Regardless of how dubious its documentary tactics may be, Bowling for Columbine is powerfull, thought-provoking, and, upon occasion, bitingly funny. Moore's easygoing tone nver makes the viewer feel threatened - just as his rumpled personal appearance puts his victims and adversaries at ease. He's a predator in disguise. The movie offers something for everyone. Even those who disagree with Moore's politics will find themselves thinking during and after the movie. Whether you agree with the director's conclusions isn't the issue - it's that you recognize the problem.
The point of the film is to determine why gun violence, especially that of children on children, is rampant in this country. At first, Moore is guided by the precept that easy access to guns is the cause. And, despite being a card-carrying member of the NRA, he is more than willing to point the finger at Heston and his cronies. But, along the way Moore makes a discovery - there are more guns per household in Canada than in the United States, yet the death toll, even when adjusted to consider the unequal populations, is much lower. This forces Moore to conclude that, while the ready availability of firearms in the United States may be a contributing factor to the high number of gun-related homicides, it's not the primary reason.
Eventually, after conducting various interviews and hopping around the country (and out of it), Moore suggests that fear, enhanced by the media's obsession with death and violent crime, may be the root cause of America's death-by-gun problem. Americans are frightened. They live in gated communities and lock their doors at night. THey sleep with loaded guns under their pillows because only a firearm at-the-ready gives them a sense of security. Fear makes people jumpy and apprehensive, and more apt to resort to violence. And there's no cure for it. It is a societal ill that is perpetuated by the evening news and reality TV shows like "Cops".
Once in a while Moore goes down a rat hole. He tries, with limited success, to blame the deat of a six year-old girl on a work-for-welfare program. If you follow his convoluted logic, it makes a certain kind of sense, but he's stretching things. A more likely culprit is the uncle who didn't keep his guns safely locked away from the youngster who brought it to school and fired it. Strangley, Moore never addresses the issues of gun responsiblity and safety.
The film features a number of fascinating interviews. The one with Heston is the most predictable, since there's probably nothing he and Moore agree upon. The most unusual is probably the chat with James Nicols (the brother of Oklahoma City co-conspirator Terry Nichols), who makes a comment along the lines of: "The pen is mightier than the sword, but you have to have the sword for when the pen fails." Nichols also makes a statement about weapons-grade Plutonium that has to be heard to be believed. Other interview subjects include Columbine alumnist (and co-creator of "South Park") Matt Stone and goth rocker Marilyn Manson (who was blamed in some circles for Columbine).
Moore engages in his share of grandstanding stunts, one of which suprisingly pays off. He brings two Columbine survivors to the Michigan headquarters of K-Mart (then ammunition used to shot them was purchased at a K-Mart store), and asks if the boys can return the bullets that are still in their bodies. The next day, K-Mart announces that, after a 90-day phase out period, it will no longer be selling handgun ammuntion.
I can predict with a large degree of certainty that Bowling for Columbine will outrage viewers who political leanings are conservative. In additon to portraying may gun owners in an unflattering light, Moore insinuates that the CIA was indirectly responsible for 9/11 terrorists attacks on the World Trade Center. The film is a times laugh-out-loud, viciously funny (provided you aren't amoung Moore's targets). But, above all, no matter how much you love or despise the messenger and his means, there's no denying that message bears consideration and rumination. Imperfect as it may be, Bowling for Columbine is riveting stuff.
Porculus