|

The urban nightmare
Zaigham Khan
The world is entering a historic urban transition;
in 2007, for the first time in history, the
world's urban population will exceed the rural
population. Most of the world's urban growth -- 95
per cent -- in the next two decades will be
absorbed by cities of the developing world, which
are least equipped to deal with rapid urbanisation.
In most Third World countries, growth in cities is
synonymous with growth in slums. In South Asia,
for example, annual slum and urban growth rates
are 2.2 per cent and 2.89 per cent respectively,
which means that 76 per cent urban growth in this
region is in fact growth in slums.
This is the context in which United Nations held
its World Urban Forum from June 19 to June 23 in
the sanitised environment of Vancouver, Canada,
thousands of miles away from mega-slums of cities
like Mumbai, Nairobi and Karachi. The stated aim
of the forum was to "examine one of the most
pressing issues facing the world today: rapid
urbanisation and its impact on communities,
cities, economies and policies."
On the sidelines of the conference, UN-Habitat
(United Nations Human Settlement Programme) also
released its State of the World's Cities Report
2006/7. The report provides concrete data that
shows that the world's one billion slum dwellers
are more likely to die earlier, experience more
hunger and disease, attain less education and have
fewer chances of employment than those urban
residents that do not reside in a slum. The report
portrays a familiar picture of the urban apartheid
in the developing world with two cities existing
within one city -- "one part of the urban
population that has all the benefits of urban
living, and the other part, the slums and squatter
settlements, where the poor often live under worse
conditions than their rural relatives." The Report
shows remarkable similarities between slums and
rural areas in health, education, employment and
mortality.
Many experts have noted that unlike nineteenth
century Europe, the mega-urbanisation in the third
world is not a 'natural' process resulting from
industrialisation and 'progress'. The rising rural
poverty, that no juggling in figures could hide,
is creating a big push in the rural areas. This
poverty, on its part, is linked to national and
international policies that discriminate against
the poor, particularly the rural peasants, in the
name of economic growth and development. Policies
of the industrialised world, together with IMF and
World Bank debt policies, have imposed ultra-low
prices on agricultural produce from poorer
countries, bankrupting hundreds of thousands of
peasants and small farmers. Many rich countries,
that support third world governments and NGOs to
fight rural poverty are not ready to provide fair
terms of trade to third world farmers whose
situation keeps deteriorating.
However, it is too convenient to lay all blame at
the door of foreign governments. The main credit
must go to the policies of efficient and
enlightened rulers of the third world countries.
Our own duly elected and fully democratic
government of the 'Islamic welfare state' of
Pakistan works overtime for the welfare of those
who deserve it the most --- the rich and the
powerful. Take the very hot example of the sugar
industry, one of the most incompetent and
protected of all industries, yet married to power
and politics. After exploiting farmers for decades
and forcing consumers to pay a premium for its
incompetence, the sugar-industry government
combine is now ready to attack and totally
annihilate the cottage industry producing gur.
Ideally, the government should have been running a
campaign to promote the use of gur, which, apart
from empowering farmers and providing employment
to hundreds of thousands of rural workers, is a
much healthier and organic sweetener. This cannot
happen because it is not poor gur but the wealthy
stepsister sugar that sits in the cabinet. Once
gur is destroyed, sugarcane farmers will be
vassals of the sugar industry forever. Any wonder
cities will get a few hundred thousand new
residents.
As a result of such policies, besides other
socio-economic factors, peasants, farmers and
artisans are leaving their lands, drifting towards
the cities, knowing that even a 'marginal' city
existence, as peddlers, beggars or even turning
over rubbish tips, gives them a better chance of
survival than a pitiful existence in the
countryside. They turn to the cities, often not
knowing that a new form of poverty, disease,
discrimination and crime awaits them in the in
their magnificent slums. Violence, drugs and child
labour are the inevitable consequences of the
magnificent way of life they are condemned to
enjoy for generations to come.
Denuded of their ancient identities based on
family, clan and caste, the young ones in the
slums look to sectarian and ethnic groups for new
identities. Some even end up in sectarian and
jihadi militant organisations in order to give
some meaning to their lives and find a better life
in paradise, which is often the only way to
improve their existence. Ask patron saints of
these outfits for a list of addresses and you will
find ninety-nine of them in a city slum.
Using ingenuity, energy and resourcefulness of the
existing and potential slum dwellers, capable
urban planners working under an efficient local
government might have changed things for the
better. But urban planning is non-existent and
local governments, when functional, are
ill-equipped, inefficient, starved for resources
and well manipulated by the omnipotent puppeteers.
The ruling wisdom, therefore, is to shut the filth
out by creating lovely islands of prosperity, many
being designed and developed by foreign
consultants and firms. These heavens on earth need
land, which has to be snatched away from suburban
villages, at prices that are often thousands and
at times hundreds of thousand times less than the
market prices. When newly rootless and
disintegrated communities ask where they can go,
they are given addresses of a nearby slum.
Perhaps, I should not be so pessimistic. Migrating
to Islamabad the beautiful from a village in the
Southern Punjab, I have landed full three hundred
feet away from Maira Basti slum, inside a sector
developed by the Capital Development Authority (CDA).
Mercifully, my father was not a sugar-cane farmer.
The writer is an Islamabad-based journalist and
development consultant.
Email: [email protected]
|