Her hair was jet black
But her eyes were blue
It wasn't like when I first met you
Mainly because she was riding a plastic horse and you weren't
chorus
Yes, I may have loved you at one time
But in my heart I know this girl must be mine
Yes, I found love
Love on a stolen plastic horsey
She's not like the other girls, like you
You would've looked silly, you would've picked blue
But the horse that she rode on was gray
That's how she stole my heart away
And now, I'm proud to say
That I found love riding around on a horse
Stolen from the carousel in front of K-Mart