church was still called a virgin, for it had not
yet
been corrupted by false tidings. But
Thebouthis, because he had
failed to become a bishop, was first to begin
its corruption among the
people by means of the seven heresies, to which he belonged. From these
sects
came Simon, whence arose the Simonians;
Cleobius, from which came
the Cleobians; Dositheus, whose
followers were Dosithians; and
Gorthaeus, founder of the Gorthenians and Masbothians. From these came
the Menandrians, the Marcianists, the
Carpocratians, the Valentinians,
the Basilidians, and the Saturnilians.
In their own way by different
means, each proclaimed its own doctrine. From them came false Christs,
false
prophets, false apostles who, against God and
His Christ, split
the unity of the church with their words of
destruction. . ."3
This type of deception continues to this day.
Elect Deceived
When Jesus warned
His disciples about false
Christs and false prophets to come after the tribulation,
He
said they would deceive, if possible, the very elect. He was not
speaking of the unbelieving Jews as elect,
because they were to be
destroyed in His vengeance. It would indeed be shocking if Jesus
brought
vengeance upon the very elect of God!
The natural Jews
were broken off (Romans
11:17-24) because of their unbelief, and a new covenant
brought
a new "elect," the church. This new covenant was
established by grace through faith in the
Lord Jesus Christ, whom most
Jews rejected. Those who did receive Him and were the first Christians,
and numerous ones thereafter, were numbered
among the "elect," because
they were grafted in again and
became a part of His church, in which
there is no distinction between Jew and Greek, bond and free, male
and
female. All are one in Christ Jesus (Colossians 3:11-12).
Those under the
new
covenant of salvation
by grace through faith make up the "elect" spoken of by Jesus,
and they
are those whom He warned of the desolation to come. Jesus said to
the unbelieving Jews: "you are
not my sheep." John 10:26. He
called them "this evil generation," Matthew 12:45, and told
them:
"The kingdom shall be taken away from you and
given to a nation
producing the fruit of it:" Matthew 21:43.
The clear meaning
of
Matthew 24:28 is not
obvious: "For wheresoever the carcase is, there will the eagles
be
gathered together." Perhaps it refers to the prophecy of Jeremiah: "And
the carcases of this people shall
be meat for the fowls of heaven, and
for the beasts of the earth; and none shall fray them away."
Jeremiah
7:33-34. The words "fowls of heaven" could refer to eagles or vultures.
The Roman eagles,
which were the standards
of the Roman army could be referred to here as they were
gathered where
the dead bodies of the Jews were.
"For as lightning,
that lighteneth out of
the one part under heaven, shineth unto the other part under
heaven; so
shall also the Son of man be in his day. But first must he
suffer many things and be rejected of
this generation." Luke
17:24-25.
Signs After the Tribulation
What signs did
Jesus
foretell after the
"great tribulation?" Matthew 24:29 begins: "Immediately after
the
tribulation of those days..." Mark says: "but in those days, after
that tribulation, the sun shall be
darkened and the moon shall not
give her light, and the stars of the heaven shall fall, and the powers
that
are in heaven shall be shaken." Mark 13:24.
Luke also spoke of
signs in the sun, moon and stars in Luke 21:15.
The word
"immediately," used in Matthew
24:29, has caused a lot of difficulty for those who believe that
the
great tribulation was fulfilled in A. D. 70. It is probably the main
reason that many people believed that
the great tribulation will be
repeated. But we know that Scripture precludes that, so we must deal
with the
word "immediately." There is, what I believe
to be, a
plausible explanation for these signs in the sky which
Jesus
prophesied. Bear in mind that everything after Luke 21:24 occurs "after
the great tribulation."
Fulfillments of Prophecy
First, let us talk
about prophecy.
Fulfillments of prophecy were not always easy to recognize. When Jesus
said that John the baptist was the fulfillment
of the prophecy that
Elijah would come, it was not at all clear
to His disciples. John (the
baptist), himself, had stated that he was not Elijah, yet Jesus said
that he fulfilled
the prophecy that Elijah would come before the
great
and dreadful day of the Lord. (Malachi 4:5). The
explanation, which
makes this fulfillment about Elijah come clear, is found in Luke
1:13-17. It tells of an
angelic visitation to Zacharias, father of
John
(the baptist). As recorded in verse 17, the angel said: "And
he shall
go before Him in the spirit and power of Elias [Greek equivalent of
Elijah], to turn the hearts of the
fathers to the children...." This
even quotes some of the words of Malachi 4:6.
We can see that there is sufficient Scripture to establish that John did fulfill the prophecy of Elijah.
In some instance,
it
took very little to
fulfill a prophecy. In Luke 22:36, Jesus said, ". . . and he that hath
no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy
one." That was to fulfill
the Scripture that Jesus would be
reckoned among criminals. It sounded
as if every one of them would have to buy a sword, but in verse 38,
they said, ". . . Lord, behold, here are two
swords." And He said unto
them, "It is enough." Not much was
required to adequately fulfill the
prophecy.
Perhaps we are looking for too spectacular a display in the heavens to fulfill the prophecy of Matthew 24:29.
The Jews did not
recognize Jesus as their
long awaited Messiah, in spite of the vast number of old testament
prophecies which were fulfilled by His life.
Could we be lacking in our
understanding of Bible prophecy as well?
"Men's hearts failing them for fear, and for looking after those things which are coming on the earth
Stars Falling
The closest star
to
the earth, excluding
our own sun, is 4.3 light-years from the earth. It is called Proxima
Centauri, and it takes its light 4.3 years
to
reach us. If it were
possible for this star to travel at the speed of
light, 186,282 miles
per second, it would take it 4.3 years to reach earth. Such a speed is
unheard of. If
Proxima Centauri ceased to emit its light,
it
would be
4.3 years before we would know it. That's the closest
one. The average
distance between stars in the Milky Way is four to five light-years.
The farthest star is said to be billions of light-years away. Its light takes billions of years to reach the earth.
What would happen
if
a star really fell
to
earth? The smallest star is 5,200 miles in diameter, compared to
the
earth's diameter of 7,930 miles at the equator. If such a star fell
upon the earth, it would take only one
to destroy the entire earth. The
earth's atmosphere would not be sufficient to cause it to burn up,
because of
its enormous size. Further, if such a
phenomenon began to
occur, there would be an indication of its
movement long before its
actual arrival, because its light would travel faster than the star
itself. As it
approached earth, it would be like another
sun.
Since stars are
nuclear fusion and
radiate
tremendous heat (millions of degrees) and ultra violet and X-rays,
it
would never reach the earth before all forms of life on this planet
ceased to exist.
Stars, even when
they die, do not fall
from
the sky. Aside from "proper motion," which is almost
undetectable, they
are stationary.
What we usually
refer to as falling stars
are actually meteors. When they fall into the earth's atmosphere,
at
about sixty-five miles up, the friction of the air causes them to heat
up to about 4000 degrees and
glow brightly, giving the appearance of a
shooting or falling star. They must be in the earth's atmosphere
to be
visible. There have been meteor showers upon the earth from the
earliest times. They occur so
frequently that, to be a real indicator
of prophetic fulfillment, it would necessitate a rather spectacular
display to distinguish it from so many
previous occurrences.
The most
significant
meteor shower on
record was on November 13, 1833. This vast group of meteors is
called
the Leonid meteor shower, and the earth comes in contact with it each
November. The November
13, l833 encounter was with the most dense
portion of this group. Many who saw this meteor shower were
convinced
that it was the time of the second coming of Jesus. They were,
unfortunately, misinformed.
Could it be that we have misunderstood what "stars falling" from the sky really indicates?
If we can call
meteors "falling stars,"
then it is also possible that brightly glowing cinders from a volcano
could represent stars as they fall from
being
spewed high into the sky.
To someone totally unaccustomed to
such a phenomenon, it would seem as
if stars were falling. In this age, with knowledge increased, we would
not think so, but in those days, it could
have
been.
Luke wrote: ". . .
and Jerusalem shall be
trodden down of the nations [gentiles] until the seasons of the nations
(and they shall be) are fulfilled. And signs
shall be in sun and moon
and stars; and upon the earth distress of
nations, in perplexity for
the roaring of sea and billow; men fainting for fear, and expectation
of the things
coming on the inhabited earth [Roman
Empire].
Luke
21:24-26, NENT.
What could cause
the
seas to act in such
a
violent manner, and sufficiently fulfill this prophecy? Did such an
event occur after A. D. 70?
Volcanic tremors
in
the ocean stir up
waves, today called "tsunamis." They often reach tidal wave proportion.
So a volcanic eruption of sufficient
proportion could actually fulfill
all five signs.
A volcanic
eruption
could also fulfill
the
Scripture in Acts which says: "and I will grant wonders in the sky
above and signs on the earth beneath, blood
and fire, and vapor of
smoke. The sun shall be turned into
darkness and the moon into blood,
before the great and glorious day of the Lord shall come." Acts
2:19-20,
NASB. Notice that this is before the
great
and glorious day,
not before the great and terrible day of the
Lord. I
believe the great and terrible day of the Lord was the destruction of
Jerusalem in A. D. 70.
The obstruction of
the atmosphere caused
by
smoke and ashes from a volcano can filter the light from the sun
so
that when the light reaches the moon, it appears very red. This was
seen in recent years in the eruption of
Mt. St. Helens in Washington
state.
An erupting
volcano
may also cause
earthquakes. But was there such a volcanic eruption in that region at
that time?
Let me tell you of
a
possible fulfillment
of all these signs which occurred in A. D. 79, in the proper location,
right from the pages of history, immediately
after that tribulation of
those days, and you decide if it could be
the actual
fulfillment of the prophecies of Jesus.
Mt. Vesuvius
On August 24, A.
D.
79, Mt. Vesuvius in
Italy erupted, after centuries of being dormant. It had caused
earthquakes almost continuously since A. D.
63, seven years prior to
the desolation of Jerusalem [see
Matthew 24:7-8].
It was not too
distant from Rome, where
many of the survivors of the destruction of Jerusalem had been
taken.
There is an
account
in secular history,
by
Pliny, the younger, available in most libraries, which describes
this
eruption in detail. It appears to be exactly what Jesus foretold. The
timing of its eruption is not
coincidental.
The sun and moon
were obliterated from
sight, and it was the blackest of days and nights. Jesus said there
would be signs in the heavens [sky] and
distress upon the earth, but He
did not say that the earth would be
destroyed at that time. These signs
occurred after the tribulation of A. D. 70.
According to
Pliny's
account, men's
hearts
failed for fear and the waves (tsunamis) of the sea were great and
very
destructive. He described the beginning of the eruption as looking like
a tall pine tree. The cloud was
filled with cinders which made it
spotted with what would appear to be stars, falling in all directions.
Compare
that to this Scripture: "And the stars of
heaven [the sky] fell
unto the earth, even as a fig tree casteth her
untimely figs, when she
is shaken of a mighty wind." Revelation 6:13.
The sea seemed to roll back upon itself, the shore was enlarged and several dead sea-animals were left on it.
The greater part
of
the people imagined
that the last and eternal night was come, which was to destroy the
[pagan] gods and the world together. Pliny
stated in a letter: "I
imagined that I was perishing with the world
itself."
In a more recent
eruption of Vesuvius, in
472, ashes and smoke were carried by winds as far as Constantinople
(Istanbul), fifteen hundred miles distant.
