March 11, 2008-American Idol Beatles Night
| Beatle's Night..... David Archuleta | Save by his supporter but the worst performance of the night | | | |
| Brooke White | it was a good song highlighted by her piano accompaniment | | | |
| Chikezie Eze | his performance has a wow factor, 2nd best of the night | | | |
| Carly Smithson | I disagree with Simon. she's by far not a Kelly Clarkson. Carly is good but not really impressive and doesn't have a wow factor sounding the same everyweek | | | |
| Amanda Overmyer | She is unique tonight. I like the way she performed her song. she reminds me of Janis Joplin | | | |
| Kristy Lee Cook | I disagree with the judges. Kristy did a good country interpretation of Eight Days a Week. Love it. | | | |
| David Cook | David is the best tonight. The best rendition and performer of the night. | | | |
| Jason Castro | Jason is one of my favorites. Good voice, but need to step up to the plate and he needs to learn to adjust his voice with the song as he sounded really struggling with the high notes | | | |
| Michael Johns | great voice. the song choice was good but he needs to pick up the pace. He is another of my favorite. | | | |
| Ramiele Malubay | She needs to stay away from ballads for a while. needs to pick up the pace and show her range. her song choices are not the greatest either. if she sings one more ballad with a 'blah' factor, she will be one of the early casualties. | | | |
| David Hernandez--- bad performance-- I believe he is the first casualty of the Top 12; if it's not Syesha Mercado whose performance was unforgettable. |
| |
Bottom three prediction: David Hernandez, Syesha Mercado and Ramiele Malubay 
