=sc_aa6a R. Shlomo Carlebach -- Typed input of Xerox Ms. AA6 -- San Francisco Summer 1973 , Sunday Tape 2 -- Page 1 The transcriber is the usual one, from the handwriting Don't know who. Maybe Illana Rappaport (Schachter) but that's just a guess. No further Ptovenance Info on Manuscript. This manuscript is listed in my inventory of the Witt collection. That inventory is included on my Website, www.geocities.com/sa73122a This manuscript I xeroxed from the BZ Collection, which he copied from the HH Collection, which I duplicate of a part of the Witt Collection. I think Hatzkala (one of the H's of HH) had it first, from the HLP. I am grateful to Miriam Gal-Or for recopying this xeroxes and mailing them to me at Campra, Airmail Registered. I wrote on the number AA7 when I inventoried the Witt Collection, ca. 1988 . I have not looked the Witt Collection since. Notes will be Deep6'd to =scsanaa6 or some such; Caveat Lector, Hector. That's your Caveat Tabbycat, Blackhat. EDITORIAL NOTES: I try to start each line where it's started on the ms. But sometimes I break it early and start a new paragiraffe, in the interests of like enhancing clarity. And somtimes I alter the punctuation of the ms., because punctuation is like Dealer's Choice. ================================================================= START MS. AA6 PAGE 1 Ms. AA6 pages 1 starts with an ellipsis, indicating that the Rabbi raced the tape to the starting post and won ... -------------------- ... that's the whole thing. That's the secret. The secret is to get the two together. That means that every scheduled flight should be a non-schedulted flight. The surpise you know. If you can live on that level every morning when you wake up your are so surprised you woke up you know. You know the holy SANZER, you know the Sanzer never slept -- but regardless. One morning he was supposed to meet this great Rabbi in the synagogue and he was five hours late. The Rabbi was burning up, he says, what's going on here. I've been waiting here for five hours. The Sanzer didn't want to say that he prayed so long, you know, till he was finished with his prayers. This anti_ , you know (aa6-1) straight Rabbi, he knocks off his prayers in ten minutes. So he says to him, you know, I tell you something. I woke up so late, therefore I'm late. He says you woke up late ! -- why did you go to sleep late. He says, I just went to sleep very late. He says, but you knew you have to meet me this morning, why didn't you go to sleep early. SANZER looks at him, he says, did I know I'll wake up this morning? (aa6-2) [ and if that ain't Zen, I'll give back my chopsticks ] ---------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 2 OF RSC MS. AA6 Ok listen kids something very deep: What's the difference you know, sometimes you meet a good friend, and you meet them for one second and it's just so good. Because it was completely beyond time right. You were tasting eternity. Ok listen, I'll just trandlate a little bit [ SOMEONE SAY -- FROM WHAT WAS RSC TEACHING HERE ] but then we'll get to it. Before G_d created the world everything was infinite. But G_d wanted to reveal 'HIS' Kingdom. And there is no king without people. (aa6-3) And 'HE' needed to create a world with people who know there is a King. But you can not understand G_d without certain knowlege, certain emotions,. certain kinds of vessels to undertand 'HIM'. (aa6-4) Because there must be emotion of love, of strength, of beauty, of eternity, [ As to why RSC chooses these emotions -- he is just running down the 7 lower sfirot -- chesed, gvurah, tiferet, netzach ... ] all kinds of deep emotions because you only know G_d via your heart. (aa6-5) And the moment you have emotions, already finite. And G_d put aside all the the great lights on the side and there was left an empty space and in this empty space 'HE' created the world. You know G_d is infinite. But we can not understand G_d in an infinite way. We can only understand G_d in a finte way, because wear finite people. So ---------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 3 OF RSC MS. AA6 therefore G_d had to create finite vessels to create the world. Finite vessels is that we can know G_d in a finite way. Then it says: And what is the vessels for all the vessels for those emotions of my heart. [ What follows is R. Shlomo's commentary, merely exegesis really, on the phrase he translated (from Source -- UNKOWN TO ME ) as 'emotions of my heart' ] Because you know there is something very deep: There is wisdom in my mind, there is wisdom in my heart. The wisdom of my mind is very good but it's nothing. It's deep but it doesn't get there. You can not know G_d just with the wisdom of your mind. You have to know G_d with the wisdom of your heart. (aa6-6) Becasue the heart is the deepest depth there is. Then G_d created two