HOME                                         BACK

Correspondence between Kim Bax, mum, and Barbara Stone MP (Labour), Springwood - on the issue of seatbelts on school buses

 

This is Barbara Stone MP.  Click on the picture to email her.

 

 

 

This is Kim Bax, mum.  Click on the picture to email me

 

 

Barbara Stone's reply to Kim Bax's questions - received on the 30th January 2004.

Kim Bax's response to Barbara Stone - sent on the 31st January 2004

4 weeks later, on the 28th February 2004, Barbara Stone had still not replied to Kim Bax's email of 31st January 2004 - so Kim Bax sent Barbara a reminder

Over 4 weeks MORE, on the 28th March 2004, Barabara Stone continues to ignore the emails - so Kim Bax sent her another reminder

 

Barbara Stone's reply to Kim Bax's questions - received on the 30th January 2004:-      (TOP)

Dear Kim
 
Barbara has requested I contact you to thank you for your email.  The Beattie Government's current position on the issues you have raised are as follows...
 

Seatbelts on school buses

 

The Beattie Government has identified the safety of students travelling to and from school as one of the most important issues for both parents and communities.

 

In 2003, a trial of seatbelts on school buses was conducted in response to recommendations made by the independent School Transport Safety Task Force and the Interdepartmental Working Group.

 

The trial involved fitting ADR68/00 seats and seat belts to 12 school buses throughout Queensland operating on long steep and very steep bus routes – where standing passengers are currently not permitted. The buses involved in the trial were split into either a low, medium or high encouragement group in order to measure the effect of education on seat belt wearing rates and student behaviour in the buses.

 

The aim of this trial was to identify and develop solutions for a range of legal, behavioural and operational issues before further consideration for inclusion in the Queensland school bus fleet.

 

The evaluation of the trial, which ran for six months, was conducted by the independent transport research organisation ARRB Transport Research. The key aim of the evaluation was to establish seat belt usage rates and identify the impact of seat belts on student behaviour.

 

The School Transport Safety Interdepartmental Working Group has been reconvened to examine the results of the trial and further investigate issues such as legal responsibility and compliance. The taskforce will provide recommendations by April 2004.

 

Other initiatives implemented as a direct result of the School Transport Safety Task Force include:

§       Development of the School Environment Safety Guidelines to help local schools and communities to improve safety around schools;

§       Safe Communities Trial to assist school based community groups through facilitating, engaging and observing these groups as they considered transport safety issues in their local community;

§       Increased school transport safety public education to improve road safety for children travelling to and from school;

§       SchoolBUS (School Bus Upgrade Scheme), which provides $3 million each year to help school bus operators across Queensland progressively upgrade their fleets; and

§       Launch and implementation of the Managing Student Behaviour Training Package for school bus operators.

 

Once again, thank you for contacting our office regarding this issue.

 

Kind regards,

 

Clare Gillic
Electorate Officer for
Barbara Stone MP
State Member for Springwood
Phone : 3808 4219
Fax : 3208 9632
                                                           (TOP)

 

 

Kim Bax's response to Barbara Stone - sent on the 31st January 2004:-                           (TOP)

Dear Barabara,

Thankyou for your email to me of 30th January 2004 (or rather, your employees email).

I must confess, that as I read the various responses from parliamentary representatives, I am struck by two things. 

Firstly, the word "various" is a misnomer.  I appear to be receiving the the same rote response culled (I assume), from Party head office, from several members - yourself included.  The electors of Springwood deserve a great deal better from you - especially when it comes to the lives of their children.

Secondly, I have acute memories of flunking the ocassional exam at school - not because I didn't have the information or wasn't able to write - but because I didn't answer the question that was on the exam paper.  In other words, I went off on my own little tangent, completely ignoring what had actually been asked.  After doing this a few times, I learnt to pay closer attention, and improved my score.  Have you ever been there and done that?  Did you ever learn to pay closer attention to what had actually been asked of you?  In reading your response of 30th January 2004, I'm having some doubts  . . . . . . . . . .

You neither acknowledge or answer the questions I asked in my original correspondence - so for the benefit of your electors (and most importantly, for the benefit of the children who use school transport in your electorate), I'll ask those questions again:-

 

 

In reading your correspondence of 30th January 2004, I am very much reminded of the comedy skit that sometimes graces the end of the ABC's "7.30" Report, (John Clark and Phillip Dawes).  They parody that typical (and infuriating), political response - you know, the one where the politician answers everything but the question that was put to them.  That scenario is very funny - but it is also extremely sad, and goes a long way towards illustrating (in a very stark way), why many people have lost faith in politicians. The residents of Springwood deserve a GREAT deal better from you when it comes to the safety of their children.