In
1631 there was another
eruption in which streams of lava and
boiling water fell on the
villages beneath it, killing 18,000 people. It is reasonable to assume
that the A.D. 79
eruption was at least as widespread as the
472
and
1631 eruptions, after such a long dormant period (400
years). The
pressure that was necessary to blow the top off the mountain would have
had tremendous force.5
I would not be so
dogmatic as to say that
the eruption of Mt. Vesuvius was absolutely the only possible
fulfillment of the heavenly disturbances,
because Scripture does not
specifically preclude the recurrence of such
signs as it precludes the
recurrence of the "great tribulation." And perhaps these signs
could appear again,
but it is quite likely that Jesus was
announcing
the exact events which I have enumerated, since all the other
parts of
the prophecy were of a local nature, and were for that generation.
The first
converts to
Christianity
were Jews. So the gospel was not taken away, nor withheld from them, it
actually went to them first; but the
old covenant was made obsolete and
a new covenant was instituted
(Hebrews 8:13).
The old
covenant was based upon
ordinances and animal sacrifices, and the new covenant is based upon
salvation by grace through faith in
Jesus, the Christ; Jesus Himself
being the permanent sacrifice for all men,
for all times.
Unbalanced View of the Jews
Some
people
literally hate all
Jews, committing violent, anti-Semitic acts against them. On the other
hand,
because of the teaching of some of
our
church leaders, many
Christians stand in awe of the Jews, "God's
chosen people." In my opinion, both
views
are unbalanced, or extreme.
The fact
is,
that the majority of
the Jews rejected Jesus and the prophets, and God cut them off. He
considers
them to be dead. "For if the casting
away of them be
the reconciling of the world, what shall the receiving of them
be,
but life from the dead?" Romans 11:15.
"As
regards
indeed the glad
tidings
(gospel), [they are] enemies on your account; but as regards the
election,
beloved on account of the fathers.
For
not to be repented of
are the gifts and the calling of God."
Romans 11:28-29, BINT.
In other
words, the Jews are
enemies of those who are preaching the gospel, but if they will repent
and accept it,
God will welcome them in again,
through Jesus as their
Savior.
No Respecter of Persons
The Bible
tells us that God is no
respecter of persons. Gentiles who do not know Christ are also
considered,
just as the Jews, to be dead.
"Let not sin
therefore reign in your mortal body, that ye should obey it in the lust
thereof. Neither yield ye your
members
as instruments of
unrighteousness unto sin: but yield yourselves unto God,
as those that
are alive from the dead..." Romans 6:12-13.
Here
again,
all are equal who do
not know Christ, equally lost in their sins, and all are equal who do
know Him,
and have their names written in the
Lamb's book of life.
"...even
when we were dead
in our transgressions, made us alive together with Christ." Ephesians
2:5, NASB.
Everyone regardless of race or
nationality, is spiritually
"dead" until they accept the atonement of Jesus Christ.
God did
not
cast the Jews off
totally, but left a remnant which He did not destroy, kept by election
of grace
(Romans 11:5-7). So a balanced view
of
the Jews is to consider
them to be equal with all other people. They, like
gentiles, must come
to salvation by grace through faith in Jesus Christ as their Savior to
be grafted in again
(Romans 11). Jews who accept Jesus
as
their Savior
are call "Christians," just like everyone else. The majority
of the
early Christians were converted Jews.
Apostle to the Gentiles
The reason
that Paul had so much
to
say about the "mystery," was that it was directly related to the
gentile
believers, and he was the Apostle
to the gentiles [in
the sense of masses (nations), not necessarily in the
sense of
"heathen"]. Almost every mention of the "mystery" has in it a
"gentile connection."
The gospel
(good news), which
Jesus
gave us was a gospel of salvation by grace through faith for all people
(nations, gentiles). All races, of
people may come into the kingdom of
God, through Jesus Christ our Lord, by
the new birth. Each man must
receive or reject it for himself until the harvest is full.
First to the Jews
As we have
seen, the gospel was
first preached to the Jews, and after they rejected it, it was taken to
the
gentiles. Because God foreordained
this
"mystery," which
would bring salvation to all who would accept it, it
is accurate to
state, that the gospel would have gone to the nations regardless of
what the Jews did in response
to Jesus, since it was not a taking
away
of anything from the Jews, but a bringing in of a better covenant both
for
them and adding to it, the nations.
This addition of the masses as
"fellow-heirs" to the kingdom is a part of the
"mystery," ordained from
the foundation of the earth.
The Mystery
This is one of the
most enlightening
chapters in this book. It contains a very clear explanation of the
"mystery" of God which we all need to
understand.
I recall reading a
book in which a
Christian writer detailed what he thought the mystery of God was all
about.
As I read, I became convinced that he had no
understanding
whatsoever of the "mystery," but I had to
confess that I,
myself, did not know what it meant, either. I began to seek the
Lord for a deeper understanding
of the "mystery," and as I
studied, it began to come clear.
Jesus had said:
"Because it is given
unto you to know the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven, but to
them
it is not given." Matthew 13:11, Mark
4:11. So let's
begin with a prophetic Scripture from Isaiah 42, and
unravel this
"mystery."
"Behold, My
Servant,
whom I uphold; My
Chosen One in whom My soul delights. I have put My Spirit upon
Him; He
will bring forth justice to the gentiles. He will not cry out or raise
His
voice, nor make His voice heard in the
street,
a bruised reed He
will not break, and a dimly burning wick He
will not extinguish; He
will faithfully bring forth justice. He will not be disheartened or
crushed, until He has
established justice in the earth; and the
coastlands will wait expectantly for His law." Isaiah 42:1-4, NASB.
Although this
Scripture does not mention
the word "mystery," it is a prophecy about that very
thing which
Paul called the "mystery" of Christ.
Isaiah said in
verse
one, "He will bring
forth justice." The word justice is the Hebrew word "mishpat,"
which
means a particular right or privilege. The
word which is rendered
"gentiles" is the Hebrew word "goy," which
can also be translated
"nations," in the sense of massing, or simply, the "masses." So
this verse literally says:
He will bring forth a particular right
or privilege to the masses. It then goes on to say
that He will
establish justice (right or privilege) in
the
earth; and
the coastlands will wait expectantly for His law (the
perfect law of
liberty, James 1:25).
The word
coastlands
or isles above is
from
a Hebrew word meaning literally: a habitable spot. Again, this
pointed
to the masses.
The Chosen One in
verse one is
obviously Jesus. What the "mystery" shows us is that Jesus came for the
specific purpose of making it
possible
for the masses
to obtain access to the kingdom of God: for the "gentiles"
to receive
the right or privilege of sonship. For this purpose, consider
the words "gentiles" and "masses" to
have the same meaning.
Old Covenant
God had
established
the old covenant
between Himself and a chosen race, Israel. If that covenant had
been
perfect, through the blood of animal
sacrifices, there
would have been no necessity for the Son of God, Jesus,
the Christ, to
have shed His innocent blood to redeem fallen man (Hebrews 8:7).
The fact is, that
the old covenant
was far from perfect, and was only a type of the new
covenant to follow.
The blood shed under the old covenant was
only
temporary, while the work of the blood of the perfect
sacrificed
Lamb, Jesus, is permanent. Jesus was the sacrificed Lamb slain
from the foundation of the world,
the focal point of God's
redemption of man.
Not only was the
old
covenant imperfect,
but one of its greatest shortcomings was that it excluded the majority
of mankind, the masses of the people
(gentiles) who were not of
the natural nation Israel.
God, in His
infinite
wisdom, established
a
plan from the beginning of this world, to destroy the works of the
devil.
This plan would be God's secret (a
mystery)
until the
proper time, then He would display it openly.
Why would God want to keep a secret? From whom would He hide His plans for man's redemption?
What is the Mystery?
The "Mystery"
is, that after
giving
Israel as a type of chosen people (in the flesh), God fulfilled His
original
plan which He foreordained before the ages
(in
the Spirit),
but which was kept hidden (secret) until the time of
Christ, and that
was salvation by grace through faith.
Now let us back
that
statement up with
plenty of Scripture. "For I would not, brethren, have you ignorant of
this mystery, lest you be wise in your own
conceits, that a hardening
in part has befallen [the] Israel, till what
time the fullness of the
nations [masses] be come in; and so [meaning: "in this way"],
all Israel shall be saved:
even as it is written." Romans 11:25, NASB. Bracketed information added by author.
That Scripture
tells
us how all
the
Israel of God [Abraham's seed and heirs according to promise, Galatians
3:29]
will be saved. In the Greek text, the first
word Israel
is preceded by the definite article, denoting a specific
people, and the second usage for all
Israel
does not use the
definite article. This is only a small "clue" which
Scripture bears out
to be true. It denotes another "Israel" of God, the church.
"Now to him that
is
of power to stablish
you according to my gospel, and the preaching of Jesus Christ,
according
to the revelation of the mystery,
which
was kept
secret [hidden] since the world began, But now is made
manifest,
and by the scriptures of the prophets, according to the commandment of
the everlasting God, made
known to all nations for the
obedience of faith: To God only wise, be glory through
Jesus Christ for ever.
Amen." Romans 16:25-27.
What a
power-packed
Scripture! The "mystery"
was hidden, though prophesied, then it was made manifest
according to
God's commandment, and it is made known unto all the nations [masses],
and it is the gospel of
Jesus Christ of salvation by grace
through
faith.
In I Corinthians,
Paul, writing to Greeks
(gentiles) said: "but we speak God's wisdom in a mystery, the hidden
wisdom which God foreordained before the
ages
unto our glory: which
none of the rulers of this age has known:
for had they known, they
would not have crucified the Lord of glory: but as it is written,
things which eye saw
not, and ear heard not, and entered not into
heart
of man, whatsoever things God prepared for them that love
Him." I
Corinthians 2:7-10, NENT. This speaks of salvation by grace through
faith.
God prepared
beforehand this salvation,
and
Jesus the Christ would bring it to all nations, and to do so, it was
necessary for Him to be slain as a sacrifice
to forever atone for man's
sins, once for all. If the rulers of that
age had known what
they were doing, they would not have killed Him. Therefore, God had to
keep it a
"mystery" until it was accomplished.
Only through the
death of a sinless man could redemption come. There
was only one
sinless man, Jesus.
"According to the
riches of His grace,
which He made to abound toward us in all wisdom and prudence, having
made known to us the mystery of His
will, according to His good
pleasure which He purposed in Him unto a
dispensation of the
fullness of the season, to sum up all in the Christ, those
upon the heavens, and those
upon the earth; in Him whom also we were
made a heritage, foreordained according to the purpose of Him
who worketh all things...." Ephesians
1:7-11,
NENT.
Again, there is
great substance in that
Scripture. It speaks of grace (by which we must be saved, through
faith)
and His good pleasure in making known to us
the
"mystery."
He purposed that the "mystery" would be
administered to us at
the appropriate time, and that all would be summed up in Christ. We
will see in the next
Scripture what that summing up means.
"Wherefore
remember,
that once you, the
nations [gentiles] in the flesh, who are called uncircumcision by what
is call circumcision in the flesh made by
hands; that ye were at that
season apart from Christ, alienated from
the commonwealth of Israel,
and strangers to the covenant of promise [Abrahamic covenant based on
faith],
having no hope and without God in the world.