things. There is a good voice in my heart. Thdt means my vessel is a vessel for good and my heart is also a vessel for evil. OK, that's momish gevalt you know. (aa6-7) So G_d created me and gave me a heart and all those deep things and with all those emotiongs I should know there is One G_d. But what happens if I have evil thoughts. (aa6-8) Then I'm defiling this holy dephts of me which G_d gave me in order to understand 'HIM'. And you know what, I want you to know someting very deep: Metaumtim [ thansriber adds (?) ] means (aa6-9a} --------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 4 OF RSC MS. AA6 I'm closing up, you know. (aa6-9b) What happens to you when you're evil. (aa6-10) You're closing yourself up from G_d, from the world, something happens to you.- You're covered up, you know. Like you take a bottle and you close it; you can't put anything in anymore. (aa6-11) (aa6-11) I suppose this is RSC's exegesis of the notion of 'klipot', but I don't know becase I lack practically all Jewish education. So someone who has some should do some serious commentary on these teachings. (aa6--11a) To be holy means to be completely open, everything is flowing into you. But when you're wrong your're just closed up, nothing happens. But then you have to know, the truth is: The heart, basically, the heart is a great fire burning in the heart, but the heart is so big the heart wants to know G_d also in an infinite way. So therefore it says: King David says: I made a little hole in my heart. The hole means -- I made myself everybody also has to do the same thing. The same way as G_d made an empty space in my heart, in 'HIS' world for me, so I have to make like an empty space for G_d, to understand 'HIM' in my heart. And this is, because then if I make a little empty space in my heart, then in this little empty space G_d can shine all the vessels of holiness, of emotions into me, then I know how to serve G_d. But if I think evil things all --------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 5 OF RSC MS. AA6 the time then mys heart is closed up and then I can not use the same heart to understand G_d. So therefore he says something very deep: The moment you think I want to serve G_d, (aa6-12) that means at that moment you make a little empty space in your heart and G_d can areveal 'HIM'SELF to you there. He says: What does it mean to pray. This is momish a gvalt. In a nutshell, someone asks you what is to pray: To pray means to make an empty space in your heart, with words. And you know, what it is: Every word you utter, I make a little depth in my soul, a little empty space in my heart. Listen to this -- You know what praying is: Praying is that G_d is revealing 'HIM'SELF to me you know. We always thikn I'm asking G_d. It's nozttrue. Prayer means that G_d is revealing 'HIS' Kingdom to me. And with every word I utter, like I make a little empty space in my heart and G_d can be there. But then you have to know that YeRUSheLaYiM is a House of Prayer. There is a high YeRUSheLaYiM, there is a low YerRUSheLaYiM. There are two houses. There is a a high hosue and there is a low house. And therefore he says: But then when you make a little empty space in your heart, you don't --------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 6 OF MS. AA6 overdo it because otherwise you'll burst. So in a certain crazy way you know you have to yearn for the infinite -- but if you're infinite, so G_d cannot tell you -- so you have to yearm in an infinite way for the finite. (aa6-13) Because what does it mean to have holy thoughts: That means that the holy thoughts, like, make G_d a little bit finite to bring 'HIM' closer to your head. (aa6-14) What is a high house and what is a low house: The low house is that I in a finite way am making a way for G_d, and through this finite little house G_d is shining the infinite. So therefore he says, Reb Nathan says, so this is what Reb Nachman is saying: Because evrybody knows that I am a little part of G_d. And where is G_d. G_d is in my heart. If G_d is in my heart that means my heart is infinite. And therefore, like, the flame in my heart is momish infinite and in the most infinite way I'm burninng up, I want to know what G_d is. But sometimes I'm burning up so much because therefore I can not do anything. (aa6-15) Because every act I'm doing is a finite act. And therefore it's really hard you know, somestimes I want to be so ---------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 7 OF MS. AA6 infinite, but this isn't how it is, you know. It's very strange. If you come to somebody and say would you like to know G_d in an infinite way he's ready. Ask him would you like to know G_d in a finite way, put on tfilin ever morning, svach. (aa6-16) Why. Because basically basically I'm yearning for the infinite, right. I'd