From what I can gather, you are a highly educated and intelligent woman.  Can I suggest you read my original correspondence more carefully - so as to provide a thoughtful, personal and considered response - one that acknowledges and addresses the questions that have actually been put to you.

I look forward to your further response.

Regards - Kim Bax (mum)

PS - I assume that Clare Gillick, your employee, is very able and conscientious - however, this issue demands your PERSONAL attention (not to mention interest).  Warren Pitt, your colleague (Member for Mulgrave), took the time to phone me at home last week.  It was 8pm in the evening, and he'd already had a frantically busy day in his electorate - but then Warren has had intimate experience of this issue. He knows what it's like for a community to pull 8 dead kids out of a school bus (and 12 mutilated ones).  Gordonvale, electorate of Mulgrave, 1987.  I hope to God you never learn the hard way to pay attention to this issue.                      (TOP)

 

4 weeks later, on the 28th February 2004, Barbara Stone had still not replied to Kim Bax's email of 31st January 2004 - so Kim Bax sent Barbara a reminder:-                                (TOP)

From Kim Bax - mum & school bus seatbelt campaigner, Beaudesert Shire
 
Goodmorning,
 
Four weeks ago as of to-day's date (28th February 2004), I sent you some correspondence in relation to school bus safety/seatbelts.  This has neither been acknowledged or answered.  I look forward to hearing from you in the near future.
 
For your convenience, here is a link to the correspondence in question:-
 
http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2004/springwood.htm
 
Regards - Kim Bax
 
PS - the above page will be updated with this reminder to-day.                          (TOP)

 

Over 4 weeks MORE, on the 28th March 2004, Barabara Stone continues to ignore the emails - so Kim Bax sent her another reminder:-          (TOP)

From Kim Bax, mum & schoolbus seatbelt campaigner, Beaudesert Shire
 
Goodmorning Barbara,
 
On the 22nd January 2004 and 31st January 2004, I sent you an email containing 3 specific questions about seatbelting Queensland children in schoolbuses.  To date, you have not addressed those questions.  I also sent you a reminder on the 28th February 2004 (4 weeks ago), again - I have not had a response.
 
For your convenience, here's a direct link to my questions of 22nd January 2004:-
 
http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2005/correspondence.htm#email22january2004
 
And here's a direct link to your response, received on the 30th January 2004 (I use the word "response" here deliberately - as none of my questions were actually "answered"):-                                                                                                                                 

http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2005/springwood.htm#barbara30jan

 
Here's a direct link to my reply, sent to you on the 31st January 2004 - which repeated my questions of 22nd January 2004:-
 
http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2005/springwood.htm#kim31jan

 

An here's a link to the reminder I sent you on the 28th February 2004 (now over 4 weeks ago) - about my email of 31st Jan 2004:-   

http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2005/springwood.htm#kim28feb                                           

 
In reply, perhaps it may avoid any confusion about what HAS and HASN'T  been addressed if you numbered your answers "1, 2 & 3" - to correspond to my three questions.  That would appear to be a fairly simple solution.
 
Barbara - this is a very serious problem.  It involves children's lives - and deserves a great deal more personal attention from you than it has received to date.  To underline the enormity of this issue, here's a link to an article in the Australian Medical Association News (Queensland), about the potential consequences of a school bus crash - written by those we pay to know about road trauma, doctors:-
 
http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2005/chilling_quotes.htm#ama
 
Here's another link which may be of interest to you - it's to a page that gives a comprehensive breakdown of past, present and ongoing publicity (re. this campaign):-
 
http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2005/media_diary.htm
 
In a nutshell, I will continue to send you reminders (at 4 weekly intervals, over the next 3 years), until you face up to your responsibilities.  I assume children in Springwood use school buses?  Our correspondence will be (and has been), recorded on your "page":-
 
http://www.geocities.com/seatbelts2005/springwood.htm
 
At an opportune moment towards the end of this current term, I will contact your local media with regards to features about this problem.  I am sure they will find my meticulously kept records of my correspondence with yourself (plus all the other horrifying information on my website), more than enough material for news items.
 
I look forward to hearing from you.
 
Regards - Kim Bax                                       (TOP)

HOME                                         BACK

Hosted by www.Geocities.ws

1