But now in Christ
Jesus ye that once were far off are become nigh
in the blood of the
Christ. For He is our peace, who made both one, and break down the
middle wall of the
partition, having abolished in His flesh the
enmity,
the law of the commandments contained in ordinances; that
He might
create in Himself of the two [Israel and the nations], one
new man, making peace; and might reconcile
both in one body [the
church] to God through the cross, having slain the enmity thereby."
Ephesians 2:11-17, NENT.
Notice that there are several points presented here:
1. The gentiles were apart from Christ.
2. They were alienated from the commonwealth of Israel.
3. They were strangers to the covenant of promise, having no hope without God in the world.
Through His
sacrificial death, He
abolished
the law of commandments contained in ordinances, and broke down
the
wall of partition separating the nations from God and from the
commonwealth of Israel. He brought the
"masses" into the (Abrahamic)
covenant of promise.
So through Christ,
all nations are made
equal in God. And all must come through the blood of Christ. The
two
are made oneonly in Him. The
enmity (hatred,
hostility, animosity) between nations was slain and their
reconciliation came about through the His
sacrificial death on cross,
bringing a "new creation," (Galatians 6:15).
This new creation is made
up of people from all nations on the face of the earth, but
only includes those
persons who come through Christ Jesus. For
those
who have not accepted Jesus, the hostility remains.
"And He came and
preached peace to you
which were afar off, and to them that were nigh. For through him we
both have access by one Spirit unto the
Father." Ephesians 2:17-18.
A New Temple
The access is
through Christ. Both
are equal through Him! "Now therefore ye are no more strangers
and
foreigners, but fellow citizens with the
saints, and of the
household of God; And are built upon the foundation of
the apostles and
prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner stone; In
whom all the building fitly
framed together groweth unto an holy temple
in the Lord: In whom ye also are builded together for an
habitation
of God through the Spirit. Ephesians 2:19-22.
This is no natural
covenant as was the
old
covenant, but it is in the Spirit, through faith in the Christ,
likewise,
this temple is no natural temple, but it is
the
church,
His body, and the only temple that the Bible predicts will
be
built. The old covenant was centered around the old temple buildings
with its altars and animal sacrifices,
with strict ordinances which no
one could fully keep. The new covenant is centered upon Christ,
and His Spirit
inhabits a collective temple, not made with
hands, the
hearts of men, making up His body, the church. This body
needs no
natural temple building or altars, because Jesus became the sacrifice
forever for all who receive Him.
This breaking down
of the middle wall of
partition, then, is not to make unbelieving Jews one with Christians,
or gentiles as to that matter, but both
groups
must come through the
blood of Jesus to become one in Him.
Jesus did the work, but we must
receive it for it to be effective in our lives.
"For this cause I
Paul, the prisoner of
the
Christ Jesus, in behalf of you nations [gentiles], if so that
you
have heard of the dispensation of the grace
of
God given me toward
you; how that by revelation was made
known to me the mystery, as
I wrote afore in few words, whereby when you read, you can perceive my
understanding in the mystery of the Christ;
which in other generations
was not made known to the sons of men
as it has now been revealed to
His holy apostles and prophets in Spirit; that the nations [gentiles]
are
fellow-partakers of the promise in
Christ Jesus through the
Gospel, whereof I became a minister, according
to the gift of the grace
of God given me according to the working of His power (to me, the least
of all saints, was
this grace given), to preach to the
nations
[gentiles] the unsearchable riches of the Christ and to bring to
light
what is the dispensation of the mystery hid for the ages
in God who created all things; in order that
now unto the
principalities and the powers in the heavenlies be made known
through the church the
manifold wisdom of God according to a plan
of the ages which he made in the Christ, Jesus our Lord;"
Ephesians
3:1-11, NENT.
It is obvious that
this is the body of
Christ, the church, which God will work through until the "times
of the
gentiles" be fulfilled. The nations are
fellow-heirs through the
"promise" in Christ through the gospel. His body
includes both natural
Israelites (Including Jews) and gentiles, all who have accepted Jesus
as their Savior, as
one new man. It is also interesting
to
see
that Paul was imprisoned because of preaching the "mystery" to
the gentiles. This is seen in Ephesians 3:1
and Colossians 4:2-4.
No wonder the Jews
wanted to stop him, he
was teaching the gentiles about the fulfillment of the "mystery"
that the kingdom of God had now come to
them.
The Jews did not
understand that God had made the gentiles,
whom they considered
heathen, to be equal with them, and fellow-heirs. Many
Christians do not understand
that today. But the fact is, those Jews
who did not accept Christ died in their sins and were not heirs at all.
Some teach that
Jesus descended into hell
and preached to the Israelites who had died without Jesus, and led
them
away to heaven. I think that this is a total distortion of Scripture.
If the Israelites believed in a coming
Messiah, it was reckoned to them
as righteousness. If they died unbelieving, they are lost. It is
appointed unto
man once to die and after that the
judgment.
"Now I rejoice in
my
suffering for you,
and
fill up on my part what are lacking of the afflictions of the Christ in
my flesh for His body, which is the church;
whereof I
became minister, according to the dispensation of God
given toward you,
to fulfill the word of God, the mystery hidden from the ages and
from the generations: but
now has it been manifested to His saints, to
whom God was pleased to make known what is the riches of the
glory of
this mystery among the nations, which is Christ in you
[gentiles], the hope of glory:" Colossians 1:24-29,
NENT.
Isn't that a
fantastic revelation? That
the
hope of glory is Christ in the masses. But remember that the
term
gentiles, in this sense, includes all
those who come to
accept Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior. Whosoever
will, remember?
Notice that He called the gentiles His saints. In Romans 1:7,
Paul said the beloved of God in
Rome were also called as saints.
"And confessedly
great is the mystery
of godliness; Who was manifested in flesh, justified in Spirit, seen of
angels, preached among nations
[gentiles], believed on in the
world, received up in glory [brilliancy and splendor],"
I Timothy 3:16,
NENT. There's that gentile connection again.
"I want you to
know
how much I am
struggling for you and for those at Laodicea, and for all who have not
met me
personally. My purpose is that they may be
encouraged in heart
and united in love, so that they may have the
full riches of complete
understanding, in order that they may know the mystery of God,
namely, Christ, in
whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom
and knowledge. Colossians 2:1-3. NIV.
So, the "mystery"
of God is
completely expressed in Christ Himself, and His manifestation
was for the purpose
of bringing forth this "mystery,"
making
all one in Himself.
According to Faith
"Christ hath
redeemed us from the curse
of
the law, being made a curse for us: for it is written, Cursed is every
one that hangeth on a tree: That the
blessings
of Abraham might come on
the Gentiles [masses], through Jesus
Christ; that we might
receive the promises of the Spirit through faith." Galatians 3:13-14.
There it is again,
the blessings of
Abraham, which are according to "promise," and by "faith," not under
the law.
And the promise that was given to Abraham is
now appropriated
to these Gentiles. Everyone who accepts
Christ into his life
and walks in obedience to Him is in this group of "Gentiles" [masses].
Without the marvelous
work that Christ did by His sacrificial
death
on
the cross, the covenant of Abraham would never have been
extended to
the gentiles. It was for this reason that Christ came.
The ministry of the gospel during the intervening years has continued and it will continue into the future.
This was, again, a
prophecy of the A.D.
70
destruction of Jerusalem, perhaps, updated by Paul. Are these
two
Scriptures contradictory? No! Realize that the epistle to the church at
Rome was written before the A.D.
70 desolation of Jerusalem, in which
1,100,000 Jews were killed. They died without Christ.
Those Jews had
said
to Pilate, concerning
the crucifixion of Jesus, "His blood be upon us, and upon our
children."
Matthew 27:25, NENT.
Even though Jesus
prayed on the cross,
"Father forgive them, for they know not what they do," it is obvious
that those Jews were not saved and will not
be, unless they repented
and accepted Jesus as their Christ. Jesus
said, "No man cometh to the
Father but by Me." John 14:6. It would be pure folly to believe that He
would
give eternal salvation to those whom He
destroyed in His wrath.
So the Scripture
in
Romans 9:27-28 is
referring to the A.D. 70 desolation, while the one in Romans 11:26 is
addressing the salvation of all the Israel
of
God, Christians
[Abraham's seed and heirs according to promise].
There will be no blanket salvation for all Jews no more that there is blanket salvation for all mankind.
"And he saith to
me,
Seal not the words
of
the prophecy of this booklet; for the season is nigh. Who is
unrighteous, let him be unrighteous still:
and
who is filthy, let him
be made filthy still: and who is righteous, let
him do righteousness
still: and who is holy, let him be made holy still." Revelation
22:10-11, NENT.
It is quite clear,
that all Jews will not
be saved, neither will all natural Israel, nor all the gentiles, but
only those
who accept Jesus the Christ. The Israel of
God
is not the
natural nation called Israel, but the Israel which is
circumcised of
the heart and not the flesh. It is made up of members of all peoples
who have, through Christ,
entered into a personal relationship with
Almighty God, walking in obedience to His will. "If you belong to
Christ, then you are Abraham's seed, and
heirs
according to promise."
Galatians 3:29, NIV.
Now the promise
was
given to Abraham, but
it was of faith, not a natural promise. Those after the flesh, which
are described (in Galatians 4:21-28) as the
Jerusalem of that day, were
not of promise, and were cut-off and
destroyed. But the Jerusalem above
(Hebrews 12:22) is our mother, and that's the only way anyone can
obtain the promises given to Abraham,
administered through his seed,
Jesus, in the fullness of time, the
revealing of the "mystery" of God.
"For neither is
circumcision anything,
nor
uncircumcision, but a new creation. And as many as shall walk by
this
rule, peace upon them, and mercy, and upon the Israel of God."
Galatians 6:15, NENT.
When we read the
old
testament accounts of
God's dealings with Israel, and the Jews specifically, it becomes
abundantly clear that, though given centuries
of time, the natural
nation Israel could never achieve salvation.
They were almost
continually wicked, doing
abominations in the sight of God. One generation would seek God,
and
the next would go back into worship of pagan gods.
Yet, through His
prophets, God foretold
that He would someday save Israel. This would not be their doing,
but
would be fully accomplished by God at His appointed time, and in His
way.
Since it proved
impossible for Israel
(except for a small remnant) to walk with God, even after He sent His
own
son Jesus to die for our sins, it would seem
that those old
testament prophecies could never be fulfilled. In the
natural, that
would be a true assumption, but with God, we see the supernatural at
work, and all things are possible.
God required
holiness, and man could not
produce it. It would take a perfect people who had walked upright
with
God all their days to fulfill the righteousness required for salvation.
No such people ever existed. Only one
perfect man ever lived on the
earth, Jesus, the Christ, the only begotten son of God. Only He could
lay claim to
the promises of God for the nation Israel. In
Him, God
would fulfill His old testament prophecies of Israel. Not
in a natural
nation, but in one man would come a holy nation, the Israel of
God. Not by natural procreation, but
a new creation. That one man, who
only did what the Father showed Him, fulfilled all Scripture, all types
given
by the law and the prophets, taking upon
Himself the iniquity of
us all, and nailing sin and death to a cross, He
arose victorious over
it. He bought salvation for all who would accept Him. In Him would the
gentiles hope.