like to know G_d in an infinite way which is really true. But you have to realize one thing. You're living in this world and you will not know G_d unless you do the finite things. G_d promises you, in this finite thing, I'll pour in the infinte. This is the vessel. (aa6-17) So the same way, he says, as G_d made empty space for me, I got to make myself empty. Empty means I for one minute stop being infinite. That's very strong. Everyobdy wants to know G_d in an infinte way. But you can't. So you have to make yourself finite, means take your infinatism away from you, make yourself empty. Empty means that you're not infinite there. This is the place where G_d is really living and this is the secret of creating the world [ tzim-tzum ]. And this is the secret of serving G_d more and more and more. QUESTION: "Shlomo, there's something bothering me about --------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 8 OF RSC MS. AA6 what you said about your heart bursting. RSC: Sure, if I'm serving G_d in an infinite way I'll blow my mind. (aa6-18) I'll get crazy the next minute, you know. Why do a lot of kids become a little bit religious and then they momish get crazy. It's a holy thing you know because they're really yearning for G_d in an infinite way. But they didn't keep it, they didn't make an empty vessel in their hearts. ARTHUR: That's what you mean by annihilation. isn't it. RSSC: That's pretty good. Arthur is momish top, you know. It's one of the ways but its a very strong thing. Annihilation means to make an empty space. To go against your being infinite and let G_d do the thing, you know. I'm saying to G_d I'm ready to let me know you on your terms. Listen to this: What's the whole thing of having good thoughts or evil thoughts. Good thoughts mean I want this world to be right. What's the greatest greatest holiest thought. I want this world to exist. I want me to exist. I want G_d to exist in this world. So the way for G_d to exist in the world is there has to -------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 9 OF RSC MS. AA6 be a little empty space. RABBI LEIBOWITZ: Just one little thing. HOw do you divide the finite of the acts of deeds that you're talking about, like tfilin and tzittzit from the finite of, it sounfs stupid, the finite of making money that comes from the same source. RSC: Everthing is the same thing you know. I mean what we were talking about that Reb Nachman says the most empty space is money. But this is G_d's empty space you know. G_d emptied 'HIM'SELF, wherever I make money G_d isn't there because I think I'm doing it, right. It's my power, right. Money makes you powerful, right. This is one spot where G_d isn't manifest, right. It''s empty space. And you have to fill it with G_d again. So but here, this is my back answer you know: The empty space Reb Nachman is talkng about here that I want to serve G_d so much --- Listen to me: I can walk up to a person, love them so much that I momish kill them with my loving, right. Coming on too strong brother, you know, cool it. And the same way we come to G_d we say, listen G_d, I want to serve YOU in an infinite way, you know blow my mind you know. (aa6-19) ----------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 10 OF RSC MS- AA6 So G_d says cool it brother you know. But the thing is, if I cool it completely I become dead, it's bad too, right. It has to be both, right. RABBI LEIBOWITZ: See, what bothers me is, if you're speaking in really terms of actually the way it is, as long as both are the same areas , money and tfilin and tzittzit, it's not so great you know. (aa16-20) RSC: No, it's a different thing because I'm talking about your empty space and G_d's empty space. G_d's empty space is money. My empty space is mitzvas. You know, I don't know if I make myself clear. (aa6-21) RABBI LEIBOWITZ: There's a good finite and ther's a bad finite. It's not all just -- RSC: So that's the thing but there has to be finite. The thing is, but this finite has to be such a holy finite it doesn't cover up the infinite you know. Has to be infinitely finite you know. And this is the house above the house below. (aa6-22) Listen, I'll tell you something very very deep you know. Even on a human level you know: Take married couples you know. In a very deep way. Imagine a lot of people are very close before they get married. And then when ----------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 11 OF RSC MS. AA6 it comes to the finite thing you know, waking up in the morning and talking to each other its noz so much, right. Because they're very good on the infinte level but on this empty space level they don't click. (aa6-23) And then there's a lot ogf couples, they're tremendous on the finite level, but thy're dead, right. Everything goes clock clock clock but there is nothing