| * denotes home games. | |||||||||||
| 1993 (8-2) | Drake classified I-AA | 1994 (7-3) | |||||||||
| Coach: Rob Ash | Coach: Rob Ash | ||||||||||
| Simpson* | W | 35-9 | Simpson | W | 22-6 | ||||||
| Augustana (Ill.) | W | 54-48 | San Diego* | W | 14-9 | ||||||
| Butler | L | 3-28 | Aurora | W | 26-0 | ||||||
| Aurora* | W | 47-14 | Butler* | L | 20-28 | ||||||
| Chicago | W | 33-19 | Evansville | W | 31-21 | ||||||
| Valparaiso | W | 31-12 | Valparaiso* | W | 23-3 | ||||||
| Dayton* | L | 7-35 | Dayton | L | 7-24 | ||||||
| Benedictine (Ill.)* | W | 48-33 | Nebraska-Kearney | L | 14-17 | ||||||
| San Diego | W | 17-14 | Wisconsin-Oshkosh* | W | 41-7 | ||||||
| Evansville* | W | 29-27 | Saint Ambrose* | W | 19-0 | ||||||
| 1995 (8-1-1) | PFL Champion | 1996 (8-3) | |||||||||
| Coach: Rob Ash | Coach: Rob Ash | ||||||||||
| Missouri Western* | T | 19-19 | Morningside* | W | 32-26 | ||||||
| Saint Ambrose | W | 23-0 | Saint Norbert | W | 31-0 | ||||||
| Wisconsin-La Crosse | L | 7-14 | San Diego* | W | 34-7 | ||||||
| Aurora* | W | 37-7 | Saint Mary's (Cal.) | L | 12-16 | ||||||
| Butler | W | 29-8 | Butler* | W | 51-7 | ||||||
| Evansville* | W | 23-6 | Evansville | W | 55-34 | ||||||
| Valparaiso | W | 28-21 | Valparaiso* | W | 27-12 | ||||||
| Dayton* | W | 34-23 | Dayton | L | 16-19 | ||||||
| San Diego | W | 9-0 | Aurora | W | 43-13 | ||||||
| Northwestern (Iowa)* | W | 28-6 | Wayne State (Neb.)* | W | 54-41 | ||||||
| Northwestern (Iowa) | L | 6-13 | |||||||||
| 1997 (8-3) | 1998 (7-3) | PFL Champion | |||||||||
| Coach: Rob Ash | Coach: Rob Ash | ||||||||||
| Morningside | W | 7-0 | Morningside* | W | 12-0 | ||||||
| Saint Norbert* | W | 48-7 | Saint Ambrose | L | 18-24 | ||||||
| South Florida | W | 23-22 | Wisconsin-La Crosse* | W | 28-21 | ||||||
| Valparaiso | W | 27-7 | Quincy | W | 59-34 | ||||||
| Wayne State (Neb.) | W | 35-17 | Valparaiso* | W | 33-18 | ||||||
| Dayton* | L | 13-14 | Dayton | W | 28-21 | ||||||
| Evansville* | W | 28-18 | San Diego* | W | 37-13 | ||||||
| San Diego | L | 30-39 | Butler* | W | 41-7 | ||||||
| Aurora* | W | 45-0 | Saint Mary's (Cal.) | L | 21-27 | ||||||
| Butler | L | 13-14 | Towson | L | 14-17 | ||||||
| Northwestern (Iowa)* | W | 27-20 | |||||||||
| 1999 (7-4) | |||||||||||
| Coach: Rob Ash | |||||||||||
| Morningside | W | 21-17 | |||||||||
| Saint Ambrose* | W | 47-3 | |||||||||
| Wisconsin-Stevens Point* | L | 17-28 | |||||||||
| Quincy* | W | 48-7 | |||||||||
| Valparaiso | L | 17-27 | |||||||||
| Saint Mary's (Cal.)* | W | 38-7 | |||||||||
| Dayton* | L | 14-20 | |||||||||
| Butler | W | 53-6 | |||||||||
| San Diego | W | 41-20 | |||||||||
| Jacksonville | W | 34-14 | |||||||||
| Western Illinois | L | 0-24 | |||||||||