He was the focal
point of Israel,
and in Him exists the Israel of God, Abraham's seed and heirs
according
to promise (Galatians 3:29). 'But it is not as
though the
word of God has failed. For they are not all Israel who
are descended
from Israel; neither are they all children because they are Abraham's
descendants, but:
"through Isaac your descendants will be
named."
That is, it is not the children of the flesh who are
children of God,
but the children of the promise are regarded as descendants.'
All past history
focused upon the Christ,
and all future claims to eternal life spring forth from and through
Him.
He was the manifestation of God in the flesh;
the first born of
many brethren.
The old Israel was
a
natural nation, a
chosen race. The new Israel is a Spiritual nation, the body of Christ,
"the
church." And if we belong to Christ, and His
righteousness is
manifested in our lives, the free gift of God's
salvation, eternal,
victorious life with Jesus is ours.
"And then shall
they
see the Son of man
coming in a cloud [Matthew 24:30 says "on the clouds of heaven"] with
power and great glory." Luke 21:27.
There are various
opinions of the meaning
of this Scripture. Some Bible commentators see this as a coming of
Christ "in the clouds" above Jerusalem at the
time of the destruction,
to actually direct the desolation of the city,
or a manifestation of
His power is so doing. This is because Luke 21:32 says: "Verily I say
unto you, This
generation shall not pass away, till all be
fulfilled."
Of this, Bible commentator Matthew Henry wrote: "The
destruction of
Jerusalem was in a particular manner an act of Christ's judgment, so
that it might justly be looked
upon as a coming of the Son of man, in
power and great glory, but in the clouds."1
In Clarke's
Commentary, Vol. V., p. 232,
Adam Clarke states (regarding Matthew 24:30, "Then shall appear the
sign of the Son of man...") 'The plain meaning
of this is, that the
destruction of Jerusalem will be a remarkable
instance of Divine
vengeance, such a signal manifestation of Christ's power and glory,
that all the Jewish tribes
shall mourn, and many will, in consequence
of this manifestation of God, be led to acknowledge Christ and his
religion." At first reading, it sounds as
though he is placing this as
a future event, but read further and it becomes
obvious that he was
referring to A.D. 70. The Scripture on which he was commenting had put
it in a future
setting, because it had been written before
the fact,
and he handled it in that same way.
'By "of the land"
in
the text, is evidently
meant here, as in several other places, the land of Judea and its
tribes...'
He identified the angel sent out in verse 31
as "his
messengers, the apostles, and their successors in the Christian
ministry." (Which followed the sign of the son
of man) The trumpet, he
identified, as "the earnest affectionate
call of the Gospel of peace,
life and salvation." (Which occurs during the "times of the gentiles.")
The elect which
were to be gathered together, he said, were
"The
Gentiles, who were now chosen or elected, in place of the
rebellious,
obstinate Jews, according to our Lord's prediction, Matthew 8:11-12 and
Luke 13:28-29." He further
said: "It is worth serious observation, that
the Christian religion spread and prevailed mightily after this period:
and nothing contributed more to the success of
the Gospel than the
destruction of Jerusalem happening in the
very time and manner, and
with the very circumstances, so particularly foretold by our Lord. It
was after this
period that the kingdom of Christ began, and
his reign
was established in almost every part of the world."
I have often
wondered if the gathering of
the elect would be accomplished through the preaching of the gospel.
That is literally what is happening. We are
being gathered unto Him
through acceptance of Christ into our lives.
The Greek word translated
"angels" does mean literally "messengers," and they are sent out by
Jesus to carry
the message of the good news of the gospel of
Christ. As
sinners are converted, they come into the fellowship of
Christ and
become "one" with Him.
This joining with Christ is a "union" or "betrothal" of the believer to Jesus, as a part of His bride, the church.
Some Bible
scholars
see this coming in
Matthew 24:30 as His second coming at the end of this age. This is the
traditional view and perhaps the most popular
one, but not what the
Bible teaches.
Jesus told His
followers: "But when these
things begin to come to pass, look up and lift up your heads; because
your redemption draweth nigh." Luke 21:28.
This He told them
not us.
The greatest
persecution of Christians,
prior to A.D. 64, was from the Jews. But when the Jews began to fight
among themselves, and later, against the
Romans, they were too busy to
persecute Christians. So in the
desolation (and the troublous times
before and after) there was a kind of redemption for the Christians. Of
course, the later persecutions came from the
Roman Emperors, but there
were also several periods, between
persecutions, in which the gospel
was freely preached to all nations.
Look up, Lift up Your Heads
When the
Scripture in Luke 21:28 says
"look up" and "lift up" your heads, it does not indicated a looking up
into the sky as
some suppose, but merely to "unbend," "rise," and "be
elated," not with head hanging down in
dismay, but to hold your head
erect, knowing that you are about to be ransomed by the Lord.
The remainder of
Matthew 24, beginning with
verse 32, is made up of parables, which show clearly that there
would
be signs when this "great tribulation" was to begin (as in the
parable of the fig tree putting forth
leaves) and that it would catch
the unprepared by surprise [as in the days of Noah, when the wicked
knew not
until the flood came and took them (the
wicked) all away].
The Greek text says: presence of the Son of man." Matthew 24:37-29, NENT.
The word used
here,
which in many
translations is rendered "coming," is the Greek word "parousia" which
means "presence." It is showing how the
desolation of Jerusalem would
come upon the Jews to destroy them
in the same way that the flood
destroyed the wicked in the time of Noah. Notice that, in Matthew 13,
in the
parable of the tares and wheat, and the
parable of the fish in
the sea, the wicked are taken from among the
just. Just
as in the days of Noah.
"Then
shall two be in
the field; the one shall be taken, and the other left, two women shall
be grinding at the
mill; the one shall be
taken and the other left.
Watch therefore: for ye know not what hour your Lord doth
come."
Matthew 24:40-42.
Each of these is a
warning to stay on the
alert for the signs which would alert them that it was time to flee
Jerusalem. In the parable of the good man of
the house, and the
faithful and wise servant, and again the
parable of the ten virgins, in
Matthew Chapter 25, they were admonished to be prepared at all times
for the
coming of the fulfillment of His prophecies. "Watch therefore, for ye know neither the day nor the
hour."
Matthew 25:13.
When the time was
fulfilled, and Jerusalem
was finally threatened, first by rumors of (talk about) wars, with
Galigula wanting to place a statue of himself
in the Sanctuary of the
Temple (A.D. 38), to the attack upon
Jerusalem by Cestius Gallus (A.D.
66), when the Jewish Christians fled Jerusalem traveling about a
hundred
miles over the mountains of Judea and Moab, to
Pella, the
warning signs all came, and all the prophetic words
of Jesus were
fulfilled.
Important Questions
At this point, I
would like to address some
questions that may have arisen in your minds concerning the
material
covered in this book and its implications.
Question 1. If the
"great tribulation"
came in A.D. 70, and John, writer of the book of the Revelation,
survived past that time, to possibly A.D. 100,
why didn't he write
about it in the books of the Bible which he
authored after that time?
Answer: There is
very good evidence that
the Book of the Revelation was written prior to A.D. 66. It describes
the events of the Great Tribulation period
which took place around A.D.
70.
The Christians who
fled to Pella were well
aware of the destruction of Jerusalem, just as Jesus had foretold. The
early church had no doubt that the "great
tribulation" had
indeed come to Jerusalem. This gave great
impetus to the Christian
movement, because they could see that Jesus was the Christ, as He had
declared,
from the fulfillments of the things He
foretold; from the
coming of the Holy Spirit on the day of Pentecost to the
destruction of
Jerusalem and the temple. It happened just as He had said it would.
John mentioned the
"great
tribulation" as a current event in the book of the Revelation.
The first mention
is Revelation 1:9, "I John, your brother and
partaker
with you in the tribulation..." NENT.
The second mention
is Revelation 8:14, "And
he spake to me, These are they that come out of the great
tribulation,
and they washed their robes, and made them white in the blood of the
Lamb." NENT. This
obviously refers to Christians. It was, a
vision of
the future of what was about to take place.
Revelation 1:9, quoted above, was not in a
vision, but was introductory to the book of the Revelation, yet he
spoke of the "tribulation" as if it
were a current event.
Matthew Henry, in
his Bible commentary on
Matthew 24, stated that none of the twelve apostles, except
John, lived
to see the destruction of Jerusalem, but they left directions to their
successors, and that it was
useful to them.
He says that when
the Christians in
Jerusalem and Judea saw the ruin coming, they fled to Pella, across
the
Jordan. He also states that of the thousands that perished in the
destruction of Jerusalem, there was
not so much as one Christian.
It is interesting
that John's Gospel does
not include the prophecies of the Olivet discourse as do the other
Gospels. It is likely that the Gospel
according to John was written
after A.D. 70, and that John did not include
those prophecies because
they had been entirely fulfilled. This is merely speculation, and
should be
received as such.
Question 2. If the
A.D. 70 desolation was
not the fulfillment of Matthew 24, Mark 13 and Luke 21, what
events
would have to happen before the second coming of the Lord?
Answer: If the
"great tribulation"
was not fulfilled in A.D. 70, and was yet future, then among other
things, it would be necessary for the
following events to occur to
fulfill prophecy:
1. The temple in Jerusalem would have to be rebuilt. This would mean clearing the land of existing structures.
2. Animal
sacrifice
would have to be
reinstated. This would be a great abomination to God, refusing to
acknowledge the sacrifice of His only begotten
Son as a permanent
atonement, once for all.
3. Jerusalem would have to experience wars and tumults and rumors of (talk about) wars.
4. Her enemies
would
have to surround her,
and throw up a bank [siege wall] against her, hemming her in
on all
sides.
5. There would
have
to be famine,
pestilence and the Jews would have to be killed by sword (an outmoded
weapon).
6. The reinstated sacrifice would have to cease again.
7. The city and
the
temple would have to be
destroyed again, leaving no stone upon another that was not
cast down.
8. Their survivors
would then have to be
scattered into all nations (as they have already been for two
thousand
years).
9. The "times of the gentiles" would come.
10. False prophets and false Christs would have to appear during the time after the destruction.
11. There would have to be wonders in the sky,
12. Finally, Christ would come again.
After having read
this book, you can easily
see that these events have all occurred, in the exact order,
as
foretold
by Jesus, in the forty years following the
crucifixion of
Christ.
If we are unable
to
recognize these
fulfillments that were so literal and precise, how could
we ever hope to
recognize any fulfillment of prophecy today,
or in the
future?
Some say that we
are
going through great
tribulation even now, and what of the destruction of Hiroshima and
Nagasaki in Japan during WWII, and the
holocaust of Hitler's
concentration camps? That was against Jews!
Christians are being
persecuted in many lands right now, and some estimate that over fifty
million were killed
in the name of Christianity by the Roman
church
during the dark ages. What of them? What of all the martyrs?
Could none
of this be the "great tribulation?"
All of these are,
perhaps by definition,
"great tribulation," but Hiroshima and Nagasaki are not
prophesied
about in Matthew 24, Mark 13 and Luke 21.
Although the
hollocaust was perpetrated against Jews, it was not
the "great
tribulation" of Scripture, because it was not in Jerusalem, and
did not involve the destruction of
the Temple and the City. The
martyrdom of Christians is foretold as a continuing thing in the Bible,
but again, it
was not exclusively during the "great
tribulation" in
Jerusalem.