between them. This infinte thing isn't between them, you know. So this is called the low house and the high house. Very strong theng you know. And the same om the service pf G_d. Everybody wamts to, I just want to have a relation of G_d. I'm ready to be Moses on Mt. Sinai. But are you ready to be Moshela the water Carrier and kindle lights at the proper time, you know. (aa6-24) Now listen to this. This is unbelieveable. In a nery deep way: Why, what happened to me when I sinned. Why did I do wrong. Because when I'm born, basically every child wants to serve G_d in the most infinte way. The only thing which I failed G_d is I couldn't make this empty space within me. So tchuva is, tchuva is that I'm connebting again the infinte to the finite. But tchuva, since I'm doing it --------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 12 OF RSC MS. AA6 (I marked this AA6 Pt. 2, but I think that was just because my stapler couldn't do more than 11 pages. ) so strong so therefore the wall between the infinite and the finite is less. Obbviouyly a tzadik is a very holy person. But you see more the finite than the infinite. And a Baal tchuva, the holiness is, of repenting is, that this infinite fire is momish obivous you know. It's momish burning in an infinite way. Therefore he says: This is the whole thing about Shabos. ShaBaT is, the holiness of ShaBaT is, that on ShaBaT the vessel of ShaBaT is that on ShaBat I'm yearning for G_d in a most infintie way and even the ShaBaT is also infinite. That means all the mitzvas that I'm doing, they're finiteł mitzvas. They're very holy, but they're cutting me off a little bit from the infinite you know. It's hard. But Shabos is not doing anything you know. so on ShaBaT, ShaBat itself is a vessel for the infinite. That means, on ShaBaT my infinite and my finite are together. It's top. RABHBI LEIBOWITZ: But you do things on Shabos in a finite way. RSC: Whst do you do. RABBI LEIBOWITZ: Pray. {aa6-24a} RSC: But the mitzva of ShaBaT is praying? [ Rhetorical interrogative, meaning, surely old chap you don't mean to imply that, wot ] the mitzva of Shabos is Shabos, right. Listen, ShaBaT you eat also, and you sleep. But this isn't where (aa6-25) ------------------------------------------------------------------ START PAGE 13 OF RSC MS. AA6 its at. This finite is more more on the top level of infinttie you know. There's a strong differnece betwween me eating matza and eating Friday night. Because matza I got to take a matza, it's got to be taken care of and that matza has to be that long or that short and that thin right. On shaBaT even if I eat challah it has to be kosher but this isn't where its at you know. It has to be kosher anyway you know. Or it has to be challah. (aa6-26) RABBI LEIBOWITZ: Has noting to do with Shabos. (aa6-27) RSC: It has to do with Shabos but is still infinite right cause on Shabos the mitzva is bliss of Shabos, and I have to eat to keep up my bliss you know. (aa6-27a) But its, you know I'm not fulfilling the mitzva with the chewing like with matza. I'm doing the mitzva on being on the stete of bliss. (aa6-28) So therefore he says BReAShiT is ReAShIT Bet , two beginnings. There is a beginning on the infinite and a beginning on the finite. RABBI LEIBOWITZ, I PRESSUME: What do you mean about beginning. RSC: When G_d created the world, BReAShiT is at the begininng. and BReAShIT, the Zohar Kodesh says means ReAShiT Bet, two beginnings. -------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 14 OF RSC MS. AA6 (aa6-28a) So therefore, yeah. RABBI NUDNIK: Would you clarify what you mean about 'two beginnings'. (aa6-28b) RSC: I don't know exactly either you know. Reb Nachman says about the two beginnings, the finite beginning and infinte. This is how I'll create the world. The infinite has to be completely intact and they both have to go together. That means if for one thing you're just becoming a finite yidala, you're off, right. You're a Burro Park Yidalah. (AA6-29g) And if you're just infinite you're a very holy yidala but you're not the way you should be, right. Have to be both, right. Two beginnings, infinite and finite. RABBI LEIBOWITZ STRIKES AGAIN: (aa6-30) Shlomo, a finite vessel can receive the infinite [Nu?] (aa6-31) RSC: There are vessels that can. The is the whole thing of Tora Mitzvas that in finite vessels I receive the infinite. But if you don't use those vessels -- or you're completely nothing or you'll blow your mind. (aa6-32) What is a real person. A real person is someone who the infinite and finite are really together. In a million ways. And most people, either they're completely infinite or ------------------------------------------------------------------ START PAGE 15 OF RSC MS. AA6 they're finite. Ejither wys is bad you know. That means even whatever you do do, you want to do it, you