Kleenex Girl Wonder
Posted Questions by a Kleenex Girl Wonder Sceptic
< Return To Articles



Original http://www.greenspun.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id=006n8O
Kleenex Girl Wonder: Classic or Dud?

Question


So, is Graham Smith the strongest man alive or just another whiney indie pop one man show?...I like his ponyoak album, it's quite raw, but he writes some really hummable tunes...though, it is a far too long album.
Anyway, what do you think...also Search and Destroy.

james ([email protected]), October 23, 2001

 

Answer Two


Saw him in concert in Washington a few years ago. It was amusing. Search a second hand copy of Ponyoak.

nathalie ([email protected]), October 23, 2001

 

Answer Three


Whiney, yes. "Why I Write Such Good Songs" is damn catchy tho.

Ariën ([email protected]), October 23, 2001

 

Answer Four


'sexual harassment' and 'can't pull the wool over these eyes' = classic. graham's cover of 'the boy is mine' = classic.
i can't really comment on the rest of it because i haven't paid too much attention (even though i have the records! bad maura!), but i have to say that i find the idea of combining lyrical bragging with the indie-boy aesthetic is more than a little terrifying, especially for people who might *date* these boys.

maura ([email protected]), October 23, 2001

 

Answer Five


Kleenex were certainly girl wonders... although I prefer to use the word 'woman' instead

Jerry ([email protected]), October 23, 2001

 

Answer Six


Disclaimer: KGW once did a song for a compilation I put out.
I think Graham's an AMAZING songwriter at his best, and I think someday he's going to put out an album that's gonna make everyone wonder why they've been sleeping. To date, you sort of have to take him song-by- song. But if you've missed "Why I Write Such Good Songs"--Nietzsche by way of N'Sync--or "Bones and the Smiling Mackerel" (beating GBV at their own game) or "Wireless" or "Sexual Harassment" or "Ponyoak" or "The Bostonians" or that friggin' amazing "Coda" piece at the end of _Smith_, well, you probably have a lot of room for useful things in your head that's occupied in mine by his tunes/words running through it.

Douglas Wolk ([email protected]), October 23, 2001

 

Answer Seven


The most recent record he's made was done in by the curse of the skit. His other stuff ranges from subpar to stellar, making all stops in between.
:jek

jek ([email protected]), October 23, 2001

 

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1