Matthew 24, Mark
13
and Luke 21, in short,
contain very specific prophecies which predict the acts of vengeance
and wrath of God upon an obstinate and
disobedient generation of
unbelieving Jews.
Some of these
prophecies are found in the
predictions of Jesus in Matthew 23:34. There are many other related
scriptures of prophecy in the Bible. They do
not address a worldwide
conflict and tribulation, but only that which
related to Judea and its
inhabitants of that day, the Jews.
Question 3. If the
"great tribulation" is
past history and cannot be repeated, then what can be expected to
occur
in the future, between now and the second coming of Jesus?
It is not our
purpose here to detail what
will happen in the future, but rather, to show, unquestionably, what
has
already come to pass, in fulfillment of Bible
prophecy.
However, there are
several conclusions
which can be drawn. The first is that there cannot be a
pre-tribulation
rapture of the saints, as many have
confidently taught
for over a hundred and fifty years, because the "great
tribulation"
is past. Jesus said, "But watch at every season,
making supplication, that ye may prevail to escape
all these things
that shall come to pass, and to stand before the Son of man."
Luke 21:36, NENT. The King James
Version says: "pray
that ye may be accounted worthy to escape." This Jesus spoke,
not of an end-time
pre-tribulational "rapture" of the church, but
of
the escape of His disciples from Jerusalem to prevent being
killed in
the destruction. As we have already stated several times, the saints
who were in Jerusalem at that
season did escape to Pella in Perea.
History bears this out.
Question 4. Will Antichrist come in the future?
Many end-time
teachers talk about the
coming of "the Antichrist." They are apparently referring to one
of
the beasts in the Book of the Revelation,
calling him "the
Antichrist." This is simply not Scriptural. In Revelation
13:1-18,
there are three wicked ones mentioned, a dragon, and two beasts (one of
which is smitten unto death
and his stroke of death has been healed),
and there is the image of the first beast.
The Bible does not
refer to any of
these as "the Antichrist." In Revelation 16:13, the dragon, the beast
and
the false prophet (which could be the second
beast of Revelation
13) are all mentioned, and in Revelation 20:10,
all three have been
cast into the lake of fire and brimstone.
The word
"antichrist" appears in only two
books of the entire Bible, 1 John and 2 John. "Little Children, it is
the last time: and as ye have heard that
antichrist shall come, even now
are there many antichrists." (Notice,
not "the" antichrist, but
"many" antichrists.) 1 John 2:18.
"Who is a liar but
he that denieth that
Jesus is the Christ? He is antichrist, that denieth the Father
and the
Son." 1 John 2:22. "and every spirit that
confesseth not that
Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God: and
that is that spirit
of antichrist, whereof ye have heard that it should come;
and even now already is in the
world." 1 John 4:3.
Before John died, (history says near A.D. 100), the spirit of
antichrist was already in
the world.
"For many deceiver
are entering into the
world, who confess not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh. This is
a deceiver and an antichrist."
2 John :7. This he spoke
of the heresies which were beginning to creep into
Christianity.
The word antichrist comes from the Greek word "antichristos," meaning: "an opponent of the Messiah."
The only mentions
of
this word in the Bible
are those listed above, and they do not refer to any one individual
as
"the Antichrist." John was merely warning them of those who would come
and oppose the Messiah, as many
had already begun to do. So there is no
authority in the Scriptures to refer to an individual as "the
Antichrist,"
in regard to end-time events. All who oppose
the Messiah
are antichrist, of which there are still very many.
Some refer to the
"man of sin" in 2
Thessalonians Chapter 2, as "the Antichrist," but again, the Scripture
does not so name him. "...he that opposeth and
exalteth himself against
every one called God or an object of
worship; so that he sitteth in the
temple of God, setting himself forth as being God." 2 Thessalonians
2:4,
NENT. This Scripture is also used by some to
show that the Temple
in Jerusalem must be rebuilt before the
Lord can return. On closer
examination, we find that the word translated "temple" is the Greek
word "naos,"
which is the same word in I Corinthians 6:19,
saying:
"What! know ye not that your body is the temple [naos]
of the Holy
Ghost, which is in you, which ye have of God, and ye are not your own?"
The Greek word for
the physical temple
building is "hieron" (the entire precincts of the temple). But "naos"
(the central sanctuary of the temple) is used
numerous times in the
Bible to identify the dwelling place of
God, in the Spirit, the hearts
of men (I Corinthians 3:16, 6:19, II Corinthians 6:16, Ephesians 2:21).
In this day, a
person totally sold out to
humanism would be described as having the "man of sin" sitting in the
temple, "naos" (his heart), where God should
be. The "man of sin"
represents everyone who exalts himself
above God in his own heart, and
tries to run his own life apart from, and in opposition to Christ. Such
a one
is sent a working of error from God to believe
what is false,
because he has not a love of the truth.
(2 Thessalonians 2:10-12).
Most of the
confusion concerning the "man
of sin" comes from the King James Version. I believe that the
rendering
of this Scripture from Greek to English could be greatly improved.
Perhaps then our theologians
could understand it. That is just my
opinion, and it's worth as much as it cost you.
Question 5. Since
the Temple in Jerusalem
was fully destroyed in A.D. 70, does the Bible predict that it will
have to be rebuilt before Jesus comes again?
Answer: The Bible
makes no such
prediction. It is possible, I suppose, that the present-day Jews,
in
their zeal, could rebuild it, but prophecy
does not foretell such.
Standing in the
way
of such a
reconstruction of the temple is the Moslem mosque, called the "Dome of
the
Rock," which presently occupies much of the
location of the temple.
Of course that is no problem to God, but
the New Jerusalem, described
in Revelation 21, has no temple in it, (vs 22) "for the Lord God and
the Lamb
are its temple."
The Bible makes it
perfectly clear that
under the new covenant, God inhabits those who are His through
Jesus
our Lord. He needs no temple building to reside in. He has made for
Himself a body, the church, and
therein will He dwell.
Conclusion
To be very
clear about it, our
conclusion, after all the evidence has been examined, is that the
"great
tribulation" prophesied by Jesus, and
previously announced
as the day of God's wrath and judgment
upon the Jews, was entirely
fulfilled, attended with famine, pestilence, death by starvation and
the sword,
the cessation of sacrifices, the abomination
of desolation,
the total and final destruction of the Temple at
Jerusalem and the
dispersing of survivors into all nations, in the time period between
A.D. 66 and A.D. 73.
Further, that a repeat of such events is not
prophesied in the Bible and is, in fact, precluded by Matthew
24:21 and
Mark 13:19.
These facts have been adequately shown both Biblically and historically.
What Difference does it Make?
"For as I passed
by,
and beheld your
devotions, I found an altar with this inscription TO THE UNKNOWN
GOD,
whom therefore ye ignorantly worship, him declare I unto you. Acts
17:23. As Paul stood on Mars hill,
he pointed out how the men of Athens
were too superstitious. He also said that they were ignorant and went
on to say: "And the times of this ignorance
God winked at; but now
commandeth all men everywhere to
repent:" Acts 17:31.
In Romans Chapter
ten, Paul wrote:
"Brethren, my heart's desire and prayer to God for Israel is, that they
might be saved. For I bear them record that
they have a zeal of God,
but not according to knowledge. For they
being ignorant of God's
righteousness, and going about to establish their own righteousness,
have not
submitted themselves unto the righteousness of
God." Romans
10:1-3.
Paul also wrote in
Romans 1:13, "Now I
would not have you ignorant, brethren...," and this statement he
made
at least seven times, concerning Paul's purpose, righteousness,
baptism, Spiritual gifts, Paul's
desperation of
life, concerning the
dead, and the fact that, to the Lord, a day is as a thousand years and
a
thousand years as
a day.
If we are willing to receive what Paul is
saying, we must acknowledge the fact that God does not desire that
we
be ignorant. He has given us the capability to obtain accurate
knowledge about Him, and He expects us
to be diligent to learn the
truth. Otherwise, we might be like Israel, trying to go about serving
God in the
wrong way.
This is what I believe is happening in our
day. We have, in our laziness, allowed someone else to explain
the
Bible to us, instead of studying it for ourselves. We are
individually responsible to God for what we
do with our lives, and
no one else can stand in our place. So it is vital that we learn as
much of the truth as
we can, from the best source (the Bible), so
as to
dispel the traditions of men (which make the Word of God
of non-effect)
in our lives.
God has given us inquiring minds, and in
much of our secular activity, we use them very well, but when it
comes
to our knowledge of God, we too often place our trust in men.
Men figure out things, then expound upon
what they have found, much as I have done in this book. And we
should
listen, or read these things, perhaps we will learn something. But, as
we have our minds stimulated by
men's input, let us turn to God's
sources and examine for ourselves if these things be true, as the noble
men
of Berea did in Acts 17:11.
I have had the opportunity several times,
in recent years, to discuss some of my findings, from independent
Bible
study, with others who have studied in much the same way. It is amazing
how we have reached the
same conclusions, independently, about so many
Bible doctrines. Yet I do not desire that anyone take what
I say as
truth, without first checking it out in the Bible and the sources cited.
Corporate Bible studies are good, and group
discussions are valuable, but never abandon your own individual
Bible
studies. Try to put aside traditions you have been exposed to, and see
what the Scriptures say to you
by the power of the Holy Spirit. This I
say, not to everyone, but to those who are able to do so. Rest assured,
if those things you have been taught are true,
they will be
reinforced by Scripture. If not, Scripture will
expose them.
Do not be apprehensive about the great
tribulation which, so many teach, is yet future, when in fact it is
past.
Jesus came to set the captives free. Incorrect
understanding
holds us captive. Before conversion, fear of
death holds men captive,
but afterwards, with the assurance of eternal life, the fear of death
can no longer
hold us, the "portals of the grave" (gates of hell),
cannot prevail against the church because we are in Christ
Jesus. Jesus
led captive the fear of death which had sway over us. Now we are free
to live our lives, and die
with that blessed assurance that we shall
forever be with Him.
The fear of what is coming upon the earth,
especially when we believe error, can cause us much unnecessary
anxiety. Here, again, the truth can set us
free. "Be careful for
nothing; but in everything by prayer and
supplication with thanksgiving
let your requests be made known unto God. And the peace of God, which
passeth all understanding, shall keep your
hearts and minds through
Christ Jesus. Philippians 4:6-7.
I am not a great prophet of God, who can
give you all the facts about what will happen in the future. I am,
however, a reasonably intelligent historian
and Bible scholar, who can
relate to you those most obvious
events which have already come,
fulfilling Bible prophecy. I can also assure you that "neither death,
nor
life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor
powers, nor things
present, nor things to come, nor height, nor depth,
nor any other
creature, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is
in Christ Jesus our Lord."
Romans 8:23-39. Neither can "tribulation, or
distress, or persecution, or famine, or nakedness, or
peril,
or sword." Romans 8:35.
The future is in God's capable hands, and
if we place ourselves in His hands, He will fit us into His Master
plan, so that all things will work out for our
good.
No man knows what lies ahead for us, but be
assured that those belong to our Lord we'll have nothing to fear.
I'm sure,
if
you have heard any of the
"end-time" preaching on TV, or read Hal Lindsay's books, you have heard
about "the Antichrist." You may
have heard your pastor speak of
such a one from the pulpit.