must have the strength to do it in a finte way. You see, most of us, why aren't we better. Becuase I'd like to be the holiest man the next morning. So I wake up the next morninh I'm not the holiest man I give up. Becuae I have this infinite yearning but I don't have the strength just to be finite, you know. !Don't be the holiest. Just do a little bit holy.! Like one Rebbe said, 'Everyobdy would like to be the greatest scholar in one night, but this one night he wants to sleep also. Especially when it comes to the service of G_d it's a very delicate thing , you know. You got to have this infinite yearning because if you don't have infinite yearning, you're not with it. Got to be infinite. !So the doing has to be finite and the yearning has to be infinite.! Reb Nacham says something at the end: That's why a kallah gives her chasan a tallis, because a tallis is infinte, to let him know that the house will be a combination of the finite and hte infinite. This is a gvalt you know. RABBI LEIBOWITZ POSETH ANOTHER QUESTION: As you become more infinite, or aware ---------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 16 OF RSC MS. AA6 of more of the infinite, do you become less finite. RSC: No, on the contrary. I'll tell you something very deep: If you love someobdy very much, then you're ready to do them little favors also. They both become deep because if you're really with it then you know that the fnite is also infinite, you know. And if you're bad then the infinite is finite. (aa6-33) This completeness you know this holy depth. The combination of th High House and the low house. Then you can say: When I pray it has to be in a completely infinite way and yet it has to be finite. You know, the holiness of the prayer book -- it's the most finite thing in the world, those words are written up two thousand years ago. But the way I'm praying it has to be in an infinite way. (aa6-33a) You see what it is: Today a lot of people say, creative service. And it's a beautiful thing. I wish we could make up prayers, but why does it fail. You know why: Becuase crestive service means, I'm praying in an infinte way, you know, but they're using the most finite language there is, right. Because they don't have the holiness to know the secret of saying finite words which (aa6-34) ---------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 17 OF RSC MS. AA6 contain the infinite, right. I heard this reform rabbi creative service at a meting of the Sisterhood. Its sweet, basically its sweet you know. He wants to say something but the way the said it is not even finite anymore. Just stupid you know. Because between finite and stupid is a very fine line. When you study something its also very deep. Yo can understand dthe words or you can, because everything is really infinite, right. Whst's a good doctor , let's say. A good doctor, if he looks at your nose and he is a certain way infinite he can momish see the way the nose is connected to the foot, right. (aa6-35) And the way the connection to the foot is connected to the brain and the brain to your whole personality, right. Infinite ways, right. And if he's a finite doctor he'll look at your nose, he says, I'll give you a spray for your nose, right. (aa6-36) In the same way between people you know. Somoene can tell you a little thing but if you're on the infinite level you hear everything out of it , you know, this one word you know. But Reb Nachan is saying one word: Reb Nachmam is saying basically, since my heart is the place where I --------------------------------------------------------------- START PAGE 18 OF RSC MS. AA6 -- LAST PAGE fathom G_d, its infinite. Its infinte. Becuade if it wasn't infinite how could G_d be there. But since I'm living in the world G_d gave me finite vesseld to understand his infinitism. Reb Nachman says: You know the heart is there because, the heart, real wisdom is in my heart. It's much deeper than the mind. The mind receives from the heart. (aa6-37) TRANSCRIBER NOTES: END OF SIDE 1 TAPE 2 I assume that Tape is long gone. Maybe Ben-Zion at Mevo Modi'in knows of it. I presently have no sense of how the sequence of tapes fits with this sequence -- collection really, I numbered them in the order I took them out of the Witts file drawer, and the Witts were never clerically meticulous -- END RSC MS. AA6 ------------------------------------------------------------------ THIS DOC WILL BE =SC_AA6 THE NOTES TO THIS DOC WILL BE DEEP6'D TO =scsanaa6 I WILL DO A FLYING EDIT OF THIS DOC AND CALL IT =sce_aa6 ---------------------------------------------------------------- sa, Campra, 20 May '05 -- 11 AIYaR -- hod sh'b' NETZACH -- 21 Rabi' al Thaanay , whatever that is ----------------------------------------------------------------- =================================================================