Movie mostakes (by harrypotternetwork)
![]()
1. Peeves was not
present
2. The students sometimes wore
Muggle clothing, and wore it well! Note, Wood when he was teaching Harry about Quidditch
or nearly the Weasleys before they get on the train. In GoF it was made clear Magic Folk
are not very good at dressing in Muggle clothing...much less dress like Muggles in their
off hours - Micheal
3. McGonagall doesn't change
into a cat during class in the first book ... she does it in the third book after a
Divination lesson, and wondered why there was no applause. - Joshua
4. When Hagrid arrives with baby
Harry he makes no mention of the fact that he got the motorbike from young Sirius
Black. We never see what Dursely life was like before Harry enters their lives, but
I assume this is because of time purposes (The movie was over two hours as is.)
5. The snake at the zoo in the
book was a Brazilian Boa and in the movie it was a Burmese Python. -Micheal
6. Harry never changed rooms, so
the letters never changed ("The Cupboard under the Stairs", "The Smallest
Bedroom" etc.) So in the second movie is he still going to be in the cupboard? -
Jar48
7. When the Griphook opened
vault 713 in Gringotts the door just melted away, there were no locks as in the movie. -
Micheal
8. There isn't a magical
measuring tape measuring Harry while he's at Ollivanders.
9. Harry and Hagrid go from
Diagon alley to Kings Cross Station where Hagrid suddenly has to leave and therefore Harry
has to find platform 9 � by himself. No Dursleys and their sniggering.
Harry's Birthday is July 31, 1980. If that's so, then the movie would have taken place in
1991. But, in the movie, when Harry and the Dursleys' are leaving the house to go to the
zoo, the car they get into is a '98. - NYKitten99
10. Harry never read the back of
the Dumbledore Card.
11. Harry never meets Draco
Malfoy on the train nor at Madame Malkins. Instead he meets him while waiting to be
sorted.
12. The sorting hat doesnt
sing.
13. The sorting doesnt go
in alphabetical order
14. We dont meet the
ghosts until after theyve been sorted
15. When Nearly-headless-Nick,
pops throught the plate of chicken Ron was eating at the moment at the feast at the
beginning of the year, he didn't mention not being able to join the headless hunt then,
that doesn't come up untill the second book. He doesn't come through the chicken either,
he was already sitting at the table. - Maureen
16. In the movie, although they
only show Charms, Transfiguration and Potions, Draco Malfoy's face seems to appear in all
three classes. But in the book, Slytherin only have Potions with Gryffindor. - Bhavani
17. In the books Snape's class
is supposed to be in the dungeon, but in the movie the potions class has very tall
windows. - Micheal
18. After the first flying
lesson when McGonagall brings Harry to meet with Oliver Wood she actually "borrows
Wood" not from Quirell and not Flitwick - Micheal
19. In the book, Harry being
Seeker is kept secret until Malfoy catches him walking up the stairs with his broomstick.
In the Movie, Everybody knows he's seeker from the moment he finishes talking with
McGonagall and Wood. - Winky
20. At the Quidditch match when
Quirrell hexes Harry broom he is sitting on the top row intead of the bottom row. - Jayln
21. Professor Dumbledore
attended the Quidditch match versus Slytherin. In the book it was an important fact that
he did not attend the first match and thats why Quirrell was able to hex Harry's broom.
However in the book Dumbledore did attend the second match. It kind of conflicts with
Hermione's statement when she said "as long as Dumbledores around you cant be
touched" to Harry. - Katy
22. In the Prisoner of Azkaban
when Gryffindor play Slytherin, the Slytherin beaters hit bludgers at Wood. Madame Hooch
shrieks "You do not attack the Keeper unless the quaffle is in the scoring area"
and awards Gryffindor a penalty. In the film the Slytherin captain is cleary seen hitting
Wood with the bludger after the ball has left the scoring area yet know penalty is given.
Also, time outs are allowed and surely Gryffindor would of called a time out if there
Keeper and captain had just been knocked to the floor unless of course only the captain
can call a time out. - Lindsey
23. The meeting between Snape
and Quirell takes place in a hall not in the Forbidden Forest.
Instead of Neville getting detention with Hermione, Harry, and Draco; Ron does. They don't
get detention because they were outside the castle at night, but because they were at the
top of the astronomy tower, handling the Norbert situation. Ron was in the infirmary -
Thanks to Mouse for the correction!
24. They never state dragons are
illegal which was why Norbert had to go in the first place
25. We don't meet Bane and
Ronan.
26. Ron and Hermione don't have
qualms over saying the name 'Voldemort' - seanluvr915
27. There is no duel
challenge which leads to the discovery of Fluffy. It happens because of an
accidental shifting of the staircases.
28. Harry gets his broom on the
same day as the first Quidditch match. It is carried by Hedwig alone.
29. Harry never gets a sweater
from Mrs. Weasely. We don't see Gred and Forge either. From George's comment "You
haven't got a letter on yours" implies that there shouldn't be a letter 'R' on Ron's
jumper.
30. Harry never gets the fifty
pence from his Aunt and Uncle. So we don't hear Ron say " Weird! What a shape! This
is money?". It makes this more perculiar because from what we saw in Gringotts,
Galleons, Knuts, and Sickles look just like enlarged 50 pences.
31. In the book, the
invisibility cloak is silvery and fluid -- in the movie its a big brown thing. - Jackie
32. There are no nightmares.
33. When Hermione shows Harry
and Ron the trophy case, she shows Harry a plaque of James Potter it states he is a
seeker, but JKR stated in a chat that James was a Chaser.
34. We never see the Christmas
feast (cut for time?)
35. The mirror of Erised is
located in a spare room, but not a classroom.
36. Harry only sees his parents,
not his whole family.
37. They hardly ever visit
Hagrid.
38. Hargid's house in the book
was made of wood (Harmione said so just after Norbert was born), but in the movie it was
made of stone. - Micheal
39. Fang was a Boar Hound, now
known as Greek Danes, in the movie he was a Neopolitan Mastiff. - Micheal
40. Norbert is sent to Romania
via Dumbledore, and the whole school knows about it. We never see Charlies friends.
41. They don't get Fluffy to
sleep cause there's a harp playing..they play the flute that Hagrid got Harry for
christmas.
42. Fluffy is
already asleep when they get there.
43. They don't meet the knocked out Troll which was supposedly Quirell's obstacle in the
path of getting the stone. - MBKoops
44. There is no 4th task. (The
bit where Hermione solves the riddle and the potions)
Hermione wins 50 points for Gryffindor for "the use of cool logic in the face of
fire" in the book... when in the movie, she did not solve the logic puzzle with the
bottles of potion. Instead, she is awarded points for "cool intellect". (This
also ruins the fact that the four professors each had their own obstacle to guard the
Stone, seeing as Snape's was supposed to be the logic puzzle.) - Ashley
45. Another Hermione mistake...
the Devil's Snare. They don't fall through; Hermione remembers that you can kill it with
fire. Ron (in the book) yells, "Are you a witch or not?"... and after she
remembers, they proceed down a stone passageway... - Ashley
46. The keys: Harry is not
attacked by the keys in the book, nor is he the only one on a broomstick. It states in the
book that they all seized a broomstick, and corner the key.- Ashley
47. When Harry finds Quirrell
with the mirror, Harry gets bound by ropes.- Ashley
In the book, Quirrell does not crumble and fade away, as he does in the movie. Harry
passes out while fighting him, and wakes up in the hospital wing.- Ashley
48. Harry ends up in the
hospital wing for a somewhat different reason.
![]()