This one
that they refer to as "the
Antichrist" is described as some awful world leader who is said to come
on
the scene at the beginning of the "great
tribulation," and then
halfway through the "great tribulation," he shows
his true colors and
does all sorts of terrible things to Christians (those who will not
take the "mark of the beast").
And it goes on and on. The same people
believe that all Christians will be "raptured" off the earth
before the
great tribulation, so I don't know who
those Christians are
who are persecuted by the Antichrist. I don't think they
have
thought their doctrine through.
What does
the Bible have to say about
this? It is really quite simple and easy to understand if you do not
allow
someone with the futurist view to cloud
up
your thinking.
The word "antichrist" is only mentioned five times, all
in the
books of 1 John and 2 John. It is not to be found anywhere
else in the Bible. I am listing all the scriptures
that mention antichrist below,
with comments.
1 John
2:18,
"Children, it is the last
hour; and just as you heard that antichrist is coming,
even now, many
antichrists have arisen; from
this
we know
that it is the last hour."
The
apostle
John was writing this in a
letter to the church. He was writing to real people who were
alive on the
earth at that time. He was
not writing to us
today, nor to those who have lived in the generations in between then
and now. There is no "code" word
there in the scriptures to
transfer what he was saying to a different time or
later
generation. He stated emphatically that "it is the last hour"
(at that time) and that "many antichrists have
arisen,"
and he said that this was evidence that it was the "last hour."
He did not say that "the" antichrist had
arisen, but "many"
antichrists.
He goes on
in verse 19 to say: "They
went out from us, but they were not really of us; for if they
had been of us,
they would have remained with us; but they
went
out, in order that it might be shown that they all are not of us."
He was
talking about people who had
been there with them, not some strange person who would be in charge
of
a "one world government." There is no one called "the
antichrist," in the Bible that is any such world leader.
The next
mention of "antichrist" is in
1 John 2:22 "Who is the liar but the one who denies that Jesus is the
Christ?
This is the antichrist,
the
one who denies the
Father and the Son."
This tells us one of the marks of an "antichrist," one who denies that Jesus is the Christ.
Then in 1
John 4:2&3 "By this you
know the Spirit of God; every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ
has
come in the flesh is from God; 3.
and every spirit that
does not confess Jesus is not from God; and this is the
spirit
of the antichrist, of which you have heard that it
is coming, and now is already in the world."
Could it
be
any clearer? He has
given us another attribute of an "antichrist," that he is one who
does not confess
Jesus. Then he goes on to
reiterate that the
spirit of antichrist "now is already in the
world." He's not writing
about an antichrist coming in
the year 2000, but at the time he was doing the writing, which was
probably around
A.D. 60-66. The antichrists he was
writing about
were already in the world at that time.
2 John 1:7
"For many deceivers have
gone out into the world, those who do not acknowledge Jesus Christ as
coming
in the flesh. This is the deceiver and the antichrist."
John was
making the church aware that
those who had walked away from them, denying that Jesus is the
Christ
were "antichrists." The word "antichrist" is from the
Greek word "antichristos,"which means one who
is an opponent
of Christ. He simply wanted them to be enlightened as to what the
"spirit of antichrist" was.
There is absolutely nothing
in these scriptures to say that some world ruler called "the
antichrist" was ever
to come upon the earth.
So where
does all this doctrine come
from? The Worldbook Encyclopedia states, under the article on
"antichrist" and the war between good
and
evil as the final battle on
earth: "The idea of such a final war between
good and evil occurred
among Babylonians, Persians and Jews before being adopted by
Christians." Of course
the first three didn't call him
"antichrist,"
but they had the same idea.
The modern
day proponents of the
futurist doctrine have misapplied the word "antichrist" to the "beast"
of
Revelation Chapter 13. Then they
tie
in 1 Thessalonians
Chapter 2 concerning the man of lawlessness and try
say that all this
describes "the antichrist." This is a twisting of the scriptures
making them say something that
was never intended.
The
"beast"
of Revelation Chapter 13
was to come at the time of the "great tribulation," which occurred
between
A. D. 66 and A. D. 73. The great
tribulation is well
documented on our webpage.
Where did the doctrine of the End-Time begin?
Daniel
mentioned "the time of the end," prophetically looking forward to
Jesus, however, what we
know as
"End-time" doctrine
originated with the "Olivet Discourse" of Jesus Christ. Because
the origin of the
"great tribulation"
doctrine comes from the
teaching of Jesus on the Mount of Olives, the Scriptures in
Matthew
24, Mark 13 and Luke 21 should be the main
source of Scripture that we study to learn about
the
subject.
The Great
Tribulation and the
"End-Time" is inextricable tied together. The "End-Time" is one
doctrine
where the majority of Christians are in darkness.
The
truth concerning the fulfillment of the Olivet Discourse
has,
for many years, been neglected. The fulfillment of all that Jesus
foretold is a powerful
testimony to the
authenticity of Jesus.
Only those, who desire to
know the truth, should venture
further into this web page.
Understanding Tribulation
Anyone who has
done
even a small amount of
reading in the New Testament will have come upon the word
"tribulation"
perhaps many times. Just what is tribulation according to the Bible?
The word
"tribulation," found in our English
Bibles, comes from a Greek word, "thlipsis," which is defined as
"affliction, distress, oppression."
This Greek word is
used at least forty-two
times in the New Testament, in various forms, but it is not always
rendered "tribulation." It is sometimes "distress," "trial," or
even "suffering."
Sometimes it describes
"anguish of mind or heart,"
or
"afflictions," or
again, it could be "trials,"
depending upon which
English translation
of the Bible you read. (See II Corinthians 1:4, 2:4
and Matthew 13:21)
Jesus warned His
disciples of personal
tribulation, which would come upon them before the "great
tribulation"
of Matthew 24:21. He said, "In this world ye
have tribulation, but be of good cheer, I have overcome the
world." John 16:33.
Paul stated in
Romans 2:9 and 10, "there will
be tribulation and distress for every soul of man who does
evil"
. . ."but glory and honor and peace to every man who does
good...." NASB.
Ever since sin entered the world, there has been some form of tribulation.
Some of the
Scriptures which tell of
personal tribulation for those who follow Jesus are: Acts 14:22b,
"...and
that we must through much tribulation enter into the kingdom of
God." This statement was made by some of
the Apostles, who knew
that they were to go through personal tribulation. Romans 5:3,
"And not only so, but
we glory in tribulation also: knowing that
tribulation worketh patience;" This indicates that personal
tribulation
can be good for us.
Some other places
where tribulation is
mentioned in the Bible include: Romans 12:12, "Rejoicing in hope;
patient
in tribulation; continuing instant in prayer;" II
Corinthinans 1:4, "Who comforteth us in all our tribulations...,"
Ephesians 3:13, "Wherefore I desire that ye faint not at my
tribulations...," and II Thessalonians 1:4, "So that we
ourselves
glory in you in the churches of God, for your patience and faith in all
your persecutions and tribulations
that ye endure."
These are not all the references to tribulation to be found in the Bible, but are representative of them.
Both the Bible and
history record that the
early church suffered much personal tribulation, and in fact, such
persecution was not unique to the early church. Even today, persecution
and tribulation continues in many parts
of the world. However, the kind
of tribulation that is common throughout history is not the
subject of this writing.
Not all
tribulation
found in the Bible is "great
tribulation." But Jesus, in the Olivet discourse of
Matthew 24,
Mark 13 and luke 21, did predict a time of "great
tribulation," and that is what this writing is about.
"For then shall be
great tribulation, such as
was not since the beginning of the world to this time, no, nor ever
shall be." Matthew 24:21.
The word for
tribulation, used here, is
"thlipsis," followed by the word "megale," meaning "great." In Mark 13,
it is rendered "affliction:" "For in those days shall be affliction
such as was not from the beginning of the creation
which God created
unto this time, neither shall be." Mark 13:19.
This is the same Greek word used for
"tribulation" in Matthew 24:21.
It is from these two Scriptures that the end-time doctrines of the "great tribulation" originate.
Several other
Scriptures in the Bible use the
word "thlipsis," referring to "tribulation," but not to a specific
period of time."Great tribulation" is named twice in the
book of the Revelation (2:22 and 7:14), and
"tribulation" is mentioned
in Revelation 1:9. We will discuss these verses later, to show how they
relate to
the "great tribulation" of Matthew 24:21.
Matthew 24:29
says:
"...after the
tribulation of those days...," and Mark 13:24 says:
"...after that tribulation...."
Both of these Scriptures refer to a specific
time
of tribulation, the worst since the beginning of the world, found
in
Matthew 24:21. The entire prophecy of the "great tribulation" is
contained in seven verses, Matthew 24:15-21.
Let's lay aside
our
preconceived ideas and
prejudices, and let Scripture and history speak for themselves.
With a lot
of people, this subject is
an emotionalone and many
are resistant to change. But if we are believing
something that is contrary to the truth and it can be
clearly shown that it is incorrect, shouldn't we be willing to
investigate it. It's the truth
that will set you free.
There are over
60 "time-statements" connected with these
prophecies
of Jesus, and if the
prophecies have
not come true, He would
be a false
prophetaccording to the Bible definition found in Deuteronomy 18:22.
Click
here to read Deuteronomy 18:22
Jesus didn't promise
to return in 2000 years. The time statements found in the Bible
tell us a
different story. They
repeatedly tell of events that
must SOON come to pass. 2000
years later
is NOT soon. He
said these events would occur in THAT generation, before some
of
the
people living at
that time died.
These events did come to pass, within the 40 years following His statements.
I challenge all futurists to try to explain away the following 67 very clear time statements!
The Bible
contains numerous statements
in Scripture as to when the "end" would
come. They are not specific
as to the day or the hour, but give a generational
guideline. Jesus made many of these
statements himself, and
the writers of other books in the New
Testament did likewise.
Are we to ignore our Lord and believe what men say instead?
Think
of how it would have been if
you were there, hearing the very words of Jesus or His
apostles. When would
you have thought these things
were
going to happen? Two thousand years later? Did
Jesus and His apostles
deliberately deceive everyone? Of
course not. It happened exactly as Jesus predicted.
Lets look at some of these time statements and you'll see what we mean:
1.
Matthew 10:23, Jesus said: "But whenever they persecute
you in this city, flee to the next; for truly I say to you,
you shall not finish going through
the cities of
Israel, until the Son of Man comes. .
2.
Matthew 24:34, Jesus said: "Truly I say to you, this
generation will not pass away until all these
things take
place. Heaven and earth will pass away, but My
words shall not pass away.
--Comment: Jesus had just told them about the
destruction of the Temple and the great tribulation that was to come
upon Jerusalem.
In Luke 11:49-51 Jesus said: "For this reason
also the wisdom of God said, 'I will send to them prophets and apostles,
and some of
them they will kill and some they
will persecute, in order that the blood of all the prophets,
shed since the foundation of the world, may
be charged against
this generation, from the blood of Abel to the blood of
Zechariah, who perished between the altar and the house
of God;
yes, I tell you, it shall be charged against this generation."
This was NOT speaking of a future generation!
3.
Matthew 26:64, Jesus said to him, "You have said it yourself;
nevertheless I tell you, hereafter you
shall see
the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of Power, and coming
on the clouds of heaven."
---Notice the word "YOU," indicating those listening to him at that time.
4.
Romans 13:12, The night is almost gone, and the day
is at hand. Let us therefore lay aside
the deeds of
darkness and put on the armor of light.
- -Comment: When He said the "night is almost
gone," what does that mean to you? What does "at hand
mean?" Does it mean
down the road 2000 years?
5. Romans 16:20, And the God of peace will soon crush Satan under your feet.
--Comment: What does soon mean?
6.
1 Corinthians 7:26-31, I think the that this is good in
view of the present distress, that it is good for a man
to remain as he is.
7.
1 Corinthians 10:11, Now these things happened to them as
examples, and they were written for our
instruction, upon
whom the ends of the ages have come.
--Comment: When it says "our instruction" it is not
referring to us today, it was Paul who was saying it to the people at
Corinth.
But when most people read it, they assume it is for
our
instruction today. The "ends of the ages" came upon them.
8.
Titus 2:11-13 "For the grace of God has appeared, bringing
salvation to all men, 12 instructing us to deny
ungodliness and worldly desires and to live sensibly, righteously and
godly in the present age, 13 looking for
the blessed
hope and the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior, Christ
Jesus;"
--Comment: He didn't say instructing you, he
said us,and he also said "in the present age," which doesn't mean
some future
age as the futurist try to tell us, and he
summed
it up with "looking for the blessed hope" and the
"appearing" of the glory of
our great "God and Savior, Christ
Jesus." These scriptures are all written right together.
I didn't gather a bunch of isolated
scriptures and fit them together
to say this. It's right there in your Bible. Please
look it up and read it for yourself. Today most
Christians
believe their blessed hope is the "rapture." The word
"rapture" is not in the Bible.
9.
Hebrews 1:2, in these last days has spoken
to us in His Son, whom He appointed heir of all things, through
whom also He made the world.
--Comment: The writer of Hebrews was identifying hisday as "these last days." Was he confused or disillusioned? I hardly think so.
10.
Hebrews 9:26, Otherwise, He would have needed to suffer
often since the foundation of the world; but now
once at the consummation,
He has been manifested to put away sin by the sacrifice of Himself.
--Comment: The Greek word translated "consummation" means "to complete entirely." What does the word "now" mean to you?
11.
Hebrews 10:25&37 not forsaking our own assembling
together, as is the habit of some, but encouraging
one another; and
all the more, as you see the day drawing near.
37. FOR YET IN A VERY LITTLE WHILE, HE
WHO
IS COMING WILL COME, AND WILL NOT DELAY.
12. 1 John 12:35, ". . . For a little while longer. . .
13. John 14:19, "After a little while the world will behold Me no more;"
- -Comment: What does a "little while"
longer mean? Does it mean 2000 years? The Greek
word for little is "mikros," meaning:
"small." The Greek word for
"while" is "chronos" meaning: "a space of time." Can you argue
with this time statement? Of course not.
So why do you
argue against all the others that have to do with the time of the end?
14.
James 5:8-7 Be patient, therefore brethren, until the
coming of the Lord. 8. You too be patient; strengthen
your
hearts, for the coming of the Lord is at hand.
9. Do not complain, brethren, against one another, that you
yourselves
may not be judged; behold, the Judge is standing right at the
door.
15.
1 Peter 4:5, "but they shall give account to Him who is ready
to judge the living and the dead. 6. for the
gospel has
for this purpose been preached even to those who are
dead.
16.
1 Peter 4:7, The end of all things is at
hand; therefore, be of sound judgment and sober spirit for
the
purpose of prayer.
17.
1 John 2:8, On the other hand, I am writing a new
commandment to you, which is true in Him and in you,
because the
darkness is passing away, and the true light is already
shining.
18.
1 John 2:17-18, And the world is passing
away, and also its lusts; but the one who does the will of
God
abides forever. 18. Children, it is the last hour;
and just as you heard that antichrist is coming, even now many
antichrists
have arisen; from this we know that it is the
last hour.
--Comment: The prediction of "antichrist" is only
found in 1 John and 2 John, and he said "many antichrists had arisen
[past
tense], back in the time between the crucifixion of
Christ and
A.D. 70. See our page on "The Antichrist."
19.
Revelation 1:1 "The revelation of Jesus Christ, which God
gave Him to show to His bond-servants, the
things which must shortly
take place; and He sent and
communicated it by His angel to His bond-servant John,"
Comment: What do you think? Does shortly indicate a long time?
20.
Revelation 1:3, Blessed is he who reads and those who
hear the words of the prophecy, and heed the
things which are written
in it; for the time is near.
21.
Revelation 3:10-11 'Because you have kept the word of My
perseverance, I also will keep you from the
hour of testing,
that hourwhich is about to come
upon the whole (inhabitable) world, to test those who dwell
upon the
earth (soil).
--Comment: This verse uses the Greek word "Mello,"
which means "about to." The words in parenthesis are
added by me.
They are the Greek meanings of the words which are
not translated in the English versions. The word used for "world," is
the Greek
"oikoumene" which means habitable earth
or
the Roman Empire. The Greek word translated earth here is the
word "Ge" which
means "soil." These words show that we
are not talking about the whole world as the text would suggest
and as many people
believe and teach. More on this later.
22.
Revelation 22:10, And he says to me, Seal not the words
of the prophecy of this book; because the
time is near.
23.
Revelation 22:6, And he said to me, These words are
faithful and true and the Lord God of the holy
prophets sent his angel
to show his bondmen the things which must come to pass soon.
24. Revelation 22:7,12,20, Behold, I am coming quickly.
25. John 16:13, "He will disclose to you what is to come."
--Comment: What was John expecting to come? Must have been a very important event to be mentioned in this way.
26. Galatians 1:4, ". . .that He might deliver us out of this present evil age. . ."
27.
1 Thessalonians 5:23 ". . .and may your spirit
and soul and body be preserved complete, without
blame at
the coming (parousia = presence) of our Lord Jesus
Christ." 24." . . .He will bring it to pass. . ."
--Comment: Paul was praying for his then present
listeners that their bodies would be preserved
complete at the coming of our
Lord etc. Sounds like a soon coming
event.
28.
2 Thessalonians 1:6 ". . . relief to you and us
. . . 7. ". . .when the Lord Jesus shall be revealed
(Apokalupsis: disclosure) from heaven with His mighty angels in
flaming fire. . ."
--Comment: Here Paul included himself. Relief
to you and us when the Lord shall be revealed.
Something Paul was expecting to happen within the
lifetime of some of those present.
29.
John 12:31, "Now
is the time for judgment on this world, now
the prince of this world will be driven out.
But I, when I
am lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto myself."
32. "But He was saying this to indicate
the kind of death by
which He was to die." (In other words, that He would die on a
cross.)
- -Comment: The word that is translated "now"
is the Greek word "nun" which means: "presently" or
"immediately." So when
was the judgment to come on the
world? Jesus said "NOW."
Is that what He meant? When was the prince of this world (which
we all believe to be Satan) to be driven out?" Was it to be 2000 years later? That's
what the futurists say.
30.
Luke 18:31, . . .will He delay long over them? Delay
is the Greek word "tachos," meaning, "in a very short
time," "a brief
space (of time)," "in haste," "fleet."
Mello
There are many time statements in the Bible that use the same Greek word, "Mello."
Here is the definition:
(3195)
me>llw, — mel’-lo; a strengthened form of (3199)
(me>lw) (through the idea of expectation); to intend,
i.e. be about to be, do, or suffer
something (of persons or things, especially
events; in
the sense of
purpose, duty, necessity, probability, possibility, or
hesitation):
This
is the Strong's Concordance definition, but some futurists
argue that it does not always mean about to.
I
have searched the scriptures for other places that the word "Mello" is
used that do not necessarily apply to
the "end times. Those
verses are listed below, and plainly show that the meaning is
consistently "about to be."
Some
good examples of the urgency of the word "Mello"
are found in two chapters of the book of John and
several verses in
Acts and Romans. There are many other examples to be found
throughout the New
Testament. You will see from these verses how
the word was consistently used to convey immediacy! But
when our Bibles were translated, the translators chose to remove the
immediacy and merely say that these
things were going to
happen, not that they were about to happen. To see
the real meaning of "mello," read
through these examples.
Next, we
will list the verses that use the word "mello," meaning "about to..." that
apply specifically to the
destruction of Jerusalem and events
related to the coming of the Lord.
31. Matthew 3:7 "But when he saw many
of the Pharisees and Sadducees coming to his baptism, he said to them,
"Brood of vipers! Who has warned you to flee
from
the wrath about
to come."
--Comment: What wrath was he talking about?
How about the destruction of Jerusalem and the Temple in A.D. 70 which
Jesus
prophesied and most Christians today don't know about?
32. Matthew 12:32 "Anyone who speaks a
word against the Son of Man, it will be forgiven him; but whoever
speaks against the Holy Spirit, it will not be
forgiven him, either in
this age or in the age about to come."
(also Luke 21:7)
33. Matthew 16:27 "For the Son of man
is about to come in the glory of His Father with His
angels, and then
He will reward each according to his works."
34. Matthew 24:6 "And you are about
to hear of wars and rumours of wars. See that you are
not troubled; for all
must come to pass, but the end is not yet."
35. Mark 13:4 "Tell us when will these
things be? And what will be the sign when all these
things should be about
to be accomplished." NIV says
"about to be fulfilled."
36. Luke 3:7 "Then He said to the
multitudes that came out to be baptized by him, "Brood of vipers!
Who warned
you to flee from the wrath about to come"
(NIV footnote wrong concerning two
fulfillments,
this is precluded by Matthew 24:21.)
37. Luke 19:11 "Now as they heard
these things, He spoke another parable, because He was near Jerusalem
and
because they thought the kingdom of God was
immediately about
to be manifested."
38. Luke 21:36 "Watch therefore, and
pray always that you may be counted worthy to escape all these things
which
are about to come to pass, and
to stand
before the Son of Man."
39. John 14:22 'Judas (not Iscariot)
said to Him, "Lord, what has occurred that to us you are about to
manifest
yourself and not to the world?"'
40.
Romans 5:14, "but death reigned from Adam until Moses
even upon those who had not sinned in the likeness of
the transgression
of Adam, who is a figure of the one about to (mello)
come.
41. Romans 8:13, "For if according to flesh you live, you are about to (mello) die."
42.
Acts 17:31 "because He has
appointed a day in which He is about to judge the
habitable world in righteousness
by the Man whom He has ordained.
He has given assurance of this to all by raising Him from the dead."
43. Acts 24:25 'Now as he
reasoned about righteousness, self-control, and the judgment about
to be, Felix was
afraid and answered, "Go away for now; when I
have a convenient time I will call for you."'
44. Acts 26:22-23 "I have stood
bearing witness both to small and to great, saying nothing else than
what both the
prophets and Moses said was to happen, whether
Christ
should suffer; whether first through resurrection of [the]
dead is about
to announce light to the people and to the nations."
45. Romans 4:23 & 24 "Now it was
not written for his sake alone that it was imputed to him, but also on
account
of us to whom it is about to be
imputed, who
believe in Him who raised up Jesus our Lord from the dead,"
46. Romans 8:18 "For I consider that
the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with
the
glory about to be revealed in
us."
47. Romans 8:38 "For I am persuaded
that neither death nor life, nor angels nor principalities nor powers,
nor
things present nor things about to
be, nor height
nor depth, nor any other created thing, shall be able to separate
us
from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus our Lord."
48. 1 Corinthians 3:21 & 22
"Therefore let no one glory in men. For all things are yours: 22.
whether Paul or
Apollos or Cephas, or the world or life or
death,
or
things present or things about to come all are yours."
49. Ephesians 1:20-21 "which He worked
in Christ when He raised Him from the dead and seated at His right
hand
in the heavenlies 21 far above all principality and power and might and
dominion, and every name that is
named, not only in this age, but also
in the one about to come."
50. Colossians 2:17 "which were a shadow of things about to come, but the substance is Christ."
51. 1 Thessalonians 3:4 "For in fact,
we told you before when we were with you that we were about to
suffer
tribulation, just as it happened, and you know."
52.
1 Timothy 4:6, "For I am already being
poured out as a drink offering, and the time of my departure has
come."
--Comment: We know that Paul was put to death shortly after this. "Already" meant what it said. So did "time of my departure."
53. 1 Timothy 4:8 "For bodily exercise
profits a little, but godliness is profitable for all things, having
promise of
the life that now is and of that which is about
to
come."
54. 1 Timothy 6:18 & 19 "Let
them do good, that they be rich in good works, ready to give,
willing to share, 19
storing up for themselves a good foundation for
the time about to come, that they may lay hold on
eternal life."
55. Hebrews 1:14 "Are they not all ministering spirits sent forth to minister for those being about to inherit salvation."
56. Hebrews 2:5 "For He has not put the world which is about to come, of which we speak, in subjection to angels.."
57. Hebrews 6:5 "and have tasted the good word of God and the power of the age about to come"
58. Hebrews 9:11 "But Christ came as High Priest of the good things about to come."
59. Hebrews 10:27 "but a certain
fearful expectation of judgment, and fiery indignation being about
to consume the
adversaries."
60. Hebrews 13:14 "For we have no continuing city, but we seek the one about to come"
61. James 2:12 "So speak and do as those being about to be judged by law of liberty."
62.
1 Peter 3:22, "Christ who is at the right hand of God,
having gone into the heavens after angels and
authorities
and powers had been subjected to Him.
63.
1 Peter 4:13, "but to the degree that you share the
sufferings of Christ, keep on rejoicing; so that also at the
revelation
of His glory, you may rejoice with exultation.
--Comment: This epistle (letter) was written
to people alive at that time and he was specifically
addressing them saying YOU may
rejoice at the relevation of
His glory.
64.
1 Peter 4:17, "For it is time for judgment to begin
with the household of God; and if it begins with us first,
what will be
the outcome for those who do not obey the gospel of God?
65. 1 Peter 5:1 "The elders who are
among you I exhort, I who am a fellow elder and a witness of the
sufferings
of Christ, and also partaker of the glory about
to
be revealed:"
66. Revelations 1:19 "Write the things
which you have seen, and the things which are, and the things which are
about
to take place after this."
67. Revelations 3:10 "Because you have
kept My command to perservere, I also will keep you from the hour of
trial which is about to come
upon
the whole habitable
world, to test those who dwell on the land."
Honestly
now, do these Scriptures sound like they are going
to be fulfilled in two thousand years,
or were they
imminent at the time they were spoken? The number
of these statements is overwhelming, too many to
ignore
or dismiss lightly as the futurist do. And this is not
an exhaustive list, there are dozens more of them that I haven't
located yet.
It's
an on-going thing with me, locating time statements in the
Bible, and they show up at some very unexpected
places. You can read a
scripture a hundred times and not see something that is in it. I just
noticed a time statement
in Matthew 24:21 that I had overlooked.
I
have been pointing out that this scriptures says that the great
tribulation can only happen once, because it says
"for then
there will be a great tribulation such as has not occurred since
the beginning of the world until now, nor
ever shall."
That precludes more than one fulfillment of the great tribulation, but
the time statement I had overlooked
was the word "now."
It designates that period as a pivotal time for the
occurrence of the great tribulation.
Although Jesus had said
"then" earlier in this scripture, the word "now" nails it down
to the transition period
between the past and the future.
Greg
Kiser and I were discussing this on the phone and he was using
the KJV while I was using the NASB.
There is a difference in that
the KJV says "until this time," and the NASB says "until now."
So this led me
to the Strong's Concordance. I looked up the word "time"
listed for that verse and here is what I found: The Greek
word was "Kairos"
{2540} and the meaning: occasion, i.e. set or proper time:
Then I looked up "this" to see
what they had for it. It
was the word "nun" {3568} which means "now," as adverb of
date, a transition or
emphasis, "present or
immediate:" Since this word meant "now," I
wondered what the word "time" was doing
there, so I looked in
the Greek text and it wasn't there. The word "kairos"
is not there at all.
This
is a Strong's mistake, of taking the KJV and listing a word
that wasn't in the Greek text. Actually in the
Greek text it says:
"until the now." It designates a present
or immediate event. It is definitely another of the
many
time statements. We have listed sixty-seven (67)
of them here, there are likely many more in the Bible.
Lets review some of these
time-statements in a briefer form:
In reference to the idea of Christ setting up a kingdom on earth:
John
18:36, Jesus answered, "My kingdom is not of this
world. If My kingdom were of this world, then My
servants
would be fighting that I might not be delivered up to the Jews, but as
it is, My kingdom is not of this
realm."
Jesus told his disciples:
Luke
17:20, "The kingdom of God is not coming with signs
to be observed; 21. nor will they say, 'Look,
here it is!' or
'There it is!' For behold, the kingdom of God is within you."
The
realm of the kingdom of God is a Spiritual kingdom and not a
natural one. It now exists in the hearts of all
the Christians on
earth. The greatest hinderance to the kingdom of God is the
belief that it is still not here, but is
coming sometime in the future.
Colossians 1:27: "Christ in you, the hope of glory."
At
any rate, can we just
ignore the "time statements?" I DON'T THINK SO.
These
are the renderings of some scriptures that contain the word
"Mello" taken from the
Greek text in an Interlinear Bible. This is
where we see what the word actually means. Do
these
scriptures sound vague and distant, or something that was going to
happen very
soon?
John 6:6, "But this He said trying him for he knew what he was about to do.
John 6:15, "Jesus therefore, knowing that they are about to come and seize him. . .
John 6:71, "But he spoke of Judas Simon's [son] Iscariote, for he was about to deliver him up. . .
John 7:35, "Is He about to go to the dispersion among the Greeks, and teach the Greeks?
Acts
32, "And a certain man, his being lame from his mother's womb,
was being carried, whom they placed
daily at the door of the temple
called Beautiful, to ask alms from those who were going into the
temple, who
seeing Peter and John being about to (mello)
enter into the temple. . ."
Acts
5:35, "And said to them, men, Israelites, take heed to
yourselves as regards these men what you are
about to
(mello) do, for before these days rose up Theudas, offering himself to
be somebody, to whom were
joined a number of men . . . who was put to
death, and all . . . persuaded by him were dispersed."
Acts
11:28, "And having risen up from among them, Agabus, by name,
he signified by the Spirit, A great famine
is about to
(mello) be over the whole habitable earth which also came to pass
under Claudius Caesar."
Acts
13:34, "And that he raised him from among [the] dead, no more
to be about to (mello) return to corruption,
thus he
spoke: I will give you the faithful mercies of David."
Acts
18:14, "But Paul, being about to (mello) open
[his] mouth, Gallio said to the Jews, If indeed therefore it
was some
unrighteousness or wicked criminality, O Jews, according to reason, I
should have borne with you,
15 but if a question it be about a word and
names and a law which [is] among you, you will see [to it] yourselves,
"
for a judge of these things I do not wish to be."
--Comment: Was Paul going to open his mouth 2000
years from then? Isn't it silly to try to put off what was said
to be about to
happen, just to make your erroneous
theology work out?
There
were men at Ephesus who made silver shrines to the goddess
Diana. As Paul was preaching the gospel
there these men got upset
and said in:
Acts
19:27, "Now not only is this dangerous to us [lest] the
business come into disrepute, but also the temple of
the great goddess
Artemis (KJV says "Diana") for nothing be reckoned, and the majesty of
her is about to
(mello) be destroyed, whom all Asia and
the habitable world worship."
Acts
20:3, "And having continued three months, having been made
against them a plot by the Jews being about
to (mello)
sail into Syria . . ."
Could this happen 2000 years later?
Acts
20:13, "But we having gone before to the ship sailed to Assos,
being about there to (mello) take in,
Paul,
for so he had appointed himself being about to
(mello) go on foot.
Its obvious that both of these were about to occur immediately.
Acts 21:37, "But being about to (mello) be brought into the fortress, Paul . . ."
Acts 22:16, "And now why delayest (mello) them?" (Reverse meaning).
Acts
22:29, "Immediately therefore departed from him those being about
to (mello) examine him, and the
chief captain also was afraid,
having ascertained that a Roman he is and because he bound him."
Acts 23:3 'Then Paul said to him, "God is about
to smite you, whitewashed wall! For you sit to judge me
according to the law, and do you command me to
be
struck contrary to
the law?"'
Acts
23:15, "Now therefore you make a representation to the chief
captain with the sanhedrim, so that tomorrow
him he may bring down to
you, as being about to (mello) examine more accurately
the things concerning him, and
we, . . ."
Acts
23:20, "And he said, the Jews agreed to request you that
tomorrow into the sanhedrim you may bring down
Paul, as being about
to (mello) inquire something more accurately concerning him."
Acts 23:27, "This man, having been seized by the Jews, and being about to (mello) be put to death by them, . . ."
---Comment: They couldn't put him to death 2000 years later.
Acts
25:4, "Festus therefore answered, Paul should be kept at
Caesarea, and himself was about to (mello)
shortly
set out."
Acts
26:2, "Concerning all of which I am accused by Jews, king
Agrippa, I esteem myself happy being about to
(mello)
make defense before you today. . ."
That's pretty immediate!
Acts
26:22, "And therefore having obtained from God unto this day I
have stood, bearing witness both to small
and to great, nothing else
saying, than what both the prophets and Moses said, was about to
(mello) happen,
whether Christ should suffer; . . ."
Acts
27:2, "And having gone on board a ship of Adramyttium about
to (mello) navigate the places along Asia we
set sail, being
with us Aristarchus a Macedonian of Thessalonica."
Acts
27:9b, 10, "Paul exhorted them saying, men, I percieve that the
voyage is about to (mello) be with disaster
and much
loss not only of the cargo and of the ship but also of our lives."
Acts
27:30, "But the sailors seeking to flee out of the ship and
having let down the boat into the sea, with pretext
as from [the] prow
being about to (mello) cast out anchors, Paul said to
the Centurion and to the soldiers. . ."
When
a viper (snake) had come out of the wood that Paul had gathered
to start a fire and it had latched onto his
hand, the scriptures says
in:
Acts
28:6, "But they were expecting him to be about to
(mello) become inflamed or to fall down suddenly dead."
Again something that was expected to happen immediately.
--Comment: The following are more time
statement scriptures which use the word "Mello" that have to
do with what Jesus called the
"end." This word demands a
more imminent rendering than what we find in our translations
such as KJV, NASB, NIV, etc.